THE IMPACT OF MARINE RESERVES: DO RESERVES WORK AND DOES RESERVE SIZE MATTER?

Marine reserves are quickly gaining popularity as a management option for marine conservation, fisheries, and other human uses of the oceans. Despite the popularity of marine reserves as a management tool, few reserves appear to have been created or designed with an understanding of how reserves affect biological factors or how reserves can be designed to meet biological goals more effectively (e.g., attaining sustainable fish populations). This shortcoming occurs in part because the many studies that have examined the impacts of reserves on marine organisms remain isolated examples or anecdotes; the results of these many studies have not yet been synthesized. Here, I review the empirical work and discuss the theoretical literature to assess the impacts of marine reserves on several biological measures (density, biomass, size of organisms, and diversity), paying particular attention to the role reserve size has in determining those impacts. The results of 89 separate studies show that, on average, with the exception of invertebrate biomass and size, values for all four biological measures are significantly higher inside reserves compared to outside (or after reserve establishment vs. before) when evaluated for both the overall communities and by each functional group within these communities (carniv- orous fishes, herbivorous fishes, planktivorous fishes/invertebrate eaters, and invertebrates). Surprisingly, results also show that the relative impacts of reserves, such as the proportional differences in density or biomass, are independent of reserve size, suggesting that the effects of marine reserves increase directly rather than proportionally with the size of a reserve. However, equal relative differences in biological measures between small and large reserves nearly always translate into greater absolute differences for larger reserves, and so larger reserves may be necessary to meet the goals set for marine reserves. The quality of the data in the reviewed studies varied greatly. To improve data quality in the future, whenever possible, studies should take measurements before and after the creation of a reserve, replicate sampling, and include a suite of representative species. Despite the variable quality of the data, the results from this review suggest that nearly any marine habitat can benefit from the implementation of a reserve. Success of a marine reserve, however, will always be judged against the expectations for that reserve, and so we must keep in mind the goals of a reserve in its design, management, and evaluation.

[1]  F. Juanes,et al.  Effects of a Marine Reserve on Recruitment of Grunts (Pisces: Haemulidae) at Barbados, West Indies , 1999, Environmental Biology of Fishes.

[2]  T. McClanahan.  Kenyan coral reef lagoon fish: effects of fishing, substrate complexity, and sea urchins , 1994, Coral Reefs.

[3]  S. McNeill.  The selection and design of marine protected areas: Australia as a case study , 1994, Biodiversity & Conservation.

[4]  N. Polunin,et al.  Are marine reserves effective in management of reef fisheries? , 1991, Reviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries.

[5]  S. Shafir,et al.  Causes and consequences of sea urchin abundance and diversity in Kenyan coral reef lagoons , 1990, Oecologia.

[6]  T. McClanahan,et al.  Changes in Kenyan coral reef community structure and function due to exploitation , 1988, Hydrobiologia.

[7]  W.,et al.  Queen conch , Strombus gigas , in fished and unfished locations of the Bahamas : effects of a marine fishery reserve on adults , juveniles , and larval production , 2004 .

[8]  C. Buxton.  Life-history changes in exploited reef fishes on the east coast of South Africa , 2004, Environmental Biology of Fishes.

[9]  E. DeMartini.  Modeling the potential of fishery reserves for managing Pacific coral reef fishes , 2004 .

[10]  Benjamin S. Halpern,et al.  Marine reserves have rapid and lasting effects , 2002 .

[11]  J. Knauss.  The Potential of Marine Fishery Reserves for Reef Fish Management in the U.S. Southern Atlantic , 2001 .

[12]  Neville S. Barrett,et al.  Effects of the declaration of marine reserves on Tasmanian reef fishes, invertebrates and plants , 1999 .

[13]  S. Wallace.  Evaluating the Effects of Three Forms of Marine Reserve on Northern Abalone Populations in British Columbia, Canada , 1999 .

[14]  J. Bohnsack,et al.  Effectiveness of an Existing Estuarine No-Take Fish Sanctuary within the Kennedy Space Center, Florida , 1999 .

[15]  G. Russ,et al.  Natural fishing experiments in marine reserves 1983 – 1993: roles of life history and fishing intensity in family responses , 1998, Coral Reefs.

