Flattening filter‐free accelerators: a report from the AAPM Therapy Emerging Technology Assessment Work Group

This report describes the current state of flattening filter‐free (FFF) radiotherapy beams implemented on conventional linear accelerators, and is aimed primarily at practicing medical physicists. The Therapy Emerging Technology Assessment Work Group of the American Association of Physicists in Medicine (AAPM) formed a writing group to assess FFF technology. The published literature on FFF technology was reviewed, along with technical specifications provided by vendors. Based on this information, supplemented by the clinical experience of the group members, consensus guidelines and recommendations for implementation of FFF technology were developed. Areas in need of further investigation were identified. Removing the flattening filter increases beam intensity, especially near the central axis. Increased intensity reduces treatment time, especially for high‐dose stereotactic radiotherapy/radiosurgery (SRT/SRS). Furthermore, removing the flattening filter reduces out‐of‐field dose and improves beam modeling accuracy. FFF beams are advantageous for small field (e.g., SRS) treatments and are appropriate for intensity‐modulated radiotherapy (IMRT). For conventional 3D radiotherapy of large targets, FFF beams may be disadvantageous compared to flattened beams because of the heterogeneity of FFF beam across the target (unless modulation is employed). For any application, the nonflat beam characteristics and substantially higher dose rates require consideration during the commissioning and quality assurance processes relative to flattened beams, and the appropriate clinical use of the technology needs to be identified. Consideration also needs to be given to these unique characteristics when undertaking facility planning. Several areas still warrant further research and development. Recommendations pertinent to FFF technology, including acceptance testing, commissioning, quality assurance, radiation safety, and facility planning, are presented. Examples of clinical applications are provided. Several of the areas in which future research and development are needed are also indicated. PACS number: 87.53.‐j, 87.53.Bn, 87.53.Ly, 87.55.‐x, 87.55.N‐, 87.56.bc

[1]  S Svanberg,et al.  Survival of mammalian cells exposed to ultrahigh dose rates from a laser-produced plasma x-ray source. , 1999, Radiology.

[2]  J. Kiefer,et al.  SOME THEORETICAL CONSIDERATIONS CONCERNING ULTRA-HIGH DOSE RATE SURVIVAL EXPERIMENTS. , 1970 .

[3]  C. Ling,et al.  The variation of OER with dose rate. , 1985, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[4]  R. Orecchia,et al.  Application of failure mode and effects analysis to intraoperative radiation therapy using mobile electron linear accelerators. , 2012, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[5]  Julian R Perks,et al.  Failure mode and effect analysis for delivery of lung stereotactic body radiation therapy. , 2012, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[6]  C. Ling,et al.  Dose-rate effects in external beam radiotherapy redux. , 2010, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[7]  Radhe Mohan,et al.  Energy spectra, sources, and shielding considerations for neutrons generated by a flattening filter-free Clinac. , 2008, Medical physics.

[8]  U Titt,et al.  Radiation safety survey on a flattening filter-free medical accelerator. , 2007, Radiation protection dosimetry.

[9]  I. Lohse,et al.  Effect of high dose per pulse flattening filter-free beams on cancer cell survival. , 2011, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[10]  T. Knöös,et al.  Prediction of stopping-power ratios in flattening-filter free beams. , 2010, Medical physics.

[11]  D. Gupta,et al.  The Use of Failure Mode and Effect Analysis in a Radiation Oncology Setting: The Cancer Treatment Centers of America Experience , 2014, Journal for healthcare quality : official publication of the National Association for Healthcare Quality.

[12]  Robert Jeraj,et al.  Radiation characteristics of helical tomotherapy. , 2004, Medical physics.

[13]  J. Cygler,et al.  Clinical use of a novel in vivo 4D monitoring system for simultaneous patient motion and dose measurements. , 2012, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[14]  E. Hall,et al.  Radiobiology for the Radiologist, 6th Edition , 2006 .

[15]  A. Mesbahi A Monte Carlo study on neutron and electron contamination of an unflattened 18-MV photon beam. , 2009, Applied radiation and isotopes : including data, instrumentation and methods for use in agriculture, industry and medicine.

[16]  Bruce Thomadsen Quality and safety in radiotherapy : learning the new approaches in task group 100 and beyond , 2013 .

[17]  J. Hendry,et al.  Radiobiology for the Radiologist , 1979, British Journal of Cancer.

[18]  Paul Keall,et al.  Failure mode and effect analysis-based quality assurance for dynamic MLC tracking systems. , 2010, Medical physics.

