Reliable predictive computational toxicology methods for mixture toxicity: toward the development of innovative integrated models for environmental risk assessment

A main objective in the field of mixture toxicity is to determine how well combined effects are predictable based on the known effects of mixture constituents. Conducting toxicity tests for all conceivable combinations of chemicals, to understand all mechanisms in the combined toxicity of environmental pollutants, is virtually unfeasible due to cost- and time-consuming procedures. Therefore, predictive tools for mixture toxicity are required to be developed within the applicable range of predictive toxicology. The concept of concentration addition (CA) model is often considered a general method for estimating mixture toxicity at the regulatory level. In the long run, however, the possibility of toxicological synergism between mixture components actually occurs, especially from the no-effect level or non-toxic substances. This is ignored under the CA concept, and needs to be examined and integrated into existing addition models at a scientific level, this paper reviews existing integrated models for estimating the toxicity of complex mixtures in literature. Current approaches to assess mixture toxicity and the need for new research concepts to overcome challenges which recent studies have confronted are discussed, particularly those involved in computational approaches to predict mixture toxicity in an environment risk assessment based on mixture components.

[1]  S. D. Kim,et al.  Estimating the combined toxicity by two‐step prediction model on the complicated chemical mixtures from wastewater treatment plant effluents , 2006, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[2]  Ryo Shoji The Potential Performance of Artificial Neural Networks in QSTRs for Predicting Ecotoxicity of Environmental Pollutants , 2005 .

[3]  S. Loewe,et al.  Über Kombinationswirkungen , 1926, Naunyn-Schmiedebergs Archiv für experimentelle Pathologie und Pharmakologie.

[4]  C. I. Bliss THE TOXICITY OF POISONS APPLIED JOINTLY1 , 1939 .

[5]  P. Lassen,et al.  Physico-chemical properties , 2008 .

[6]  A. Olmstead,et al.  Toxicity Assessment of Environmentally Relevant Pollutant Mixtures Using a Heuristic Model , 2005, Integrated environmental assessment and management.

[7]  Zhen Li,et al.  A comparison of machine learning algorithms for chemical toxicity classification using a simulated multi-scale data model , 2008, BMC Bioinformatics.

[8]  X. Wang,et al.  QSAR for Prediction of Joint Toxicity of Substituted Phenols to Tadpoles (Rana japonica) , 2003, Bulletin of environmental contamination and toxicology.

[9]  P. Gramatica,et al.  Mixture Toxicity of Priority Pollutants at No Observed Effect Concentrations (NOECs) , 2002, Ecotoxicology.

[10]  Christopher J. Borgert,et al.  Chemical Mixtures: An Unsolvable Riddle? , 2004 .

[11]  J. Hermens,et al.  Computer-modeling-based QSARs for analyzing experimental data on biotransformation and toxicity. , 2001, Toxicology in vitro : an international journal published in association with BIBRA.

[12]  J. Belden,et al.  Challenges in regulating pesticide mixtures , 2004 .

[13]  Victor J. Feron,et al.  Toxicology of chemical mixtures: international perspective. , 1998, Environmental health perspectives.

[14]  W. Greco,et al.  Extrapolation Concepts for Dealing with Multiple Contamination in Environmental Risk Assessment , 2009, Integrated environmental assessment and management.

[15]  D. Spurgeon,et al.  Measurement and modeling of the toxicity of binary mixtures in the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans—a test of independent action , 2009, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[16]  M Mwense,et al.  QSAR approach for mixture toxicity prediction using independent latent descriptors and fuzzy membership functions , 2006, SAR and QSAR in environmental research.

[17]  L. Cluff,et al.  Studies on the epidemiology of adverse drug reactions. V. Clinical factors influencing susceptibility. , 1966, Annals of internal medicine.

[18]  Kamil Kuca,et al.  What are artificial neural networks and what they can do? , 2005, Biomedical papers of the Medical Faculty of the University Palacky, Olomouc, Czechoslovakia.

[19]  M. Andersen,et al.  Mechanistic approaches for mixture risk assessments-present capabilities with simple mixtures and future directions. , 2004, Environmental toxicology and pharmacology.

