The Causes of Errors in Clinical Reasoning: Cognitive Biases, Knowledge Deficits, and Dual Process Thinking

Contemporary theories of clinical reasoning espouse a dual processing model, which consists of a rapid, intuitive component (Type 1) and a slower, logical and analytical component (Type 2). Although the general consensus is that this dual processing model is a valid representation of clinical reasoning, the causes of diagnostic errors remain unclear. Cognitive theories about human memory propose that such errors may arise from both Type 1 and Type 2 reasoning. Errors in Type 1 reasoning may be a consequence of the associative nature of memory, which can lead to cognitive biases. However, the literature indicates that, with increasing expertise (and knowledge), the likelihood of errors decreases. Errors in Type 2 reasoning may result from the limited capacity of working memory, which constrains computational processes. In this article, the authors review the medical literature to answer two substantial questions that arise from this work: (1) To what extent do diagnostic errors originate in Type 1 (intuitive) processes versus in Type 2 (analytical) processes? (2) To what extent are errors a consequence of cognitive biases versus a consequence of knowledge deficits? The literature suggests that both Type 1 and Type 2 processes contribute to errors. Although it is possible to experimentally induce cognitive biases, particularly availability bias, the extent to which these biases actually contribute to diagnostic errors is not well established. Educational strategies directed at the recognition of biases are ineffective in reducing errors; conversely, strategies focused on the reorganization of knowledge to reduce errors have small but consistent benefits.

[1]  Gavin C. Barr,et al.  Using Simulation to Instruct Emergency Medicine Residents in Cognitive Forcing Strategies , 2004, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[2]  B. Charlin,et al.  How and when do expert emergency physicians generate and evaluate diagnostic hypotheses? A qualitative study using head-mounted video cued-recall interviews. , 2014, Annals of emergency medicine.

[3]  Tamara van Gog,et al.  Exploring the role of salient distracting clinical features in the emergence of diagnostic errors and the mechanisms through which reflection counteracts mistakes , 2012, BMJ quality & safety.

[4]  R. Mayer Applying the science of learning to medical education , 2010, Medical education.

[5]  Geoffrey Norman,et al.  Diagnostic Reasoning: Where We've Been, Where We’re Going , 2013, Teaching and learning in medicine.

[6]  David L. Post,et al.  Medical Problem Solving: An Analysis of Clinical Reasoning , 1979 .

[7]  D. Kahneman,et al.  Representativeness revisited: Attribute substitution in intuitive judgment. , 2002 .

[8]  Karla K. Evans,et al.  The gist of the abnormal: Above-chance medical decision making in the blink of an eye , 2013, Psychonomic Bulletin & Review.

[9]  K. McLaughlin,et al.  To Think Is Good: Querying an Initial Hypothesis Reduces Diagnostic Error in Medical Students , 2010, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[10]  A S Elstein,et al.  Heuristics and biases: selected errors in clinical reasoning. , 1999, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[11]  Henk G. Schmidt,et al.  Conscious thought beats deliberation without attention in diagnostic decision-making: at least when you are an expert , 2010, Psychological research.

[12]  L. Brooks,et al.  Role of specific similarity in a medical diagnostic task. , 1991, Journal of experimental psychology. General.

[13]  Silvia Mamede,et al.  The structure of reflective practice in medicine , 2004, Medical education.

[14]  Jonathan Evans,et al.  Science Perspectives on Psychological , 2022 .

[15]  G. Norman,et al.  Is bias in the eye of the beholder? A vignette study to assess recognition of cognitive biases in clinical case workups , 2016, BMJ Quality & Safety.

[16]  Jennifer S Myers,et al.  Seen Through Their Eyes: Residents’ Reflections on the Cognitive and Contextual Components of Diagnostic Errors in Medicine , 2012, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[17]  V R Neufeld,et al.  The clinical reasoning of randomly selected physicians in general medical practice. , 1982, Clinical and investigative medicine. Medecine clinique et experimentale.

[18]  Jonathan Evans The heuristic-analytic theory of reasoning: Extension and evaluation , 2006, Psychonomic bulletin & review.

