The Effectiveness of Traditional Tools and Computer-Aided Technologies for Health and Safety Training in the Construction Sector: A Systematic Review

Abstract For workers, the exposure to on-site hazards can result in fatalities and serious injuries. To improve safety outcomes, different approaches have been implemented for health and safety training in the construction sector, such as traditional tools and computer-aided technologies (e.g., serious games, computer-generated simulations, virtual reality, augmented reality, and mixed reality). However, the effectiveness of these approaches has been barely explored. In order to bridge this gap, a systematic review of existing studies was conducted. Unlike previous review studies in this field that focused on uncovering the technology characters and challenges, this study mainly evaluated the effectiveness of training using traditional tools and computer-aided technologies on the well-being of individuals. Measures of the effectiveness included knowledge acquisition, unsafe behaviour alteration, and injury rate reduction. Results indicated that: 1. the effectiveness of traditional tools is sufficiently supported by statistical evidence; and 2. the use of computer-aided technologies has evidence to support its effectiveness, but more solid evidence is required to support this statement. The systematic review also revealed that the overall performance of computer-aided technologies is superior in several technical aspects compared to traditional tools, namely, representing the actual workplace situations, providing text-free interfaces, and having better user engagement.

[1]  Brian M. Kleiner,et al.  Sociotechnical systems of fatal electrical injuries in the construction industry , 2016 .

[2]  Margaret E. Gredler,et al.  Games and Simulations and Their Relationships to Learning , 2013 .

[3]  Ido Erev,et al.  On the difficulty of promoting workers' safety behaviour: overcoming the underweighting of routine risks , 2007 .

[4]  David P Gilkey,et al.  Construction work practices and conditions improved after 2-years' participation in the HomeSafe pilot program. , 2003, AIHA journal : a journal for the science of occupational and environmental health and safety.

[5]  Nurshamshida Md Shamsudin,et al.  Virtual Reality Training Approach for Occupational Safety and Health: A Pilot Study , 2018 .

[6]  Zhihan Lv,et al.  Game On, Science - How Video Game Technology May Help Biologists Tackle Visualization Challenges , 2013, PloS one.

[7]  Chan-Sik Park,et al.  A Social Virtual Reality Based Construction Safety Education System for Experiential Learning , 2014, Journal of Intelligent & Robotic Systems.

[8]  Kristin Smith-Crowe,et al.  Relative effectiveness of worker safety and health training methods. , 2006, American journal of public health.

[9]  Giuseppe Riva,et al.  The New Dawn of Virtual Reality in Health Care: Medical Simulation and Experiential Interface. , 2015, Studies in health technology and informatics.

[10]  Eddy M. Rojas,et al.  A pilot study of a 3D game environment for construction safety education , 2011, J. Inf. Technol. Constr..

[11]  Serkan Kivrak,et al.  Using Augmented Reality to Facilitate Construction Site Activities , 2019 .

[12]  Judy M. Vance,et al.  Virtual reality for assembly methods prototyping: a review , 2011, Virtual Reality.

[13]  Casper Harteveld,et al.  Triadic Game Design - Balancing Reality, Meaning and Play , 2011 .

[14]  Yifan Gao,et al.  Serious Games vs. Traditional Tools in Construction Safety Training: A Review , 2017 .

[15]  Prathap Tharyan,et al.  Increasing compliance with protective eyewear to reduce ocular injuries in stone-quarry workers in Tamil Nadu, India: a pragmatic, cluster randomised trial of a single education session versus an enhanced education package delivered over six months. , 2013, Injury.

[16]  M Chakravathi,et al.  Study on Function Ambiguity in Inheritance Using Object Oriented Programming With C++, Java and C# , 2016 .

[17]  Steven K. Feiner,et al.  Exploring MARS: developing indoor and outdoor user interfaces to a mobile augmented reality system , 1999, Comput. Graph..

[18]  Yantao Yu,et al.  Visualization technology-based construction safety management: A review , 2017 .

