Hidden treatments in ecological experiments: re-evaluating the ecosystem function of biodiversity

Abstract Interactions between biotic and abiotic processes complicate the design and interpretation of ecological experiments. Separating causality from simple correlation requires distinguishing among experimental treatments, experimental responses, and the many processes and properties that are correlated with either the treatments or the responses, or both. When an experimental manipulation has multiple components, but only one of them is identified as the experimental treatment, erroneous conclusions about cause and effect relationships are likely because the actual cause of any observed response may be ignored in the interpretation of the experimental results. This unrecognized cause of an observed response can be considered a “hidden treatment.” Three types of hidden treatments are potential problems in biodiversity experiments: (1) abiotic conditions, such as resource levels, or biotic conditions, such as predation, which are intentionally or unintentionally altered in order to create differences in species numbers for “diversity” treatments; (2) non-random selection of species with particular attributes that produce treatment differences that exceed those due to “diversity” alone; and (3) the increased statistical probability of including a species with a dominant negative or positive effect (e.g., dense shade, or nitrogen fixation) in randomly selected groups of species of increasing number or “diversity.” In each of these cases, treatment responses that are actually the result of the “hidden treatment” may be inadvertently attributed to variation in species diversity. Case studies re-evaluating three different types of biodiversity experiments demonstrate that the increases found in such ecosystem properties as productivity, nutrient use efficiency, and stability (all of which were attributed to higher levels of species diversity) were actually caused by “hidden treatments” that altered plant biomass and productivity.

[1]  P. Kareiva.  Diversity and sustainability on the prairie , 1996, Nature.

[2]  H. Mooney,et al.  Biodiversity and Ecosystem Function , 1994, Praktische Zahnmedizin Odonto-Stomatologie Pratique Practical Dental Medicine.

[3]  A. Underwood.  Experiments in Ecology: Analysis of variance , 1996 .

[4]  J. L. Gittleman,et al.  The Future of Biodiversity , 1995, Science.

[5]  D. Tilman,et al.  Productivity and sustainability influenced by biodiversity in grassland ecosystems , 1996, Nature.

[6]  R. O. Cashen.  The influence of rainfall on the yield and botanical composition of permanent grass at Rothamsted , 1947, The Journal of Agricultural Science.

[7]  Sokal Rr,et al.  Biometry: the principles and practice of statistics in biological research 2nd edition. , 1981 .

[8]  M. Huston.  Soil nutrients and tree species richness in Costa Rican forests , 1980 .

[9]  J. P. Grime,et al.  A QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS OF SHOOT PHENOLOGY AND DOMINANCE IN HERBACEOUS VEGETATION , 1977 .

[10]  David Tilman,et al.  Secondary Succession and the Pattern of Plant Dominance Along Experimental Nitrogen Gradients , 1987 .

[11]  P. Keddy,et al.  Centrifugal organization in forests , 1990 .

[12]  J. Simon,et al.  Extinction rates. , 1996, Science.

[13]  D. Tilman.  Biodiversity: Population Versus Ecosystem Stability , 1995 .

[14]  C. Gibson.  Nature management by grazing and cutting , 1990 .

[15]  N. Myers.  The Sinking Ark: A New Look at the Problem of Disappearing Species , 1979 .

[16]  Catherine E. Bach,et al.  Effects of Plant Density and Diversity on the Population Dynamics of a Specialist Herbivore, the Striped Cucumber Beetle, Acalymma Vittata (Fab) , 1980 .

[17]  A. Cropper.  Convention on Biological Diversity , 1993, Environmental Conservation.

[18]  D. Schindler,et al.  Eutrophication and Recovery in Experimental Lakes: Implications for Lake Management , 1974, Science.

[19]  Thomas M. Smith,et al.  Plant Succession: Life History and Competition , 1987, The American Naturalist.

[20]  D. L. Angelis,et al.  STABILITY AND CONNECTANCE IN FOOD WEB MODELS , 1975 .

[21]  Lawrence B. Slobodkin,et al.  A Critique for Ecology , 1991 .

[22]  E. J. Kamprath,et al.  Soil Nutrient Bioavailability—A Mechanistic Approach , 1985 .

[23]  Edward O. Wilson,et al.  The Current State of Biological Diversity , 1988 .

[24]  Charles C. Elton,et al.  The Ecology of Invasions by Animals and Plants. , 1959 .

[25]  Leslie A. Real,et al.  The Sustainable Biosphere Initiative: An Ecological Research Agenda: A Report from the Ecological Society of America , 1991 .

[26]  Margery L. Oldfield,et al.  The value of conserving genetic resources , 1986 .

[27]  J. Lawton,et al.  Biodiversity in model ecosystems , 1994, Nature.

[28]  Stuart L. Pimm,et al.  Complexity and stability: another look at MacArthur's original hypothesis , 1979 .

[29]  A. Magurran,et al.  Biological diversity : the coexistence of species on changing landscapes , 1994 .

[30]  Thomas J. Givnish,et al.  Does diversity beget stability? , 1994, Nature.

[31]  Nelson G. Hairston,et al.  Ecological Experiments: Purpose, Design and Execution , 1989 .

[32]  J. P. Grime,et al.  Competitive Exclusion in Herbaceous Vegetation , 1973, Nature.

[33]  Donald L. DeAngelis,et al.  Multiple nutrient limitations in ecological models , 1989 .

[34]  R. Reader,et al.  Variation in competition along an environmental gradient: Hieracium floribundum in an abandoned pasture , 1989 .

[35]  William M. Schaffer,et al.  Plant strategies and the dynamics and structure of plant communities , 1989 .

[36]  J. P. Grime,et al.  Plant Strategies and Vegetation Processes. , 1980 .