[19]  N. Franklin,et al.  Diagnostic error in internal medicine. , 2005, Archives of internal medicine.

[20]  Timothy M. Franz,et al.  Enhancement of clinicians' diagnostic reasoning by computer-based consultation: a multisite study of 2 systems. , 1999, JAMA.

[21]  G. Norman,et al.  The Effectiveness of Cognitive Forcing Strategies to Decrease Diagnostic Error: An Exploratory Study , 2011, Teaching and learning in medicine.

[22]  Y. Tokuda,et al.  Effects of the use of differential diagnosis checklist and general de-biasing checklist on diagnostic performance in comparison to intuitive diagnosis , 2013, Medical teacher.

[23]  Walter Schneider,et al.  Controlled and automatic human information processing: II. Perceptual learning, automatic attending and a general theory. , 1977 .

[24]  J. Sherbino,et al.  Reflecting on Diagnostic Errors: Taking a Second Look is Not Enough , 2015, Journal of General Internal Medicine.

[25]  L. Brooks,et al.  The development of expertise in dermatology. , 1989, Archives of dermatology.

[26]  Jonathan Sherbino,et al.  Ineffectiveness of cognitive forcing strategies to reduce biases in diagnostic reasoning: a controlled trial. , 2014, CJEM.

[27]  Jonathan Evans Dual-processing accounts of reasoning, judgment, and social cognition. , 2008, Annual review of psychology.

[28]  J S Blumenthal-Barby,et al.  Cognitive Biases and Heuristics in Medical Decision Making , 2015, Medical decision making : an international journal of the Society for Medical Decision Making.

[29]  Brent W. Smith,et al.  The effect of cognitive debiasing training among family medicine residents , 2015, Diagnosis.

[30]  S W Allen,et al.  Effect of prior examples on rule-based diagnostic performance. , 1988, Research in medical education : proceedings of the ... annual Conference. Conference on Research in Medical Education.

[31]  Michele Groves,et al.  Clinical reasoning: the relative contribution of identification, interpretation and hypothesis errors to misdiagnosis , 2003, Medical teacher.

[32]  Nancy F. Lenfestey,et al.  Cognitive interventions to reduce diagnostic error: a narrative review , 2012, BMJ quality & safety.

[33]  Geoff Norman,et al.  Dual processing and diagnostic errors , 2009, Advances in health sciences education : theory and practice.

[34]  J. Norcini,et al.  Certifying examination performance and patient outcomes following acute myocardial infarction , 2002, Medical education.

[35]  S. Sloman The empirical case for two systems of reasoning. , 1996 .

[36]  D A Redelmeier,et al.  Problems for clinical judgement: introducing cognitive psychology as one more basic science. , 2001, CMAJ : Canadian Medical Association journal = journal de l'Association medicale canadienne.

[37]  S. Mamede,et al.  Effects of reflective practice on the accuracy of medical diagnoses , 2008, Medical education.

[38]  Arthur S Elstein,et al.  Thinking about diagnostic thinking: a 30-year perspective , 2009, Advances in health sciences education : theory and practice.

[39]  R. Rikers,et al.  Age-related decline and diagnostic performance of more and less prevalent clinical cases , 2016, Advances in health sciences education : theory and practice.

[40]  Lola L. Lopes The Rhetoric of Irrationality , 1991 .

[41]  Gurpreet Dhaliwal,et al.  Premature closure? Not so fast , 2016, BMJ Quality & Safety.

[42]  Adam Wierman,et al.  Thinking Fast and Slow , 2017, SIGMETRICS Perform. Evaluation Rev..

[43]  Jonathan Sherbino,et al.  The Etiology of Diagnostic Errors: A Controlled Trial of System 1 Versus System 2 Reasoning , 2014, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[44]  E. Weber,et al.  Determinants of diagnostic hypothesis generation: effects of information, base rates, and experience. , 1993, Journal of experimental psychology. Learning, memory, and cognition.

[45]  A. Elstein,et al.  Pervasiveness of framing effects among physicians and medical students , 1995 .