[19]  Jason Cashmore,et al.  The characterization of unflattened photon beams from a 6 MV linear accelerator , 2008, Physics in medicine and biology.

[20]  D. Goodhead,et al.  Modelling of radiation-induced DNA damage: the early physical and chemical event. , 1994, International journal of radiation biology.

[21]  Tommy Knöös,et al.  Current status and future perspective of flattening filter free photon beams. , 2011, Medical physics.

[22]  Evan M. Thomas,et al.  Flattening filter‐free linac improves treatment delivery efficiency in stereotactic body radiation therapy , 2013, Journal of applied clinical medical physics.

[23]  S. Benedict,et al.  The biological effectiveness of intermittent irradiation as a function of overall treatment time: development of correction factors for linac-based stereotactic radiotherapy. , 1997, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[24]  B. Zackrisson,et al.  Exploration of new treatment modalities offered by high energy (up to 50 MeV) electrons and photons. , 1997, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[25]  Vikren Sarkar,et al.  Rotational IMRT delivery using a digital linear accelerator in very high dose rate 'burst mode'. , 2011, Physics in medicine and biology.

[26]  Ion recombination correction factors (Pion) for Varian TrueBeam high‐dose‐rate therapy beams , 2012, Journal of applied clinical medical physics.

[27]  D W O Rogers,et al.  Relationship between %dd(10)x and stopping-power ratios for flattening filter free accelerators: a Monte Carlo study. , 2008, Medical physics.

[28]  Radhe Mohan,et al.  Treatment-planning study of prostate cancer intensity-modulated radiotherapy with a Varian Clinac operated without a flattening filter. , 2007, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[29]  Eduardo G Moros,et al.  Treatment delivery software for a new clinical grade ultrasound system for thermoradiotherapy. , 2005, Medical physics.

[30]  R. Popple,et al.  Improved clinical efficiency in CNS stereotactic radiosurgery using a flattening filter free linear accelerator. , 2011, Journal of radiosurgery and SBRT.

[31]  Radhe Mohan,et al.  Dosimetric properties of photon beams from a flattening filter free clinical accelerator , 2005, Physics in medicine and biology.

[32]  Radhe Mohan,et al.  Treatment vault shielding for a flattening filter-free medical linear accelerator , 2009, Physics in medicine and biology.

[33]  Radhe Mohan,et al.  Monte Carlo study of photon fields from a flattening filter-free clinical accelerator. , 2006, Medical physics.

[34]  S. Seltzer,et al.  Addendum to the AAPM's TG-51 protocol for clinical reference dosimetry of high-energy photon beams. , 2014, Medical physics.

[35]  Dietmar Georg,et al.  Radiation therapy with unflattened photon beams: dosimetric accuracy of advanced dose calculation algorithms. , 2011, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[36]  H. Bartelink,et al.  Fractionation in radiotherapy. , 1994, Cancer treatment reviews.

[37]  J. Fowler,et al.  Loss of biological effect in prolonged fraction delivery. , 2004, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[38]  J. Pena,et al.  Monte Carlo study of Siemens PRIMUS photoneutron production , 2005, Physics in medicine and biology.

[39]  D. Rogers,et al.  AAPM's TG-51 protocol for clinical reference dosimetry of high-energy photon and electron beams. , 1999, Medical physics.

[40]  J. Mechalakos,et al.  IMRT commissioning: multiple institution planning and dosimetry comparisons, a report from AAPM Task Group 119. , 2009, Medical physics.

[41]  Fujio Araki,et al.  Monte Carlo study of a Cyberknife stereotactic radiosurgery system. , 2006, Medical physics.

[42]  Jianrong Dai,et al.  Delivery time comparison for intensity-modulated radiation therapy with/without flattening filter: a planning study. , 2004, Physics in medicine and biology.

[43]  A. Brahme,et al.  Biologically Optimized 3-Dimensional In Vivo Predictive Assay-based Radiation Therapy Using Positron Emission Tomography-Computerized Tomography Imaging , 2003, Acta oncologica.

[44]  T Solberg,et al.  Commissioning of the Varian TrueBeam linear accelerator: a multi-institutional study. , 2013, Medical physics.

[45]  U Titt,et al.  A flattening filter free photon treatment concept evaluation with Monte Carlo. , 2006, Medical physics.

[46]  Pietro Mancosu,et al.  Pretreatment quality assurance of flattening filter free beams on 224 patients for intensity modulated plans: a multicentric study. , 2012, Medical physics.

