Combining Equity and Utilitarianism in a Mathematical Programming Model

We discuss the problem of combining the conflicting objectives of equity and utilitarianism, for social policy making, in a single mathematical programming model. The definition of equity we use is the Rawlsian one of maximizing the minimum utility over individuals or classes of individuals. However, when the disparity of utility becomes too great, the objective becomes progressively utilitarian. Such a model is particularly applicable not only to health provision but to other areas as well. Building a mixed-integer/linear programming (MILP) formulation of the problem raises technical issues, because the objective function is nonconvex and the hypograph is not MILP representable in its initial form. We present a succinct formulation and show that it is “sharp” in the sense that its linear programming relaxation describes the convex hull of the feasible set (before extra resource allocation or policy constraints are added). We apply the formulation to a healthcare planning problem and show that instances of realistic size are easily solved by standard MILP software. This paper was accepted by Dimitris Bertsimas, optimization.

[1]  Walter Bossert,et al.  Utilitarianism and the Theory of Justice , 2002 .

[2]  Dimitris Bertsimas,et al.  The Price of Fairness , 2011, Oper. Res..

[3]  John Broome,et al.  Good, Fairness and QALYs , 1988, Royal Institute of Philosophy Lecture Series.

[4]  Amartya Sen,et al.  Utilitarianism and beyond: Contents , 1982 .

[5]  Ronald Dworkin,et al.  Taking Rights Seriously , 1977 .

[6]  A A Stinnett,et al.  Mathematical programming for the efficient allocation of health care resources. , 1996, Journal of health economics.

[7]  Robert G. Jeroslow,et al.  Representability in mixed integer programmiing, I: Characterization results , 1987, Discret. Appl. Math..

[8]  J. Roemer.  Theories of Distributive Justice , 1997 .

[9]  H. Peyton Young,et al.  Equity - in theory and practice , 1994 .

[10]  E G Lowrie,et al.  The quality of life of patients with end-stage renal disease. , 1985, The New England journal of medicine.

[11]  R. Cookson,et al.  Equity–efficiency trade-offs in health technology assessment , 2006, International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care.

[12]  A. Williams.  Economics of coronary artery bypass grafting. , 1985, British medical journal.

[13]  H. Paul Williams,et al.  Logic and Integer Programming , 2009, Logic and Integer Programming.

[14]  J. Hooker,et al.  Logic-Based Methods for Optimization: Combining Optimization and Constraint Satisfaction , 2000 .

[15]  Hanan Luss,et al.  On Equitable Resource Allocation Problems: A Lexicographic Minimax Approach , 1999, Oper. Res..

[16]  M. Yaari,et al.  On dividing justly , 1984 .

[17]  Dritan Nace,et al.  Max-min fairness and its applications to routing and load-balancing in communication networks: a tutorial , 2008, IEEE Communications Surveys & Tutorials.

[18]  John N. Hooker,et al.  Integrated methods for optimization , 2011, International series in operations research and management science.

[19]  Wlodzimierz Ogryczak,et al.  On the lexicographic minimax approach to location problems , 1997, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[20]  Christos Douligeris,et al.  Fairness in network optimal flow control: optimality of product forms , 1991, IEEE Trans. Commun..

[21]  Or Chronicle.  ON EQUITABLE RESOURCE ALLOCATION PROBLEMS: A LEXICOGRAPHIC MINIMAX APPROACH , 1999 .

[22]  John N. Hooker.  A Principled Approach to Mixed Integer/Linear Problem Formulation , 2009 .

[23]  Mark S. Stein,et al.  Distributive Justice and Disability: Utilitarianism Against Egalitarianism , 2006, Utilitas.

[24]  P. Dolan,et al.  The measurement of individual utility and social welfare. , 1998, Journal of health economics.

[25]  Norman Daniels,et al.  Reading Rawls : critical studies on Rawls' 'A theory of justice' , 1975 .

[26]  A. Sen,et al.  Utilitarianism and Beyond , 1982 .

[27]  Rakesh V. Vohra,et al.  Towards equitable distribution via proportional equity constraints , 1993, Math. Program..

[28]  W. Gaertner.  A Primer in Social Choice Theory , 2006 .

[29]  K. Taylor.  Natural justice. , 1998, The Lamp.

[30]  A Briggs,et al.  Using cost effectiveness information , 2000, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[31]  Frank Kelly,et al.  Rate control for communication networks: shadow prices, proportional fairness and stability , 1998, J. Oper. Res. Soc..

[32]  R. Cookson,et al.  Equity in health , 2000 .

[33]  Anthony J. Culyer,et al.  Center for the Evaluation of Value and Risk in Health , 2014 .

[34]  John N. Hooker,et al.  Optimality Conditions for Distributive Justice , 2009, ISAIM.