Nonautologous Interbody Fusion Materials in Cervical Spine Surgery: How Strong is the Evidence to Justify Their Use?

Study Design. A review of the literature concerning the use of interbody fusion devices and materials in anterior cervical surgery. Objectives. To examine the evidence supporting the use of interbody fusion devices as an alternative to autologous bone after anterior cervical discectomy. Summary of Background Data. Concerns over the morbidity associated with harvesting autologous bone and the risk of transmissible infectious from allografts and xenografts have prompted the search for alternative methods of achieving interbody fusion. Several of these methods have been associated with an unacceptable rate of complications. The clinical and health economic implications of the widespread introduction of interbody fusion devices in the absence of sound evidence cannot be ignored. Methods. A systematic review of the literature relating to cervical interbody fusion was undertaken. Studies were assessed critically with respect to their methodology, results, and conclusions. Results. Thirty-two clinical studies and 10 laboratory studies were analyzed. Methodologic weaknesses were identified in the majority. Only four clinical reports were either randomized or blinded or involved independent assessment of their outcomes. Fewer than half of the studies included a valid statistical analysis. Radiologic evidence of fusion was limited in many cases. There was little evidence that nonautologous fusion devices offered a reduction in the length of hospital stay. Autologous bone was as effective as, or superior to, many other fusion devices. The early results of some new fusion techniques used alone or in combination showed promise. Conclusions. There is limited evidence supporting the use of a cervical interbody fusion device in place of autologous bone. There is a need to standardize the testing of implants with good quality laboratory work preceding clinical use. Certain devices including cages, some forms of hydroxyapatite, and bone morphogenic proteins merit further study.

[1]  E. Simmons Anterior cervical discectomy and fusion. , 1969, Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine.

[2]  M. Panjabi,et al.  Biomechanical Study of Cervical Spine Stabilization with Methylmethacrylate , 1985, Spine.

[3]  B. Taylor Manual of internal fixation of the spine. , 1997 .

[4]  A. Elsmore,et al.  Extended anterior cervical decompression without fusion: a long-term follow-up study. , 1999, British journal of neurosurgery.

[5]  E White,et al.  Biomaterial aspects of Interpore-200 porous hydroxyapatite. , 1986, Dental clinics of North America.

[6]  W. Spence Internal plastic splint and fusion for stabilization of the spine. , 1973, Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research.

[7]  J. T. McFadden,et al.  Anterior cervical fusion using homologous bone grafts: a comparative study. , 1976, Surgical neurology.

[8]  T. Yamauchi,et al.  [New surgical technique for anterior cervical fusion; surgical technique for anterior cervical fusion utilizing autogenous bone graft from the cervical vertebrae]. , 1992, No shinkei geka. Neurological surgery.

[9]  Cantore Gp Long-term results with Kiel bone grafts using the Cloward procedure. , 1981 .

[10]  M. Hadley Banked fibula and anterior cervical locking plate. , 1996, Journal of neurosurgery.

[11]  A. Martins,et al.  Anterior cervical discectomy with and without interbody bone graft. , 1976, Journal of neurosurgery.

[12]  V. Sonntag,et al.  Controversy in spine care. Is fusion necessary after anterior cervical discectomy? , 1996, Spine.

[13]  W. Hayes,et al.  Compressive Strength of Autologous and Allogenous Bone Grafts for Thoracolumbar and Cervical Spine Fusion , 1990, Spine.

[14]  W. Young,et al.  An early comparative analysis of the use of fibular allograft versus autologous iliac crest graft for interbody fusion after anterior cervical discectomy. , 1993, Spine.

[15]  F. Eismont,et al.  Complications in spinal fusion. , 1998, The Orthopedic clinics of North America.

[16]  Fielding Jw Complications of anterior cervical disk removal and fusion. , 1992 .

[17]  N Yoganandan,et al.  Fusion Rate and Biomechanical Stiffness of Hydroxylapatite Versus Autogenous Bone Grafts for Anterior Discectomy: An In Vivo Animal Study , 1994, Spine.

[18]  D. Kunz,et al.  Anterior Cervical Discectomy and Fusion: A Comparison of Techniques in an Animal Model , 1992, Spine.

[19]  K. Murthy,et al.  Fracture Dislocation of the Cervical Spine: Value of Anterior Approach With Bovine Bone Interbody Fusion , 1978, Spine.

[20]  D H Wilson,et al.  Anterior cervical discectomy without bone graft. Report of 71 cases. , 1977, Journal of neurosurgery.

[21]  H. Crockard,et al.  Biocompatible Osteoconductive Polymer Versus Iliac Graft: A Prospective Comparative Study for the Evaluation of Fusion Pattern After Anterior Cervical Discectomy , 1996, Spine.

[22]  S B Sepic,et al.  Anterior Cervical Fusion for Degenerated or Protruded Discs: A Review of One Hundred Forty-Six Patients , 1984, Spine.

