Criteria for publishing papers on crop modeling

Abstract Manuscripts describing crop models are a common feature in crop science journals. Many of these papers offer important conceptual insights and advances in the understanding of crop science but some fail to offer the scientific innovation expected in a scientific publication. Even though manuscripts may describe modeling efforts of practical perspective with localized interest, they may not present an analysis of general, scientific interest. A difficult challenge for journal referees and editors is to make decisions on submitted manuscripts concerning their acceptability for journal publication. The discussion presented in this paper is intended to initiate a consideration of those traits expected of a manuscript describing a crop model. We suggest three criteria that should be met in a crop modeling paper to make it suitable for scientific publication: a clear statement of a scientific objective with a defined domain of relevance, a mechanistic framework, and an evaluation of the scientific innovation offered in the new model. We also discuss the use and abuse of three widely used modeling concepts: calibration, validation, and universality.

[1]  Kenneth J. Boote,et al.  Evaluation and improvement of CROPGRO-soybean model for a cool environment in Galicia, northwest Spain , 1999 .

[2]  James W. Jones,et al.  Dynamic concepts in biology. , 1969 .

[3]  R. Loomis,et al.  Integrative Analyses of Host-Pathogen Relations , 1983 .

[4]  I. Noy-Meir,et al.  Stability of Grazing Systems: An Application of Predator-Prey Graphs , 1975 .

[5]  Maria I. Travasso,et al.  Utility of CERES-Barley under Argentine conditions , 1998 .

[6]  R. Rabbinge,et al.  Explanatory models in crop physiology , 1979 .

[7]  Howard M. Taylor,et al.  Water Use in Agriculture. (Book Reviews: Limitations to Efficient Water Use in Crop Production) , 1984 .

[8]  Robert S. Loomis,et al.  18 – Integrating Knowledge of Crop Responses to Elevated CO2 and Temperature with Mechanistic Simulation Models: Model Components and Research Needs , 1996 .

[9]  J. Passioura.  Simulation Models: Science, Snake Oil, Education, or Engineering? , 1996 .

[10]  I. Seginer,et al.  Crop model reduction and simulation in reduced space , 1996 .

[11]  J. Monteith.  The quest for balance in crop modeling , 1996 .

[12]  M. Dingkuhn,et al.  Rice crop duration and leaf appearance rate in a variable thermal environment.: I. Development of an empirically based model , 1998 .

[13]  T. Sinclair,et al.  Crop Modeling: From Infancy to Maturity , 1996 .

[14]  Takeshi Horie,et al.  Leaf Nitrogen, Photosynthesis, and Crop Radiation Use Efficiency: A Review , 1989 .

[15]  J. Ritchie,et al.  OILCROP-SUN: A Development, Growth, and Yield Model of the Sunflower Crop , 1996 .

[16]  R. C. Muchow,et al.  Modelling sugarcane production systems I. Development and performance of the sugarcane module , 1999 .

[17]  Francisco J. Villalobos,et al.  Evaluation of sunflower (Helianthus annuus, L.) genotypes differing in early vigour using a simulation model , 1997 .

[18]  H. J. W. Mutsaers,et al.  Are Simulation Models Ready for Agricultural Research in Developing Countries , 1999 .

[19]  H. H. Laar,et al.  Products, requirements and efficiency of biosynthesis: a quantitative approach. , 1974, Journal of theoretical biology.

[20]  R. C. Muchow,et al.  Radiation Use Efficiency , 1999 .

[21]  James W. Jones,et al.  GENCALC: Software to Facilitate the Use of Crop Models for Analyzing Field Experiments , 1993 .

[22]  Harold A. Mooney,et al.  Carbon dioxide and terrestrial ecosystems , 1997 .

[23]  P. Jamieson,et al.  The role of roots in controlling soil water extraction during drought: an analysis by simulation , 1999 .

[24]  J. Goudriaan,et al.  A model for photothermal responses of flowering in rice I. Model description and parameterization , 1997 .

[25]  N Oreskes,et al.  Verification, Validation, and Confirmation of Numerical Models in the Earth Sciences , 1994, Science.

[26]  R. Rabbinge,et al.  Theoretical Production Ecology: Reflections and Prospects , 1990 .