Screening for new pharmaceutical solid forms using mechanochemistry: A practical guide☆

Abstract Within the pharmaceutical industry, and elsewhere, the screening for new solid forms is a mandatory exercise for both existing and new chemical entities. This contribution focuses on mechanochemistry as a versatile approach for discovering new and alternative solid forms. Whilst a series of recently published extensive reviews exist which focus on mechanistic aspects and potential areas of development, in this review we focus on particular practical aspects of mechanochemistry in order to allow full optimisation of the approach in searches for new solid forms including polymorphs, salts and cocrystals as well as their solvated/hydrated analogues. As a consequence of the apparent experimental simplicity of the method (compared to more traditional protocols e.g. solvent‐based methods), the high efficiency and range of conditions available in a mechanochemical screen, mechanochemistry should not be considered simply as an alternative method when other screening methods are not successful, but rather as a key strategy in any fully effective solid form screen providing reduced effort and time as well as the potential of requiring reduced amounts of material. Graphical abstract Figure. No Caption available.

[1]  Geoff G. Z. Zhang,et al.  The curious case of (caffeine)·(benzoic acid): how heteronuclear seeding allowed the formation of an elusive cocrystal , 2013 .

[2]  Katsuhiko Yamamoto,et al.  High-throughput cocrystal slurry screening by use of in situ Raman microscopy and multi-well plate. , 2010, International journal of pharmaceutics.

[3]  L. Takács The historical development of mechanochemistry. , 2013, Chemical Society reviews.

[4]  Athanassios D. Katsenis,et al.  In Situ Monitoring and Mechanism of the Mechanochemical Formation of a Microporous MOF-74 Framework. , 2016, Journal of the American Chemical Society.

[5]  B. Bogdanovic,et al.  One-step direct synthesis of a Ti-doped sodium alanate hydrogen storage material. , 2005, Chemical communications.

[6]  K. Higashi,et al.  Formation mechanism of a new carbamazepine/malonic acid cocrystal polymorph. , 2012, International journal of pharmaceutics.

[7]  Graeme M. Day,et al.  Current approaches to predicting molecular organic crystal structures , 2011 .

[8]  T. Shakhtshneider Phase transformations and stabilization of metastable states of molecular crystals under mechanical activation , 1997 .

[9]  J. Dunitz Are crystal structures predictable? , 2003, Chemical communications.

[10]  William Jones,et al.  Recent Advances in Understanding the Mechanism of Cocrystal Formation via Grinding , 2009 .

[11]  K. Terada,et al.  Stability order of caffeine co-crystals determined by co-crystal former exchange reaction and its application for the validation of in silico models. , 2015, Chemical and pharmaceutical bulletin.

[12]  Athanassios D. Katsenis,et al.  In situ X-ray diffraction monitoring of a mechanochemical reaction reveals a unique topology metal-organic framework , 2015, Nature Communications.

[13]  Tomislav Friščić,et al.  Exploring the Effect of Temperature on a Mechanochemical Reaction by in Situ Synchrotron Powder X-ray Diffraction , 2016 .

[14]  I. Paul,et al.  Solid-state formation of quinhydrones from their components: use of solid-solid reactions to prepare compounds not accessible from solution , 1984 .

[15]  W. Jones,et al.  Mechanochemistry and co-crystal formation: effect of solvent on reaction kinetics. , 2002, Chemical communications.

[16]  M. Neuburger,et al.  Piracetam Co-Crystals with OH-Group Functionalized Carboxylic Acids , 2009 .

[17]  F. Emmerling,et al.  Survival of the Fittest: Competitive Co-crystal Reactions in the Ball Mill. , 2015, Chemistry.

[18]  V. Boldyrev Control of the Reactivity of Solids , 1979 .

[19]  J. Maddox Crystals from first principles , 1988, Nature.

[20]  T. Friščić,et al.  Screening for pharmaceutical cocrystal hydrates via neat and liquid-assisted grinding. , 2007, Molecular pharmaceutics.

[21]  Tomislav Friščić,et al.  Real-time and in situ monitoring of mechanochemical milling reactions. , 2013, Nature chemistry.

