How do accountability problems lead to maternal health inequities? A review of qualitative literature from Indian public sector

BackgroundThere are several studies from different geographical settings and levels on maternal health, but none analyzes how accountability problems may contribute to the maternal health outcomes. This study aimed to analyze how accountability problems in public health system lead to maternal deaths and inequities in India.MethodsA conceptual framework was developed bringing together accountability process (in terms of standard setting, performance assessment, accountability (or answerability, and enforceability) —an ongoing cyclical feedback process at different levels of health system) and determinants of maternal health to analyze the influence of the process on the determinant leading to maternal health outcomes. A scoping review of qualitative and mixed-methods studies from public health sector in India was conducted. A narrative and interpretive synthesis approach was applied to analyze data.ResultsAn overarching influence of health system-related factors over non-health system-related factors leading to maternal deaths and inequities was observed. A potential link among such factors was identified with gaps in accountability functions at all levels of health system pertaining to policy gaps or conflicting/discriminatory policies and political commitment. A large number of gaps were also observed concerning performance or implementation of existing standards. Inherent to these issues was potentially a lack of proper monitoring and accountability functions. A critical role of power was observed influencing the accountability functions.ConclusionThe narrative and interpretive synthesis approach allowed to integrate and reframe the relevant comparable information from the limited empirical studies to identify the hot spots of systemic flaws from an accountability perspective. The framework highlighted problems in health system beyond health service delivery to wider areas such as policy or politics justifying their relevance and importance in such analysis. A crucial message from the study pertains to a need to move away from the traditional concept of viewing accountability as a blame-game approach and a concern of limited frontline health workers towards a constructive and systemic approach.

[1]  E. Jacobs,et al.  Social Accountability and its Conceptual Challenges: An analytical framework , 2013 .

[2]  Pramod K. Sah,et al.  Performance of village health, nutrition and sanitation committee: A qualitative study from rural Wardha, Maharashtra , 2013 .

[3]  D. Mavalankar,et al.  Innovations and Challenges in Reducing Maternal Mortality in Tamil Nadu, India , 2009, Journal of health, population, and nutrition.

[4]  M. Dieleman,et al.  Health provider responsiveness to social accountability initiatives in low- and middle-income countries: a realist review , 2017, Health policy and planning.

[5]  B. Avan,et al.  “Neither we are satisfied nor they”-users and provider’s perspective: a qualitative study of maternity care in secondary level public health facilities, Uttar Pradesh, India , 2015, BMC Health Services Research.

[6]  D. Maine,et al.  Too far to walk: maternal mortality in context. , 1991, Social science & medicine.

[7]  Suresh C. Sharma,et al.  Maternal Mortality in India: A Review of Trends and Patterns , 2015 .

[8]  Anuradha Joshi,et al.  Do They Work? Assessing the Impact of Transparency and Accountability Initiatives in Service Delivery , 2013 .

[9]  J. F. McCarthy,et al.  A framework for analyzing the determinants of maternal mortality. , 1992, Studies in family planning.

[10]  D. Brinkerhoff,et al.  Health governance: principal-agent linkages and health system strengthening. , 2014, Health policy and planning.

[11]  C. Ronsmans,et al.  Institutional delivery in rural India: the relative importance of accessibility and economic status , 2010, BMC pregnancy and childbirth.

[12]  P. von Dadelszen,et al.  Utilization of maternal health care services and their determinants in Karnataka State, India , 2016, Reproductive Health.

[13]  C. Galavotti,et al.  A review of CARE’s Community Score Card experience and evidence , 2016, Health policy and planning.

[14]  E. Pellegrino.  Toward a reconstruction of medical morality , 1987, The Journal of medical humanities and bioethics.

[15]  R. Khanna,et al.  An investigation of maternal deaths following public protests in a tribal district of Madhya Pradesh, central India , 2012, Reproductive health matters.