[23]  Woodall Rd,et al.  Types of anterior cervical grafts. , 1992 .

[24]  J. Thalgott,et al.  Anterior interbody fusion of the cervical spine with coralline hydroxyapatite. , 1999, Spine.

[25]  A. Abou-Madawi,et al.  Anterior Cervical Discectomy (ACD) Versus Anterior Cervical Fusion (ACF), Clinical and Radiological Outcome Study , 1999, Acta Neurochirurgica.

[26]  E. Ferrer,et al.  Results of the Biocompatible Osteoconductive Polymer (BOP) as an Intersomatic Graft in Anterior Cervical Surgery , 1998, Acta Neurochirurgica.

[27]  S. Cook,et al.  In Vivo Evaluation of Recombinant Human Osteogenic Protein (rhOP-1) Implants As a Bone Graft Substitute for Spinal Fusions , 1994, Spine.

[28]  N. Dan A prospective randomized study of anterior single-level cervical disc operations with long-term follow-up: surgical fusion is unnecessary. , 1998, Neurosurgery.

[29]  Derek L. G. Hill,et al.  Measurement of Intraoperative Brain Surface Deformation Under a Craniotomy , 1998, MICCAI.

[30]  D. Clements,et al.  Anterior Cervical Discectomy and Fusion , 1990, Spine.

[31]  H. An,et al.  Comparison Between Allograft Plus Demineralized Bone Matrix Versus Autograft in Anterior Cervical Fusion|A Prospective Multicenter Study , 1995, Spine.

[32]  S. Cook,et al.  In Vivo Evaluation of Anterior Cervical Fusions with Hydroxylapatite Graft Material , 1994, Spine.

[33]  F. P. Wirth,et al.  Anterior cervical discectomy: is fusion necessary? , 1999, Journal of neurosurgery.

[34]  D. Kraus,et al.  The Use of Freeze‐Dried Fibular Allograft ion Anterior Cervical Fusion , 1992, Spine.

[35]  H. J. Senter,et al.  Anterior cervical discectomy with hydroxylapatite fusion. , 1989, Neurosurgery.

[36]  J. Keller,et al.  Anterior cervical discectomy and interbody fusion. An experimental study using a synthetic tricalcium phosphate. , 1979, Journal of neurosurgery.

[37]  E B Siqueira,et al.  Cervical Interbody fusion using calf bone. , 1982, Surgical neurology.

[38]  R. B. Cloward The anterior approach for removal of ruptured cervical disks. , 1958, Journal of neurosurgery.

[39]  D. Kunz,et al.  ▪ Anterior Cervical Discectomy and Fusion Using a Porous Hydroxyapatite Bone Graft Substitute , 1994, Spine.

[40]  K. Nakanishi,et al.  Strain on intervertebral discs after anterior cervical decompression and fusion. , 1999, Spine.

[41]  S. Shapiro Banked fibula and the locking anterior cervical plate in anterior cervical fusions following cervical discectomy. , 1996, Journal of neurosurgery.

[42]  Rish Bl,et al.  Anterior cervical fusion using homologous bone grafts: a comparative study. , 1976 .

[43]  R. Robinson,et al.  The treatment of certain cervical-spine disorders by anterior removal of the intervertebral disc and interbody fusion. , 1958, The Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume.

[44]  T Koyama,et al.  Porous hydroxyapatite ceramics for use in neurosurgical practice. , 1986, Surgical neurology.

[45]  S. L. Griffith,et al.  Intradiscal Pressure Measurements Above an Instrumented Fusion: A Cadaveric Study , 1995, Spine.

[46]  J. Turner,et al.  Natural History and Prognosis of Cervical Spondylosis , 1963, British medical journal.

[47]  M. Brown,et al.  A roentgenographic evaluation of frozen allografts versus autografts in anterior cervical spine fusions. , 1976, Clinical orthopaedics and related research.

[48]  M. Gueramy,et al.  Experience with calf bone in cervical interbody spinal fusion. , 1972, Journal of neurosurgery.

[49]  N S Brooke,et al.  Preliminary experience of carbon fibre cage prostheses for treatment of cervical spine disorders. , 1997, British journal of neurosurgery.

[50]  T. Koyama,et al.  Cervical laminoplasty using apatite beads as implants. Experiences in 31 patients with compressive myelopathy due to developmental canal stenosis. , 1985, Surgical neurology.

[51]  M. Markel,et al.  Cervical Interbody Fusion Cages: An Animal Model With and Without Bone Morphogenetic Protein , 1998, Spine.

[52]  L. Akkermans,et al.  Long-term study of large ceramic implants (porous hydroxyapatite) in dog femora. , 1984, Clinical orthopaedics and related research.