[22]  Yang Lu,et al.  Polymorphs and Versatile Solvates of 7-Hydroxyisoflavone. , 2016, Journal of pharmaceutical sciences.

[23]  M. Zaworotko,et al.  Pharmaceutical cocrystals: along the path to improved medicines. , 2016, Chemical communications.

[24]  J. Bauer,et al.  Ritonavir: An Extraordinary Example of Conformational Polymorphism , 2001, Pharmaceutical Research.

[25]  B. Kaitner,et al.  Solvent-Free Polymorphism Control in a Covalent Mechanochemical Reaction , 2012 .

[26]  A. Newman Specialized Solid Form Screening Techniques , 2013 .

[27]  Sarah L Price,et al.  Predicting crystal structures of organic compounds. , 2014, Chemical Society reviews.

[28]  Peter York,et al.  Ultrasound assisted cocrystallization from solution (USSC) containing a non-congruently soluble cocrystal component pair: Caffeine/maleic acid. , 2010, European journal of pharmaceutical sciences : official journal of the European Federation for Pharmaceutical Sciences.

[29]  L. Takács The mechanochemical reduction of AgCl with metals , 2007 .

[30]  R. Gobetto,et al.  Mechanically Induced Phase Change in Barbituric Acid , 2008 .

[31]  E. Boldyreva High pressure and supramolecular systems , 2004 .

[32]  Yun Hu,et al.  Mechanochemical Reaction of Sulfathiazole with Carboxylic Acids: Formation of a Cocrystal, a Salt, and Coamorphous Solids , 2014 .

[33]  K. Be̅rziņš,et al.  Solvates of Dasatinib: Diversity and Isostructurality. , 2016, Journal of pharmaceutical sciences.

[34]  L. Takács M. Carey Lea, the first mechanochemist , 2004 .

[35]  Paul J. A. Kenis,et al.  Microfluidic approach to polymorph screening through antisolvent crystallization , 2012 .

[36]  Woo-Sik Kim,et al.  Application of Ionic Liquid to Polymorphic Design of Pharmaceutical Ingredients , 2010 .

[37]  Sarah L Price,et al.  Can the Formation of Pharmaceutical Cocrystals Be Computationally Predicted? 2. Crystal Structure Prediction. , 2009, Journal of chemical theory and computation.

[38]  M. Eddleston,et al.  Introductory lecture: Mechanochemistry, a versatile synthesis strategy for new materials. , 2014, Faraday discussions.

[39]  T. Friščić,et al.  Control and interconversion of cocrystal stoichiometry in grinding: stepwise mechanism for the formation of a hydrogen-bonded cocrystal , 2009 .

[40]  Sarah L Price,et al.  Challenges of crystal structure prediction of diastereomeric salt pairs. , 2005, The journal of physical chemistry. B.

[41]  M. Descamps,et al.  Perspectives on the amorphisation/milling relationship in pharmaceutical materials. , 2016, Advanced drug delivery reviews.

[42]  N Kaneniwa,et al.  Effect of seed crystals on solid-state transformation of polymorphs of chloramphenicol palmitate during grinding. , 1986, Journal of pharmaceutical sciences.

[43]  E. Boldyreva,et al.  The role of a liquid in “dry” co-grinding: a case study of the effect of water on mechanochemical synthesis in a “L-serine–oxalic acid” system , 2014 .

[44]  Jennifer L. Knight,et al.  On the mechanism of crystalline polymorph selection by polymer heteronuclei. , 2011, Langmuir : the ACS journal of surfaces and colloids.

[45]  G. G. Stokes "J." , 1890, The New Yale Book of Quotations.

[46]  Jukka Rantanen,et al.  Solid form screening--a review. , 2009, European journal of pharmaceutics and biopharmaceutics : official journal of Arbeitsgemeinschaft fur Pharmazeutische Verfahrenstechnik e.V.

[47]  E. Boldyreva,et al.  How good are the crystallisation methods for co-crystals? A comparative study of piroxicam , 2012 .

[48]  S. Price The computational prediction of pharmaceutical crystal structures and polymorphism. , 2004, Advanced drug delivery reviews.