[20]  Nagamany Nirmalakhandan,et al.  Use of QSAR models in predicting joint effects in multi-component mixtures of organic chemicals , 1998 .

[21]  T Wind,et al.  Ecotoxicity quantitative structure-activity relationships for alcohol ethoxylate mixtures based on substance-specific toxicity predictions. , 2006, Ecotoxicology and environmental safety.

[22]  K. Yin,et al.  Quantification of joint effect for hydrogen bond and development of QSARs for predicting mixture toxicity. , 2003, Chemosphere.

[23]  J. Streibig,et al.  A review of independent action compared to concentration addition as reference models for mixtures of compounds with different molecular target sites , 2008 .

[24]  K. Yin,et al.  A simple hydrophobicity-based approach to predict the toxicity of unknown organic micropollutant mixtures in marine water. , 2005, Marine pollution bulletin.

[25]  T. K. Reffstrup Risk assessment of mixtures of pesticides , 2012 .

[26]  Paolo Frasconi,et al.  Neural Networks and Kernel Machines for Vector and Structured Data , 2005 .

[27]  K. Boekelheide Toxicological highlight : Mixed messages , 2007 .

[28]  J. Larsen,et al.  Risk assessment of mixtures of pesticides. Current approaches and future strategies. , 2010, Regulatory toxicology and pharmacology : RTP.

[29]  J. Groten,et al.  Toxicological evaluation and risk assessment of chemical mixtures. , 1998, Critical reviews in toxicology.

[30]  Dr. Gerald Pöch Combined Effects of Drugs and Toxic Agents , 1993, Springer Vienna.

[31]  M. Lydy,et al.  Synergistic toxicity of atrazine and organophosphate insecticides contravenes the response addition mixture model , 1997 .

[32]  Radford M. Neal Pattern Recognition and Machine Learning , 2007, Technometrics.

[33]  Theo Vermeire,et al.  Risk assessment of chemicals : an introduction , 2007 .

[34]  Gerald T Ankley,et al.  Computational toxicology: framework, partnerships, and program development. September 29-30, 2003, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina. , 2005, Reproductive toxicology.

[35]  G. LeBlanc,et al.  Synergistic interaction of endocrine‐disrupting chemicals: Model development using an ecdysone receptor antagonist and a hormone synthesis inhibitor , 2004, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[36]  T. Backhaus,et al.  Predictability of the mixture toxicity of 12 similarly acting congeneric inhibitors of photosystem II in marine periphyton and epipsammon communities. , 2004, Aquatic toxicology.

[37]  A. Kortenkamp,et al.  Approaches to assessing combination effects of oestrogenic environmental pollutants. , 1999, The Science of the total environment.

[38]  Gehui Wang,et al.  Prediction of mixture toxicity with its total hydrophobicity. , 2002, Chemosphere.

[39]  Hugh Hansen,et al.  Using the ATSDR Guidance Manual for the Assessment of Joint Toxic Action of Chemical Mixtures. , 2004, Environmental toxicology and pharmacology.

[40]  R. Altenburger,et al.  What contributes to the combined effect of a complex mixture? , 2004, Environmental science & technology.

[41]  Linda K Teuschler,et al.  Deciding which chemical mixtures risk assessment methods work best for what mixtures. , 2007, Toxicology and applied pharmacology.

[42]  C. Rider,et al.  An integrated addition and interaction model for assessing toxicity of chemical mixtures. , 2005, Toxicological sciences : an official journal of the Society of Toxicology.

[43]  D. J. Finney THE ANALYSIS OF TOXICITY TESTS ON MIXTURES OF POISONS , 1942 .

[44]  E. Calabrese Paradigm lost, paradigm found: the re-emergence of hormesis as a fundamental dose response model in the toxicological sciences. , 2005, Environmental pollution.

[45]  D. Roberts QSAR issues in aquatic toxicity of surfactants. , 1991, The Science of the total environment.

[46]  J. Hermens,et al.  Surrogate parameter for the baseline toxicity content of contaminated water: simulating the bioconcentration of mixtures of pollutants and counting molecules. , 1995, Environmental science & technology.

