BEATING THE SPIN-DOWN LIMIT ON GRAVITATIONAL WAVE EMISSION FROM THE VELA PULSAR

We present direct upper limits on continuous gravitational wave emission from the Vela pulsar using data from the Virgo detector's second science run. These upper limits have been obtained using three independent methods that assume the gravitational wave emission follows the radio timing. Two of the methods produce frequentist upper limits for an assumed known orientation of the star's spin axis and value of the wave polarization angle of, respectively, 1.9 × 10−24 and 2.2 × 10−24, with 95% confidence. The third method, under the same hypothesis, produces a Bayesian upper limit of 2.1 × 10−24, with 95% degree of belief. These limits are below the indirect spin-down limit of 3.3  ×  10−24 for the Vela pulsar, defined by the energy loss rate inferred from observed decrease in Vela's spin frequency, and correspond to a limit on the star ellipticity of ∼10−3. Slightly less stringent results, but still well below the spin-down limit, are obtained assuming the star's spin axis inclination and the wave polarization angles are unknown.

C. Broeck | V. Moscatelli | S. Klimenko | M. Satterthwaite | J. Worden | S. Babak | J. Cannizzo | G. Prodi | S. Fairhurst | A. Heptonstall | S. Yoshida | P. Wessels | W. Kells | A. Khalaidovski | F. Khalili | E. Khazanov | N. Kim | P. King | D. Kinzel | J. Kissel | V. Kondrashov | W. Korth | I. Kowalska | D. Kozak | V. Kringel | B. Krishnan | G. Kuehn | M. Landry | B. Lantz | A. Lazzarini | P. Leaci | J. Leong | N. Leroy | N. Letendre | T. G. F. Li | N. Lockerbie | M. Lorenzini | V. Loriette | M. Lormand | G. Losurdo | A. Lundgren | B. Machenschalk | M. Macinnis | M. Mageswaran | E. Majorana | I. Maksimovic | N. Man | I. Mandel | V. Mandic | M. Mantovani | F. Marchesoni | F. Marion | E. Maros | F. Martelli | I. Martin | R. Martin | J. Marx | K. Mason | A. Masserot | F. Matichard | L. Matone | N. Mavalvala | D. McClelland | S. McGuire | G. McIntyre | G. Meadors | A. Melatos | G. Mendell | R. Mercer | S. Meshkov | C. Messenger | H. Miao | L. Milano | J. Miller | Y. Minenkov | V. Mitrofanov | G. Mitselmakher | R. Mittleman | S. Mohapatra | D. Moraru | G. Moreno | K. Mossavi | B. Mours | C. Mow-Lowry | G. Mueller | A. Mullavey | J. Munch | P. Murray | G. Newton | F. Nocera | D. Nolting | E. Ochsner | G. Ogin | C. Ott | R. Ottens | H. Overmier | B. Owen | C. Palomba | C. Pankow | F. Paoletti | M. Papa | A. Pasqualetti | R. Passaquieti | D. Passuello | M. Pedraza | L. Pekowsky | S. Penn | A. Perreca | M. Phelps | M. Pichot | F. Piergiovanni | L. Pinard | I. Pinto | M. Pitkin | R. Poggiani | V. Predoi | L. Price | M. Prijatelj | M. Principe | S. Privitera | L. Prokhorov | M. Punturo | P. Puppo | V. Quetschke | F. Raab | D. Rabeling | H. Radkins | P. Raffai | M. Rakhmanov | P. Rapagnani | V. Raymond | V. Re | T. Regimbau | S. Reid | D. Reitze | F. Ricci | K. Riles | N. Robertson | F. Robinet | A. Rocchi | L. Rolland | J. Rollins | R. Romano | S. Rowan | P. Ruggi | F. Salemi | L. Sammut | V. Sandberg | B. Sassolas | R. Savage | R. Schilling | R. Schnabel | R. Schofield | B. Schutz | J. Scott | S. Scott | D. Sellers | D. Sentenac | D. Shaddock | M. Shaltev | B. Shapiro | P. Shawhan | X. Siemens | D. Sigg | A. Singer | L. Singer | A. Sintes | J. Smith | N. Smith | B. Sorazu | J. Steinlechner | R. Stone | S. Strigin | R. Sturani | T. Summerscales | P. Sutton | B. Swinkels | M. Tacca | D. Talukder | D. Tanner | S. Tarabrin | R. Taylor | P. Thomas | K. Thorne | K. Thorne | E. Thrane | M. Tonelli | C. Torres | F. Travasso | G. Traylor | D. Ugolini | H. Vahlbruch | G. Vajente | J. Brand | A. Veggel | S. Vass | R. Vaulin | B. Abbott | R. Biswas | The Ligo Scientific Collaboration | R. Smith | R. Abbott | F. Acernese | C. Adams | R. Adhikari | C. Affeldt | S. Anderson | W. Anderson | K. Arai | M. Araya | S. Aston | P. Astone | P. Aufmuth | P. Baker | G. Ballardin | S. Ballmer | D. Barker | S. Barnum | F. Barone | B. Barr | L. Barsotti | M. Barsuglia | I. Bartos | R. Bassiri | A. Basti | M. Bejger | A. Bell | A. Bertolini | J. Betzwieser | I. Bilenko | G. Billingsley | J. Birch | M. Bitossi | J. Blackburn | D. Blair | F. Bondu | R. Bonnand | R. Bork | V. Boschi | C. Bradaschia | P. Brady | A. Brillet | M. Brinkmann | A. Brooks | T. Bulik | H. Bulten | A. Buonanno | D. Buskulic | C. Buy | R. Byer | L. Cadonati | G. Cagnoli | E. Calloni | J. Camp | K. Cannon | J. Cao | F. Carbognani | S. Caride | S. Caudill | M. Cavaglià | R. Cavalieri | G. Cella | E. Cesarini | O. Chaibi | P. Charlton | É. Chassande-Mottin | Y. Chen | A. Chincarini | N. Christensen | S. Chua | S. Chung | F. Clara | J. Clark | F. Cleva | E. Coccia | T. Corbitt | N. Cornish | A. Corsi | C. Costa | M. Coughlin | J. Coulon | D. Coward | D. Coyne | J. Creighton | A. Cumming | L. Cunningham | E. Cuoco | S. Danilishin | S. D’Antonio | K. Danzmann | V. Dattilo | E. Daw | D. DeBra | J. Degallaix | T. Dent | R. Rosa | R. DeSalvo | S. Dhurandhar | L. Fiore | A. Lieto | I. Palma | F. Donovan | K. Dooley | M. Drago | J. Driggers | S. Dwyer | M. Edwards | A. Effler | P. Ehrens | T. Etzel | M. Evans | V. Fafone | B. Farr | I. Ferrante | F. Fidecaro | I. Fiori | R. Flaminio | J. Fournier | S. Frasca | F. Frasconi | Z. Frei | A. Freise | R. Frey | P. Fritschel | V. Frolov | P. Fulda | M. Fyffe | L. Gammaitoni | F. Garufi | G. Gemme | E. Génin | A. Gennai | S. Ghosh | J. Giaime | A. Giazotto | E. Goetz | M. Gorodetsky | R. Gouaty | C. Graef | M. Granata | A. Grant | S. Gras | C. Gray | H. Grote | S. Grunewald | G. Guidi | E. Gustafson | R. Gustafson | G. Hammond | J. Hanks | C. Hanna | J. Hanson | J. Harms | G. Harry | I. Harry | K. Haughian | H. Heitmann | M. Hendry | I. Heng | S. Hild | D. Hoak | K. Holt | J. Hough | E. Howell | B. Hughey | S. Husa | S. Huttner | R. Inta | P. Jaranowski | D. Jones | R. Jones | L. Ju | S. Kandhasamy | J. Kanner | W. Katzman | K. Kawabe | R. Kumar | J. Li | H. Luck | M. Mehmet | C. Michel | B. O'reilly | R. O’Shaughnessy | D. Ottaway | O. Puncken | A. Rudiger | K. Ryan | P. Saulson | A. Sengupta | D. Shoemaker | B. Slagmolen | K. Strain | A. Vecchio | G. Vedovato | J. Veitch | P. Veitch | D. Verkindt | F. Vetrano | J. Vinet | H. Vocca | C. Vorvick | L. Wallace | R. Ward | M. Was | M. Weinert | A. Weinstein | R. Weiss | L. Wen | K. Wette | J. Whelan | B. Whiting | B. Willke | W. Winkler | C. Wipf | G. Woan | H. Yamamoto | M. Yvert | M. Zanolin | L. Zhang | C. Zhao | M. Zucker | J. Zweizig | L. Finn | S. M'arka | M. Bizouard | S. Bose | V. Brisson | F. Cavalier | M. Davier | M. D'iaz | G. Gonz'alez | P. Hello | D. Huet | V. Kalogera | A. Kr'olak | Z. M'arka | D. Rosi'nska | B. Sathyaprakash | A. Stuver | A. Vicer'e | M. Abernathy | B. Allen | D. Amariutei | C. Aulbert | B. Behnke | O. Bock | T. Bodiya | C. Bogan | V. Braginsky | D. Brown | C. Capano | C. Cepeda | T. Chalermsongsak | A. Colla | D. Cook | H. Daveloza | R. Day | G. Debreczeni | V. Dergachev | R. Derosa | R. Drever | M. Factourovich | H. Fehrmann | T. Fricke | K. Giardina | M. Hartman | K. Hodge | D. Hosken | D. Ingram | T. Isogai | W. Johnson | E. Katsavounidis | F. Kawazoe | M. Mohan | S. Mukherjee | J. O'Dell | J. Romie | K. Tokmakov | C. Torrie | T. Westphal | D. White | J. Yablon | M. Boyle | R. Prix | J. Romano | S. Steinlechner | S. Whitcomb | R. Matzner | C. Osthelder | G. Pagliaroli | C. Reed | M. Barton | A. Virgilio | K. Hayama | S. Kawamura | H. Kim | O. Miyakawa | S. Sato | K. Somiya | K. Yamamoto | M. Lubinski | L. Blackburn | S. Foley | C. Ramet | T. Eberle | D. Feldbaum | S. Gossler | R. Greenhalgh | A. Gretarsson | C. Guido | M. Hewitson | D. Keppel | T. Bauer | M. Blom | L. Bonelli | L. Bosi | B. Canuel | M. Colombini | J. Marque | N. Morgado | I. Neri | I. R'acz | M. V. D. Sluys | J. Colas | F. Seifert | M. Edgar | J. Brau | S. Pardi | M. Emilio | G. Persichetti | J. Heefner | D. Lodhia | T. Creighton | A. Wiseman | M. Sakosky | J. Garcia | A. Toncelli | S. Braccini | T. Nash | S. Koranda | D. Atkinson | D. Hammer | H. Pletsch | J. Nelson | M. Salit | A. Wanner | V. Sannibale | M. Vallisneri | M. Prato | B. Schulz | E. Robinson | A. Ivanov | A. Marandi | C. Veltkamp | M. Flanigan | P. Kwee | M. Frede | L. Winkelmann | G. Santostasi | E. Tournefier | D. Clark | E. Campagna | J. Franc | R. Nawrodt | P. Willems | S. Krishnamurthy | C. Rover | E. Ceron | B. Aylott | J. Bauchrowitz | N. Beveridge | P. Beyersdorf | E. Black | B. Bland | M. Born | J. Breyer | M. Britzger | J. Burguet-Castell | P. Campsie | K. Dahl | B. Daudert | G. Davies | T. Dayanga | A. Dietz | J. Dumas | R. Engel | T. Evans | D. Fazi | E. Forsi | N. Fotopoulos | M. Frei | D. Friedrich | S. Giampanis | C. Gill | E. Harstad | T. Hong | S. Hooper | P. Kalmus | E. Macdonald | K. Mailand | T. Meier | B. Moe | E. Nishida | A. Nishizawa | C. Peralta | M. Pickenpack | F. Postiglione | T. Reed | R. Riesen | S. Roddy | I. Santiago-Prieto | P. Schwinberg | G. Skelton | J. Slutsky | M. Stefszky | S. Steplewski | A. Stochino | A. Stroeer | S. Susmithan | M. West | C. Wilkinson | L. Williams | R. Wooley | I. Yakushin | D. Yeaton-Massey | N. Zotov | Y. Pan | F. Speirits | S. Wen | J. R. Taylor | S. Buchner | A. Hotan | J. Luan | S. Mohanty | G. Jones | A. Melissinos | R. Bondarescu | B. Hage | A. Sergeev | A. Searle | R. Grosso | R. Conte | S. Chelkowski | T. Hayler | A. Bellétoile | K. Urbanek | S. Schlamminger | J. Palfreyman | R. Kopparapu | M. Sung | I. Belopolski | A. Cruise | D. Bridges | R. Amin | M. Arain | P. Barriga | M. Bastarrika | O. Burmeister | E. Chalkley | L. Goggin | I. Leonor | P. Lindquist | P. Lu | D. McKechan | P. Patel | C. Robinson | S. Sakata | L. D. L. Jordana | S. Saraf | A. Sibley | M. Trias | A. Villar | H. R. Williams | M. Benacquista | J. Clayton | R. Dannenberg | S. Dorsher | Y. Fan | J. Hallam | V. Herrera | N. Lastzka | P. Moesta | R. Oldenburg | A. Page | M. Plissi | B. Rankins | K. Redwine | M. Smith | J. Soto | A. Stein | C. Titsler | K. Tseng | S. Waldman | P. Wei | P. Yu | F. Antonucci | S. Birindelli | M. Prete | C. Greverie | A. Morgia | S. Mosca | S. V. D. Putten | E. Douglas | L. Santamar'ia | Y. Mino | J. Podkaminer | M. Parisi | J. Cain | L. Sperandio | M. Galimberti | B. Bouhou | M. E. G'asp'ar | Z. Zhang | C. Colacino | M. Pietka | M. Vavoulidis | T. Accadia | M. Beker | R. Culter | K. Das | J. Hayau | N. Liguori | L. Merill | L. Palladino | D. Pathak | B. Vaishnav | A. Thuring | L. Forte | R. Budzy'nski | H. Muller-Ebhardt | P. Roberts | S. Vyachanin | H. Yang | O. Torre | M. Meyer | L. Turner | R. McCarthy | M. Vasúth | J. Garofoli | R. Gupta | C. Chung | G. Allen | A. Brummit | J. Pold | G. Szokoly | T. V. C. J. Abadie | M. Kelner | A. Parameswaran | T. S. Weerathunga | M. Smith | T. Li | Y. Pan | R. Smith | D. Brown | S. Ghosh | C. Zhao | M. Smith