[49]  T. Friščić,et al.  Guest-Directed Assembly of Caffeine and Succinic Acid into Topologically Different Heteromolecular Host Networks upon Grinding , 2008 .

[50]  Guan-Wu Wang,et al.  Mechanochemical organic synthesis. , 2013, Chemical Society reviews.

[51]  T. Rades,et al.  Formation Kinetics and Stability of Carbamazepine―Nicotinamide Cocrystals Prepared by Mechanical Activation , 2009 .

[52]  B. Perissutti,et al.  Mechanochemical activation of vincamine mediated by linear polymers: assessment of some "critical" steps. , 2013, European journal of pharmaceutical sciences : official journal of the European Federation for Pharmaceutical Sciences.

[53]  E. Franceschinis,et al.  Multidisciplinary approach on characterizing a mechanochemically activated composite of vinpocetine and crospovidone. , 2011, Journal of pharmaceutical sciences.

[54]  M. Eddleston,et al.  Screening for polymorphs of cocrystals: a case study , 2013 .

[55]  Ferdi Schüth,et al.  One-step direct synthesis of a Ti-doped sodium alanate hydrogen storage material. , 2005, Chemical communications.

[56]  Y. Ikeda,et al.  Establishment of cocrystal cocktail grinding method for rational screening of pharmaceutical cocrystals. , 2012, International journal of pharmaceutics.

[57]  J. Gougoutas,et al.  Solid state chemistry of organic polyvalent iodine compounds. II. The crystal structure of 2-iodo-3′-chlorodibenzoyl peroxide , 1973 .

[58]  G. Coquerel,et al.  Inhibition of the spontaneous polymorphic transition of pyrazinamide γ form at room temperature by co-spray drying with 1,3-dimethylurea. , 2015, International journal of pharmaceutics.

[59]  V. Boldyrev,et al.  Following the products of mechanochemical synthesis step by step , 2011 .

[60]  D. Braga,et al.  Mechanochemical preparation of co-crystals. , 2013, Chemical Society reviews.

[61]  Elena Boldyreva,et al.  Mechanochemistry of inorganic and organic systems: what is similar, what is different? , 2013, Chemical Society reviews.

[62]  M. Eddleston,et al.  Polymorphs, hydrates and solvates of a co-crystal of caffeine with anthranilic acid. , 2014, Acta crystallographica Section B, Structural science, crystal engineering and materials.

[63]  F. Emmerling,et al.  Direct in situ investigation of milling reactions using combined X-ray diffraction and Raman spectroscopy. , 2015, Angewandte Chemie.

[64]  James Mack,et al.  Mechanochemistry: opportunities for new and cleaner synthesis. , 2012, Chemical Society reviews.

[65]  W. Jones,et al.  Mechanochemical Synthesis of Multicomponent Crystals: One Liquid for One Polymorph? A Myth to Dispel , 2016 .

[66]  S. Price,et al.  A new polymorph of 5-fluorouracil found following computational crystal structure predictions. , 2005, Journal of the American Chemical Society.

[67]  A. Matzger,et al.  The use of polymer heteronuclei for crystalline polymorph selection. , 2002, Journal of the American Chemical Society.

[68]  S. Bates,et al.  Analysis of Amorphous and Nanocrystalline Solids from Their X-Ray Diffraction Patterns , 2006, Pharmaceutical Research.

[69]  B. Perissutti,et al.  Drug salt formation via mechanochemistry: the case study of vincamine. , 2013, Molecular pharmaceutics.

[70]  William Jones,et al.  Achieving Polymorphic and Stoichiometric Diversity in Cocrystal Formation: Importance of Solid-State Grinding, Powder X-ray Structure Determination, and Seeding , 2005 .

[71]  T. Friščić,et al.  Ion- and liquid-assisted grinding: improved mechanochemical synthesis of metal-organic frameworks reveals salt inclusion and anion templating. , 2010, Angewandte Chemie.

[72]  R. Tan,et al.  Thermal and in situ x-ray diffraction analysis of a dimorphic co-crystal 1:1 caffeine-glutaric acid , 2016 .

