Ethical and regulatory considerations in HIV prevention studies employing respondent-driven sampling.

OBJECTIVE To review the scientific, ethical, and regulatory literature because no official guidance exists on remuneration for participant-driven recruitment or on investigators' responsibilities for informing participants of their discordant partnerships. METHODS We reviewed the studies that used RDS to recruit injection-drug users (IDUs), 1995-2006, and the relevant scientific, ethical, and regulatory literature that shed light on arguments for and against practices that can be used in studies employing RDS. RESULTS Concerns that payments can be used to buy drugs or can subvert altruistic motivations for study participation are not supported by the literature. Concerns about peers' coercion to barter coupons or surrender payments are offset by safeguards used in RDS. Remuneration shows respect for participants' time and effort in recruitment and judgment to use remuneration for personal needs. Tension between ensuring participants' confidentiality and protecting the health of network members highlights difference in roles between investigators and health care providers. Investigators can choose to rely on public health agencies for partner notification services, ask participants if and how they would like to be informed of their discordant partnerships, and offer training on how to disclose HIV status and adopt risk-reduction and harm-reduction behaviours. CONCLUSION Clarifying ethical and regulatory considerations is important for research sponsors, institutional review boards (IRBs), ethics review committees (ERCs), investigators, and participants. We provide a checklist of ethics and regulatory variables to be included as feasible in future studies to enhance development of evidence-based ethics.

[1]  J. Catania,et al.  Methodological problems in AIDS behavioral research: influences on measurement error and participation bias in studies of sexual behavior. , 1990, Psychological bulletin.

[2]  G. Marks,et al.  Serostatus disclosure, sexual communication and safer sex in HIV-positive men , 2003, AIDS care.

[3]  T. Rhodes,et al.  The social structural production of HIV risk among injecting drug users. , 2005, Social science & medicine.

[4]  A. Fairchild,et al.  Ethics and the Conduct of Public Health Surveillance , 2004, Science.

[5]  Douglas D. Heckathorn,et al.  Effectiveness of Respondent-Driven Sampling for Recruiting Drug Users in New York City: Findings from a Pilot Study , 2006, Journal of Urban Health.

[6]  Courtney McKnight,et al.  Respondent-Driven Sampling in a Study of Drug Users in New York City: Notes from the Field , 2006, Journal of Urban Health.

[7]  Akira Akabayashi,et al.  Informed Consent Revisited: Japan and the U.S. , 2006, The American journal of bioethics : AJOB.

[8]  D. Zion.  Does Autonomy Require Freedom? The Importance of Options in International HIV/AIDS Research , 2005, Health Care Analysis.

[9]  R. Amdur,et al.  Institutional Review Board: Management and Function , 2002 .

[10]  Taking Names: The Ethics of Indirect Recruitment in Research on Sexual Networks , 2000, Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics.

[11]  W. Halperin,et al.  Public health surveillance : toolkit , 2002 .

[12]  Ronald C. Kessler,et al.  Methodological Issues in AIDS Behavioral Research , 1993, AIDS Prevention and Mental Health.

[13]  E. Emanuel.  Ending Concerns about Undue Inducement , 2004, The Journal of law, medicine & ethics : a journal of the American Society of Law, Medicine & Ethics.

[14]  D. Rosenstein,et al.  Reporting of ethical issues in publications of medical research , 2002, The Lancet.

[15]  A. Lansky,et al.  Developing an HIV Behavioral Surveillance System for Injecting Drug Users: The National HIV Behavioral Surveillance System , 2007, Public health reports.

[16]  Stephanie Tortu,et al.  Recruiting Injection Drug Users: A Three-Site Comparison of Results and Experiences with Respondent-Driven and Targeted Sampling Procedures , 2006, Journal of Urban Health.

[17]  M. Wilkinson,et al.  Inducement in research. , 1997, Bioethics.

[18]  David R. Holtgrave,et al.  Utilizing HIV transmission rates to assist in prioritizing HIV prevention services , 2004, International journal of STD & AIDS.

[19]  Francis Galton,et al.  English men of science : their nature and nurture , 1874 .

[20]  C. Weijer,et al.  The ethics wars. Disputes over international research. , 2001, The Hastings Center report.

