Journal of Experimental Psychology : General Breaking the Cycle of Mistrust : Wise Interventions to Provide Critical Feedback Across the Racial Divide

Three double-blind randomized field experiments examined the effects of a strategy to restore trust on minority adolescents' responses to critical feedback. In Studies 1 and 2, 7th-grade students received critical feedback from their teacher that, in the treatment condition, was designed to assuage mistrust by emphasizing the teacher's high standards and belief that the student was capable of meeting those standards--a strategy known as wise feedback. Wise feedback increased students' likelihood of submitting a revision of an essay (Study 1) and improved the quality of their final drafts (Study 2). Effects were generally stronger among African American students than among White students, and particularly strong among African Americans who felt more mistrusting of school. Indeed, among this latter group of students, the 2-year decline in trust evident in the control condition was, in the wise feedback condition, halted. Study 3, undertaken in a low-income public high school, used attributional retraining to teach students to attribute critical feedback in school to their teachers' high standards and belief in their potential. It raised African Americans' grades, reducing the achievement gap. Discussion centers on the roles of trust and recursive social processes in adolescent development.

[1]  Carrie B. Fried,et al.  Reducing the Effects of Stereotype Threat on African American College Students by Shaping Theories of Intelligence , 2002 .

[2]  Stigmatized and Dominant Cultural Groups Differentially Interpret Positive Feedback , 2011 .

[3]  Geoffrey L. Cohen,et al.  Chapter 19. A Social Psychological Approach to Educational Intervention , 2013 .

[4]  K. Dodge.  Translational science in action: Hostile attributional style and the development of aggressive behavior problems , 2006, Development and Psychopathology.

[5]  Joshua Aronson,et al.  Improving adolescents' standardized test performance: An intervention to reduce the effects of stereotype threat , 2003 .

[6]  Geertjan Overbeek,et al.  On feeding those hungry for praise: person praise backfires in children with low self-esteem. , 2014, Journal of experimental psychology. General.

[7]  Glenn I. Roisman,et al.  Developmental cascades: linking academic achievement and externalizing and internalizing symptoms over 20 years. , 2005, Developmental psychology.

[8]  Joshua Aronson.  Improving academic achievement: Impact of psychological factors on education , 2002 .

[9]  J. Mathews.  Escalante: The Best Teacher in America , 1988 .

[10]  McAlister Al.  Social-psychological approaches. , 1983 .

[11]  K. Pribram,et al.  of the feeding , 2013 .

[12]  Lisa S. Blackwell,et al.  Implicit theories of intelligence predict achievement across an adolescent transition: a longitudinal study and an intervention. , 2007, Child development.

[13]  Valerie Purdie-Vaughns,et al.  Recursive Processes in Self-Affirmation: Intervening to Close the Minority Achievement Gap , 2009, Science.

[14]  K. Harber,et al.  The positive feedback bias as a response to self-image threat. , 2010, The British journal of social psychology.

[15]  M. Ruck,et al.  Evaluations of interracial peer encounters by majority and minority US children and adolescents , 2007, International journal of behavioral development.

[16]  C. Dweck,et al.  Praise for intelligence can undermine children's motivation and performance. , 1998, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[17]  C. Heath,et al.  Made to Stick: Why Some Ideas Survive and Others Die , 2007 .

[18]  Jerome S. Bruner,et al.  Going Beyond the Information Given , 2006 .

[19]  E. Langer,et al.  The Mindlessness of Ostensibly Thoughtful Action: The Role of "Placebic" Information in Interpersonal Interaction , 1978 .

[20]  J. Bachman,et al.  Racial, Ethnic, and Gender Differences in School Discipline among U.S. High School Students: 1991-2005. , 2008, The Negro educational review.

[21]  Glynis M. Breakwell,et al.  The Social Psychological Approach , 1982 .

[22]  U. Bronfenbrenner.  The Ecology of Human Development: Experiments by Nature and , 1979 .

[23]  Brian F. Bowdle,et al.  Insult, aggression, and the southern culture of honor: an "experimental ethnography". , 1996, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[24]  M. Shanahan,et al.  The Life Course and Human Development. , 2007 .

