A multi-criteria sustainability assessment for biodiesel and liquefied natural gas as alternative fuels in transport systems

Abstract The incorporation of clean-fuel technologies has become essential for the sustainability of the transportation sector. Natural gas technology, especially the use of liquefied natural gas (LNG), has become a possible alternative to diesel oil in freight transport because of its acceptable autonomy and low fuel prices. For the introduction of this alternative fuel, freight companies need tools that allow them to perform an integrated assessment of relevant aspects related to environment, economy and social responsibility. This paper introduces a multi-criteria based methodology that integrates the key factors involved in the transport system: vehicles, infrastructure and fuels, and consideration of the three pillars of sustainability, as well as the reliability of technology, legislation and market issues. In particular, a case study for the impact assessment of LNG in comparison to hydrotreated vegetable oil (HVO) and diesel oil as regular long-haul freight transport fuels in Spain was developed. The information for the comparison process was obtained from peer-reviewed articles and reports from international and Spanish institutions, while the primary data was obtained through semi-structured in-depth interviews to the different stakeholders. A weighted sustainability index for each alternative was developed to integrate the data obtained through the analytic hierarchy process. The results indicate that LNG trucks would be an attractive option compared to diesel oil and HVO, provided that decision-makers give significant weight to social and environmental criteria, and that the government guarantees a legislative security to maintain the low taxes on natural gas. Integration of stakeholders allows making the most appropriate decision according to the objectives of the company. The application of the proposed methodology shows consistent results, which should ensure the success of a long-term alternative in the dynamic market for transportation fuels.

[1]  Patrick Schmidt,et al.  LNG as an alternative fuel for the operation of ships and heavy-duty vehicles , 2014 .

[2]  Katarzyna Solecka,et al.  Application of AHP method for multi-criteria evaluation of variants of the integration of urban public transport , 2014 .

[3]  Alicia Valero,et al.  Multicriteria analysis for the assessment of energy innovations in the transport sector , 2013 .

[4]  Richard de Neufville,et al.  Life cycle model of alternative fuel vehicles: emissions, energy, and cost trade-offs , 2001 .

[5]  LNG in Germany: Liquefied Natural Gas and Renewable Methane in Heavy-Duty Road Transport. , 2014 .

[6]  Ali Nejat,et al.  Selection of CO2 mitigation strategies for road transportation in the United States using a multi-criteria approach , 2014 .

[7]  L. Ellram.  Total cost of ownership: an analysis approach for purchasing , 1995 .

[8]  P. Zambelli,et al.  Matching socio-economic and environmental efficiency of wood- residues energy chain: a partial equilibrium model for a case study in Alpine area , 2014 .

[9]  Mikhail Chester,et al.  Goods Movement Life Cycle Assessment for Greenhouse Gas Reduction Goals , 2016 .

[10]  Julián A. Quintero,et al.  Fuel ethanol production from sugarcane and corn: Comparative analysis for a Colombian case , 2008 .

[11]  Sabina Scarpellini,et al.  LNG: An Alternative Fuel For Road Freight Transport In Europe , 2015 .

[12]  Clinton N. Jenkins,et al.  The Impacts of Oil Palm on Recent Deforestation and Biodiversity Loss , 2016, PloS one.

[13]  Steven Jones,et al.  Proposed framework for sustainability screening of urban transport projects in developing countries: A case study of Accra, Ghana , 2013 .

[14]  Szabolcs Duleba,et al.  A dynamic analysis on public bus transport's supply quality by using AHP , 2012 .

[15]  Dominik Röser,et al.  Sustainability impact assessment of increasing resource use intensity in forest bioenergy production chains , 2011 .

[16]  M. Janić.  Modelling the full costs of an intermodal and road freight transport network , 2007 .

[17]  Cathy Macharis,et al.  A Road Network for Freight Transport in Flanders: Multi-Actor Multi-Criteria Assessment of Alternative Ring Ways , 2013 .

[18]  Kevin F. R. Liu,et al.  Decision-support for environmental impact assessment: A hybrid approach using fuzzy logic and fuzzy analytic network process , 2009, Expert Syst. Appl..

[19]  Umut Rifat Tuzkaya,et al.  Evaluating the environmental effects of transportation modes using an integrated methodology and an application , 2009 .

[20]  T. Sowlati,et al.  Assessment and optimization of forest biomass supply chains from economic, social and environmental perspectives – A review of literature , 2014 .

[21]  M. Lenzen,et al.  Triple bottom line study of a lignocellulosic biofuel industry , 2016 .

[22]  A. Horvath,et al.  Evaluation of life-cycle air emission factors of freight transportation. , 2007, Environmental science & technology.

[23]  Ender Özcan,et al.  Fuzzy multi-criteria decision making for carbon dioxide geological storage in Turkey , 2015 .