[16]  G. Russ,et al.  Natural fishing experiments in marine reserves 1983–1993: community and trophic responses , 1998, Coral Reefs.

[17]  R. Steneck.  Human influences on coastal ecosystems: does overfishing create trophic cascades? , 1998, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[18]  E. Sala,et al.  Fishing, trophic cascades, and the structure of algal assemblages : evaluation of an old but untested paradigm , 1998 .

[19]  S. Hall,et al.  Closed areas for fisheries management-the case consolidates. , 1998, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[20]  E. Sala,et al.  Temporal variability in abundance of the sea urchins Paracentrotus lividus and Arbacia lixula in the northwestern Mediterranean: comparison between a marine reserve and an unprotected area , 1998 .

[21]  Garry R. Russ,et al.  Marine reserves: patterns of adult movement of the coral trout (Plectropomus leopardus (Serranidae)) , 1998 .

[22]  Jane Lubchenco,et al.  MARINE RESERVES ARE NECESSARY BUT NOT SUFFICIENT FOR MARINE CONSERVATION , 1998 .

[23]  M. Kulbicki,et al.  Effects of marine reserves on coral reef fish communities from five islands in New Caledonia , 1997, Coral Reefs.

[24]  C. Roberts,et al.  Connectivity and management of caribbean coral reefs , 1997, Science.

[25]  T. McClanahan.  Primary succession of coral-reef algae: Differing patterns on fished versus unfished reefs , 1997 .

[26]  C. Roberts,et al.  How small can a marine reserve be and still be effective? , 1997, Coral Reefs.

[27]  M. Childress.  Marine reserves and their effects on lobster populations: report from a workshop , 1997 .

[28]  C. Marine.  THE BENEFITS OF A MARINE FISHERY RESERVE FOR NASSAU GROUPER EP .LmLPHELUS STRIATUS IN THE CENTRAL BAHAMAS , 1997 .

[29]  E. Sala,et al.  Fish predation and the structure of the sea urchin Paracentrotus lividus populations in the NW Mediterranean , 1996 .

[30]  G. Russ,et al.  Marine Reserves: Rates and Patterns of Recovery and Decline of Large Predatory Fish , 1996 .

[31]  S. Morand,et al.  Population structure of Gobius bucchichii, in a Mediterranean marine reserve and in an unprotected area , 1996 .

[32]  T. McClanahan,et al.  Fishery Recovery in a Coral‐reef Marine Park and Its Effect on the Adjacent Fishery , 1996 .

[33]  Colin W. Clark,et al.  Marine Reserves and the Precautionary Management of Fisheries , 1996 .

[34]  G. Polis,et al.  Food Web Complexity and Community Dynamics , 1996, The American Naturalist.

[35]  S. Jennings,et al.  Effects of fishing effort and catch rate upon the structure and biomass of Fijian reef fish communities , 1996 .

[36]  D. Kramer,et al.  Effect of a marine reserve on the distribution of coral reef fishes in Barbados , 1996 .

[37]  D. Righton,et al.  The Effects of Fishing on Coral Reef Fish Abundance and Diversity , 1996, Journal of the Marine Biological Association of the United Kingdom.

[38]  G. Russ,et al.  Population structure of the leopard coralgrouper, Plectropomus leopardus, on fished and unfished reefs off Townsville, central Great Barrier Reef, Australia , 1996 .

[39]  Y. Letourneur.  Réponses des peuplements et populations de poissons aux réserves marines: le cas de l’île de Mayotte, Océan Indien occidental , 1996 .

[40]  S. Jennings,et al.  Seychelles' marine protected areas: Comparative structure and status of reef fish communities , 1996 .

[41]  J. Bohnsack.  Maintenance and recovery of reef fishery productivity , 1996 .

[42]  B. Bennett,et al.  Modelling the effect of marine reserves on the recreational shore-fishery of the South-Western Cape, South Africa , 1995 .

[43]  J. Harmelin,et al.  Mediterranean Marine Reserves: Fish Indices as Tests of Protection Efficiency , 1995 .

[44]  C. Roberts.  Rapid Build-up of Fish Biomass in a Caribbean Marine Reserve , 1995 .

[45]  Tim R. McClanahan,et al.  A coral reef ecosystem-fisheries model: impacts of fishing intensity and catch selection on reef structure and processes , 1995 .