[47]  Max Dahele,et al.  Dosimetric impact of the interplay effect during stereotactic lung radiation therapy delivery using flattening filter-free beams and volumetric modulated arc therapy. , 2013, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[48]  D. Rogers,et al.  The central electrode correction factor for high-Z electrodes in small ionization chambers. , 2011, Medical physics.

[49]  Dietmar Georg,et al.  Impact of a flattening filter free linear accelerator on structural shielding design. , 2014, Zeitschrift fur medizinische Physik.

[50]  Radhe Mohan,et al.  Stereotactic radiotherapy for lung cancer using a flattening filter free Clinac , 2009, Journal of applied clinical medical physics.

[51]  D. Lea,et al.  The mechanism of the induction by radiation of chromosome aberrations inTradescantia , 1942, Journal of Genetics.

[52]  James A Scott Measurement of Dose Equivalents from External Photon and Electron Radiations ICRU Report 47. International Commission on Radiation Units and Measurements, Bethesda, 1992, $40.00 , 1993 .

[53]  Andrea Molineu,et al.  Credentialing results from IMRT irradiations of an anthropomorphic head and neck phantom. , 2013, Medical physics.

[54]  G. Starkschall,et al.  American Association of Physicists in Medicine Radiation Therapy Committee Task Group 53: quality assurance for clinical radiotherapy treatment planning. , 1998, Medical physics.

[55]  B. S. Sørensen,et al.  Dependence of cell survival on instantaneous dose rate of a linear accelerator. , 2011, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[56]  P. Mancosu,et al.  Dosimetric validation of the Acuros XB Advanced Dose Calculation algorithm: fundamental characterization in water , 2011, Physics in medicine and biology.

[57]  P F O'Brien,et al.  Radiosurgery with unflattened 6-MV photon beams. , 1991, Medical physics.

[58]  C. Ling,et al.  Oxygen sensitization of CHO cells at ultrahigh dose rates: prelude to oxygen diffusion studies. , 1978, Radiation research.

[59]  Y. Shibamoto,et al.  Recovery from sublethal damage during intermittent exposures in cultured tumor cells: implications for dose modification in radiosurgery and IMRT. , 2004, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[60]  Niko Papanikolaou,et al.  QA for helical tomotherapy: Report of the AAPM Task Group 148a). , 2010, Medical physics.

[61]  R. Weichselbaum,et al.  Dose-escalated radiotherapy for high-risk prostate cancer: outcomes in modern era with short-term androgen deprivation therapy. , 2009, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[62]  H. O. Wyckoff,et al.  The International Commission on Radiation Units and Measurements , 2001, Journal of the ICRU.

[63]  Todd Pawlicki,et al.  Cyberknife image-guided delivery and quality assurance. , 2008, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[64]  Tommy Knöös,et al.  Dosimetric characteristics of 6 and 10MV unflattened photon beams. , 2009, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[65]  Jan Hrbacek,et al.  The use of photon beams of a flattening filter-free linear accelerator for hypofractionated volumetric modulated arc therapy in localized prostate cancer. , 2012, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[66]  R. Mohan,et al.  Reduced neutron production through use of a flattening-filter-free accelerator. , 2007, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[67]  R K Sachs,et al.  The link between low-LET dose-response relations and the underlying kinetics of damage production/repair/misrepair. , 1997, International journal of radiation biology.

[68]  T Lindmo,et al.  Monte Carlo study of in-field and out-of-field dose distributions from a linear accelerator operating with and without a flattening-filter. , 2012, Medical physics.

[69]  Pietro Mancosu,et al.  Volumetric modulation arc radiotherapy with flattening filter-free beams compared with static gantry IMRT and 3D conformal radiotherapy for advanced esophageal cancer: a feasibility study. , 2012, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[70]  J C Rosenwald,et al.  On-axis and off-axis primary dose component in high energy photon beams. , 1994, Medical physics.

[71]  Timothy C Zhu,et al.  Accelerator beam data commissioning equipment and procedures: Report of the TG-106 of the Therapy Physics Committee of the AAPM. , 2008, Medical physics.

[72]  Niko Papanikolaou,et al.  Treatment planning and delivery of IMRT using 6 and 18MV photon beams without flattening filter. , 2009, Applied radiation and isotopes : including data, instrumentation and methods for use in agriculture, industry and medicine.

[73]  Max Dahele,et al.  Flattening filter free vs flattened beams for breast irradiation. , 2013, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[74]  Otto A Sauer,et al.  Determination of the quality index (Q) for photon beams at arbitrary field sizes. , 2009, Medical physics.

[75]  Vitali Moiseenko,et al.  In vitro study of cell survival following dynamic MLC intensity-modulated radiation therapy dose delivery. , 2007, Medical physics.