[16]  A. Hurtig,et al.  Socio-cultural and service delivery dimensions of maternal mortality in rural central India: a qualitative exploration using a human rights lens , 2015, Global health action.

[17]  M. Gordon,et al.  Reducing maternal mortality in Nepal , 2011, BJOG : an international journal of obstetrics and gynaecology.

[18]  David Osrin,et al.  Reproductive health, and child health and nutrition in India: meeting the challenge , 2011, The Lancet.

[19]  Larry Diamond,et al.  The Self Restraining State: Power and Accountability in New Democracies , 1999 .

[20]  J. Shiffman,et al.  The state of political priority for safe motherhood in India , 2007, BJOG : an international journal of obstetrics and gynaecology.

[21]  Stephanie L. Smith.  Political contexts and maternal health policy: insights from a comparison of south Indian states. , 2014, Social science & medicine.

[22]  R. Reinikka,et al.  Making Services Work for Poor People , 2004 .

[23]  J. Pradhan,et al.  Maternal health care in India: access and demand determinants , 2013, Primary Health Care Research & Development.

[24]  S. Theobald,et al.  Community health workers in rural India: analysing the opportunities and challenges Accredited Social Health Activists (ASHAs) face in realising their multiple roles , 2015, Human Resources for Health.

[25]  D. Mavalankar,et al.  Saving mothers and newborns through an innovative partnership with private sector obstetricians: Chiranjeevi scheme of Gujarat, India , 2009, International journal of gynaecology and obstetrics: the official organ of the International Federation of Gynaecology and Obstetrics.

[26]  G. Murthy,et al.  Community Based Maternal Death Review: Lessons Learned from Ten Districts in Andhra Pradesh, India , 2015, Maternal and Child Health Journal.

[27]  M. Kaur,et al.  Maternal and Perinatal Death Inquiry and Response Project Implementation Review in India , 2013, The Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology of India.

[28]  A. George,et al.  'By papers and pens, you can only do so much': views about accountability and human resource management from Indian government health administrators and workers. , 2009, The International journal of health planning and management.

[29]  Bengt Åhgren,et al.  Health system capacity: maternal health policy implementation in the state of Gujarat, India , 2013, Global health action.

[30]  M. Sudhinaraset,et al.  Decision-making for delivery location and quality of care among slum-dwellers: a qualitative study in Uttar Pradesh, India , 2016, BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth.

[31]  Patricia McInerney,et al.  The Joanna Briggs Institute reviewers' manual 2015: methodology for JBI scoping reviews , 2015 .

[32]  L. Say,et al.  Obstetric transition: the pathway towards ending preventable maternal deaths , 2014, BJOG : an international journal of obstetrics and gynaecology.

[33]  M. San Sebastiån,et al.  The emergence of maternal health as a political priority in Madhya Pradesh, India: a qualitative study , 2013, BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth.

[34]  Prabhat Jha,et al.  Maternal Mortality in India: Causes and Healthcare Service Use Based on a Nationally Representative Survey , 2014, PloS one.

[35]  P. Ariana,et al.  What influences the decision to undergo institutional delivery by skilled birth attendants? A cohort study in rural Andhra Pradesh, India. , 2012, Rural and remote health.

[36]  A. Joshi.  Producing Social Accountability? The Impact of Service Delivery Reforms , 2007 .

[37]  M. Bhandankar,et al.  Determinants of postnatal maternity care service utilization in rural Belgaum of Karnataka, India: A community based cross-sectional study , 2014 .

[38]  A. Goetz,et al.  Hybrid Forms Of Accountability: Citizen engagement in institutions of public-sector oversight in India , 2001 .

[39]  S. Suresh,et al.  Primary Health Centres: Preferred Option for Birthing Care in Tamilnadu, India, from Users’ Perspectives , 2015, Journal of Health, Population and Nutrition.

[40]  A. George.  Using Accountability to Improve Reproductive Health Care , 2003, Reproductive health matters.