[19]  Alan Platt,et al.  International overview of high-level simulation education initiatives in relation to critical care. , 2014, Nursing in critical care.

[20]  Kathryn Davies,et al.  Toward a Learning-Styles Profile of Construction Students: Results from New Zealand , 2007 .

[21]  Lianne Sheppard,et al.  A multi-component intervention to promote hearing protector use among construction workers , 2011, International journal of audiology.

[22]  Behzad Esmaeili,et al.  State-of-the-Art Review of Virtual Reality Environment Applications in Construction Safety , 2015 .

[23]  Eric Marks,et al.  A Framework for Developing an As-built Virtual Environment to Advance Training of Crane Operators , 2014 .

[24]  Judit Bar-Ilan,et al.  Which h-index? — A comparison of WoS, Scopus and Google Scholar , 2008, Scientometrics.

[25]  V G Hadjianastassiou,et al.  A comparison between different formats of educational feedback to junior doctors: a prospective pilot intervention study. , 2001, Journal of the Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh.

[26]  Kumar Neeraj Jha,et al.  Neural Network Model for the Prediction of Safe Work Behavior in Construction Projects , 2015 .

[27]  Chan-Sik Park,et al.  Construction safety education model based on second life , 2012, Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Teaching, Assessment, and Learning for Engineering (TALE) 2012.

[28]  Frédéric Bosché,et al.  Towards a Mixed Reality System for Construction Trade Training , 2016, J. Comput. Civ. Eng..

[29]  Heng Li,et al.  Using game technologies to improve the safety of construction plant operations. , 2012, Accident; analysis and prevention.

[30]  Helen Lingard,et al.  The effect of first aid training on Australian construction workers' occupational health and safety motivation and risk control behavior. , 2002, Journal of safety research.

[31]  OiSaeng Hong,et al.  Efficacy of a computer-based hearing test and tailored hearing protection intervention , 2006, International journal of behavioral medicine.

[32]  Susan P. Miller,et al.  Comparing Web-based to Traditional Instruction for Teaching Special Education Content , 2007 .

[33]  Fabiane Barreto Vavassori Benitti,et al.  Exploring the educational potential of robotics in schools: A systematic review , 2012, Comput. Educ..

[34]  Sarah Howard.  Get your headsets ready! Which Virtual Reality headset best suits your library? , 2018 .

[35]  Rafael Bidarra,et al.  Balancing Play, Meaning and Reality: The Design Philosophy of LEVEE PATROLLER , 2010 .

[36]  N. Wallerstein,et al.  Health and safety education for workers with low-literacy or limited-English skills. , 1992, American journal of industrial medicine.

[37]  Alex Albert,et al.  Development of Immersive Personalized Training Environment for Construction Workers , 2017 .

[38]  Luca Chittaro,et al.  Assessing Knowledge Retention of an Immersive Serious Game vs. a Traditional Education Method in Aviation Safety , 2015, IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics.

[39]  Bernhard Rinner,et al.  Demo: VSNsim - A Simulator for Control and Coordination in Visual Sensor Networks , 2014, ICDSC.

[40]  Salman Azhar,et al.  Role of Visualization Technologies in Safety Planning and Management at Construction Jobsites , 2017 .

[41]  Olaf Kolditz,et al.  Concept and workflow for 3D visualization of atmospheric data in a virtual reality environment for analytical approaches , 2014, Environmental Earth Sciences.

[42]  Kihong Ku,et al.  Building interactive modeling for construction education in virtual worlds , 2011, J. Inf. Technol. Constr..

[43]  Pedro F. Hernández-Ramos,et al.  How do presence, flow, and character identification affect players' empathy and interest in learning from a serious computer game? , 2016, Comput. Hum. Behav..

[44]  Frédéric Bosché,et al.  An immersive hybrid reality system for construction training , 2015 .

[45]  José Manuel Andújar Márquez,et al.  Augmented Reality for the Improvement of Remote Laboratories: An Augmented Remote Laboratory , 2011, IEEE Transactions on Education.