[24]  Wladyslaw Gardziejczyk,et al.  The influence of the scenario and assessment method on the choice of road alignment variants , 2014 .

[25]  Gjalt Huppes,et al.  Life cycle assessment and sustainability analysis of products, materials and technologies. Toward a scientific framework for sustainability life cycle analysis , 2010 .

[26]  M. Ramachandran,et al.  Application of multi-criteria decision making to sustainable energy planning--A review , 2004 .

[27]  M. Bohanec,et al.  The Analytic Hierarchy Process , 2004 .

[28]  T. E. Kleynhans,et al.  Determining the most sustainable lignocellulosic bioenergy system following a case study approach. , 2014 .

[29]  Cathy Macharis,et al.  THE STRATEGIC EVALUATION OF NEW TECHNOLOGIES THROUGH MULTICRITERIA ANALYSIS: THE ADVISORS CASE. IN: ECONOMIC IMPACTS OF INTELLIGENT TRANSPORTATION SYSTEMS: INNOVATIONS AND CASE STUDIES , 2004 .

[30]  Tracey Holloway,et al.  Carbon payback times for crop-based biofuel expansion in the tropics: the effects of changing yield and technology , 2008 .

[31]  Alejandro Tudela,et al.  Comparing the output of cost benefit and multi-criteria analysis: An application to urban transport investments , 2006 .

[32]  Anjali Awasthi,et al.  Using AHP and Dempster-Shafer theory for evaluating sustainable transport solutions , 2011, Environ. Model. Softw..

[33]  Eva Llera-Sastresa,et al.  Liquefied natural gas: Could it be a reliable option for road freight transport in the EU? , 2017 .

[34]  R. P. Verbeek,et al.  LNG for trucks and ships: fact analysis review of pollutant and GHG emissions. Final draft , 2014 .

[35]  A. Verma,et al.  Sustainability impact assessment of transportation policies – A case study for Bangalore city , 2015 .

[36]  Walter Klöpffer,et al.  Life cycle assessment , 1997, Environmental science and pollution research international.

[37]  Cathy Macharis,et al.  Modal choice in freight transport: combining multi-criteria decision analysis and geographic information systems , 2016 .

[38]  Paolo Beria,et al.  Multicriteria versus Cost Benefit Analysis: a comparative perspective in the assessment of sustainable mobility , 2012 .

[39]  Erik Kjeang,et al.  Life cycle emissions and cost of transportation systems: Case study on diesel and natural gas for light duty trucks in municipal fleet operations , 2015 .

[40]  Licinio da Silva Portugal,et al.  Location of cargo terminals in metropolitan areas of developing countries: the Brazilian case , 2011 .

[41]  Pascal Lesage,et al.  Guidelines for Social Life Cycle Assessment of Products. : Social and socio-economic LCA guidelines complementing environmental LCA and Life Cycle Costing, contributing to the full assessment of goods and services within the context of sustainable development. , 2009 .

[42]  Laurence Turcksin,et al.  A Combined AHP-PROMETHEE Approach for Selecting the Most Appropriate Policy Scenario to Stimulate a Clean Vehicle Fleet , 2011 .

[43]  Selçuk Bilgen,et al.  New horizon in energy: Shale gas , 2016 .

[44]  Danièle Revel,et al.  Annual European Union greenhouse gas inventory 1990-…2011 and inventory report 2013 , 2013 .

[45]  Andrzej Kraslawski,et al.  Analysis of rationality of coal-based synthetic natural gas (SNG) production in China , 2014 .

[46]  Jiangjiang Wang,et al.  Multi-objective energy planning for regional natural gas distributed energy: A case study , 2016 .

[47]  Stefan Lochner,et al.  Modeling the European natural gas market during the 2009 Russian–Ukrainian gas conflict: Ex-post simulation and analysis , 2011 .

[48]  Steen Leleur,et al.  Composite decision support by combining cost-benefit and multi-criteria decision analysis , 2011, Decis. Support Syst..

[49]  Petros A. Pilavachi,et al.  Evaluation of next generation biomass derived fuels for the transport sector , 2013 .

[50]  P. W. Madson,et al.  Fuel ethanol production , 2003 .

[51]  A. V. Kale,et al.  Assessment of alternative fuels for transportation using a hybrid graph theory and analytic hierarchy process method , 2015 .

[52]  Zouheir Fawaz,et al.  Evaluation of microalgal alternative jet fuel using the AHP method with an emphasis on the environmental and economic criteria , 2013 .

[53]  Dalia Streimikiene,et al.  Comparative assessment of road transport technologies , 2013 .

[54]  Jiangjiang Wang,et al.  Review on multi-criteria decision analysis aid in sustainable energy decision-making , 2009 .

