A comparison of the nutritional profile and nutrient density of commercially available plant-based and dairy yogurts in the United States

Introduction Plant-based yogurts are sustainable alternatives to dairy yogurts, but a nutritional comparison of plant-based yogurts within the context of dairy yogurts has not yet been applied to commercially available products in the United States. Dairy yogurts provide significant dietary nutrients, and substituting plant-based yogurts may have unintended nutritional consequences. The objective of this study was to compare the macronutrient and micronutrient values of commercially available plant-based and dairy yogurts launched between 2016 and 2021. Methods Nutritional information for yogurts were collected through Mintel Global New Products Database, and products were categorized according to their primary ingredient. Regular-style yogurts (n = 612) were included in this study: full-fat dairy (n = 159), low and nonfat dairy (n = 303), coconut (n = 61), almond (n = 44), cashew (n = 30), and oat (n = 15). We utilized the Nutrient Rich Foods (NRF) Index, a comprehensive food guidance system that assigns a score based on the nutrient density of individual foods. This allowed us to compare the nutritional density of the yogurts based on nutrients to encourage (protein, fiber, calcium, iron, potassium, vitamin D) and nutrients to limit (saturated fat, total sugar, sodium). Results Compared to dairy yogurts, plant-based yogurts contained significantly less total sugar, less sodium, and more fiber. However, plant-based yogurts contained significantly less protein, calcium, and potassium than dairy yogurts. The yogurts were ranked from the highest to lowest nutrient density based on the NRF Index as follows: almond, oat, low and nonfat dairy, full-fat dairy, cashew, and coconut. Almond yogurts scored significantly higher than all other yogurts, indicating the highest nutrient density. Discussion The highest NRF scores were awarded to almond and oat yogurts, likely a result of their low levels of total sugar, sodium, and saturated fat. By applying the NRF model to plant-based and dairy yogurts, we have identified opportunities for the food industry to improve the formulation and nutritional composition of plant-based yogurts. In particular, fortification is an opportunity to improve plant-based yogurt nutritional properties.

[1]  M. Sandell,et al.  What if plant-based yogurts were like dairy yogurts? Texture perception and liking of plant-based yogurts among US and Finnish consumers , 2023, Food Quality and Preference.

[2]  C. Forde,et al.  The Nutritional Quality of Plant-Based Foods , 2023, Sustainability.

[3]  M. Kapsokefalou,et al.  Nutritional Quality of Plant-Based Meat and Dairy Imitation Products and Comparison with Animal-Based Counterparts , 2023, Nutrients.

[4]  A. Drewnowski Most Plant-Based Milk Alternatives in the USDA Branded Food Products Database Do Not Meet Proposed Nutrient Standards or Score Well on Nutrient Density Metrics , 2022, Nutrients.

[5]  S. Jaeger,et al.  Understanding barriers to consumption of plant-based foods and beverages: Insights from sensory and consumer science , 2022, Current Opinion in Food Science.

[6]  A. Nolden,et al.  Physicochemical Properties and Mouthfeel in Commercial Plant-Based Yogurts , 2022, Foods.

[7]  Shaoquan Liu,et al.  Ingredients, Processing, and Fermentation: Addressing the Organoleptic Boundaries of Plant-Based Dairy Analogues , 2022, Foods.

[8]  S. Henjum,et al.  Plant-based meat and dairy substitutes on the Norwegian market: comparing macronutrient content in substitutes with equivalent meat and dairy products , 2022, Journal of Nutritional Science.

[9]  L. Ong,et al.  Plant and Dairy-Based Yogurts: A Comparison of Consumer Sensory Acceptability Linked to Textural Analysis , 2022, Foods.

[10]  D. Mcclements,et al.  Functional Performance of Plant Proteins , 2022, Foods.

[11]  N. J. Watson,et al.  Energy management for a net zero dairy supply chain under climate change , 2022, Trends in Food Science & Technology.

[12]  D. Mcclements,et al.  The science of plant-based foods: Approaches to create nutritious and sustainable plant-based cheese analogs , 2021, Trends in Food Science & Technology.

[13]  Cecilia Katzeff,et al.  Differences in Environmental Impact between Plant-Based Alternatives to Dairy and Dairy Products: A Systematic Literature Review , 2021, Sustainability.

[14]  L. Snetselaar,et al.  Dietary Guidelines for Americans, 2020–2025 , 2021, Nutrition today.

