Prediction of Reading Comprehension: Relative Contributions of Word Recognition, Language Proficiency, and Other Cognitive Skills Can Depend on How Comprehension Is Measured

Reading comprehension scores from the Wechsler Individual Achievement Tests, the Gates-MacGinitie Reading Test, and the Gray Oral Reading Test were examined in relation to measures of reading, language, and other cognitive skills that have been hypothesized to contribute to comprehension and account for comprehension differences. In a sample of 97 first through tenth graders, the relative contributions of word recognition/decoding and oral language skills to comprehension varied from test to test. The inclusion of reading speed accounted for additional variance, but prediction of comprehension scores was minimally improved by including measures of rapid serial naming, verbal memory, IQ, or attention. The findings suggest that commonly used tests of reading comprehension, such as the three we compared, may not tap the same array of cognitive processes. Implications for research and practice are discussed.

[1]  Rosemary Tannock,et al.  Listening Comprehension and Working Memory Are Impaired in Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder Irrespective of Language Impairment , 2003, Journal of abnormal child psychology.

[2]  T. Conway,et al.  Intensive Remedial Instruction for Children with Severe Reading Disabilities , 2001, Journal of learning disabilities.

[3]  Bente Eriksen Hagtvet,et al.  Listening comprehension and reading comprehension in poor decoders: Evidence for the importance of syntactic and semantic skills as well as phonological skills , 2003 .

[4]  H. Scarborough,et al.  Very early language deficits in dyslexic children. , 1990, Child development.

[5]  C. Perfetti,et al.  Relationship Between Single Word Decoding and Reading Comprehension Skill , 1975 .

[6]  Jack M. Fletcher,et al.  Early Interventions for Children with Reading Disabilities. , 1997 .

[7]  T. Achenbach.  Manual for the child behavior checklist/4-18 and 1991 profile , 1991 .

[8]  John O. Willis,et al.  Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test–Third Edition , 2008 .

[9]  Richard K. Olson,et al.  The Etiology and Remediation of Phonologically Based Word Recognition and Spelling Disabilities: Are Phonological Deficits the 'Hole' Story? , 1997 .

[10]  J. Epstein,et al.  Conners Rating Scales-Revised. , 1999 .

[11]  K. Nation,et al.  Assessing reading difficulties: the validity and utility of current measures of reading skill. , 1997, The British journal of educational psychology.

[12]  S. Ellis Weismer,et al.  Language deficits in poor comprehenders: a case for the simple view of reading. , 2006, Journal of speech, language, and hearing research : JSLHR.

[13]  J. B. Wyman,et al.  What is reading ability , 1921 .

[14]  P. Skudlarski,et al.  Development of left occipitotemporal systems for skilled reading in children after a phonologically- based intervention , 2004, Biological Psychiatry.

[15]  Jack M. Fletcher,et al.  Comprehension and Decoding: Patterns of Association in Children With Reading Difficulties , 1999 .

[16]  L. Cohen.  Wechsler Individual Achievement Test. , 1993 .

[17]  Jack M. Fletcher,et al.  The Role of Instruction in Learning To Read: Preventing Reading Failure in At-Risk Children. , 1998 .

[18]  Donald Shankweiler,et al.  Words to Meanings , 1999 .

[19]  K. Nation,et al.  Working memory deficits in poor comprehenders reflect underlying language impairments. , 1999, Journal of experimental child psychology.

[20]  T. Conway,et al.  Preventing reading failure in young children with phonological processing disabilities: Group and individual responses to instruction. , 1999 .

[21]  K. A. Williams,et al.  Not All Reading Disabilities Are Alike , 1999, Journal of learning disabilities.

[22]  Rachelle M. Bruno,et al.  Comprehensive Test of Phonological Processing (CTOPP) , 1999 .

[23]  K. Nation,et al.  Developmental differences in sensitivity to semantic relations among good and poor comprehenders: evidence from semantic priming , 1999, Cognition.

[24]  H. Swanson,et al.  Learning disabled and average readers' working memory and comprehension: does metacognition play a role? , 1996, British Journal of Educational Psychology.

[25]  D. Share,et al.  Language Impairment at School Entry and Later Reading Disability: Connections at Lexical Versus Supralexical Levels of Reading , 2004 .