[73]  I. Halasz,et al.  Mechanochemical reactions studied by in situ Raman spectroscopy: base catalysis in liquid-assisted grinding. , 2015, Chemical communications.

[74]  E. Boldyreva,et al.  Complexities of mechanochemistry: elucidation of processes occurring in mechanical activators via implementation of a simple organic system , 2013 .

[75]  G. Day,et al.  Terahertz time-domain spectroscopy and the quantitative monitoring of mechanochemical cocrystal formation. , 2007, Nature Materials.

[76]  F. Emmerling,et al.  Supply and Demand in the Ball Mill: Competitive Cocrystal Reactions , 2016 .

[77]  R. Tan,et al.  Operating Regions in Cooling Cocrystallization of Caffeine and Glutaric Acid in Acetonitrile , 2010 .

[78]  H. Tung,et al.  Industrial Perspectives of Pharmaceutical Crystallization , 2013 .

[79]  L. Schultz,et al.  In situ pressure and temperature monitoring during the conversion of Mg into MgH2 by high-pressure reactive ball milling , 2007 .

[80]  A. Kwade,et al.  Process engineering with planetary ball mills. , 2013, Chemical Society reviews.

[81]  G. Day,et al.  Structure prediction, disorder and dynamics in a DMSO solvate of carbamazepine. , 2011, Physical chemistry chemical physics : PCCP.

[82]  V. Caron,et al.  Transformation of pharmaceutical compounds upon milling and comilling: the role of T(g). , 2007, Journal of pharmaceutical sciences.

[83]  A. Al-Azzawi,et al.  Mechanical Alloying and Milling , 2015 .

[84]  S. Myz,et al.  Different effect of impact and shear mechanical treatment on mechanochemical cocrystallization of piroxicam and succinic acid , 2014, Doklady Chemistry.

[85]  Adam J. Matzger,et al.  Towards Exhaustive and Automated High-Throughput Screening for Crystalline Polymorphs , 2014, ACS combinatorial science.

[86]  J. Siepmann,et al.  Preparation of polymeric fenofibrate formulations with accelerated drug release: Solvent evaporation versus co-grinding , 2015 .

[87]  N. Rodríguez-Hornedo,et al.  Crystallization pathways and kinetics of carbamazepine-nicotinamide cocrystals from the amorphous state by in situ thermomicroscopy, spectroscopy, and calorimetry studies. , 2007, Journal of pharmaceutical sciences.

[88]  I. Colombo,et al.  Drug mechanochemical activation. , 2009, Journal of pharmaceutical sciences.

[89]  M. Senna,et al.  Hallmarks of mechanochemistry: from nanoparticles to technology. , 2013, Chemical Society reviews.

[90]  S. R. Bysouth,et al.  Cocrystallization via planetary milling: enhancing throughput of solid-state screening methods. , 2011, International journal of pharmaceutics.

[91]  Naír Rodríguez-Hornedo,et al.  Cocrystal Formation during Cogrinding and Storage is Mediated by Amorphous Phase , 2006, Pharmaceutical Research.

[92]  V. Stilinović,et al.  Controlling Solvate Formation of a Schiff Base by Combining Mechano-chemistry with Solution Synthesis , 2012 .

[93]  M. Descamps,et al.  Solid State Amorphization of Pharmaceuticals , 2009 .

[94]  Steven A. Ross,et al.  Engineering and manufacturing of pharmaceutical co-crystals: a review of solvent-free manufacturing technologies. , 2016, Chemical communications.

[95]  Davin Tan,et al.  Towards medicinal mechanochemistry: evolution of milling from pharmaceutical solid form screening to the synthesis of active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs). , 2016, Chemical communications.

[96]  T. Friščić,et al.  The role of mechanochemistry and supramolecular design in the development of pharmaceutical materials , 2012 .

[97]  D. Voinovich,et al.  Cocrystal Formation through Mechanochemistry: from Neat and Liquid-Assisted Grinding to Polymer-Assisted Grinding. , 2015, Angewandte Chemie.