[46]  A Bhattacharya,et al.  An ergonomic education and evaluation program for apprentice carpenters. , 1997, American journal of industrial medicine.

[47]  Zhenan Feng,et al.  Rapid 3D Reconstruction of Indoor Environments to Generate Virtual Reality Serious Games Scenarios , 2018, ArXiv.

[48]  Wen Yi,et al.  A critical review of virtual and augmented reality (VR/AR) applications in construction safety , 2018 .

[49]  Kenneth A Johnson,et al.  A Job Safety Program for Construction Workers Designed to Reduce the Potential for Occupational Injury Using Tool Box Training Sessions and Computer-Assisted Biofeedback Stress Management Techniques , 2002, International journal of occupational safety and ergonomics : JOSE.

[50]  Chan-Sik Park,et al.  A framework for using mobile based virtual reality and augmented reality for experiential construction safety education , 2015 .

[51]  Anne Seppala.  Promoting safety by training supervisors and safety representatives for daily safety work , 1995 .

[52]  B. Kapralos,et al.  Using Serious Games and Virtual Simulation for Training in the Fire Service: A Review , 2015 .

[53]  Javier Irizarry,et al.  Applying advanced technology to improve safety management in the construction industry: a literature review , 2013 .

[54]  Peter M Smith,et al.  The development of a conceptual model and self-reported measure of occupational health and safety vulnerability. , 2015, Accident; analysis and prevention.

[55]  Asif Iqbal,et al.  A collaborative augmented reality based modeling environment for construction engineering and management education , 2011, Proceedings of the 2011 Winter Simulation Conference (WSC).

[56]  Rafael Sacks,et al.  Construction safety training using immersive virtual reality , 2013 .

[57]  Weihua Gao,et al.  An Intervention Effectiveness Study of Hazard Awareness Training in the Construction Building Trades , 2009, Public health reports.

[58]  Stefan Greuter,et al.  Engaging students in OH&S hazard identification through a game , 2013, DiGRA Conference.

[59]  Vijay Kumar,et al.  101 Design Methods: A Structured Approach for Driving Innovation in Your Organization , 2012 .

[60]  Sungjoo Hwang,et al.  What drives construction workers' acceptance of wearable technologies in the workplace?: Indoor localization and wearable health devices for occupational safety and health , 2017 .

[61]  Koen Milisen,et al.  Work environment and workforce problems: a cross-sectional questionnaire survey of hospital nurses in Belgium. , 2006, International journal of nursing studies.

[62]  Jean Écalle,et al.  Serious games as new educational tools: how effective are they? A meta-analysis of recent studies , 2013, J. Comput. Assist. Learn..

[63]  Louise Sauvé,et al.  Distinguishing between Games and Simulations: A Systematic Review , 2007, J. Educ. Technol. Soc..

[64]  Johnny Dyreborg,et al.  The construction of the Øresund link between Denmark and Sweden: the effect of a multi-faceted safety campaign , 2002 .

[65]  Mehmet S. Kizil,et al.  What can virtual reality do for safety , 2001 .

[66]  Nashwan Dawood,et al.  Construction health and safety training: the utilisation of 4D enabled serious games , 2014, J. Inf. Technol. Constr..

[67]  Richard Neitzel,et al.  Development and pilot test of hearing conservation training for construction workers. , 2008, American journal of industrial medicine.

[68]  Walid Y. Thabet,et al.  Managing electrocution hazards in the US construction industry using VR simulation and cloud technology , 2012 .

[69]  R. V. Krejcie,et al.  Determining Sample Size for Research Activities , 1970 .

[70]  Darren E. Wishart,et al.  Integration of work-related fleet safety within a Workplace Health and Safety Management System: A case study approach , 2006 .

[71]  Ken-Yu Lin,et al.  Developing 3D Safety Training Materials on Fall Related Hazards for Limited English Proficiency (LEP , 2012 .