[37]  S. Hurlbert.  Pseudoreplication and the Design of Ecological Field Experiments , 1984 .

[38]  M. Huston.  A General Hypothesis of Species Diversity , 1979, The American Naturalist.

[39]  J. M. Anderson,et al.  Biodiversity and Ecosystem Function in Agricultural Systems , 1994 .

[40]  J. P. Grime.  Control of species density in herbaceous vegetation , 1973 .

[41]  P. Thibault,et al.  Biodiversity in model ecosystems , 1994, Nature.

[42]  Kristin Shrader-Frechette,et al.  Method in Ecology: Strategies for Conservation , 1993 .

[43]  D. L. DeAngelis,et al.  Dynamics of Nutrient Cycling and Food Webs , 1992, Population and Community Biology Series.

[44]  T. Schoener.  Mechanistic Approaches to Community Ecology: A New Reductionism , 1986 .

[45]  W. Post,et al.  Influence of climate, soil moisture, and succession on forest carbon and nitrogen cycles , 1986 .

[46]  D. DeAngelis,et al.  Competition and Coexistence: The Effects of Resource Transport and Supply Rates , 1994, The American Naturalist.

[47]  P. Kareiva.  Diversity begets productivity , 1994, Nature.

[48]  K. McConway,et al.  Stability in the plant communities of the Park Grass Experiment: the relationships between species richness, soil pH and biomass variability , 1994 .

[49]  Christopher B. Field,et al.  RESPONSES OF TERRESTRIAL ECOSYSTEMS TO THE CHANGING ATMOSPHERE: A Resource-Based Approach*'** , 1992 .

[50]  John Bennet Lawes,et al.  XXVIII. Agricultural, botanical, and chemical results of experiments on the mixed herbage of permanent meadow, conducted for more than twenty years in succession on the same land. — Part. II. The botanical results , 1882, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London.

[51]  D. Tilman.  Resource competition and community structure. , 1983, Monographs in population biology.

[52]  M. Austin,et al.  BEHAVIOUR OF EXPERIMENTAL PLANT COMMUNITIES ALONG A NUTRIENT GRADIENT , 1980 .

[53]  Jonathan Silvertown,et al.  THE DYNAMICS OF A GRASSLAND ECOSYSTEM: BOTANICAL EQUILIBRIUM IN THE PARK GRASS EXPERIMENT , 1980 .

[54]  Ecological theory and anuran declines , 1996 .

[55]  Alan Randall.  Biodiversity and Landscapes: Thinking about the value of biodiversity , 1994 .

[56]  V. Heywood,et al.  Global Biodiversity Assessment , 1996 .

[57]  J. Ewel,et al.  Plant Life-Forms and Tropical Ecosystem Functioning , 1996 .

[58]  Arthur Cronquist,et al.  Manual of Vascular Plants of Northeastern United States and Adjacent Canada , 2004 .

[59]  D. Tilman,et al.  PLANT PRODUCTION AND SOIL MICROORGANISMS IN LATE-SUCCESSIONAL ECOSYSTEMS: A CONTINENTAL-SCALE STUDY' , 1994 .

[60]  P. Kapoor-Vijay,et al.  Global Biodiversity Strategy. , 1992 .

[61]  David Tilman,et al.  Plant Traits and Resource Reduction For Five Grasses Growing on a Nitrogen Gradient , 1991 .

[62]  Paul G. Risser,et al.  Global warming and biological diversity , 1992 .

[63]  John Vandermeer,et al.  The Ecology of Intercropping by John H. Vandermeer , 1989 .

[64]  D. Tilman.  Species Richness of Experimental Productivity Gradients: How Important is Colonization Limitation? , 1993 .

[65]  P. Hamilton,et al.  Experimental evidence for interactive impacts of human activities on lake algal species richness , 1996 .

[66]  C. T. Wit,et al.  Competition between legumes and grasses , 1966 .

[67]  S. McNaughton.  Diversity and Stability of Ecological Communities: A Comment on the Role of Empiricism in Ecology , 1977, The American Naturalist.

[68]  D. Tilman.  The Importance of the Mechanisms of Interspecific Competition , 1987, The American Naturalist.

[69]  J. Lawton,et al.  Empirical Evidence that Declining Species Diversity May Alter the Performance of Terrestrial Ecosystems , 1995 .

[70]  A. Moffat,et al.  Ecology: Biodiversity Is a Boon to Ecosystems, Not Species , 1996 .

[71]  J. Downing,et al.  Biodiversity and stability in grasslands , 1996, Nature.

[72]  Paul L. Angermeier,et al.  Ecological Experiments: Purpose, Design, and Execution , 1991 .

[73]  J. Denslow.  Functional Group Diversity and Responses to Disturbance , 1996 .

[74]  Robert M. May,et al.  Stability and Complexity in Model Ecosystems , 2019, IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics.

[75]  S. Pimm.  The complexity and stability of ecosystems , 1984, Nature.

[76]  C. Stace,et al.  New Flora Of The British Isles , 1998 .

[77]  J. Lawton,et al.  Declining biodiversity can alter the performance of ecosystems , 1994, Nature.

[78]  P. Vitousek,et al.  Biological Diversity and Terrestrial Ecosystem Biogeochemistry , 1994 .

[79]  Keith Goulding,et al.  Soil acidification during more than 100 years under permanent grassland and woodland at Rothamsted , 1986 .

[80]  Creation : God and endangered species , 1994 .

[81]  P. Ehrlich,et al.  Biodiversity Studies: Science and Policy , 1991, Science.

[82]  Kevin McConway,et al.  Rainfall, Biomass Variation, and Community Composition in the Park Grass Experiment , 1994 .