[47]  R. Altenburger,et al.  Algal toxicity of nitrobenzenes: Combined effect analysis as a pharmacological probe for similar modes of interaction , 2005, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[48]  Richard C Hertzberg,et al.  Synergy and other ineffective mixture risk definitions. , 2002, The Science of the total environment.

[49]  J. Deneer Toxicity of mixtures of pesticides in aquatic systems , 2000 .

[50]  T. Backhaus,et al.  Toxicity of a mixture of dissimilarly acting substances to natural algal communities: predictive power and limitations of independent action and concentration addition. , 2004, Environmental science & technology.

[51]  A. Kortenkamp,et al.  Combining xenoestrogens at levels below individual no-observed-effect concentrations dramatically enhances steroid hormone action. , 2002, Environmental health perspectives.

[52]  Li Zhang,et al.  Computer-based QSARs for predicting mixture toxicity of benzene and its derivatives. , 2007, Chemosphere.

[53]  P. Gramatica,et al.  Water quality objectives for mixtures of toxic chemicals: problems and perspectives. , 2003, Ecotoxicology and environmental safety.

[54]  Ord,et al.  Guidelines for the Health Risk Assessment of Chemical Mixtures , 2014 .

[55]  T. Backhaus,et al.  Application and validation of approaches for the predictive hazard assessment of realistic pesticide mixtures. , 2006, Aquatic toxicology.

[56]  C. Hansch,et al.  QSAR treatment of multiple toxicities: the mutagenicity and cytotoxicity of quinolines. , 1997, Mutation research.

[57]  J. Belden,et al.  How Well Can We Predict the Toxicity of Pesticide Mixtures to Aquatic Life? , 2007 .

[58]  R. Altenburger,et al.  Mixture toxicity and its modeling by quantitative structure‐activity relationships , 2003, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[59]  Anita Young,et al.  Prediction of Noninteractive Mixture Toxicity of Organic Compounds Based on a Fuzzy Set Method , 2004, J. Chem. Inf. Model..

[60]  Ken Sexton,et al.  Assessing Cumulative Health Risks from Exposure to Environmental Mixtures—Three Fundamental Questions , 2007, Environmental health perspectives.

[61]  Z. Y. Chen,et al.  Joint Toxicity Evaluation and QSAR Modeling of Aromatic Amines and Phenols to Bacteria , 2009, Bulletin of environmental contamination and toxicology.

[62]  J W Clark,et al.  Neural network modelling , 1991, Physics in medicine and biology.

[63]  Nina Cedergreen,et al.  On the Use of Mixture Toxicity Assessment in REACH and the Water Framework Directive: A Review , 2009 .

[64]  R. A. McGill,et al.  Solubility properties in polymers and biological media. II. A new method for the characterisation of the adsorption of gases and vapours on solids. , 1987, Journal of chromatography.

[65]  Shixiang Gao,et al.  Use of partition coefficients to predict mixture toxicity. , 2003, Water research.

[66]  Lars Carlsen,et al.  The Interplay between QSAR/QSPR Studies and Partial Order Ranking and Formal Concept Analyses , 2009, International journal of molecular sciences.

[67]  Thomas Hartung,et al.  Chemical regulators have overreached , 2009, Nature.

[68]  C. T. Chiou,et al.  Reply to comments by MacIntyre and Smith on: Partition equilibria of nonionic organic compounds between soil-organic matter and water. , 1984, Environmental science & technology.

[69]  J. Devillers,et al.  Practical applications of quantitative structure-activity relationships (QSAR) in environmental chemistry and toxicology , 1990 .

[70]  C. Blaise,et al.  Predicting the toxicity of complex mixtures using artificial neural networks. , 1997, Chemosphere.

[71]  Gerrit Schüürmann,et al.  Quantitative structure-activity relationships in environmental sciences, VII , 1997 .

[72]  J. Streibig,et al.  A review of independent action compared to concentration addition as reference models for mixtures of compounds with different molecular target sites , 2008, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[73]  Ian Fleming,et al.  Frontier Orbitals and Organic Chemical Reactions , 1977 .