[46]  R. Galzin,et al.  Study of a Mediterranean reef fish assemblage. Comparisons of population distributions between depths in protected and unprotected areas over one decade , 1995 .

[47]  N. Shackell,et al.  Marine protected areas and sustainable fisheries : proceedings of the symposium... conducted at the Second international conference on science and the management of protected aeras , 1995 .

[48]  T. Agardy.  The science of conservation in the coastal zone : new insights on how to design, implement and monitor marine protected areas , 1995 .

[49]  R. Law,et al.  Role of marine reserves in recruitment to reef fisheries: A metapopulation model , 1995 .

[50]  P. Hockey,et al.  Conserving marine biodiversity on the African coast: Implications of a terrestrial perspective , 1994 .

[51]  R. Rowley.  Marine reserves in fisheries management , 1994 .

[52]  M. Watson,et al.  Effect of an artisanal fishery on the fish and urchin populations of a Kenyan coral reef. , 1994 .

[53]  R. Grigg.  Effects of sewage discharge, fishing pressure and habitat complexity on coral ecosystems and reef fishes in Hawaii , 1994 .

[54]  P. Francour.  L'ichtyofaune de l'herbier à Posidonia oceanica dans la réserve marine de Scandola (Corse, Méditerranée Nord-Occidentale): influence des mesures de protection , 1994 .

[55]  Patrice Francour,et al.  Pluriannual analysis of the reserve effect on ichthyofauna in the Scandola natural reserve (Corsica, Northwestern Mediterranean) , 1994 .

[56]  B. Ballantine.  THE PRACTICALITY AND BENEFITS OF A MARINE RESERVE NETWORK , 1994 .

[57]  James F. Quinn,et al.  Harvest Refugia in Marine Invertebrate Fisheries: Models and Applications to the Red Sea Urchin, Strongylocentrotus franciscanus , 1993 .

[58]  N. Polunin,et al.  Marine reserves: simple solutions to managing complex fisheries? , 1993 .

[59]  J. Dugan,et al.  Applications of marine refugia to coastal fisheries management , 1993 .

[60]  D. Reed,et al.  Conceptual Issues Relevant to Marine Harvest Refuges: Examples from Temperate Reef Fishes , 1993 .

[61]  M. Tegner.  Southern California Abalones: Can Stocks Be Rebuilt Using Marine Harvest Refugia? , 1993 .

[62]  T. Lasiak.  TEMPORAL AND SPATIAL VARIATIONS IN EXPLOITED AND NON- EXPLOITED POPULATIONS OF THE INTERTIDAL LIMPET CELLANA CAPENSIS , 1993 .

[63]  N. Polunin,et al.  Greater biomass and value of target coral-reef fishes in two small Caribbean marine reserves. , 1993 .

[64]  N. Polunin,et al.  Effects of marine reserve protection on northern Red Sea fish populations. , 1992 .

[65]  P. Francour.  The effect of protection level on a coastal fish community at Scandola, Corsica , 1991 .

[66]  B. Bennett,et al.  Evidence for recovery of a surf-zone fish assemblage following the establishment of a marine reserve on the southern coast of South Africa , 1991 .

[67]  Carl J. Walters,et al.  Large‐Scale Management Experiments and Learning by Doing , 1990 .

[68]  Tom Polacheck,et al.  YEAR AROUND CLOSED AREAS AS A MANAGEMENT TOOL , 1990 .

[69]  R. Cole,et al.  Effects of marine reserve protection at Goat Island, northern New Zealand , 1990 .

[70]  J. Castilla,et al.  Impact of human exploitation on populations of the intertidal southern bull-kelp Durvillaea antarctica (Phaeophyta, Durvilleales) in Central Chile , 1990 .

[71]  M. Zabala,et al.  Effects of total fishing prohibition on the rocky fish assemblages of Medes Islands marine reserve (NW Mediterranean) , 1990 .

[72]  G. Russ,et al.  A direct test of the effects of protective management on abundance and yield of tropical marine resources , 1990 .

[73]  L. Durán,et al.  Variation and persistence of the middle rocky intertidal community of central Chile, with and without human harvesting , 1989 .

[74]  C. Buxton,et al.  Abundance and distribution patterns of three temperate reef fishes (Teleostei:Sparidae) in exploited and unexploited areas off the southern Cape coast , 1989 .