[46]  Tamara van Gog,et al.  Effect of availability bias and reflective reasoning on diagnostic accuracy among internal medicine residents. , 2010, JAMA.

[47]  K. Eva,et al.  Adjusting our lens: can developmental differences in diagnostic reasoning be harnessed to improve health professional and trainee assessment? , 2011, Academic emergency medicine : official journal of the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine.

[48]  Geoffrey R. Norman,et al.  Impact of a clinical scenario on accuracy of electrocardiogram interpretation , 1999, Journal of General Internal Medicine.

[49]  Pat Croskerry,et al.  A universal model of diagnostic reasoning. , 2009, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[50]  P. Croskerry The Importance of Cognitive Errors in Diagnosis and Strategies to Minimize Them , 2003, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[51]  R. Rikers,et al.  Experienced physicians benefit from analyzing initial diagnostic hypotheses , 2013, Canadian medical education journal.

[52]  D. Gaba,et al.  Decision-Making and Cognitive Strategies , 2015, Simulation in healthcare : journal of the Society for Simulation in Healthcare.

[53]  Pat Croskerry,et al.  Clinical cognition and diagnostic error: applications of a dual process model of reasoning , 2009, Advances in health sciences education : theory and practice.

[54]  Timothy J. Wood,et al.  The Relationship Between Response Time and Diagnostic Accuracy , 2012, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[55]  S. Mamede,et al.  Cognitive debiasing 1: origins of bias and theory of debiasing , 2013, BMJ quality & safety.

[56]  J. Klein,et al.  Five pitfalls in decisions about diagnosis and prescribing , 2005, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[57]  Edmund A Franken,et al.  Satisfaction of search from detection of pulmonary nodules in computed tomography of the chest. , 2013, Academic radiology.

[58]  Cordula Wagner,et al.  Relating Faults in Diagnostic Reasoning With Diagnostic Errors and Patient Harm , 2012, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[59]  Kevin W Eva,et al.  Comparing Diagnostic Performance and the Utility of Clinical Vignette-Based Assessment Under Testing Conditions Designed to Encourage Either Automatic or Analytic Thought , 2013, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[60]  Wolfgang Gaissmaier,et al.  Disrupting diagnostic reasoning: do interruptions, instructions, and experience affect the diagnostic accuracy and response time of residents and emergency physicians? , 2015, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[61]  Irene W. Y. Ma,et al.  Emotion, cognitive load and learning outcomes during simulation training , 2012, Medical education.

[62]  Henk G. Schmidt,et al.  Why Do Doctors Make Mistakes? A Study of the Role of Salient Distracting Clinical Features , 2014, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[63]  Jennifer S Myers,et al.  Teaching about how doctors think: a longitudinal curriculum in cognitive bias and diagnostic error for residents , 2013, BMJ quality & safety.

[64]  Guido G. Gatti,et al.  Do physicians know when their diagnoses are correct? , 2005, Journal of General Internal Medicine.

[65]  G. Logan Toward an instance theory of automatization. , 1988 .

[66]  Silvia Mamede,et al.  Does Time Pressure Have a Negative Effect on Diagnostic Accuracy? , 2016, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[67]  Jonathan Evans In two minds: dual-process accounts of reasoning , 2003, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[68]  D. Murray,et al.  Decision Making in Trauma Settings: Simulation to Improve Diagnostic Skills , 2015, Simulation in healthcare : journal of the Society for Simulation in Healthcare.

[69]  B. Miller,et al.  Improving Diagnosis in Health Care. , 2016, Military medicine.

[70]  P. Croskerry When I say… cognitive debiasing , 2015, Medical education.

[71]  R. Rikers,et al.  Influence of Perceived Difficulty of Cases on Physicians' Diagnostic Reasoning , 2008, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[72]  Tamara van Gog,et al.  Exposure to Media Information About a Disease Can Cause Doctors to Misdiagnose Similar-Looking Clinical Cases , 2014, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[73]  F. Wolf,et al.  The contribution of different components of the clinical encounter in generating and eliminating diagnostic hypotheses. , 1988, Research in medical education : proceedings of the ... annual Conference. Conference on Research in Medical Education.