Abstract Context Tumor progression in surgically treated patients with nonfunctioning pituitary adenomas (NFPAs) is associated with excess mortality. Reliable biomarkers allowing early identification of tumor progression are missing. Objective To explore DNA methylation patterns associated with tumor progression in NFPA patients. Methods This case-controlled exploratory trial at a university hospital studied patients who underwent surgery for NFPA that had immunohistochemical characteristics of a gonadotropinoma. Cases included patients requiring reintervention due to tumor progression (reintervention group, n = 26) and controls who had a postoperative residual tumor without tumor progression for at least 5 years (radiologically stable group, n = 17). Genome-wide methylation data from each tumor sample were analyzed using the Infinium MethylationEPIC BeadChip platform. Results The analysis showed that 605 CpG positions were significantly differently methylated (differently methylated positions, DMPs) between the patient groups (false discovery rate adjusted P value < 0.05, beta value > 0.2), mapping to 389 genes. The largest number of DMPs were detected in the genes NUP93 and LGALS1. The 3 hypomethylated DMPs and the 3 hypermethylated DMPs with the lowest P values were all significantly (P < 0.05) and individually associated with reintervention-free survival. One of the hypermethylated DMPs with the lowest P value was located in the gene GABRA1. Conclusion In this exploratory study, DNA methylation patterns in NFPA patients were associated with postoperative tumor progression requiring reintervention. The DMPs included genes that have been previously associated with tumor development. Our study is a step toward finding epigenetic signatures to predict tumor progression in patients with NFPA.