Retrospective estimation of the electric and magnetic field exposure conditions in in vitro experimental reports reveal considerable potential for uncertainty

Experiments on cell cultures exposed to extremely low frequency (ELF, 3–300 Hz) magnetic fields are often subject to multiple sources of uncertainty associated with specific electric and magnetic field exposure conditions. Here we systemically quantify these uncertainties based on exposure conditions described in a group of bioelectromagnetic experimental reports for a representative sampling of the existing literature. The resulting uncertainties, stemming from insufficient, ambiguous, or erroneous description, design, implementation, or validation of the experimental methods and systems, were often substantial enough to potentially make any successful reproduction of the original experimental conditions difficult or impossible. Without making any assumption about the true biological relevance of ELF electric and magnetic fields, these findings suggest another contributing factor which may add to the overall variability and irreproducibility traditionally associated with experimental results of in vitro exposures to low‐level ELF magnetic fields. Bioelectromagnetics. 39:231–243, 2018. © 2017 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

[1]  F. Prato,et al.  Biological effects of the hypomagnetic field: An analytical review of experiments and theories , 2017, PloS one.

[2]  Matti Viluksela,et al.  Assessment of Health Risks of Intermediate Frequency Magnetic Fields , 2017 .

[3]  M. Markov, Dosimetry in Bioelectromagnetics , 2017 .

[4]  Luc Martens,et al.  Measurements of intermediate‐frequency electric and magnetic fields in households , 2017, Environmental research.

[5]  Vijayalaxmi Biological and health effects of radiofrequency fields: Good study design and quality publications. , 2016, Mutation research.

[6]  N. Kuster,et al.  Calcium homeostasis and low-frequency magnetic and electric field exposure: A systematic review and meta-analysis of in vitro studies. , 2016, Environment international.

[7]  S. Goodman,et al.  Statistical tests, P values, confidence intervals, and power: a guide to misinterpretations , 2016, European Journal of Epidemiology.

[8]  Kenneth R. Foster,et al.  The Problem of False Discovery: Many Scientific Results Can't Be Replicated, Leading to Serious Questions about What's True and False in the World of Research , 2016, IEEE Pulse.

[9]  Quirino Balzano,et al.  In vitro exposure: Linear and non‐linear thermodynamic events in Petri dishes , 2015, Bioelectromagnetics.

[10]  G. Thuróczy,et al.  Extremely low frequency (ELF) stray magnetic fields of laboratory equipment: a possible co-exposure conducting experiments on cell cultures , 2015, Electromagnetic biology and medicine.

[11]  Q. Balzano,et al.  Culture Medium Geometry: The Dominant Factor Affecting In Vitro RF Exposure Dosimetry , 2015 .

[12]  D. Loiselle,et al.  A counterview of ‘An investigation of the false discovery rate and the misinterpretation of p-values’ by Colquhoun (2014) , 2015, Royal Society Open Science.

[13]  F. Prato Non‐thermal extremely low frequency magnetic field effects on opioid related behaviors: Snails to humans, mechanisms to therapy , 2015, Bioelectromagnetics.

[14]  D. Curran‐Everett,et al.  The fickle P value generates irreproducible results , 2015, Nature Methods.

[15]  Ben Greenebaum,et al.  The effects of weak magnetic fields on radical pairs , 2015, Bioelectromagnetics.

[16]  David Colquhoun,et al.  An investigation of the false discovery rate and the misinterpretation of p-values , 2014, Royal Society Open Science.

[17]  James C. Lin Reassessing laboratory results of low-frequency electromagnetic field exposure of cells in culture [telecommunications health and safety] , 2014, IEEE Antennas and Propagation Magazine.

[18]  James C. Lin,et al.  Reexamining Biological Studies of Effect of Low-Frequency Electromagnetic Field Exposure on Cells in Culture [Health Effects] , 2014, IEEE Microwave Magazine.

[19]  J. Lekner Conducting cylinders in an external electric field: Polarizability and field enhancement , 2013 .

[20]  Frank S. Barnes,et al.  Inhomogeneous background magnetic field in biological incubators is a potential confounder for experimental variability and reproducibility , 2013, Bioelectromagnetics.

[21]  Le-Qing Wu,et al.  Neural Correlates of a Magnetic Sense , 2012, Science.

[22]  T. Masuzawa,et al.  Nano-vibration effect on cell adhesion and its shape. , 2011, Bio-medical materials and engineering.

[23]  D. Herndon,et al.  Calcium and ER stress mediate hepatic apoptosis after burn injury , 2009, Journal of cellular and molecular medicine.

[24]  K. H. Mild,et al.  Background ELF magnetic fields in incubators: A factor of importance in cell culture work , 2009, Cell biology international.

[25]  Steven M. Reppert,et al.  Cryptochrome mediates light-dependent magnetosensitivity in Drosophila , 2008, Nature.

[26]  Hideyuki Okano,et al.  Effects of static magnetic fields in biology: role of free radicals. , 2008, Frontiers in bioscience : a journal and virtual library.

[27]  Salvatore Celozzi,et al.  Electromagnetics behind Shielding , 2008 .

[28]  J. Craigon,et al.  Physiological temperature variants and culture media modify meiotic progression and developmental potential of pig oocytes in vitro. , 2007, Reproduction.

