Stability, robustness, vulnerability and resilience of agricultural systems. A review

Global warming and price volatility are increasing uncertainty for the future of agriculture. Therefore, agricultural systems must be sustainable not only under average conditions, but also under extreme changes of productivity, economy, environment and social context. Here, we review four concepts: stability, robustness, vulnerability and resilience. Those concepts are commonly used but are sometimes difficult to distinguish due to the lack of clear boundaries. Here, we clarify the role of these concepts in addressing agronomic issues. Our main findings are as follows: (1) agricultural systems face different types of perturbations, from small and usual perturbations to extreme and unpredictable changes; (2) stability, robustness, vulnerability and resilience have been increasingly applied to analyze the agricultural context in order to predict the system response under changing conditions; (3) the four concepts are distinguished by the nature of the system components and by the type of perturbation studied; (4) assessment methods must be tested under contrasted situations; and (5) the major options allowing system adaptation under extreme and unpredictable changes are the increase of diversity and the increase of the adaptive capacity.

[1]  Myles Oelofse,et al.  An Indicator Framework for Assessing Agroecosystem Resilience , 2012 .

[2]  Claudia Ringler,et al.  Vulnerability of the South African farming sector to climate change and variability: An indicator approach , 2010 .

[3]  Laura Astigarraga,et al.  Production Flexibility in Extensive Beef Farming Systems , 2011 .

[4]  Frank Ewert,et al.  Using the Concepts of Resilience, Vulnerability and Adaptability for the Assessment and Analysis of Agricultural Systems , 2014 .

[5]  Bruce Kelly N. Silva,et al.  Indicator of Agriculture Vulnerability to Climatic Extremes. A Conceptual Model with Case Study for the Northeast Brazil , 2014 .

[6]  D. Lobell,et al.  A method for quantifying vulnerability, applied to the agricultural system of the Yaqui Valley, Mexico , 2003 .

[7]  Lael Parrott,et al.  Future landscapes: managing within complexity , 2012 .

[8]  T. D. Mitchell,et al.  Ecosystem Service Supply and Vulnerability to Global Change in Europe , 2005, Science.

[9]  Pereira,et al.  Plant diversity and productivity experiments in european grasslands , 1999, Science.

[10]  B. Wisner,et al.  At Risk: Natural Hazards, People's Vulnerability and Disasters , 1996 .

[11]  M. Warburton,et al.  Plant genetic resources: what can they contribute toward increased crop productivity? , 1999, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[12]  M. Rounsevell,et al.  The vulnerability of ecosystem services to land use change , 2006 .

[13]  M. Bindi,et al.  Impacts of Present and Future Climate Variability on Agriculture and Forestry in the Temperate Regions: Europe , 2005 .

[14]  S. Frank,et al.  Genotypically diverse cultivar mixtures for insect pest management and increased crop yields , 2012 .

[15]  Laurence Guichard,et al.  Comparison of methods to assess the sustainability of agricultural systems. A review , 2011, Agronomy for Sustainable Development.

[16]  T. Neset,et al.  Assessment of composite index methods for agricultural vulnerability to climate change. , 2015, Journal of environmental management.

[17]  C. Nicholls,et al.  Agroecology and the design of climate change-resilient farming systems , 2015, Agronomy for Sustainable Development.

[18]  James Justus.  Complexity, Diversity, and Stability , 2008 .

[19]  A. Mishra,et al.  Stability of Farm Income and the Role of Nonfarm Income in U.S. Agriculture , 2002 .

[20]  David B Lobell,et al.  The fingerprint of climate trends on European crop yields , 2014, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[21]  Xiaodong Yan,et al.  Climate change and drought: a risk assessment of crop-yield impacts. , 2009 .

[22]  M. Trnka,et al.  Agroclimatic conditions in Europe under climate change , 2011 .

[23]  F. Chapin,et al.  Principles of Ecosystem Stewardship , 2009 .

[24]  E. Knol,et al.  New phenotypes for new breeding goals in pigs , 2010 .

[25]  N. Sabaghnia,et al.  Genotype by environment interaction and stability analysis for grain yield of lentil genotypes. , 2012 .

[26]  J. Anderies,et al.  From Metaphor to Measurement: Resilience of What to What? , 2001, Ecosystems.

[27]  David Gouache,et al.  Why are wheat yields stagnating in Europe? A comprehensive data analysis for France , 2010 .

[28]  A. Wagner.  Robustness and evolvability: a paradox resolved , 2008, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[29]  A. Messéan,et al.  Robust cropping systems to tackle pests under climate change. A review , 2014, Agronomy for Sustainable Development.

