Review of evidence regarding trauma system effectiveness resulting from panel studies.

OBJECTIVE The objectives this study are to elucidate the advantages and disadvantages of the panel method for evaluating the quality of trauma care and to review the individual and collective evidence in support of regionalized trauma care derived from these studies. METHOD A review of the published literature was conducted and identified 10 panel studies that compared appropriateness of care and/or the preventability of deaths occurring either across hospitals in a trauma system versus non-trauma system, in a defined region before and after implementation of a trauma system, between trauma center and non-trauma center hospitals within a defined region, or across hospitals of varying levels of care presystem. RESULTS Panel studies vary widely in the approaches used to elicit judgments; low rates of inter-rater reliability have been reported. The strength of the evidence derived from panel studies in support of trauma system effectiveness must be reviewed in this context. CONCLUSION All panel studies are classified as providing weak, Class III evidence. Yet, collectively they provide some face validity in support of the hypothesis that treatment at a trauma versus non-trauma center may be associated with less inappropriate care and fewer preventable deaths among the seriously injured.

[1]  F. H. VAN WAGONER.  A three year study of deaths following trauma. , 1961, The Journal of trauma.

[2]  E. Mackenzie,et al.  Inter-rater reliability of preventable death judgments , 1992 .

[3]  L. Koran,et al.  The reliability of clinical methods, data and judgments (second of two parts). , 1975, The New England journal of medicine.

[4]  J. Sampalis,et al.  Preventable death classification: interrater reliability and comparison with ISS-based survival probability estimates. , 1995, Accident; analysis and prevention.

[5]  D. Detmer,et al.  Regional categorization and quality of care in major trauma. , 1977, The Journal of trauma.

[6]  R H Brook,et al.  Preventable deaths: who, how often, and why? , 1988, Annals of internal medicine.

[7]  L. Fielding,et al.  Identification of preventable trauma deaths: confounded inquiries? , 1992, The Journal of trauma.

[8]  S. Shackford,et al.  Assuring quality in a trauma system--the Medical Audit Committee: composition, cost, and results. , 1987, The Journal of trauma.

[9]  T. Esposito,et al.  Analysis of preventable trauma deaths and inappropriate trauma care in a rural state. , 1995, The Journal of trauma.

[10]  F. H. V. Wagoner.  A three year study of deaths following trauma. , 1961 .

[11]  W. Baxt,et al.  The impact of a regionalized trauma system on trauma care in San Diego County. , 1989, Annals of emergency medicine.

[12]  D. Detmer,et al.  Evaluation of the quality of hospital care for major trauma. , 1976, Journal of Trauma.

[13]  C N Mock,et al.  Systematic review of published evidence regarding trauma system effectiveness. , 1999, The Journal of trauma.

[14]  E Thoburn,et al.  System care improves trauma outcome: patient care errors dominate reduced preventable death rate. , 1993, The Journal of emergency medicine.

[15]  J. G. West,et al.  Systems of trauma care. A study of two counties. , 1979, Archives of surgery.

[16]  D. Kreis,et al.  Preventable deaths in a self-designated trauma system. , 1989, The American surgeon.

[17]  W. Baxt,et al.  An autopsy study of traumatic deaths; San Diego County, 1979. , 1982, American journal of surgery.

[18]  D. Lowe,et al.  Patterns of death, complication, and error in the management of motor vehicle accident victims: implications for a regional system of trauma care. , 1982, The Journal of trauma.

[19]  C. Cayten,et al.  Analyses of preventable deaths by mechanism of injury among 13,500 trauma admissions. , 1991, Annals of surgery.

[20]  J. G. West,et al.  Impact of regionalization. The Orange County experience. , 1983, Archives of surgery.

[21]  P. Byers,et al.  Preventable trauma deaths: Dade County, Florida. , 1986, The Journal of trauma.

[22]  J. G. West.  Validation of autopsy method for evaluating trauma care. , 1982, Archives of surgery.

[23]  R. Maio,et al.  A study of preventable trauma mortality in rural Michigan. , 1996, The Journal of trauma.

[24]  R. Cales.  Trauma mortality in Orange County: the effect of implementation of a regional trauma system. , 1984, Annals of emergency medicine.

[25]  L. Koran,et al.  The reliability of clinical methods, data and judgments (first of two parts). , 1975, The New England journal of medicine.

[26]  S. Shackford,et al.  The effect of regionalization upon the quality of trauma care as assessed by concurrent audit before and after institution of a trauma system: a preliminary report. , 1986, The Journal of trauma.

[27]  S. Cordner,et al.  Reproducibility of preventable death judgments and problem identification in 60 consecutive road trauma fatalities in Victoria, Australia. Consultative Committee on Road Traffic Fatalities in Victoria. , 1997, The Journal of trauma.

[28]  D. Trunkey,et al.  Preventable trauma deaths. A review of trauma care systems development. , 1985, JAMA.