[75]  John R. Clark,et al.  Benefits from Coral Reef Protection: Looe Key Reef, Florida , 1989 .

[76]  T. McClanahan.  Kenyan coral reef-associated gastropod fauna: a comparison between protected and unprotected reefs , 1989 .

[77]  A. Alcala,et al.  Effects of intense fishing pressure on an assemblage of coral reef fishes , 1989 .

[78]  J. Castilla,et al.  Human exclusion from rocky intertidal of Las Cruces, central Chile: effects on Durvillaea antarctica (Phaeophyta, Durvilleales) , 1989 .

[79]  G. Davis,et al.  Recreational fishery and population dynamics of spiny lobsters, Panulirus argus, in Florida Bay, Everglades National Park, 1977-1980 , 1989 .

[80]  Michael A. Rice,et al.  Effects of intensive fishing effort on the population structure of quahogs, Mercenaria mercenaria (Linnaeus, 1758), in Narragansett Bay , 1989 .

[81]  John R. Clark,et al.  Marine and coastal protected areas: a guide for planners and managers. , 1989 .

[82]  Alan T. White.  The Effect of Community Managed Marine Reserves in the Philippines on Their Associated Coral Reef Fish Populations , 1988, Asian Fisheries Science.

[83]  H. Pulliam,et al.  Sources, Sinks, and Population Regulation , 1988, The American Naturalist.

[84]  J. Roughgarden,et al.  Recruitment dynamics in complex life cycles. , 1988, Science.

[85]  A. Alcala.  Effects of marine reserves on coral fish abundances and yields of Philippine coral reefs [marine parks, Sumilon Island] , 1988 .

[86]  J. Koslow,et al.  Effects of fishing on reef fish communities at Pedro Bank and Port Royal Cays, Jamaica , 1988 .

[87]  M. McCormick,et al.  Estimating total abundance of a large temperate-reef fish using visual strip-transects , 1987 .

[88]  J. Castilla,et al.  Intensity of Human Predation on Rocky Shores at Las Cruces in Central Chile , 1987, Environmental Conservation.

[89]  S. Ortega.  THE EFFECT OF HUMAN PREDATION ON THE SIZE DISTRIBUTION OF SIPHONARIA-GIGAS (MOLLUSCA, PULMONATA) ON THE PACIFIC COAST OF COSTA-RICA , 1987 .

[90]  G. Conan.  Summary of Session 5: Recruitment Enhancement , 1986 .

[91]  J. Castilla,et al.  The effect of human exclusion on the population structure of key-hole limpets Fissurella crassa and F. Limbata on the coast of central Chile , 1986 .

[92]  G. Matthews,et al.  Synopsis of the Tortugas Pink Shrimp Fishery, 1960-1983, and the Impact of the Tortugas Sanctuary , 1986 .

[93]  C. Moreno,et al.  The Response of an Intertidal Concholepas concholepas (Gastropoda) Population to Protection from Man in Southern Chile and the Effects on Benthic Sessile Assemblages , 1986 .

[94]  P. Hockey,et al.  Man as an Intertidal Predator in Transkei: Disturbance, Community Convergence and Management of a Natural Food Resource , 1986 .

[95]  J. Castilla,et al.  Human exclusion from the rocky intertidal zone of central Chile: the effects on Concholepas concholepas (Gastropoda) , 1985 .

[96]  P. Hockey,et al.  Exploitation and Conservation of Brown Mussel Stocks by Coastal People of Transkei , 1985, Environmental Conservation.

[97]  C. Moreno,et al.  Man as a predator in the intertidal zone of southern Chile , 1984 .

[98]  J. Bell.  EFFECTS OF DEPTH AND MARINE RESERVE FISHING RESTRICTIONS ON THE STRUCTURE OF A ROCKY REEF FISH ASSEMBLAGE IN THE NORTH-WESTERN MEDITERRANEAN SEA , 1983 .

[99]  G. Davis,et al.  Marine parks and sanctuaries for spiny lobster fisheries management , 1980 .

[100]  L. Hay.  The Great Barrier Reef Marine Park. , 1978 .

[101]  R. Macarthur,et al.  The Theory of Island Biogeography , 1969 .