[41]  A. George.  Persistence of High Maternal Mortality in Koppal District, Karnataka, India: Observed Service Delivery Constraints , 2007, Reproductive health matters.

[42]  M. Dixon-Woods,et al.  Conducting a critical interpretive synthesis of the literature on access to healthcare by vulnerable groups , 2006 .

[43]  M. Mahapatro.  Equity in utilization of health care services: Perspective of pregnant women in southern Odisha, India , 2015, The Indian journal of medical research.

[44]  S. Mayhew,et al.  What can we learn on public accountability from non-health disciplines: a meta-narrative review , 2016, BMJ Open.

[45]  K. Iyengar,et al.  Pregnancy-related Deaths in Rural Rajasthan, India: Exploring Causes, Context, and Care-seeking Through Verbal Autopsy , 2009, Journal of health, population, and nutrition.

[46]  J. Raven,et al.  Does the Janani Suraksha Yojana cash transfer programme to promote facility births in India ensure skilled birth attendance? A qualitative study of intrapartum care in Madhya Pradesh , 2015, Global health action.

[47]  R. Kesarwani,et al.  EFFECT OF INDIVIDUAL AND COMMUNITY FACTORS ON MATERNAL HEALTH CARE SERVICE USE IN INDIA: A MULTILEVEL APPROACH , 2015, Journal of Biosocial Science.

[48]  René Tonglet,et al.  Strategies for reducing maternal mortality in developing countries: what can we learn from the history of the industrialized West? , 1998, Tropical medicine & international health : TM & IH.

[49]  C. Pope,et al.  Evaluating meta-ethnography: systematic analysis and synthesis of qualitative research. , 2011, Health technology assessment.

[50]  J. Dasgupta.  Ten years of negotiating rights around maternal health in Uttar Pradesh, India , 2011, BMC international health and human rights.

[51]  I. Danel,et al.  Accountability for improving maternal and newborn health. , 2016, Best practice & research. Clinical obstetrics & gynaecology.

[52]  Manas Ranjan Pradhan,et al.  Identifying Factors Associated with Maternal Deaths in Jharkhand, India: A Verbal Autopsy Study , 2013, Journal of health, population, and nutrition.

[53]  P. Hunt.  Right to the highest attainable standard of health , 2006, The Lancet.

[54]  Mike Weed,et al.  A Potential Method for the Interpretive Synthesis of Qualitative Research: Issues in the Development of ‘Meta-Interpretation’ , 2008 .

[55]  J. Bueno de Mesquita,et al.  Maternal mortality and human rights: landmark decision by United Nations human rights body. , 2012, Bulletin of the World Health Organization.

[56]  N. Ng,et al.  Factors affecting the use of maternal health services in Madhya Pradesh state of India: a multilevel analysis , 2011, International journal for equity in health.

[57]  D. Coffey.  Costs and consequences of a cash transfer for hospital births in a rural district of Uttar Pradesh, India. , 2014, Social science & medicine.

[58]  R. Keogh,et al.  Indigenous Health: ACTION on Prevention , 2011 .

[59]  J. Liljestrand,et al.  Investing in Maternal Health in Malaysia and Sri Lanka , 2003 .

[60]  C. Goodman,et al.  Community accountability at peripheral health facilities: a review of the empirical literature and development of a conceptual framework , 2012, Health policy and planning.

[61]  J. Hanefeld,et al.  Understanding the dynamic interactions driving Zambian health centre performance: a case-based health systems analysis , 2014, Health policy and planning.

[62]  O. Solar,et al.  A conceptual framework for action on the social determinants of health. , 2007 .

[63]  Richard Mulgan,et al.  Holding Power to Account , 2003 .

[64]  S V Subramanian,et al.  Health care and equity in India , 2011, The Lancet.

[65]  A. Reeves,et al.  Has India’s national rural health mission reduced inequities in maternal health services? A pre-post repeated cross-sectional study , 2015, Health policy and planning.

