The Effects of Service Availability and Recognition Errors on Trust in Voice User Interfaces

This study was conducted to determine the effects of speech recognition accuracy and system availability on customers' perceptions of a speech-enabled Interactive Voice Response (IVR) system. Fifty-six participants searched for bank rate information using a prototype speech recognition banking system in one of four conditions: (1) perfect system performance when obtaining rate information, (2) occasional speech recognition errors, (3) occasional loss of system availability, and (4) a combination of recognition errors and loss of system availability. A “system trust” measure was a better discriminator between conditions than a commonly-used subjective satisfaction measure: participants who experienced periods of unavailable service trusted the system less than those who experienced fully available service, but these groups reported similar subjective satisfaction rates. Participants who encountered speech recognition errors reported no lower levels of trust or satisfaction than those who experienced perfect recognition accuracy. The paper discusses the relationship between system trust and the willingness to use self-service systems, as well as special aspects of speech recognition systems in terms of “persona” and users' perceptions.