[30]  Sandra Lavorel,et al.  Ecological diversity and resilience of Mediterranean vegetation to disturbance , 1999 .

[31]  Stéphane Bellon,et al.  Adaptiveness to Enhance the Sustainability of Farming Systems , 2011 .

[32]  Hiroaki Kitano,et al.  Biological robustness , 2008, Nature Reviews Genetics.

[33]  E. Fèvre,et al.  Animal movements and the spread of infectious diseases , 2006, Trends in Microbiology.

[34]  O. Martin,et al.  Robustesse, rusticité, flexibilité, plasticité... les nouveaux critères de qualité des animaux et des systèmes d'élevage: définitions systémique et biologique des différents concepts , 2010 .

[35]  Salvatore Di Falco,et al.  Crop genetic diversity, productivity and stability of agroecosystems : a theoretical and empirical investigation , 2003 .

[36]  Rocco Scolozzi,et al.  Exploring Panarchy in Alpine Grasslands: an Application of Adaptive Cycle Concepts to the Conservation of a Cultural Landscape , 2012 .

[37]  P. Reich,et al.  Biodiversity and ecosystem stability in a decade-long grassland experiment , 2006, Nature.

[38]  J. ten Napel,et al.  Utilising intrinsic robustness in agricultural production systems: Inventions for a sustainable development of agriculture , 2006 .

[39]  Miguel A. Altieri,et al.  Biodiversity And Pest Management In Agroecosystems , 1994 .

[40]  A. P. Bos,et al.  Re-design and co-design of farming systems. An overview of methods and practices , 2012 .

[41]  R. O'Neill,et al.  A revised concept of landscape equilibrium: Disturbance and stability on scaled landscapes , 1993, Landscape Ecology.

[42]  Iliana Chollett,et al.  Ecological resilience, robustness and vulnerability: how do these concepts benefit ecosystem management? , 2014 .

[43]  E. Holt-gimenez.  Measuring farmers’ agroecological resistance after Hurricane Mitch in Nicaragua: a case study in participatory, sustainable land management impact monitoring , 2002 .

[44]  E. Knol,et al.  Estimation of genetic parameters and breeding values across challenged environments to select for robust pigs. , 2015, Journal of animal science.

[45]  Norman Kin-Wai Cheung.  At Risk: Natural Hazards, People's Vulnerability and Disasters ‐ by Ben Wisner, Piers Blaikie, Terry Cannon, and Ian Davis , 2007 .

[46]  M. Price.  Panarchy: Understanding Transformations in Human and Natural Systems , 2003 .

[47]  G. Edwards‐Jones,et al.  Modelling farmer decision-making: concepts, progress and challenges , 2006 .

[48]  Birgit Kopainsky,et al.  Food system resilience: Defining the concept , 2015 .

[49]  C. Winson.  27—REPORT ON A METHOD FOR MEASURING THE RESILIENCE OF WOOL , 1932 .

[50]  S. Carpenter,et al.  Anticipating Critical Transitions , 2012, Science.

[51]  M. Zeller,et al.  What determines farmers’ resilience towards ENSO-related drought? An empirical assessment in Central Sulawesi, Indonesia , 2008 .

[52]  W. Adger,et al.  Assessing and enhancing adaptive capacity , 2005 .

[53]  medolbec.  Linkages between vulnerability, resilience, and adaptive capacity , 2010 .

[54]  Olga V. Wilhelmi,et al.  Assessing Vulnerability to Agricultural Drought: A Nebraska Case Study , 1999 .

[55]  Millenium Ecosystem Assessment.  Ecosystems and human well-being: synthesis , 2005 .

[56]  Jouni Paavola,et al.  Livelihoods, vulnerability and adaptation to climate change in Morogoro, Tanzania , 2008 .

[57]  F. Bocquier,et al.  Robustesse, flexibilité, plasticité: des processus adaptatifs révélés dans les systèmes d'élevage extensifs de ruminants , 2010 .

[58]  F. Thomalla,et al.  The Role of Collective Action in Enhancing Communities’ Adaptive Capacity to Environmental Risk: An Exploration of Two Case Studies from Asia , 2011, PLoS currents.

[59]  Alain Peeters,et al.  Grasslands and herbivore production in Europe and effects of common policies , 2014 .

[60]  D. Lobell,et al.  Adaptation potential of European agriculture in response to climate change , 2014 .

[61]  John M. Anderies,et al.  Insight, part of a Special Feature on Exploring Resilience in Social-Ecological Systems Fifteen Weddings and a Funeral: Case Studies and Resilience- based Management , 2006 .

[62]  C. S. Holling.  From Complex Regions to Complex Worlds , 2004 .

