Road traffic fatalities in Arkhangelsk, Russia in 2005-2010: reliability of police and healthcare data.

PURPOSE To estimate and compare reliability of traffic mortality data of the police and the healthcare sector in Arkhangelsk, Russia. METHODS The study matched traffic mortality data of the police and the regional healthcare statistics centre for the period from 2005 to 2010. Individual investigations of unmatched cases were performed, and the underlying causes of the non-matches were established. The obtained distribution of non-matches by causes served as basis for estimating the true numbers of traffic fatalities in the two sources, in appliance with corresponding fatality definitions and registration rules. A data accuracy index (DAI) was calculated for each source by using an adapted version of the formula for calculating accuracy of a diagnostic test. This was used as a measure for data reliability. Time trends in annual DAIs were estimated for each source by χ(2)-test for linear trend. RESULTS During the 6-year period, the police and the healthcare statistics centre registered 217 and 237 traffic fatalities in Arkhangelsk, respectively. Matching of data from the two sources resulted in 162 matched cases, 55 unmatched cases in the police data, and 75 unmatched cases in the healthcare data. More than a half (56%) of the non-matches were attributed to incompatibility of the definitions in the two data registration systems; 39% were attributed to failures in the healthcare data. Other non-matches were due to scarce identifying information (2%) or were not classifiable (2%). None of the non-matches were clearly attributable to failures in the police data. The 6-year DAI was 98% for the police data and 80% for the healthcare data. The DAI for the police data was stable over 2005-2010 (ranging from 96% to 100%). The DAI for the healthcare data increased from 66% in 2005 to 98% in 2010 (Ptrend<0.001). CONCLUSION The findings suggest that traffic mortality data of the police were more reliable, compared to the healthcare data. However, reliability of the healthcare data was improving during the study period.

[1]  Kavi Bhalla,et al.  Estimating the incidence of road traffic fatalities and injuries in Sri Lanka using multiple data sources , 2010, International journal of injury control and safety promotion.

[2]  A. Morrison,et al.  Capture-recapture: a useful methodological tool for counting traffic related injuries? , 2000, Injury prevention : journal of the International Society for Child and Adolescent Injury Prevention.

[3]  Andy H. Lee,et al.  Estimating crashes involving heavy vehicles in Western Australia, 1999-2000: a capture-recapture method. , 2006, Accident; analysis and prevention.

[4]  Muhammad Usman Lateef,et al.  Estimation of fatalities due to road traffic crashes in Karachi, Pakistan, using capture-recapture method. , 2010, Asia-Pacific journal of public health.

[5]  N. Haworth,et al.  SUICIDE AND NATURAL DEATHS IN ROAD TRAFFIC: REVIEW , 2003 .

[6]  R R Regal,et al.  Capture-recapture methods in epidemiology: methods and limitations. , 1995, Epidemiologic reviews.

[7]  H. Kelly,et al.  Using the two-source capture-recapture method to estimate the incidence of acute flaccid paralysis in Victoria, Australia. , 2002, Bulletin of the World Health Organization.

[8]  E. Begier,et al.  Etiology of Nonspecific Cause of Death Coding in New York City Motor Vehicle Crash–Related Fatalities , 2011, Traffic injury prevention.

[9]  D L Rosman,et al.  The western australian road injury database (1987-1996): ten years of linked police, hospital and death records of road crashes and injuries. , 2001, Accident; analysis and prevention.

[10]  B. Ytterstad,et al.  The Harstad Injury Prevention Study: evaluation of hospital-based injury recording and community-based intervention for traffic injury prevention. , 1995, Accident; analysis and prevention.

[11]  M W Knuiman,et al.  A comparison of hospital and police road injury data. , 1994, Accident; analysis and prevention.

[12]  J. Razzak,et al.  Estimating deaths and injuries due to road traffic accidents in Karachi, Pakistan, through the capture-recapture method. , 1998, International journal of epidemiology.

[13]  Ronald E. LaPorte,et al.  Capture-recapture and multiple-record systems estimation I: History and theoretical development ( Review ) , 1995 .

[14]  Jean-Louis Martin,et al.  Actual incidences of road casualties, and their injury severity, modelled from police and hospital data, France. , 2008, European journal of public health.

[15]  Joseph H Abramson,et al.  WINPEPI (PEPI-for-Windows): computer programs for epidemiologists , 2004, Epidemiologic perspectives & innovations : EP+I.

[16]  Tami Toroyan,et al.  Global Status Report on Road Safety: Time for Action , 2009 .

[17]  Rune Elvik,et al.  Incomplete Accident Reporting: Meta-Analysis of Studies Made in 13 Countries , 1999 .

[18]  Ronan A Lyons,et al.  Using multiple datasets to understand trends in serious road traffic casualties. , 2008, Accident; analysis and prevention.

[19]  D H Stone,et al.  An evaluation of police reporting of road casualties , 2009, Injury Prevention.

[20]  L R Salmi,et al.  Road accident statistics: discrepancies between police and hospital data in a French island. , 1999, Accident; analysis and prevention.

[21]  George Yannis,et al.  Linking Emergency Medical Department and Road Traffic Police Casualty Data: A Tool in Assessing the Burden of Injuries in Less Resourced Countries , 2009, Traffic injury prevention.

[22]  W. Dunsmuir,et al.  How comparable are road traffic crash cases in hospital admissions data and police records? An examination of data linkage rates , 2008, Australian and New Zealand journal of public health.

[23]  O. Nilssen,et al.  Injury Prevention and Safety Promotion course in a Russian Master of Public Health programme , 2012, International journal of injury control and safety promotion.

[24]  A. Grjibovski,et al.  Road traffic crashes with fatal and non-fatal injuries in Arkhangelsk, Russia in 2005–2010 , 2013, International journal of injury control and safety promotion.

[25]  Stephen P. Glasser,et al.  Essentials of Clinical Research , 2008 .

[26]  H Brenner,et al.  Application of Capture-Recapture Methods for Disease Monitoring: Potential Effects of Imperfect Record Linkage , 1994, Methods of Information in Medicine.

[27]  V W Sidel,et al.  Capture-recapture methods for assessing the completeness of case ascertainment when using multiple information sources. , 1974, Journal of chronic diseases.

[28]  Emmanuelle Amoros,et al.  Under-reporting of road crash casualties in France. , 2006, Accident; analysis and prevention.

[29]  Kavi Bhalla,et al.  Methods for developing country level estimates of the incidence of deaths and non-fatal injuries from road traffic crashes , 2009, International journal of injury control and safety promotion.

[30]  Ton J. Cleophas,et al.  Statistics Applied to Clinical Trials , 2000 .

[31]  Publication: Bulletin of the World Health Organization; Type: Research Article , 2002 .

[32]  D. Clark,et al.  Practical introduction to record linkage for injury research , 2004, Injury Prevention.