[15]  M. Castellari,et al.  Vegan Alternatives to Processed Cheese and Yogurt Launched in the European Market during 2020: A Nutritional Challenge? , 2021, Foods.

[16]  W. Craig,et al.  Nutritional Content and Health Profile of Non-Dairy Plant-Based Yogurt Alternatives , 2021, Nutrients.

[17]  S. Stergiadis,et al.  A comparative assessment of the nutritional composition of dairy and plant-based dairy alternatives available for sale in the UK and the implications for consumers' dietary intakes. , 2021, Food research international.

[18]  A. Flysjö,et al.  Analysing the interaction between the dairy sector and climate change from a life cycle perspective: A review , 2021, Trends in Food Science & Technology.

[19]  C. Forde,et al.  Unintended Consequences: Nutritional Impact and Potential Pitfalls of Switching from Animal- to Plant-Based Foods , 2021, Nutrients.

[20]  A. Drewnowski Perspective: Identifying Ultra-Processed Plant-Based Milk Alternatives in the USDA Branded Food Products Database. , 2021, Advances in nutrition.

[21]  C. Rotz,et al.  Current state of enteric methane and the carbon footprint of beef and dairy cattle in the United States. , 2021, Animal frontiers : the review magazine of animal agriculture.

[22]  Aylin W. Sahin,et al.  Nutritional properties and health aspects of pulses and their use in plant-based yogurt alternatives. , 2021, Comprehensive reviews in food science and food safety.

[23]  D. Mcclements,et al.  The science of plant-based foods: Constructing next-generation meat, fish, milk, and egg analogs. , 2021, Comprehensive reviews in food science and food safety.

[24]  J. Bogue,et al.  Market-oriented Development of Plant-based Food and Beverage Products: A Usage Segmentation Approach , 2021 .

[25]  M. Montemurro,et al.  Plant-Based Alternatives to Yogurt: State-of-the-Art and Perspectives of New Biotechnological Challenges , 2021, Foods.

[26]  A. Nolden,et al.  Dynamic texture perception in plant-based yogurt alternatives: Identifying temporal drivers of liking by TDS , 2020 .

[27]  M. T. Knudsen,et al.  Potential to reduce GHG emissions and land use by substituting animal-based proteins by foods containing oat protein concentrate , 2020 .

[28]  F. Perez-Cueto,et al.  Plant-based food and protein trend from a business perspective: markets, consumers, and the challenges and opportunities in the future , 2020, Critical reviews in food science and nutrition.

[29]  D. Mcclements Development of Next-Generation Nutritionally Fortified Plant-Based Milk Substitutes: Structural Design Principles , 2020, Foods.

[30]  J. O’Mahony,et al.  Composition, Physicochemical and Sensorial Properties of Commercial Plant-Based Yogurts , 2020, Foods.

[31]  E. Kebreab,et al.  Greenhouse gas, water, and land footprint per unit of production of the California dairy industry over 50 years. , 2020, Journal of dairy science.

[32]  A. Ibrahimi,et al.  Syneresis investigations of lacto-fermented sodium caseinate in a mixed model system , 2019, BMC Biotechnology.

[33]  N. Shah Yogurt in health and disease prevention , 2017 .

[34]  A. Drewnowski Uses of nutrient profiling to address public health needs: from regulation to reformulation , 2017, Proceedings of the Nutrition Society.

[35]  E. Arendt,et al.  Past, present and future: The strength of plant-based dairy substitutes based on gluten-free raw materials. , 2017, Food research international.

[36]  Goutham Rao,et al.  The Nutrient Density of Snacks , 2017, Global pediatric health.

[37]  Goutham Rao,et al.  The Nutrient Density of Snacks , 2016, Global pediatric health.

[38]  A. Drewnowski The Nutrient Rich Foods Index helps to identify healthy, affordable foods. , 2010, The American journal of clinical nutrition.

[39]  Adam Drewnowski,et al.  Defining Nutrient Density: Development and Validation of the Nutrient Rich Foods Index , 2009, Journal of the American College of Nutrition.

[40]  Masaomi Teshigawara,et al.  Structural Design Principles , 2001 .

[41]  A. Drewnowski,et al.  Nutrient profiling of foods: creating a nutrient-rich food index. , 2008, Nutrition reviews.

[42]  Teresa Foo,et al.  : SYSTEMATIC LITERATURE REVIEW , 2004 .

[43]  Robert C. Wolpert,et al.  A Review of the , 1985 .

[44]  A. Harper,et al.  Dietary guidelines for Americans. , 1981, The American journal of clinical nutrition.