[63]  Kyle C. Meng,et al.  General Resilience to Cope with Extreme Events , 2012 .

[64]  S. Leeuw,et al.  A Long-Term Perspective on Resilience in Socio-Natural Systems , 2001 .

[65]  Rodolphe Sabatier,et al.  Grazing in an Uncertain Environment: Modeling the Trade‐Off between Production and Robustness , 2015 .

[66]  J. ten Napel,et al.  A conceptual approach to design livestock production systems for robustness to enhance sustainability , 2011 .

[67]  D. Rodríguez,et al.  The intrinsic plasticity of farm businesses and their resilience to change. An Australian example , 2011 .

[68]  P. Annicchiarico.  Genotype x environment interaction: challenges and opportunities for plant breeding and cultivar recommendations. , 2002 .

[69]  B. Lin.  Resilience in Agriculture through Crop Diversification: Adaptive Management for Environmental Change , 2011 .

[70]  Stewart J. Cohen,et al.  Climate Change 2014: Impacts,Adaptation, and Vulnerability. Part A: Global and Sectoral Aspects. Contribution of Working Group II to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change , 2014 .

[71]  Shibu Jose,et al.  Agroforestry for ecosystem services and environmental benefits: an overview , 2009, Agroforestry Systems.

[72]  M. Huchet-Bourdon,et al.  Agricultural Commodity Price Volatility: An Overview , 2011 .

[73]  B. Győrffy,et al.  Effect of crop rotation and fertilisation on maize and wheat yields and yield stability in a long-term experiment , 2000 .

[74]  D. M. De Goede,et al.  Robust agriculture: Balancing between vulnerability and stability , 2013 .

[75]  Martin Ravallion,et al.  Are the Poor Less Well-Insured? Evidence on Vulnerability to Income Risk in Rural China , 1999 .

[76]  Marten Scheffer,et al.  Resilience thinking: integrating resilience, adaptability and transformability , 2010 .

[77]  R. Leemans,et al.  Adaptation to climate change and climate variability in European agriculture: The importance of farm level responses , 2010 .

[78]  Mette Termansen,et al.  Typologies of crop-drought vulnerability: an empirical analysis of the socio-economic factors that influence the sensitivity and resilience to drought of three major food crops in China (1961–2001) , 2009 .

[79]  Frans W. A. Brom,et al.  A plea to implement robustness into a breeding goal: poultry as an example , 2008 .

[80]  D. Makowski,et al.  Estimating variability in grain legume yields across Europe and the Americas , 2015, Scientific Reports.

[81]  Frédéric Jiguet,et al.  Community richness and stability in agricultural landscapes: The importance of surrounding habitats , 2007 .

[82]  B. Smit,et al.  Vulnerability to climate change hazards and risks: crop and flood insurance , 2006 .

[83]  J. P. Grime,et al.  Testing predictions of the resistance and resilience of vegetation subjected to extreme events , 1995 .

[84]  S. Ingrand,et al.  Long-term strategies and flexibility of organic farmers in southeastern France , 2010 .

[85]  Stéphane Bellon,et al.  Farms and farmers facing change: The adaptive approach , 2012 .

[86]  L. Lefkovitch,et al.  Stability Analysis : Where Do We Stand ? , 2003 .

[87]  W. Adger,et al.  Adaptation to Environmental Change: Contributions of a Resilience Framework , 2007 .

[88]  Tim G Benton,et al.  Landscape diversity and the resilience of agricultural returns: a portfolio analysis of land-use patterns and economic returns from lowland agriculture , 2013, Agriculture & Food Security.

[89]  R. Naylor.  Managing Food Production Systems for Resilience , 2009 .

[90]  E. Malone,et al.  Adaptation Policy Frameworks for Climate Change: Developing Strategies, Policies and Measures , 2004 .

[91]  C. S. Holling,et al.  Resilience and Sustainable Development: Building Adaptive Capacity in a World of Transformations , 2002, Ambio.

[92]  E. T. Lammerts van Bueren,et al.  Time for a shift in crop production: embracing complexity through diversity at all levels , 2009 .

[93]  Ronald W. Davis,et al.  Role of duplicate genes in genetic robustness against null mutations , 2003, Nature.

[94]  Ika Darnhofer,et al.  Strategies of family farms to strengthen their resilience , 2010 .

[95]  Maria Tengö,et al.  Management practices for building adaptive capacity : a case from northern Tanzania , 2003 .

[96]  Anand Patwardhan,et al.  Assessing vulnerability for climate adaptation , 2005 .

[97]  John Doyle,et al.  Complexity and robustness , 2001, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[98]  M P L Calus,et al.  Genetic correlations between milk production and health and fertility depending on herd environment. , 2006, Journal of dairy science.