[76]  B A Faddegon,et al.  Calculation of x-ray spectra for radiosurgical beams. , 1995, Medical physics.

[77]  D. Jameson,et al.  Time effects in molecular radiation Biology , 1980, Radiation and environmental biophysics.

[78]  Jason Cashmore,et al.  Lowering whole-body radiation doses in pediatric intensity-modulated radiotherapy through the use of unflattened photon beams. , 2011, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[79]  David S Followill,et al.  Algorithms used in heterogeneous dose calculations show systematic differences as measured with the Radiological Physics Center's anthropomorphic thorax phantom used for RTOG credentialing. , 2012, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[80]  Elinore Wieslander,et al.  A Monte Carlo study of a flattening filter-free linear accelerator verified with measurements , 2010, Physics in medicine and biology.

[81]  M. Scorsetti,et al.  Feasibility and early clinical assessment of flattening filter free (FFF) based stereotactic body radiotherapy (SBRT) treatments , 2011, Radiation oncology.

[82]  Tobias Pommer,et al.  A treatment planning and delivery comparison of volumetric modulated arc therapy with or without flattening filter for gliomas, brain metastases, prostate, head/neck and early stage lung cancer , 2014, Acta oncologica.

[83]  W. Grant,et al.  QA for helical tomotherapy: report of the AAPM Task Group 148. , 2010, Medical physics.

[84]  P. Mancosu,et al.  Chest wall radiotherapy with volumetric modulated arcs and the potential role of flattening filter free photon beams , 2012, Strahlentherapie und Onkologie.

[85]  Ion recombination corrections of ionization chambers in flattening filter‐free photon radiation , 2012, Journal of applied clinical medical physics.

[86]  T C Zhu,et al.  The fraction of photons undergoing head scatter in x-ray beams. , 1995, Physics in medicine and biology.

[87]  A Fogliata,et al.  Definition of parameters for quality assurance of flattening filter free (FFF) photon beams in radiation therapy. , 2012, Medical physics.

[88]  Eric C Ford,et al.  Evaluation of safety in a radiation oncology setting using failure mode and effects analysis. , 2009, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[89]  Radhe Mohan,et al.  Properties of unflattened photon beams shaped by a multileaf collimator. , 2006, Medical physics.

[90]  Lei Xing,et al.  Image-guided radiotherapy in near real time with intensity-modulated radiotherapy megavoltage treatment beam imaging. , 2009, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[91]  Radhe Mohan,et al.  Out-of-field photon dose following removal of the flattening filter from a medical accelerator , 2010, Physics in medicine and biology.

[92]  Fang-Fang Yin,et al.  Task Group 142 report: quality assurance of medical accelerators. , 2009, Medical physics.

[93]  Tommy Knöös,et al.  Photon beam quality variations of a flattening filter free linear accelerator. , 2009, Medical physics.

[94]  M Tatcher,et al.  [Fractionation in radiotherapy]. , 1972, Harefuah.

[95]  M N Cornforth,et al.  A quantitative comparison of potentially lethal damage repair and the rejoining of interphase chromosome breaks in low passage normal human fibroblasts. , 1987, Radiation research.

[96]  Jan Hrbacek,et al.  Ion-recombination correction for different ionization chambers in high dose rate flattening-filter-free photon beams. , 2012, Physics in medicine and biology.

[97]  T. Zhu,et al.  Accelerator beam data commissioning equipment and procedures: Report of the TG-106 of the Therapy Physics Committee of the AAPM. , 2008, Medical physics.

[98]  R Roots,et al.  Estimation of life times and diffusion distances of radicals involved in x-ray-induced DNA strand breaks of killing of mammalian cells. , 1975, Radiation research.

[99]  Pietro Mancosu,et al.  Volumetric modulated arc therapy with flattening filter free (FFF) beams for stereotactic body radiation therapy (SBRT) in patients with medically inoperable early stage non small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). , 2013, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[100]  Joseph Y Ting,et al.  Surface dose investigation of the flattening filter-free photon beams. , 2012, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[101]  M T Gillin,et al.  Measurements of in-air output ratios for a linear accelerator with and without the flattening filter. , 2006, Medical physics.

[102]  T. Krieger,et al.  Stereotactic body radiotherapy for local boost irradiation in unfavourable locally recurrent gynaecological cancer. , 2010, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[103]  Mikael Karlsson,et al.  The effect of fraction time in intensity modulated radiotherapy: theoretical and experimental evaluation of an optimisation problem. , 2003, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.