[21]  Douglas D. Heckathorn,et al.  From Networks to Populations: The Development and Application of Respondent-Driven Sampling Among IDUs and Latino Gay Men , 2005, AIDS and Behavior.

[22]  M. Heywood,et al.  Opening up the HIV / AIDS epidemic. Guidance on encouraging beneficial disclosure ethical partner counselling and appropriate use of HIV case-reporting. Executive summary. , 2000 .

[23]  C. Latkin,et al.  Injection Drug Users' Disclosure of HIV Seropositive Status to Network Members , 2004, AIDS and Behavior.

[24]  Julian Savulescu,et al.  Addiction and autonomy: can addicted people consent to the prescription of their drug of addiction? , 2006, Bioethics.

[25]  J. Monahan,et al.  Two scales for measuring patients' perceptions for coercion during mental hospital admission. , 1993, Behavioral sciences & the law.

[26]  Douglas D. Heckathorn,et al.  Respondent-driven sampling II: deriving valid population estimates from chain-referral samples of hi , 2002 .

[27]  Leslie Kish,et al.  Taxonomy of elusive populations , 1992 .

[28]  R. Dwyer,et al.  For love or money? An exploratory study of why injecting drug users participate in research. , 2001, Addiction.

[29]  Don C. Des Jarlais,et al.  Interventions to reduce the sexual risk behaviour of injecting drug users , 2005 .

[30]  J. Gerberding,et al.  Advancing HIV prevention: new strategies for a changing epidemic--United States, 2003. , 2003, MMWR. Morbidity and mortality weekly report.

[31]  S. Tortu,et al.  The impact of providing incentives for attendance at AIDS prevention sessions. , 1994, Public health reports.

[32]  Rebeca Ramos,et al.  Respondent-Driven Sampling of Injection Drug Users in Two U.S.–Mexico Border Cities: Recruitment Dynamics and Impact on Estimates of HIV and Syphilis Prevalence , 2006, Journal of Urban Health.

[33]  H. Handsfield,et al.  Behavioral interventions for prevention and control of sexually transmitted diseases , 2007 .

[34]  H. Hearnshaw.  Comparison of requirements of research ethics committees in 11 European countries for a non-invasive interventional study , 2004, British medical journal.

[35]  C. Grady,et al.  Money for Research Participation: Does It Jeopardize Informed Consent? , 2001, The American journal of bioethics : AJOB.

[36]  Wolzt,et al.  World Medical Association Declaration of Helsinki: ethical principles for medical research involving human subjects. , 2003, The Journal of the American College of Dentists.

[37]  J. Gagnon,et al.  The Social Organization of Sexuality: Sexual Practices in the United States , 1994 .

[38]  David R. Holtgrave,et al.  Can Increasing Awareness of HIV Seropositivity Reduce Infections by 50% in the United States? , 2007, Journal of acquired immune deficiency syndromes.

[39]  D. Marlowe,et al.  Do research payments precipitate drug use or coerce participation? , 2005, Drug and alcohol dependence.

[40]  Edward L. Deci,et al.  Intrinsic Motivation and Self-Determination in Human Behavior , 1975, Perspectives in Social Psychology.

[41]  S. Halpern.  Towards evidence based bioethics , 2005, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[42]  J. Kleinig.  Ethical Issues in Substance Use Intervention , 2004, Substance use & misuse.

[43]  Alden S. Klovdahl,et al.  Social network research and human subjects protection: Towards more effective infectious disease control , 2005, Soc. Networks.

[44]  C. Latkin,et al.  HIV seropositive drug users' attitudes towards partner notification (PCRS): results from the SHIELD study in Baltimore, Maryland. , 2007, Patient education and counseling.

[45]  L. Hedges,et al.  The Handbook of Research Synthesis , 1995 .

[46]  Charles Weijer,et al.  Informing study participants of research results: an ethical imperative. , 2003, IRB.

[47]  Robert G Carlson,et al.  Respondent-driven sampling to recruit MDMA users: a methodological assessment. , 2005, Drug and alcohol dependence.

[48]  Dimitri Prybylski,et al.  Application of Respondent Driven Sampling to Collect Baseline Data on FSWs and MSM for HIV Risk Reduction Interventions in Two Urban Centres in Papua New Guinea , 2006, Journal of Urban Health.