[1]  Gabriela Gonzalez,et al.  The LIGO Scientific Collaboration , 2015 .

[2]  C. Palomba,et al.  A method for detection of known sources of continuous gravitational wave signals in non-stationary data , 2010 .

[3]  Benno Willke,et al.  The Einstein Telescope: a third-generation gravitational wave observatory , 2010 .

[4]  V. Moscatelli,et al.  Calibration and sensitivity of the Virgo detector during its second science run , 2010, 1009.5190.

[5]  J. K. Blackburn,et al.  FIRST SEARCH FOR GRAVITATIONAL WAVES FROM THE YOUNGEST KNOWN NEUTRON STAR , 2010, 1006.2535.

[6]  G. M. Harry,et al.  Advanced LIGO: the next generation of gravitational wave detectors , 2010 .

[7]  P. Jaranowski,et al.  Searching for gravitational waves from known pulsars using the and statistics , 2010, 1004.0324.

[8]  Vincent Loriette,et al.  Measurements of Superattenuator seismic isolation by Virgo interferometer , 2010 .

[9]  R. Ciolfi,et al.  Structure and deformations of strongly magnetized neutron stars with twisted torus configurations , 2010, 1003.2148.

[10]  Vincent Loriette,et al.  Cleaning the Virgo sampled data for the search of periodic sources of gravitational waves , 2009 .

[11]  Piotr Jaranowski,et al.  Analysis of Gravitational-Wave Data , 2009 .

[12]  K. S. Thorne,et al.  SEARCHES FOR GRAVITATIONAL WAVES FROM KNOWN PULSARS WITH SCIENCE RUN 5 LIGO DATA , 2009, 0909.3583.

[13]  B. Krishnan,et al.  Targeted search for continuous gravitational waves: Bayesian versus maximum-likelihood statistics , 2009, 0907.2569.

[14]  K. Kadau,et al.  Breaking strain of neutron star crust and gravitational waves. , 2009, Physical review letters.

[15]  M. Ando,et al.  Search for continuous gravitational waves from PSR J0835-4510 using CLIO data , 2008 .

[16]  F. Antonucci,et al.  Detection of periodic gravitational wave sources by Hough transform in the f versus plane , 2008, 0807.5065.

[17]  D. Steinberg,et al.  Technometrics , 2008 .

[18]  L. Gualtieri,et al.  Relativistic models of magnetars: structure and deformations , 2007, 0712.2162.

[19]  R. Romani,et al.  Fitting Pulsar Wind Tori. II. Error Analysis and Applications , 2007, 0710.4168.

[20]  D. Sonnenwald Scientific collaboration , 2007, Annu. Rev. Inf. Sci. Technol..

[21]  D. Jones,et al.  Are neutron stars with crystalline color-superconducting cores relevant for the LIGO experiment? , 2007, Physical review letters.

[22]  L. Lin Constraining crystalline color superconducting quark matter with gravitational-wave data , 2007, 0708.2965.

[23]  I. Wasserman,et al.  Toroidal magnetic fields in type II superconducting neutron stars , 2007, 0705.2195.