[25]  Uri Treisman.  Studying Students Studying Calculus: A Look at the Lives of Minority Mathematics Students in College. , 1992 .

[26]  U. Bronfenbrenner.  Toward an Experimental Ecology of Human Development. , 1977 .

[27]  R. Weinstein,et al.  The development and consequences of stereotype consciousness in middle childhood. , 2003, Child development.

[28]  G. King,et al.  Analyzing Incomplete Political Science Data: An Alternative Algorithm for Multiple Imputation , 2001, American Political Science Review.

[29]  P. Black,et al.  Assessment and Classroom Learning , 1998 .

[30]  Geoffrey L. Cohen,et al.  A question of belonging: race, social fit, and achievement. , 2007, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[31]  J. C. Smart,et al.  Higher Education: Handbook of Theory and Research , 2001, Higher Education: Handbook of Theory and Research.

[32]  S. Smith.  Race and Trust , 2010 .

[33]  Tim Schmitz,et al.  Contrast Analysis Focused Comparisons In The Analysis Of Variance , 2016 .

[34]  J. Ioannidis,et al.  An exploratory test for an excess of significant findings , 2007, Clinical trials.

[35]  K. Lewin,et al.  Group decision and social change. , 1999 .

[36]  M. Biernat,et al.  Shifting standards and stereotype-based judgments. , 1994, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[37]  Jerome S. Bruner,et al.  Contemporary approaches to cognition , 1958 .

[38]  Anthony S. Bryk,et al.  Finding a Measure of Trust@@@Trust in Schools: A Core Resource for Improvement , 2004 .

[39]  Kristin E. Voelkl,et al.  Social Stigma: The Affective Consequences of Attributional Ambiguity , 1991 .

[40]  G. Elder,et al.  The Craft of Life Course Research , 2009 .

[41]  D. Firth.  Bias reduction of maximum likelihood estimates , 1993 .

[42]  K. Harber,et al.  Students' race and teachers' social support affect the positive feedback bias in public schools , 2012 .

[43]  J. Coopersmith.  Characteristics of Public, Private, and Bureau of Indian Education Elementary and Secondary School Teachers in the United States: Results From the 2007-08 Schools and Staffing Survey. First Look. NCES 2009-324. , 2009 .

[44]  Jere Brophy,et al.  Teacher Praise: A Functional Analysis , 1981 .

[45]  Timothy D. Wilson,et al.  Improving the academic performance of college freshmen: Attribution therapy revisited. , 1982 .

[46]  A. Kluger,et al.  The effects of feedback interventions on performance: A historical review, a meta-analysis, and a preliminary feedback intervention theory. , 1996 .

[47]  I. Sigel,et al.  HANDBOOK OF CHILD PSYCHOLOGY , 2006 .

[48]  Georg Heinze,et al.  A comparative investigation of methods for logistic regression with separated or nearly separated data , 2006, Statistics in medicine.

[49]  C. Dweck,et al.  A Blueprint for Social Cognitive Development , 2008, Perspectives on psychological science : a journal of the Association for Psychological Science.

[50]  Valerie Purdie-Vaughns,et al.  Deflecting the trajectory and changing the narrative: how self-affirmation affects academic performance and motivation under identity threat. , 2013, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[51]  R. Cialdini.  CURRENT DIRECTIONS IN PSYCHOLOGICAL SCIENCE Crafting Normative Messages to Protect the Environment , 2022 .

[52]  E. Aronson.  The Jigsaw Classroom , 1978 .

[53]  Jen D. Wong,et al.  Life transitions and daily stress processes. , 2009 .

[54]  K. Harber.  Feedback to minorities: evidence of a positive bias. , 1998, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[55]  Gregory M. Walton,et al.  A Brief Social-Belonging Intervention Improves Academic and Health Outcomes of Minority Students , 2011, Science.

[56]  E. E. Maccoby.  The Uniqueness of the Parent-Child Relationship , 1999 .

[57]  K. Dodge,et al.  Testing an idealized dynamic cascade model of the development of serious violence in adolescence. , 2008, Child development.