[26]  Kate Nation,et al.  Children's Reading Comprehension Difficulties , 2008 .

[27]  H. Lee Swanson,et al.  Working memory in skilled and less skilled readers , 1989, Journal of abnormal child psychology.

[28]  Jack M. Fletcher,et al.  Dimensions Affecting the Assessment of Reading Comprehension , 2005 .

[29]  William H. Rupley,et al.  Exploration of the Developmental Components Contributing to Elementary School Children's Reading Comprehension , 1998 .

[30]  G. Whitehurst,et al.  Oral language and code-related precursors to reading: evidence from a longitudinal structural model. , 2002, Developmental psychology.

[31]  J. Bowey.  Syntactic awareness in relation to reading skill and ongoing reading comprehension monitoring. , 1986 .

[32]  M W Lovett,et al.  A developmental approach to reading disability: accuracy and speed criteria of normal and deficient reading skill. , 1987, Child development.

[33]  Joseph K. Torgesen,et al.  Effects of two types of phonological awareness training on word learning in kindergarten children. , 1992 .

[34]  Joseph K. Torgesen,et al.  Individual Differences in Response to Early Interventions in Reading: The Lingering Problem of Treatment Resisters , 2000 .

[35]  H. Scarborough,et al.  Late-emerging reading disabilities. , 2003 .

[36]  J. Torgesen,et al.  The Effectiveness of a Group Reading Instruction Program with Poor Readers in Multiple Grades , 2001 .

[37]  L. Fuchs,et al.  Sources of Individual Differences in Reading Comprehension and Reading Fluency. , 2003 .

[38]  W. Warde,et al.  THE COMPONENT MODEL OF READING: SIMPLE VIEW OF READING MADE A LITTLE MORE COMPLEX , 2000 .

[39]  Peter W. Foltz,et al.  Sources of comprehension failure: Theoretical perspectives and case studies. , 1996 .

[40]  Philip B. Gough,et al.  Decoding, Reading, and Reading Disability , 1986 .

[41]  S. Jay Samuels,et al.  Toward a theory of automatic information processing in reading , 1974 .

[42]  Margaret J. Snowling,et al.  Semantic processing and the development of word-recognition skills: Evidence from children with reading comprehension difficulties. , 1998 .

[43]  E. Kaplan,et al.  The Boston naming test , 2001 .

[44]  R. Tannock,et al.  Reading comprehension and reading related abilities in adolescents with reading disabilities and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. , 2004, Dyslexia.

[45]  David Wechsler,et al.  Manual for the Wechsler intelligence scale for children , 1974 .

[46]  A. B. Hollingshead,et al.  Four factor index of social status , 1975 .

[47]  M. Lovett.  Treating the Core Deficits of Developmental Dyslexia: Evidence of Transfer of Learning after Phonologically- and Strategy-Based Reading Training Programs. , 1994 .

[48]  P. Carpenter,et al.  Individual differences in working memory and reading , 1980 .

[49]  J. Tomblin,et al.  Language Basis of Reading and Reading Disabilities: Evidence From a Longitudinal Investigation , 1999 .

[50]  C. Juel.  Learning to read and write: A longitudinal study of 54 children from first through fourth grades. , 1988 .

[51]  Margaret J. Snowling,et al.  Factors influencing syntactic awareness skills in normal readers and poor comprehenders , 2000 .

[52]  H. Scarborough,et al.  Predicting, Explaining, and Preventing Children's Reading Difficulties , 2001 .

[53]  Frank R. Vellutino,et al.  Components of reading ability: Issues and problems in operationalizing word identification, phonological coding, and orthographic coding. , 1994 .

[54]  D. R. Smith,et al.  CHAPTER 6 – Wechsler Individual Achievement Test , 2001 .

[55]  G. Lyon,et al.  Toward a definition of dyslexia , 1995, Annals of dyslexia.

[56]  M. Barnes,et al.  Comprehension skill, inference-making ability, and their relation to knowledge , 2001, Memory & cognition.

[57]  Marilyn Jager Adams,et al.  Beginning To Read: Thinking and Learning about Print. , 1991 .

[58]  Louise Spear-Swerling.  FOURTH GRADERS' PERFORMANCE ON A STATE-MANDATED ASSESSMENT INVOLVING TWO DIFFERENT MEASURES OF READING COMPREHENSION , 2004 .