[55]  Ram M. Shrestha,et al.  MULTI-CRITERIA APPROACH FOR THE SELECTION OF ALTERNATIVE OPTIONS FOR ENVIRONMENTALLY SUSTAINABLE TRANSPORT SYSTEM IN DELHI , 2003 .

[56]  P Klungboonkrong,et al.  A microcomputer-based- system for multicriteria environmental impacts evaluation of urban road networks , 1998 .

[57]  B. Laponche,et al.  The green paper «Towards a European Strategy for the security of energy supply » , 2001 .

[58]  Reinout Heijungs,et al.  LCA of second generation bioethanol: A review and some issues to be resolved for good LCA practice , 2012 .

[59]  Joyendu Bhadury,et al.  Optimization Modeling in Acquisitions: A Case Study from the Motor Carrier Industry , 2006 .

[60]  B. Richardson.  Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change , 1998 .

[61]  Cheng-Wei Lin,et al.  Multi-criteria analysis of alternative-fuel buses for public transportation , 2005 .

[62]  Stephen T Muench,et al.  Roadway Construction Sustainability Impacts , 2010 .

[63]  Pradip Majumdar,et al.  Feasibility analysis for solid oxide fuel cells as a power source for railroad road locomotives , 2010 .

[64]  M. Blom,et al.  How to socially assess biofuels : a case study of the UNEP/SETAC Code of Practice for social- economical LCA , 2009 .

[65]  Paolo Ferrari,et al.  A method for choosing from among alternative transportation projects , 2003, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[66]  Jingzheng Ren,et al.  Fuzzy multi-criteria decision-making method for technology selection for emissions reduction from shipping under uncertainties , 2015 .

[67]  Petros A. Pilavachi,et al.  Evaluation of alternative fuels for the Greek road transport sector using the analytic hierarchy process , 2012 .

[68]  Hua Jiang,et al.  Life cycle sustainability assessment of fuels , 2007 .

[69]  Riccardo Rossi,et al.  Comparison of fuzzy-based and AHP methods in sustainability evaluation: a case of traffic pollution-reducing policies , 2012, European Transport Research Review.

[70]  Jessica E. Leahy,et al.  Social life cycle assessment of palm oil biodiesel: a case study in Jambi Province of Indonesia , 2013, The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment.

[71]  Thomas L. Saaty,et al.  Models, Methods, Concepts & Applications of the Analytic Hierarchy Process , 2012 .

[72]  J. Hansson,et al.  Addressing positive impacts in social LCA—discussing current and new approaches exemplified by the case of vehicle fuels , 2018, The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment.

[73]  B. Nwankwo.  The Politics of Conflict over Oil in the Niger Delta Region of Nigeria: A Review of the Corporate Social Responsibility Strategies of the Oil Companies , 2015 .

[74]  Jorge Curiel-Esparza,et al.  Prioritization by consensus of enhancements for sustainable mobility in urban areas , 2016 .

[75]  Anthony Halog,et al.  A meta‐analytic review of life cycle assessment and flow analyses studies of palm oil biodiesel , 2013, Integrated environmental assessment and management.

[76]  John Psarras,et al.  How does a natural gas supply interruption affect the EU gas security? A Monte Carlo simulation , 2015 .

[77]  S. Gialanella,et al.  Photodegradation of Pollutants in Air: Enhanced Properties of Nano-TiO2Prepared by Ultrasound , 2008, Nanoscale research letters.

[78]  Christian Thiel,et al.  Assessing factors for the identification of potential lead markets for electrified vehicles in Europe: expert opinion elicitation , 2012 .

[79]  R. Handfield,et al.  Managing Conflict of Interest Issues in Purchasing , 2006 .

[80]  John Elkington,et al.  Partnerships from cannibals with forks: The triple bottom line of 21st‐century business , 1998 .

[81]  Simone P. Souza,et al.  Environmental benefits of the integrated production of ethanol and biodiesel , 2013 .

[82]  A. Sanders.  Taxation and Customs Union , 2017 .

[83]  Nydia Suppen,et al.  A Review of Environmental Life Cycle Assessments of Liquid Transportation Biofuels in the Pan American Region , 2015, Environmental Management.

[84]  Kai Chen Goh,et al.  Managing cost implications for highway infrastructure sustainability , 2014, International Journal of Environmental Science and Technology.

[85]  S. Luca.  Public engagement in strategic transportation planning: An analytic hierarchy process based approach , 2014 .

[86]  Eric D. Larson,et al.  A review of life-cycle analysis studies on liquid biofuel systems for the transport sector , 2006 .

[87]  M. Lindner,et al.  A concept for assessing sustainability impacts of forestry-wood chains , 2010, European Journal of Forest Research.

[88]  Florian Weiser,et al.  An Embargo of Russian Gas and Security of Supply in Europe , 2015 .