[24]  K. Glampedakis,et al.  Modelling magnetically deformed neutron stars , 2007, 0705.1780.

[25]  M. Pitkin,et al.  Binary system delays and timing noise in searches for gravitational waves from known pulsars , 2007, gr-qc/0703152.

[26]  M. M. Casey,et al.  Upper limits on gravitational wave emission from 78 radio pulsars (Physical Review D - Particles, Fields, Gravitation and Cosmology (2007) 76, (042001)) , 2007, gr-qc/0702039.

[27]  R. Manchester,et al.  tempo2, a new pulsar timing package ¿ II. The timing model and precision estimates , 2006, astro-ph/0607664.

[28]  T. Hayler,et al.  Searches for periodic gravitational waves from unknown isolated sources and Scorpius X-1: Results from the second LIGO science run , 2006 .

[29]  Bernard F. Schutz,et al.  Status of the GEO600 detector , 2006 .

[30]  R. Manchester,et al.  TEMPO2, a new pulsar-timing package - I. An overview , 2006, astro-ph/0603381.

[31]  C. Palomba,et al.  The short FFT database and the peak map for the hierarchical search of periodic sources , 2005 .

[32]  G. Woan,et al.  Bayesian estimation of pulsar parameters from gravitational wave data , 2005, gr-qc/0508096.

[33]  B. Schutz,et al.  Generalized F-statistic : Multiple detectors and multiple gravitational wave pulsars , 2005, gr-qc/0504011.

[34]  B. Owen Maximum elastic deformations of compact stars with exotic equations of state. , 2005, Physical review letters.

[35]  M. M. Casey,et al.  Limits on gravitational-wave emission from selected pulsars using LIGO data. , 2004, Physical review letters.

[36]  M. M. Casey,et al.  Setting upper limits on the strength of periodic gravitational waves from PSR J1939+2134 using the first science data from the GEO 600 and LIGO detectors , 2004 .

[37]  R. Romani,et al.  Fitting Pulsar Wind Tori , 2003, astro-ph/0310155.

[38]  P. McCulloch,et al.  The Vela Pulsar’s Proper Motion and Parallax Derived from VLBI Observations , 2003, astro-ph/0302374.

[39]  M. Bejger,et al.  Accelerated expansion of the Crab Nebula and evaluation of its neutron-star parameters , 2003, astro-ph/0301071.

[40]  M. Bejger,et al.  Moments of inertia for neutron and strange stars: Limits derived for the Crab pulsar , 2002, astro-ph/0209151.

[41]  C. Cutler Gravitational Waves from Neutron Stars with Large Toroidal B-fields , 2002, gr-qc/0206051.

[42]  E. al.,et al.  Search for periodic gravitational wave sources with the Explorer detector , 2000, gr-qc/0011072.

[43]  G. Mendell,et al.  Second-order rotational effects on the r-modes of neutron stars. , 1999, gr-qc/9902052.

[44]  Bernard F. Schutz,et al.  Gravitational waves from hot young rapidly rotating neutron stars , 1998, gr-qc/9804044.

[45]  B. Schutz,et al.  Data analysis of gravitational-wave signals from spinning neutron stars. I. The signal and its detection , 1998, gr-qc/9804014.

[46]  Gudrun Wolfschmidt,et al.  From astronomy to astrophysics. , 1997 .

[47]  F. Camilo,et al.  Very low braking index for the Vela pulsar , 1996, Nature.

[48]  E. Coccia,et al.  First Edoardo Amaldi Conference on Gravitational Wave Experiments , 1995 .

[49]  Joshua R. Smith,et al.  LIGO: the Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory , 1992, Science.

[50]  L. Rezzolla,et al.  Classical and Quantum Gravity , 1996 .

[51]  G. Bignami,et al.  Is the Vela pulsar associated with the Vela SNR? , 1987 .

[52]  R. Fesen,et al.  Recent Developments Concerning the Crab Nebula , 1985 .

[53]  M. Zimmermann Revised estimate of gravitational radiation from Crab and Vela pulsars , 1978, Nature.

[54]  W. Press,et al.  Gravitational-wave astronomy , 1972 .

[55]  J. Levine,et al.  UPPER LIMIT ON THE GRAVITATIONAL FLUX REACHING THE EARTH FROM THE CRAB PULSAR. , 1972 .

[56]  A. Vaughan,et al.  A Pulsar Supernova Association? , 1968, Nature.

[57]  Space Science Reviews , 1962, Nature.