[53]  A. S. Taylor FRACTURE DISLOCATION OF THE CERVICAL SPINE. , 1929, Annals of surgery.

[54]  T. Ducker,et al.  Trends and complications in cervical spine surgery: 1989-1993. , 1997, Journal of spinal disorders.

[55]  R. Hardy,et al.  Relief of pain by anterior cervical-spine fusion for spondylosis. A report of sixty-five patients. , 1973, The Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume.

[56]  E. Hanley,et al.  Types of anterior cervical grafts. , 1992, The Orthopedic clinics of North America.

[57]  P S Ramani,et al.  Cervical spinal interbody fusion with Kiel bone , 1975, The British journal of surgery.

[58]  S. Emery,et al.  Ceramic Anterior Spinal Fusion: Biologic and Biomechanical Comparison in a Canine Model , 1996, Spine.

[59]  T. Yoshimoto,et al.  Biomechanical evaluation of hydroxyapatite intervertebral graft and anterior cervical plating in a porcine cadaveric model. , 1997, Bio-medical materials and engineering.

[60]  Crockard Ha,et al.  Failure of osseous conduction with cervical interbody BOP graft , 1997 .

[61]  R. Doremus,et al.  Dense hydroxylapatite: fatigue and fracture strength after various treatments, from diametral tests , 1980 .

[62]  A. Hilibrand,et al.  Radiculopathy and myelopathy at segments adjacent to the site of a previous anterior cervical arthrodesis. , 1999, The Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume.

[63]  S. Cook,et al.  Evaluation of Hydroxylapatite Graft Materials in Canine Cervical Spine Fusions , 1986, Spine.

[64]  G. McMurray The evaluation of Kiel bone in spinal fusions. , 1982, The Journal of bone and joint surgery. British volume.

[65]  R. Laing,et al.  A survey of the peri-operative management of patients undergoing anterior cervical decompression in the UK and Eire. , 1998, British journal of neurosurgery.

[66]  K. S. St John,et al.  Comparison of anterior cervical fusions using autogenous bone graft obtained from the cervical vertebrae to the modified Smith-Robinson technique. , 1994, Journal of spinal disorders.

[67]  Augustus A. White,et al.  Clinical Biomechanics of Cervical Spine Implants , 1989, Spine.

[68]  L. Claes,et al.  Intradiscal pressure recordings in the cervical spine. , 1999, Neurosurgery.

[69]  L. Riley,et al.  The results of anterior interbody fusion of the cervical spine. Review of ninety-three consecutive cases. , 1962, Journal of neurosurgery.

[70]  L. Riley,et al.  Results of anterior interbody fusion of the cervical spine. , 1968, Clinical orthopaedics and related research.

[71]  M. Brown,et al.  Bone allografts in spinal surgery. , 1981, Clinical orthopaedics and related research.

[72]  V. Sonntag,et al.  Is fusion necessary after anterior cervical discectomy , 1996 .

[73]  P. Marks,et al.  Extrusion of BOP-B graft orally following anterior cervical discectomy and fusion. , 1996, British journal of neurosurgery.

[74]  G. Cantore Long-term results with Kiel bone grafts using the Cloward procedure. , 1981, Journal of Neurosurgical Sciences.

[75]  G. Muschler,et al.  Evaluation of Collagen Ceramic Composite Graft Materials in a Spinal Fusion Model , 1996, Clinical orthopaedics and related research.

[76]  M. J. van den Bent,et al.  Anterior Cervical Discectomy With or Without Fusion With Acrylate: A Randomized Trial , 1996, Spine.

[77]  B. Cunningham,et al.  A biomechanical analysis of decompression and reconstruction methods in the cervical spine. Emphasis on a carbon-fiber-composite cage. , 1993, The Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume.

[78]  T. Karring,et al.  Kielbone in new attachment attempts in Humans. , 1981, Journal of periodontology.

[79]  Cloward Rb The anterior surgical approach to the cervical spine: the cloward procedure: past, present, and future ― The presidential guest lecture, cervical spine research society , 1988 .

[80]  F. Kummer,et al.  Optimal Selection and Preparation of Fresh Frozen Corticocancellous Allografts for Cervical Interbody Spinal Fusion , 1998, Spine.

[81]  A. Hilibrand,et al.  The Success of Anterior Cervical Arthrodesis Adjacent to a Previous Fusion , 1997, Spine.

[82]  H. An,et al.  Evaluation of Porous Biphasic Calcium Phosphate Ceramics for Anterior Cervical Interbody Fusion in a Caprine Model , 1995, Spine.

[83]  N. Sharkey,et al.  Bone ingrowth and mechanical properties of coralline hydroxyapatite 1 yr after implantation. , 1993, Biomaterials.

[84]  R. Kirollos,et al.  Value of early postoperative plain radiography following BOP fusion in cervical spinal surgery. , 1997, British Journal of Neurosurgery.