[66]  Sanjay Dixit,et al.  Assessment of Functioning of Village Health And Sanitation Committees (Vhscs) Of Indore District , 2014 .

[67]  M. Bovens.  Analysing and Assessing Accountability: A Conceptual Framework , 2007 .

[68]  P. Sahoo,et al.  Emergency referral transport for maternal complication: lessons from the community based maternal death audits in Unnao district, Uttar Pradesh, India. , 2015, International journal of health policy and management.

[69]  J. Shiffman,et al.  Holding health providers in developing countries accountable to consumers: a synthesis of relevant scholarship. , 2012, Health policy and planning.

[70]  Peter Hupe,et al.  STREET-LEVEL BUREAUCRACY AND PUBLIC ACCOUNTABILITY , 2007 .

[71]  Jameen Kaur.  The role of litigation in ensuring women's reproductive rights: an analysis of the Shanti Devi judgement in India , 2012, Reproductive health matters.

[72]  International Institute for Population Sciences (IIPS) , 2019, The Grants Register 2022.

[73]  D. Stuckler,et al.  A qualitative study of factors impacting accessing of institutional delivery care in the context of India's cash incentive program , 2017, Social science & medicine.

[74]  Peter Hall,et al.  The right to the highest attainable standard of health , 2015, The Lancet.

[75]  A. Joshi,et al.  Widgets or Watchdogs? , 2012 .

[76]  A. George,et al.  Sparking, supporting and steering change: grounding an accountability framework with viewpoints from Nigerian routine immunization and primary health care government officials. , 2016, Health policy and planning.

[77]  A. De Costa,et al.  India’s Conditional Cash Transfer Programme (the JSY) to Promote Institutional Birth: Is There an Association between Institutional Birth Proportion and Maternal Mortality? , 2013, PloS one.

[78]  W. Van Damme,et al.  The impact of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) service scale-up on mechanisms of accountability in Zambian primary health centres: a case-based health systems analysis , 2015, BMC Health Services Research.

[79]  S. Bosomprah,et al.  Scorecards and social accountability for improved maternal and newborn health services: A pilot in the Ashanti and Volta regions of Ghana , 2016, International journal of gynaecology and obstetrics: the official organ of the International Federation of Gynaecology and Obstetrics.

[80]  S. Sarkar,et al.  Utilization of maternal health-care services by tribal women in Kerala , 2014, Journal of natural science, biology, and medicine.

[81]  Strategies toward ending preventable maternal mortality ( EPMM ) , 2014 .

[82]  C. Campbell,et al.  Improving maternal health through social accountability: A case study from Orissa, India , 2013, Global public health.

[83]  N. Bannert,et al.  High variability of HIV and HCV seroprevalence and risk behaviours among people who inject drugs: results from a cross-sectional study using respondent-driven sampling in eight German cities (2011–14) , 2016, BMC Public Health.

[84]  T. Ravindran,et al.  Social and health system factors contributing to maternal deaths in a less developed district of Kerala, India , 2016 .

[85]  D. Brinkerhoff,et al.  Accountability and health systems: toward conceptual clarity and policy relevance. , 2004, Health policy and planning.

[86]  Richard Mulgan,et al.  Holding Power to Account: Accountability in Modern Democracies , 2003 .

[87]  Özge Tunçalp,et al.  Global causes of maternal death: a WHO systematic analysis. , 2014, The Lancet. Global health.

[88]  A. Garg,et al.  Closing the health and nutrition gap in Odisha, India: A case study of how transforming the health system is achieving greater equity. , 2015, Social science & medicine.

[89]  R. Jeffery,et al.  Only when the boat has started sinking: A maternal death in rural north India , 2010, Social science & medicine.

[90]  A. Costello,et al.  Are village health sanitation and nutrition committees fulfilling their roles for decentralised health planning and action? A mixed methods study from rural eastern India , 2015, BMC Public Health.

[91]  L. Emanuel,et al.  What Is Accountability in Health Care? , 1996, Annals of Internal Medicine.