[29]  R. Takeuchi,et al.  Effects of Acceleration Amplitude and Frequency of Mechanical Vibration on Osteoblast-Like Cells , 2007 .

[30]  J. Ioannidis Why Most Published Research Findings Are False , 2005, PLoS medicine.

[31]  K. Yoshitomi,et al.  Extremely low frequency magnetic fields originating from equipment used for assisted reproduction, umbilical cord and peripheral blood stem cell transplantation, transfusion, and hemodialysis , 2005, Bioelectromagnetics.

[32]  Norbert Felber,et al.  In vitro exposure apparatus for ELF magnetic fields , 2004, Bioelectromagnetics.

[33]  F. P. Magee,et al.  Combined magnetic fields increased net calcium flux in bone cells , 1994, Calcified Tissue International.

[34]  K. Hahlbrock Further studies on the relationship between the rates of nitrate uptake, growth and conductivity changes in the medium of plant cell suspension cultures , 2004, Planta.

[35]  I. Chatterjee,et al.  Numerical study of induced current perturbations in the vicinity of excitable cells exposed to extremely low frequency magnetic fields. , 2003, Physics in medicine and biology.

[36]  N. Kuster,et al.  Effect of the meniscus at the solid/liquid interface on the SAR distribution in Petri dishes and flasks , 2003, Bioelectromagnetics.

[37]  K. Hansson Mild,et al.  Magnetic Fields in Incubators a Risk Factor in IVF/ICSI Fertilization? , 2003 .

[38]  Hiroki Yokota,et al.  Effects of broad frequency vibration on cultured osteoblasts. , 2003, Journal of biomechanics.

[39]  I. Chatterjee,et al.  Numerical computation of distortions in magnetic fields and induced currents in physiological solutions produced by microscope objectives , 2001, Bioelectromagnetics.

[40]  G. Bartosz,et al.  Light-dependent generation of reactive oxygen species in cell culture media. , 2001, Free radical biology & medicine.

[41]  N Kuster,et al.  Recommended minimal requirements and development guidelines for exposure setups of bio-experiments addressing the health risk concern of wireless communications. , 2000, Bioelectromagnetics.

[42]  W. Robberecht,et al.  Abnormal intracellular ca(2+)homeostasis and disease. , 2000, Cell calcium.

[43]  M M Methner,et al.  Hazard surveillance for industrial magnetic fields: II. Field characteristics from waveform measurements. , 2000, The Annals of occupational hygiene.

[44]  I. Chatterjee,et al.  Effects of microscope objectives on magnetic field exposures. , 1999, Bioelectromagnetics.

[45]  S. Snyder,et al.  Lymphocyte Apoptosis: Mediation by Increased Type 3 Inositol 1,4,5-Trisphosphate Receptor , 1996, Science.

[46]  F. Hart,et al.  Cell culture dosimetry for low-frequency magnetic fields. , 1996, Bioelectromagnetics.

[47]  P A Valberg,et al.  Designing EMF experiments: what is required to characterize "exposure"? , 1995, Bioelectromagnetics.

[48]  M A Stuchly,et al.  Modelling induced currents in biological cells exposed to low-frequency magnetic fields. , 1994, Physics in medicine and biology.

[49]  G. G. Karady,et al.  Comparison of calibration systems for magnetic field measurement equipment , 1994 .

[50]  T. Litovitz,et al.  Determination of the induced ELF electric field distribution in a two layer in vitro system simulating biological cells in nutrient solution. , 1993, Bioelectromagnetics.

[51]  R P Liburdy,et al.  Biological Interactions of Cellular Systems with Time‐varying Magnetic Fields a , 1992, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[52]  J. Kirschvink,et al.  Uniform magnetic fields and double-wrapped coil systems: improved techniques for the design of bioelectromagnetic experiments. , 1992, Bioelectromagnetics.

[53]  T Litovitz,et al.  ELF in vitro exposure systems for inducing uniform electric and magnetic fields in cell culture media. , 1992, Bioelectromagnetics.

[54]  D. House,et al.  The influence of temperature during electric- and magnetic-field-induced alteration of calcium-ion release from in vitro brain tissue. , 1991, Bioelectromagnetics.

[55]  R P Liburdy,et al.  Nonthermal 60 Hz sinusoidal magnetic‐field exposure enhances 45Ca2+ uptake in rat thymocytes: dependence on mitogen activation , 1990, FEBS letters.

[56]  R. Ian Freshney,et al.  Culture of Animal Cells: A Manual of Basic Technique and Specialized Applications , 2010 .

[57]  R. London,et al.  Elevation in Cytosolic Free Calcium Concentration Early in Myocardial Ischemia in Perfused Rat Heart , 1987, Circulation research.

[58]  G. Stroink,et al.  Uniform magnetic field produced by three, four, and five square coils , 1983 .

[59]  R. J. Pawluk,et al.  ACCELERATION OF FRACTURE REPAIR BY ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS. A SURGICALLY NONINVASIVE METHOD , 1974, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[60]  A. Hale Electromagnetic Shielding , 1973 .

[61]  D. E. Speliotis,et al.  A theoretical analysis of saturation magnetic recording , 1966 .