[98]  A. Ogienko,et al.  ‘Hedvall effect’ in cryogrinding of molecular crystals. A case study of a polymorphic transition in chlorpropamide , 2011 .

[99]  Julie M. Schoenung,et al.  Technical Cost Modeling for the Mechanical Milling at Cryogenic Temperature (Cryomilling) , 2004 .

[100]  William Jones,et al.  Solvent-drop grinding: green polymorph control of cocrystallisation. , 2004, Chemical communications.

[101]  F. Emmerling,et al.  Polymorphism of Mechanochemically Synthesized Cocrystals: A Case Study , 2016 .

[102]  J. Anwar,et al.  Secondary Crystal Nucleation: Nuclei Breeding Factory Uncovered. , 2015, Angewandte Chemie.

[103]  W. Jones,et al.  Polymer-Assisted Grinding, a Versatile Method for Polymorph Control of Cocrystallization , 2016 .

[104]  Michael J Cima,et al.  High-throughput crystallization: polymorphs, salts, co-crystals and solvates of pharmaceutical solids. , 2004, Advanced drug delivery reviews.

[105]  Geoff G. Z. Zhang,et al.  Phase transformation considerations during process development and manufacture of solid oral dosage forms. , 2004, Advanced drug delivery reviews.

[106]  J. Rimer,et al.  A high‐throughput assay for screening modifiers of calcium oxalate crystallization , 2016 .

[107]  B. Kaitner,et al.  Polymorphism control in the mechanochemical and solution-based synthesis of a thermochromic Schiff base , 2015 .

[108]  Pól Macfhionnghaile,et al.  Effects of ball-milling and cryomilling on sulfamerazine polymorphs: a quantitative study. , 2014, Journal of pharmaceutical sciences.

[109]  Ana M. Belenguer,et al.  Real-time in situ powder X-ray diffraction monitoring of mechanochemical synthesis of pharmaceutical cocrystals. , 2013, Angewandte Chemie.

[110]  S. Childs,et al.  The role of solvent in mechanochemical and sonochemical cocrystal formation: a solubility-based approach for predicting cocrystallisation outcome , 2009 .

[111]  William Jones,et al.  Selective polymorph transformation via solvent-drop grinding. , 2005, Chemical communications.

[112]  Beatrice Perissutti,et al.  Enhanced Oral Bioavailability of Vinpocetine Through Mechanochemical Salt Formation: Physico-Chemical Characterization and In Vivo Studies , 2011, Pharmaceutical Research.

[113]  Henrique A. Matos,et al.  Screening for pharmaceutical cocrystals using the supercritical fluid enhanced atomization process , 2010 .

[114]  R. Pinal,et al.  The nature of crystal disorder in milled pharmaceutical materials , 2008 .

[115]  Wolfgang Beckmann,et al.  Seeding the Desired Polymorph: Background, Possibilities, Limitations, and Case Studies , 2000 .

[116]  Tejender S. Thakur,et al.  Polymorphs, Pseudopolymorphs, and Co-Crystals of Orcinol: Exploring the Structural Landscape with High Throughput Crystallography , 2011 .

[117]  Jean Martínez,et al.  Poly(ethylene) glycols and mechanochemistry for the preparation of bioactive 3,5-disubstituted hydantoins , 2016 .

[118]  A. Navrotsky Nanoscale effects on thermodynamics and phase equilibria in oxide systems. , 2011, Chemphyschem : a European journal of chemical physics and physical chemistry.

[119]  M. Caira,et al.  Selective formation of hydrogen bonded cocrystals between a sulfonamide and aromatic carboxylic acids in the solid state , 1995 .

[120]  Masako Kato,et al.  Control of differential inclusion complexation in the solid state by seed crystals. , 2005, Angewandte Chemie.

[121]  G. Zografi,et al.  Cryogenic grinding of indomethacin polymorphs and solvates: assessment of amorphous phase formation and amorphous phase physical stability. , 2002, Journal of pharmaceutical sciences.

[122]  F. Leusen,et al.  Coformer Replacement as an Indicator for Thermodynamic Instability of Cocrystals: Competitive Transformation of Caffeine:Dicarboxylic Acid , 2016 .