[89]  A. Faaij,et al.  Different palm oil production systems for energy purposes and their greenhouse gas implications , 2008 .

[90]  Eftihia Nathanail,et al.  Optimization of Decision-Making in Port Logistics Terminals: Using Analytic Hierarchy Process for the Case of Port of Thessaloniki , 2014 .

[91]  Cathy Macharis,et al.  The importance of stakeholder analysis in freight transport , 2004 .

[92]  S. Polasky,et al.  Land Clearing and the Biofuel Carbon Debt , 2008, Science.

[93]  Bo Pedersen Weidema,et al.  The Integration of Economic and Social Aspects in Life Cycle Impact Assessment , 2006 .

[94]  Ignacio Zabalza Bribián,et al.  Energy efficiency in transport and mobility from an eco-efficiency viewpoint , 2011 .

[95]  Yasanur Kayikci,et al.  A conceptual model for intermodal freight logistics centre location decisions , 2010 .

[96]  H. Hasibuan,et al.  Alternatives Selection for Sustainable Transportation System in Kasongan City , 2016 .

[97]  F. Godlee.  An international standard for disclosure of clinical trial information , 2006, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[98]  Walter Kloepffer,et al.  Life cycle sustainability assessment of products , 2008 .

[99]  Gholam R. Amin,et al.  Railway station site selection using analytical hierarchy process and data envelopment analysis , 2010, Comput. Ind. Eng..

[100]  Kim-Leng Poh,et al.  Transportation fuels and policy for Singapore: an AHP planning approach , 1999 .

[101]  How to model different socio-economic and environmental aspects of biomass utilisation: Case study in selected regions in Slovenia and Croatia , 2007 .

[102]  Joseph C. Ebegbulem,et al.  Oil Exploration and Poverty in the Niger Delta Region of Nigeria: A Critical Analysis , 2013 .

[103]  Javier Monsalve-Serrano,et al.  The potential of RCCI concept to meet EURO VI NOx limitation and ultra-low soot emissions in a heavy-duty engine over the whole engine map , 2015 .

[104]  Alex Fiz.  2014 SUSTAINABILITY REPORT , 2014 .

[105]  Athakorn Kengpol,et al.  The development of a framework for route selection in multimodal transportation , 2014 .

[106]  D. Mavrakis,et al.  Multi‐criteria evaluation of climate policy interactions , 2006 .

[107]  R. Clift,et al.  Support for Sustainable Development Policy Decisions A Case Study from Highway Maintenance , 2006 .

[108]  Tzay-An Shiau,et al.  Developing an indicator system for local governments to evaluate transport sustainability strategies , 2013 .

[109]  L. Phillips,et al.  Multi-criteria analysis: a manual , 2009 .

[110]  L. Ellram,et al.  The Use of Total Cost of Ownership Concepts to Model the Outsourcing Decision , 1995 .

[111]  F. You,et al.  Optimal design of sustainable cellulosic biofuel supply chains: Multiobjective optimization coupled with life cycle assessment and input–output analysis , 2012 .

[112]  Jason C. Quinn,et al.  The potentials and challenges of algae based biofuels: a review of the techno-economic, life cycle, and resource assessment modeling. , 2015, Bioresource technology.

[113]  Göran Finnveden,et al.  Screening potential social impacts of fossil fuels and biofuels for vehicles , 2014 .

[114]  Nurbanu Caliskan.  A decision support approach for the evaluation of transport investment alternatives , 2006, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[115]  J. M. Vleugel,et al.  Estimating potential reductions in externalities from rail–road substitution in Trans-European freight transport corridors , 2012 .

[116]  Shabbir H. Gheewala,et al.  Life cycle cost analysis of alternative vehicles and fuels in Thailand , 2007 .

[117]  Dimitrios A Tsamboulas,et al.  Use of Multicriteria Methods for Assessment of Transport Projects , 1999 .

[118]  S. Underwood,et al.  A MULTIATTRIBUTE ANALYSIS OF GOALS FOR INTELLIGENT TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM PLANNING , 1996 .

[119]  M. Curran,et al.  A review of assessments conducted on bio-ethanol as a transportation fuel from a net energy, greenhouse gas, and environmental life cycle perspective , 2007 .

[120]  Sonia Yeh,et al.  An empirical analysis on the adoption of alternative fuel vehicles: The case of natural gas vehicles , 2007 .

[121]  Geoffrey P. Hammond,et al.  Environmental life cycle assessment of lignocellulosic conversion to ethanol: A review , 2012 .

[122]  Philipp M. Richter,et al.  All Quiet on the Eastern Front? Disruption Scenarios of Russian Natural Gas Supply to Europe , 2014 .

[123]  S. Gheewala,et al.  Biofuels: economic, environmental and social benefits and costs for developing countries in Asia , 2013 .