[49]  N. Crepaz,et al.  A Systematic Review of HIV Partner Counseling and Referral Services: Client and Provider Attitudes, Preferences, Practices, and Experiences , 2006, Sexually transmitted diseases.

[50]  G. Rinkel,et al.  Modified informed consent procedure: consent to postponed information , 2003, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[51]  S. Semaan,et al.  The Ethics of Public Health Practice for the Prevention and Control of STDs , 2007 .

[52]  A. Fairchild.  Dealing with Humpty Dumpty: Research, Practice, and the Ethics of Public Health Surveillance , 2003, Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics.

[53]  J. Warszawski,et al.  Sex difference in partner notification: results from three population based surveys in France , 2002, Sexually transmitted infections.

[54]  Bruce D. Johnson,et al.  How much do Manhattan-arrestees spend on drugs? , 2004, Drug and alcohol dependence.

[55]  B. Knoppers,et al.  The emergence of an ethical duty to disclose genetic research results: international perspectives , 2006, European Journal of Human Genetics.

[56]  S Sudman,et al.  Sampling Rare and Elusive Populations , 1988, Science.

[57]  S. Bartholomae,et al.  The Recruitment of Normal Healthy Volunteers: A Review of The Literature on the Use of Financial Incentives , 2002, Journal of clinical pharmacology.

[58]  D. D. Des Jarlais,et al.  “Informed Altruism” and “Partner Restriction” in the Reduction of HIV Infection in Injecting Drug Users Entering Detoxification Treatment in New York City, 1990–2001 , 2004, Journal of acquired immune deficiency syndromes.

[59]  P. Sullivan,et al.  Use of Rapid Behavioral Assessments to Determine the Prevalence of HIV Risk Behaviors in High-Risk Populations , 2007, Public health reports.

[60]  Lincoln E. Moses,et al.  AIDS: sexual behavior and intravenous drug use. , 1989 .

[61]  Jennifer Lauby,et al.  Street and network sampling in evaluation studies of HIV risk-reduction interventions. , 2002, AIDS reviews.

[62]  Tobi Saidel,et al.  Review of sampling hard-to-reach and hidden populations for HIV surveillance. , 2005, AIDS.

[63]  D. Heckathorn.  6. Extensions of Respondent-Driven Sampling: Analyzing Continuous Variables and Controlling for Differential Recruitment , 2007 .

[64]  R J Mills,et al.  Harnessing peer networks as an instrument for AIDS prevention: results from a peer-driven intervention. , 1998, Public health reports.

[65]  Violeta Andjelkovic,et al.  Exploring Barriers to ‘Respondent Driven Sampling’ in Sex Worker and Drug-Injecting Sex Worker Populations in Eastern Europe , 2006, Journal of Urban Health.

[66]  Adrian Mindel,et al.  Recent advances: Sexually transmitted infections , 1998 .

[67]  L. Wilson,et al.  Quality management in health care , 1997 .

[68]  Claire Gilbert Foster,et al.  International ethical guidelines for biomedical research involving human subjects , 1994 .

[69]  G. Rinkel,et al.  Patients' evaluation of informed consent to postponed information: cohort study , 2004, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[70]  S. Paxton.  The paradox of public HIV disclosure , 2002, AIDS care.

[71]  H. Sharp,et al.  When "Minimal Risk" Research Yields Clinically-Significant Data, Maybe the Risks Aren't So Minimal , 2004, The American journal of bioethics : AJOB.

[72]  W. Hall,et al.  The Ethics of Paying Drug Users Who Participate in Research: A Review and Practical Recommendations , 2006, Journal of empirical research on human research ethics : JERHRE.

[73]  K. Holmes,et al.  Partner Notification for HIV and STD in the United States:: Low Coverage for Gonorrhea, Chlamydial Infection, and HIV , 2003, Sexually transmitted diseases.

[74]  J. Hughes.  Paying injection drug users to educate and recruit their peers: why participant-driven interventions are an ethical public health model. , 1999, Quality management in health care.

[75]  A. Abdul-Quader,et al.  Convergence of HIV seroprevalence among injecting and non-injecting drug users in New York City , 2007, AIDS.

[76]  J. Parsons,et al.  Positive and negative consequences of HIV disclosure among seropositive injection drug users. , 2004, AIDS education and prevention : official publication of the International Society for AIDS Education.