[74]  G. Schaumann,et al.  Comparative Study of Risk Assessment Approaches Based on Different Methods for Deriving DNEL and PNEC of Chemical Mixtures , 2010 .

[75]  E. Thurman,et al.  Pharmaceuticals, hormones, and other organic wastewater contaminants in U.S. streams, 1999-2000: a national reconnaissance. , 2002, Environmental science & technology.

[76]  M. Vijver,et al.  Toxicological mixture models are based on inadequate assumptions. , 2010, Environmental science & technology.

[77]  P. Burkhardt-Holm,et al.  Challenges in ecotoxicology. , 2004, Environmental science & technology.

[78]  P. Gramatica,et al.  Joint algal toxicity of 16 dissimilarly acting chemicals is predictable by the concept of independent action. , 2003, Aquatic toxicology.

[79]  R. Taft,et al.  Solubility properties in polymers and biological media. 7. An analysis of toxicant properties that influence inhibition of bioluminescence in Photobacterium phosphoreum (the Microtox test). , 1986, Environmental science & technology.

[80]  Jens C. Streibig,et al.  The Occurrence of Hormesis in Plants and Algae , 2007, Dose-response : a publication of International Hormesis Society.

[81]  V. Ranade,et al.  Risk Assessment of Chemicals-An Introduction, 2nd ed , 2009 .

[82]  T. Backhaus,et al.  Predictability of the toxicity of multiple chemical mixtures to Vibrio fischeri: Mixtures composed of similarly acting chemicals , 2000 .

[83]  Patricia Ruiz,et al.  Computational Toxicology Methods in Public Health Practice , 2008, Toxicology mechanisms and methods.

[84]  R. L. Plackett,et al.  Quantal Responses to Mixtures of Poisons , 1952 .

[85]  Y. Wang,et al.  Integrated fuzzy concentration addition-independent action (IFCA-IA) model outperforms two-stage prediction (TSP) for predicting mixture toxicity. , 2009, Chemosphere.

[86]  W. Boedeker,et al.  Assessment of the Combined Effects of Substances: The Relationship between Concentration Addition and Independent Action , 1995 .

[87]  D. Hawker,et al.  The number of components in a mixture determines whether synergistic and antagonistic or additive toxicity predominate: the funnel hypothesis. , 1995, Ecotoxicology and environmental safety.

[88]  J. Karlsson,et al.  Are individual NOEC levels safe for mixtures? A study on mixture toxicity of brominated flame-retardants in the copepod Nitocra spinipes. , 2008, Chemosphere.

[89]  T. Backhaus,et al.  Predictability of the toxicity of a multiple mixture of dissimilarly acting chemicals to Vibrio fischeri , 2000 .

[90]  J. Groten,et al.  Toxicological evaluation of chemical mixtures. , 2002, Food and chemical toxicology : an international journal published for the British Industrial Biological Research Association.

[91]  E. Michael Thurman,et al.  Response to Comment on “Pharmaceuticals, Hormones, and Other Organic Wastewater Contaminants in U.S. Streams, 1999−2000: A National Reconnaissance” , 2002 .

[92]  M. Nendza Structure-activity relationships in environmental sciences , 1998 .

[93]  Robert J Kavlock,et al.  Computational toxicology--a state of the science mini review. , 2008, Toxicological sciences : an official journal of the Society of Toxicology.

[94]  A. Kortenkamp,et al.  Synergisms with mixtures of xenoestrogens: a reevaluation using the method of isoboles. , 1998, The Science of the total environment.

[95]  M. Moore,et al.  Synergism and antagonism among multiple stressors , 1999 .

[96]  J. Hermens,et al.  Modes of action in ecotoxicology: their role in body burdens, species sensitivity, QSARs, and mixture effects. , 2002, Environmental science & technology.

[97]  N Palmer,et al.  Mixed messages , 2005, British Dental Journal.

[98]  E. Thurman,et al.  Pharmaceuticals, hormones, and other organic wastewater contaminants in U.S. streams, 1999-2000: a national reconnaissance. , 2002 .

[99]  M. Jonker Joint toxic effects on Caenorhabditis elegans , 2003 .