[58]  U. Schimmack.  The ironic effect of significant results on the credibility of multiple-study articles. , 2012, Psychological methods.

[59]  Claude M. Steele,et al.  A Barrier of Mistrust: How Negative Stereotypes Affect Cross-Race Mentoring , 2002 .

[60]  T. Newcomb,et al.  Readings in Social Psychology , 1948, Teachers College Record.

[61]  M. Smith.  Field Theory in Social Science: Selected Theoretical Papers. , 1951 .

[62]  A. Benner,et al.  The Transition to High School: Current Knowledge, Future Directions , 2011, Educational psychology review.

[63]  J. Crocker,et al.  Social stigma and self-esteem: The self-protective properties of stigma. , 1989 .

[64]  H. Reis,et al.  The relationship context of human behavior and development. , 2000, Psychological bulletin.

[65]  Timothy D. Wilson,et al.  Improving the academic performance of college students with brief attributional interventions. , 2002 .

[66]  J. Dovidio,et al.  Aversive Racism and Selection Decisions: 1989 and 1999 , 2000, Psychological science.

[67]  D. Collard,et al.  Trust : making and breaking cooperative relations , 1989 .

[68]  K. Lewin,et al.  Defining the 'field at a given time' , 2011 .

[69]  Claude M. Steele,et al.  The Mentor’s Dilemma: Providing Critical Feedback Across the Racial Divide , 1999 .

[70]  K. Harber.  The Positive Feedback Bias as a Response to Out‐Group Unfriendliness1 , 2004 .

[71]  S. Spencer,et al.  Contending with group image: The psychology of stereotype and social identity threat , 2002 .

[72]  Larry Ambrose,et al.  The power of feedback. , 2002, Healthcare executive.

[73]  E. Uslaner.  The Moral Foundations of Trust , 2002 .

[74]  E. Goffman.  Stigma; Notes On The Management Of Spoiled Identity , 1964 .

[75]  Roger C. Shouse,et al.  Academic press and sense of community: Conflict, congruence, and implications for student achievement , 1996 .

[76]  G. Downey,et al.  Group-Value Ambiguity , 2010 .

[77]  K. Lewin,et al.  Field Theory in Social Science: Selected Theoretical Papers , 1951 .

[78]  G. S. Pettit,et al.  Domain specificity in relationship history, social-information processing, and violent behavior in early adulthood. , 2010, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[79]  T. Schmader,et al.  The feedback withholding bias: Minority students do not receive critical feedback from evaluators concerned about appearing racist , 2012 .

[80]  R. Perry,et al.  A Review of Attributional Retraining Treatments: Fostering Engagement and Persistence in Vulnerable College Students , 2009 .

[81]  Richard M. Lerner,et al.  Theoretical models of human development , 2006 .

[82]  A. Bryk,et al.  Catholic Schools and the Common Good , 1993 .

[83]  W. Hartup,et al.  Relationships as developmental contexts , 1999 .

[84]  Selcuk R. Sirin.  Socioeconomic Status and Academic Achievement: A Meta-Analytic Review of Research , 2005 .

[85]  J. Mathews.  Work hard. Be nice. : how two inspired teachers created the most promising schools in America , 2009 .

[86]  Diego Gambetta.  Can We Trust Trust , 2000 .

[87]  Sheri R. Levy,et al.  Consequences of learning about historical racism among European American and African American children. , 2007, Child development.

[88]  S. Dornbusch,et al.  Racism without Racists: Institutional Racism in Urban Schools , 1975 .

[89]  M. Banaji,et al.  Implicit social cognition: attitudes, self-esteem, and stereotypes. , 1995, Psychological review.

[90]  R. Butler.  ENHANCING AND UNDERMINING INTRINSIC MOTIVATION: THE EFFECTS OF TASK‐INVOLVING AND EGO‐INVOLVING EVALUATION ON INTEREST AND PERFORMANCE , 1988 .

[91]  G. Kochanska.  Multiple pathways to conscience for children with different temperaments: from toddlerhood to age 5. , 1997, Developmental psychology.

[92]  R. Bigler,et al.  Children's perceptions of discrimination: a developmental model. , 2005, Child development.