[77]  J. Sieber,et al.  Introducing a New Paradigm for Ethical Research in the Social, Behavioral, and Biomedical Sciences: Part I , 2006 .

[78]  Douglas D. Heckathorn,et al.  Respondent-driven sampling : A new approach to the study of hidden populations , 1997 .

[79]  J. Merz,et al.  How Much Are Subjects Paid to Participate in Research? , 2001, The American journal of bioethics : AJOB.

[80]  T. Lemmens,et al.  The Human Subjects Trade: Ethical and Legal Issues Surrounding Recruitment Incentives , 2003, Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics.

[81]  Ezekiel J Emanuel,et al.  What makes clinical research in developing countries ethical? The benchmarks of ethical research. , 2004, The Journal of infectious diseases.

[82]  D. Snider,et al.  Defining research when it comes to public health. , 1997, Public health reports.

[83]  Dana E. Katz,et al.  All Gifts Large and Small Toward an Understanding of the Ethics of Pharmaceutical Industry Gift-Giving , 2007 .

[84]  Matthew J. Salganik.  Variance Estimation, Design Effects, and Sample Size Calculations for Respondent-Driven Sampling , 2006, Journal of Urban Health.

[85]  klaguia.  The Emergence of an Ethical Duty to Disclose Genetic Research Results , 2006 .

[86]  L. Hedges,et al.  A Protocol for the Analytical Aspects of a Systematic Review of HIV Prevention Research , 2002, Journal of acquired immune deficiency syndromes.

[87]  Graham Kalton,et al.  Sampling Considerations in Research on HIV Risk and Illness , 2002 .

[88]  Arthur L. Caplan,et al.  All Gifts Large and Small , 2003 .

[89]  E. Wong,et al.  Informed consent: an international researchers' perspective. , 2007, American journal of public health.

[90]  Clarifying Confusions about Coercion , 2005, The Hastings Center report.

[91]  David R. Holtgrave.  Estimation of Annual HIV Transmission Rates in the United States, 1978–2000 , 2004, Journal of acquired immune deficiency syndromes.

[92]  J. Pape,et al.  Ten questions institutional review boards should ask when reviewing international clinical research protocols. , 2003, IRB.

[93]  Douglas D. Heckathorn,et al.  Implementation and Analysis of Respondent Driven Sampling: Lessons Learned from the Field , 2006, Journal of Urban Health.

[94]  C. Grady,et al.  An analysis of U.S. practices of paying research participants. , 2005, Contemporary clinical trials.

[95]  J. Tiffany.  Respondent-Driven Sampling in Participatory Research Contexts: Participant-Driven Recruitment , 2006, Journal of Urban Health.

[96]  L. D'Angelo,et al.  Teenagers, HIV, and AIDS: Insights from Youths Living with the Virus , 2006 .

[97]  Douglas D. Heckathorn,et al.  Drug Users versus Outreach Workers in Combating Aids: Preliminary Results of a Peer-Driven Intervention , 1995 .

[98]  C. Fisher.  Ethics in Drug Abuse and Related HIV Risk Research , 2004 .

[99]  O. Levina,et al.  An Analysis of Respondent Driven Sampling with Injection Drug Users (IDU) in Albania and the Russian Federation , 2006, Journal of Urban Health.

[100]  A. Goldworth,et al.  Informed Consent Revisited , 1996, Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics.

[101]  R. Eisenberger,et al.  Detrimental effects of reward. Reality or myth? , 1996, The American psychologist.

[102]  M. Katz,et al.  HIV prevalence, risk behaviors, health care use, and mental health status of transgender persons: implications for public health intervention. , 2001, American journal of public health.

[103]  Douglas D. Heckathorn,et al.  RATIONAL CHOICE, PUBLIC POLICY AND AIDS , 1996 .

[104]  Lisa G. Johnston,et al.  Methods to Recruit Hard-to-Reach Groups: Comparing Two Chain Referral Sampling Methods of Recruiting Injecting Drug Users Across Nine Studies in Russia and Estonia , 2006, Journal of Urban Health.

[105]  L. Moses,et al.  Sexual Behavior And Aids , 1989 .

[106]  D. Heckathorn,et al.  Extensions of Respondent-Driven Sampling: A New Approach to the Study of Injection Drug Users Aged 18–25 , 2002, AIDS and Behavior.