[72]  Xiangyu Wang,et al.  Design, strategies, and issues towards an augmented reality-based construction training platform , 2007, J. Inf. Technol. Constr..

[73]  Heng Li,et al.  Proactive training system for safe and efficient precast installation , 2015 .

[74]  Jian Chai,et al.  A framework of innovative learning for skill development in complex operational tasks , 2017 .

[75]  Wei Zhou,et al.  Safety by design: dialogues between designers and builders using virtual reality , 2015 .

[76]  Steven M. LaValle,et al.  Virtual Reality , 2004, Heilberufe.

[77]  Walid Y. Thabet,et al.  Using virtual environments to support electrical safety awareness in construction , 2009, Proceedings of the 2009 Winter Simulation Conference (WSC).

[78]  Antônio Carlos A. Mól,et al.  Using a Game Engine for VR Simulations in Evacuation Planning , 2008, IEEE Computer Graphics and Applications.

[79]  Ralph B Dell,et al.  Sample size determination. , 2002, ILAR journal.

[80]  Xiangyu Wang,et al.  Research trends and opportunities of augmented reality applications in architecture, engineering, and construction , 2013 .

[81]  Rui Wang,et al.  The Situation Engine: a hyper-immersive platform for construction workplace simulation and learning , 2013 .

[82]  Jochen Teizer,et al.  Real-time construction worker posture analysis for ergonomics training , 2012, Adv. Eng. Informatics.

[83]  Scott O. Lilienfeld,et al.  The self‑report assessment of psychopathy: Challenges, pitfalls, and promises. , 2006 .

[84]  D. Fang,et al.  Why operatives engage in unsafe work behavior: Investigating factors on construction sites , 2008 .

[85]  James P. Bliss,et al.  The Effectiveness of Virtual Reality for Administering Spatial Navigation Training to Firefighters , 1997, Presence: Teleoperators & Virtual Environments.

[86]  Ruwini Edirisinghe,et al.  Productivity Improvement in the Construction Industry: A Case Study of Mechanization in Singapore , 2018, Advances in Informatics and Computing in Civil and Construction Engineering.

[87]  Ashwani Kumar,et al.  CityHeat: visualizing cellular automata-based traffic heat in Unity3D , 2015, SIGGRAPH Asia Visualization in High Performance Computing.

[88]  Chan-Sik Park,et al.  Framework for Integrating Safety into Construction Methods Education through Interactive Virtual Reality , 2016 .

[89]  Tom Apperley.  Genre and game studies: Toward a critical approach to video game genres , 2006 .

[90]  Edmund K. Burke,et al.  A Standard Data Format for Timetabling Instances , 1997, PATAT.

[91]  Dong Zhao,et al.  Virtual reality simulation for construction safety promotion , 2015, International journal of injury control and safety promotion.

[92]  Tahira M Probst,et al.  Safety and insecurity: exploring the moderating effect of organizational safety climate. , 2004, Journal of occupational health psychology.

[93]  Min Li,et al.  LEARNING ASSESSMENT STRATEGIES FOR AN EDUCATIONAL CONSTRUCTION SAFETY VIDEO GAME , 2012 .

[94]  Ao Chen,et al.  SAVES: a safety training augmented virtuality environment for construction hazard recognition and severity identification , 2013 .

[95]  G. Sorock,et al.  Fatal occupational injuries in the New Jersey construction industry, 1983 to 1989. , 1993, Journal of occupational medicine. : official publication of the Industrial Medical Association.

[96]  Kaija Leena Saarela,et al.  A poster campaign for improving safety on shipyard scaffolds , 1989 .

[97]  Xiangyu Wang,et al.  Mixed Reality Technology Applications in Construction Equipment Operator Training , 2004 .

[98]  A. Bena,et al.  Effectiveness of the training program for workers at construction sites of the high-speed railway line between Torino and Novara: impact on injury rates. , 2009, American journal of industrial medicine.

[99]  Lorann Stallones,et al.  Effectiveness of the HomeSafe Pilot Program in reducing injury rates among residential construction workers, 1994-1998. , 2004, American journal of industrial medicine.

