Human Reliability Analysis (HRA) in surgery: Identification and assessment of Influencing Factors

Abstract Several authors encouraged the application of Human Reliability Analysis (HRA) to patient care, recognising the benefits it brought to high-risk industries in terms of human errors reduction, thanks to its anticipative approach. However, the literature on HRA in healthcare is still scanty, and shows significant gaps at methodological level. Only a very limited number of HRA studies implemented Influencing Factors (IFs) analysis in the quantification of the Human Error Probability, despite it represents a peculiar component and a well-established step in several HRA techniques. Furthermore, the need for a deep adaptation and translation of existing HRA techniques to the healthcare domain is emphasised by several authors. This paper aims at designing a taxonomy of Influencing Factors for HRA studies in surgery, and assessing their influence on surgeons’ technical performance by means of structured elicitation of experts’ judgement. An ad hoc taxonomy of 21 IFs has been validated through focus group and individual interviews, in Denmark and Italy; 215 questionnaires from expert surgeons in open and mini-invasive surgeries were then used for the quantification of the impact of each IF on surgeons’ performance. An investigation on the possible influence of different surgical techniques revealed that only two out of the twenty-one IFs show different probability density functions (pdf) when considered in open or mini-invasive surgeries. The study offers an original and relevant contribution to the development of domain-specific knowledge and, as such, to fostering the diffusion of HRA studies in healthcare, and in surgery in particular.

[1]  P S White,et al.  Using human reliability analysis to detect surgical error in endoscopic DCR surgery. , 2003, Clinical otolaryngology and allied sciences.

[2]  Alfred Cuschieri,et al.  Abdominal Wall Lift Versus Positive-Pressure Capnoperitoneum for Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy: Randomized Controlled Trial , 2004, Annals of surgery.

[3]  F Castiglia,et al.  Risk analysis using fuzzy set theory of the accidental exposure of medical staff during brachytherapy procedures , 2010, Journal of radiological protection : official journal of the Society for Radiological Protection.

[4]  M. Makary,et al.  Medical error—the third leading cause of death in the US , 2016, British Medical Journal.

[5]  George B Hanna,et al.  Is Competency Assessment at the Specialist Level Achievable? A Study for the National Training Programme in Laparoscopic Colorectal Surgery in England , 2013, Annals of surgery.

[6]  Using expert models in human reliability analysis-a dependence assessment method based on fuzzy logic. , 2010, Risk analysis : an official publication of the Society for Risk Analysis.

[7]  Wondea Jung,et al.  A taxonomy of performance influencing factors for human reliability analysis of emergency tasks , 2003 .

[8]  David Johnson,et al.  The triangular distribution as a proxy for the beta distribution in risk analysis , 1997 .

[9]  Melinda Lyons,et al.  Towards a framework to select techniques for error prediction: supporting novice users in the healthcare sector. , 2009, Applied ergonomics.

[10]  Samuel Kotz,et al.  A novel method for fitting unimodal continuous distributions on a bounded domain utilizing expert judgment estimates , 2006 .

[11]  Su Golder,et al.  Mixed methods research , 2007 .

[12]  Akio Koizumi,et al.  Application of Human Reliability Analysis to Nursing Errors in Hospitals , 2004, Risk analysis : an official publication of the Society for Risk Analysis.

[13]  Alfred Cuschieri,et al.  Proficiency-gain curve for an advanced laparoscopic procedure defined by observation clinical human reliability assessment (OCHRA) , 2009, Surgical Endoscopy.

[14]  A. Cuschieri,et al.  Analysis of technical surgical errors during initial experience of laparoscopic pyloromyotomy by a group of dutch pediatric surgeons , 2004, Surgical Endoscopy.

[15]  A Cuschieri,et al.  Human reliability assessment in surgery--a new approach for improving surgical performance and clinical outcome. , 2000, Annals of the Royal College of Surgeons of England.

[16]  Richard A. Krueger,et al.  Focus groups : a practical guide for applied research / by Richard A. Krueger , 1989 .