[99]  Arnaud Reynaud,et al.  A dynamic bio-economic model to simulate optimal adjustments of suckler cow farm management to production and market shocks in France , 2009 .

[100]  S. Polasky,et al.  Agricultural sustainability and intensive production practices , 2002, Nature.

[101]  H. Gilbert,et al.  Évolution des performances et de la robustesse des animaux en élevage porcin , 2010 .

[102]  M. Trnka,et al.  Impacts and adaptation of European crop production systems to climate change , 2011 .

[103]  J. van der Ploeg,et al.  Exploring multifunctional agriculture. A review of conceptual approaches and prospects for an integrative transitional framework. , 2009, Journal of environmental management.

[104]  Muriel Tichit,et al.  A viability model to assess the sustainability of mixed herds under climatic uncertainty , 2004 .

[105]  F. Brand,et al.  Focusing the Meaning(s) of Resilience: Resilience as a Descriptive Concept and a Boundary Object , 2007 .

[106]  Simon Maxwell.  Farming systems research: Hitting a moving target , 1986 .

[107]  R. Macarthur.  Fluctuations of Animal Populations and a Measure of Community Stability , 1955 .

[108]  M.J.P. Mens,et al.  The meaning of system robustness for flood risk management , 2011 .

[109]  Richard J. Hobbs,et al.  Resilience in ecology: Abstraction, distraction, or where the action is? , 2014 .

[110]  L. Salmaso,et al.  Direct payments, crop insurance and the volatility of farm income. Some evidence in France and in Italy , 2014 .

[111]  I. Darnhofer,et al.  Adaptiveness to enhance the sustainability of farming systems. A review , 2010, Agronomy for Sustainable Development.

[112]  J. Deckers,et al.  Stable high yields with zero tillage and permanent bed planting , 2005 .

[113]  D. Mulla.  Twenty five years of remote sensing in precision agriculture: Key advances and remaining knowledge gaps , 2013 .

[114]  R. Kasperson,et al.  A framework for vulnerability analysis in sustainability science , 2003, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[115]  Liz Carlisle.  Diversity, flexibility, and the resilience effect: lessons from a social-ecological case study of diversified farming in the northern Great Plains, USA , 2014 .

[116]  Lynn P. Nygaard,et al.  Mapping vulnerability to multiple stressors: climate change and globalization in India , 2004 .

[117]  Christian Wissel,et al.  Babel, or the ecological stability discussions: an inventory and analysis of terminology and a guide for avoiding confusion , 1997, Oecologia.

[118]  Y. Chen.  Biodiversity and Pest Management in Agroecosystems , 2005 .

[119]  Donald A. Wilhite,et al.  An Operational Agricultural Drought Risk Assessment Model for Nebraska, USA , 2004 .

[120]  K. Wiegand,et al.  Production and Robustness of a Cacao Agroecosystem: Effects of Two Contrasting Types of Management Strategies , 2013, PloS one.

[121]  A. Iglesias,et al.  Measuring the risk of climate variability to cereal production at five sites in Spain , 2007 .

[122]  C. S. Holling.  Engineering Resilience versus Ecological Resilience , 1996 .

[123]  C. S. Holling.  Resilience and Stability of Ecological Systems , 1973 .

[124]  B. Ripley,et al.  Robust Statistics , 2018, Encyclopedia of Mathematical Geosciences.

[125]  Troy Sternberg,et al.  Chinese drought, bread and the Arab Spring , 2012 .

[126]  P. W. Knap,et al.  Breeding robust pigs , 2005 .

[127]  Frank Ewert,et al.  Regional Farm Diversity Can Reduce Vulnerability of Food Production to Climate Change , 2008 .

[128]  Guy Trébuil.  Résilience et environnement : penser les changements socio-écologiques , 2014 .

[129]  Enli Wang,et al.  Adaptation to climate change of wheat growing in South Australia: Analysis of management and breeding strategies , 2014 .

[130]  J. Bennett.  Biodiversity and pest management in agroecosystems , 2005 .

[131]  Garry D. Peterson,et al.  Measuring and assessing resilience: broadening understanding through multiple disciplinary perspectives , 2016 .

[132]  France,et al.  Increased genetic diversity improves crop yield stability under climate variability: a computational study on sunflower , 2014, 1403.2825.

[133]  S. Carpenter,et al.  Adaptive Capacity and Traps , 2008 .

[134]  S. Carpenter,et al.  Stability and Diversity of Ecosystems , 2007, Science.

[135]  William Y. Fowlkes,et al.  Engineering Methods for Robust Product Design: Using Taguchi Methods in Technology and Product Development , 1995 .