[100]  Benjamin F. Jones,et al.  Supporting Online Material Materials and Methods Figs. S1 to S3 References the Increasing Dominance of Teams in Production of Knowledge , 2022 .

[101]  Ruggiero Lovreglio,et al.  Immersive Virtual Reality Serious Games for Evacuation Training and Research: A Systematic Literature Review , 2018, Comput. Educ..

[102]  Bradley A. Evanoff,et al.  Results of a fall prevention educational intervention for residential construction , 2016 .

[103]  Dave Morris.  Virtual Reality , 1993 .

[104]  Sabri Serkan Gulluoglu,et al.  The future Of technology based education on different branches of science: A conceptual basis for educational applications of virtual reality , 2010 .

[105]  Eric D. Ragan,et al.  Contextualizing construction accident reports in virtual environments for safety education , 2017, 2017 IEEE Virtual Reality (VR).

[106]  X. Dong,et al.  Occupational fatalities of Hispanic construction workers from 1992 to 2000. , 2004, American journal of industrial medicine.

[107]  Roberto Canas,et al.  Game-based trench safety education: development and lessons learned , 2011, J. Inf. Technol. Constr..

[108]  Michael Moore.  Basics of Game Design , 2011 .

[109]  Behzad Esmaeili,et al.  Using Panoramic Augmented Reality to Develop a Virtual Safety Training Environment , 2018 .

[110]  Wei Shi,et al.  Development of a Virtual Reality Safety-Training System for Construction Workers , 2006 .

[111]  Peter Leong,et al.  REAPSG: Work safety and health games for construction sector , 2013, 2013 IEEE International Games Innovation Conference (IGIC).

[112]  G. Antes,et al.  Five Steps to Conducting a Systematic Review , 2003, Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine.

[113]  Linda Forst,et al.  More than training: Community-based participatory research to reduce injuries among hispanic construction workers. , 2013, American journal of industrial medicine.

[114]  Sally Lechlitner Lusk,et al.  Effectiveness of an Intervention to Increase Construction Workers' Use of Hearing Protection , 1999, Hum. Factors.

[115]  Don B. Chaffin,et al.  An evaluation of the effect of a training program on worker lifting postures , 1986 .

[116]  J. Lachin.  Introduction to sample size determination and power analysis for clinical trials. , 1981, Controlled clinical trials.

[117]  Jun Wang,et al.  A Critical Review of the Use of Virtual Reality in Construction Engineering Education and Training , 2018, International journal of environmental research and public health.

[118]  Martin Loosemore,et al.  Barriers to implementing OHS reforms – The experiences of small subcontractors in the Australian Construction Industry , 2007 .

[119]  Sarah A. Hezlett,et al.  The impact of 360‐degree feedback on management skills development , 1993 .

[120]  Martin Skitmore,et al.  Visualizing safety assessment by integrating the use of game technology , 2012 .

[121]  Ren-Jye Dzeng,et al.  Construction safety training via e-Learning: Learning effectiveness and user satisfaction , 2010, Comput. Educ..

[122]  Marina Papastergiou,et al.  Exploring the potential of computer and video games for health and physical education: A literature review , 2009, Comput. Educ..

[123]  Gary B. Wills,et al.  Making training more cognitively effective: Making videos interactive , 2009, Br. J. Educ. Technol..

[124]  Rafael Sacks,et al.  Hazard recognition and risk perception in construction , 2014 .

[125]  Stefan Greuter,et al.  Designing a game for occupational health and safety in the construction industry , 2012, IE '12.

[126]  Markus König,et al.  First Person Virtual Reality for Evaluation and Learning of Construction Site Safety , 2016 .

[127]  Madeleine J Kerr,et al.  Effectiveness of computer-based tailoring versus targeting to promote use of hearing protection. , 2007, The Canadian journal of nursing research = Revue canadienne de recherche en sciences infirmieres.