Virtual microscopy as a tool for proficiency testing in cytopathology: a model using multiple digital images of Papanicolaou tests.

BACKGROUND Modern digital cameras can acquire images from cytologic slides at sufficient resolution to allow for digital enlargement and scrolling on a video monitor, allowing for the simulation of microscopy using a computer. OBJECTIVE The purpose of this study was to develop a tool for proficiency testing in cytopathology using multiple digital images of Papanicolaou tests. METHODS Nine images were photographed from each of 10 Papanicolaou tests at x100 optical magnification, 3400 x 2300-pixel resolution, using a light microscope and a digital camera. All images from each case were tiled in a single canvas with Photoshop 4.0 software. Two cytopathologists and 3 cytotechnologists interpreted these "virtual slides" using a computer and graded diagnostic codes (PAP program, College of American Pathologists). Subjects were retested a year later using the glass slides from the same cases and routine microscopy. Both test results, by diagnostic code, were compared with the McNemar test of symmetry. RESULTS The 5 test subjects provided 42 and 50 correct diagnostic codes by "virtual microscopy" and light microscopy, respectively. No significant asymmetry in results obtained by virtual microscopy and light microscopy was encountered with the McNemar test of symmetry. All test answers were correctly classified by selection series, using both virtual microscopy and light microscopy, and the responses would have been graded as 100% by current PAP program scoring guidelines. This suggests that virtual microscopy could be used for proficiency testing purposes. CONCLUSIONS A simple virtual microscopy method designed to challenge participants to locate and diagnose cells of interest was effective for the administration of standardized proficiency tests. Virtual microscopy methods that rely on single-plane images to locate and diagnose cells of interest could provide effective proficiency testing tools prior to the development of more computationally intensive systems that represent an entire Papanicolaou test at multiple focal planes.

[1]  A M Marchevsky,et al.  Virtual microscopy and public-key cryptography for Internet telepathology , 1999, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[2]  Proficiency testing in cytology laboratories in Ontario, Canada: a decade of experience. III. A precision study of consistency and reproducibility in cytology reporting. , 1987, Acta cytologica.

[3]  Regarding the validity of cytology proficiency testing , 2000, Diagnostic cytopathology.

[4]  CLIA program; simplifying CLIA regulations relating to accreditation, exemption of laboratories under a state licensure program, proficiency testing, and inspection--HCFA. Final rule. , 1998, Federal register.

[5]  Cytopathology: new legislative, regulatory, and proficiency testing requirements. , 1989, Maryland medical journal.

[6]  R N Taylor,et al.  CytoView. A prototype computer image-based Papanicolaou smear proficiency test. , 1999, Acta cytologica.

[7]  Quality assurance in cytology: New York State Proficiency Testing Program. , 1989, QRB. Quality review bulletin.

[8]  Quality assurance in cervical cancer screening: results of a proficiency testing scheme for cytology laboratories in the north west Thames region. , 1994, Cytopathology : official journal of the British Society for Clinical Cytology.

[9]  A M Marchevsky,et al.  "Virtual microscopy" and the internet as telepathology consultation tools: diagnostic accuracy in evaluating melanocytic skin lesions. , 1999, The American Journal of dermatopathology.

[10]  Proficiency testing in cytology—does it have any value? , 1995, Diagnostic cytopathology.

[11]  Government mandated cytology proficiency testing: Time for reality testing , 1994, Diagnostic cytopathology.

[12]  The cytology proficiency dilemma: the case for computer-based testing. , 1996, American clinical laboratory.

[13]  Cytology proficiency testing has stumped experts. , 1993, JAMA.

[14]  Gynecologic cytology from the perspective of the Laboratory Proficiency Testing Program, Ontario, Canada. , 1995, Acta cytologica.

[15]  Cytopathology laboratory improvement programs of the College of American Pathologists: Laboratory Accreditation Program (CAP LAP) and Performance Improvement Program in Cervicovaginal Cytology (CAP PAP). , 1997, Archives of pathology & laboratory medicine.

[16]  R P Singson,et al.  Virtual microscopy and the Internet as telepathology consultation tools. A study of gastrointestinal biopsy specimens. , 1999, American journal of clinical pathology.

[17]  Syed Z. Ali,et al.  Application of virtual microscopy in clinical cytopathology , 2001, Diagnostic cytopathology.

[18]  Proficiency testing in cytology laboratories in Ontario, Canada: a decade of experience. II. Results of initial surveys. , 1987, Acta cytologica.

[19]  A M Marchevsky,et al.  Virtual microscopy: high resolution digital photomicrography as a tool for light microscopy simulation. , 1999, Human pathology.

[20]  Proficiency testing in cytology laboratories in Ontario, Canada: a decade of experience. I. Introduction and description of the testing model. , 1987, Acta cytologica.

[21]  Can cytology proficiency testing programs discriminate between competent and incompetent practitioners? , 1991, QRB. Quality review bulletin.

[22]  A. Herbert.  Is proficiency testing in cervical cytology proficient? , 1997, Journal of clinical pathology.

[23]  Proficiency testing in cytology in New York. Analysis of a 14-year state program. , 1986, Acta cytologica.

[24]  Certification, licensing, accreditation, and proficiency testing in cytopathology: Let there be light! , 1998, Diagnostic cytopathology.