[17]  Erik Hollnagel,et al.  Cognitive reliability and error analysis method : CREAM , 1998 .

[18]  A. Cuschieri,et al.  Competence Assessment of Laparoscopic Operative and Cognitive Skills: Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE) or Observational Clinical Human Reliability Assessment (OCHRA) , 2006, World Journal of Surgery.

[19]  Andrea Saltelli,et al.  Sensitivity Analysis for Importance Assessment , 2002, Risk analysis : an official publication of the Society for Risk Analysis.

[20]  R. Burke Johnson,et al.  Mixed Methods Research , 2012 .

[21]  Alfred Cuschieri,et al.  Human reliability analysis (HRA) techniques and observational clinical HRA , 2010, Minimally invasive therapy & allied technologies : MITAT : official journal of the Society for Minimally Invasive Therapy.

[22]  Kal Ansari,et al.  High definition video teaching module for learning neck dissection , 2014, Journal of Otolaryngology - Head & Neck Surgery.

[23]  C J MacEwen,et al.  Human reliability analysis: a new method to quantify errors in cataract surgery , 2008, Eye.

[24]  C. Rafele,et al.  A systemic methodology for risk management in healthcare sector , 2011 .

[25]  Marie F. Shoffner,et al.  Focus Groups: A Practical and Applied Research Approach for Counselors , 2007 .

[26]  C. Verbano,et al.  A human factors and reliability approach to clinical risk management: Evidence from Italian cases , 2010 .

[27]  Benjie Tang,et al.  The effect of divided attention on novices and experts in laparoscopic task performance , 2015, Surgical Endoscopy.

[28]  A. Cuschieri,et al.  Errors enacted during endoscopic surgery--a human reliability analysis. , 1998, Applied ergonomics.

[29]  Vinh N. Dang,et al.  Understanding human performance in sociotechnical systems – Steps towards a generic framework , 2017, Safety Science.

[30]  C. Vincent,et al.  Framework for analysing risk and safety in clinical medicine. , 1998, BMJ.

[31]  Liam Chadwick,et al.  Human reliability assessment of a critical nursing task in a radiotherapy treatment process. , 2012, Applied ergonomics.

[32]  B Kirwan,et al.  The validation of three human reliability quantification techniques--THERP, HEART and JHEDI: Part II--Results of validation exercise. , 1997, Applied ergonomics.

[33]  G. Hanna,et al.  Application of objective clinical human reliability analysis (OCHRA) in assessment of technical performance in laparoscopic rectal cancer surgery , 2016, Techniques in Coloproctology.

[34]  Charles Vincent,et al.  Human reliability analysis in healthcare: A review of techniques , 2004 .

[35]  Vinod Gauba,et al.  Human Reliability Analysis of Cataract Surgery. , 2008, Archives of ophthalmology.

[36]  H Ashrafian,et al.  Safety of training and assessment in operating theatres – a systematic review and meta-analysis , 2013, Perfusion.

[37]  Esa M. Rantanen,et al.  Human Reliability Analysis in Healthcare , 2012 .

[38]  Luca Podofillini,et al.  Developing the foundations of a cognition-based human reliability analysis model via mapping task types and performance-influencing factors: Application to radiotherapy , 2017 .

[39]  Danilo Miskovic,et al.  Observational clinical human reliability analysis (OCHRA) for competency assessment in laparoscopic colorectal surgery at the specialist level , 2012, Surgical Endoscopy.

[40]  Anselm L. Strauss,et al.  Basics of qualitative research : techniques and procedures for developing grounded theory , 1998 .

[41]  Paolo Trucco,et al.  Towards a Taxonomy of Influencing Factors for Human Reliability Analysis (HRA) Applications in Surgery , 2015 .

[42]  A Cuschieri,et al.  Identification and categorization of technical errors by Observational Clinical Human Reliability Assessment (OCHRA) during laparoscopic cholecystectomy. , 2004, Archives of surgery.