Camera-based occupancy monitoring at large scales: Power to detect trends in grizzly bears across the Canadian Rockies

Abstract Monitoring carnivores is critical for conservation, yet challenging because they are rare and elusive. Few methods exist for monitoring wide-ranging species over large spatial and sufficiently long temporal scales to detect trends. Remote cameras are an emerging technology for monitoring large carnivores around the world because of their low cost, non-invasive methodology, and their ability to capture pictures of species of concern that are difficult to monitor. For species without uniquely identifiable spots, stripes, or other markings, cameras collect detection/non-detection data that are well suited for monitoring trends in occupancy as its own independent useful metric of species distribution, as well as an index for abundance. As with any new monitoring method, prospective power analysis is essential to ensure meaningful trends can be detected. Here we test camera-based occupancy models as a method to monitor changes in occupancy of a threatened species, grizzly bears (Ursus arctos), at large landscape scales, across 5 Canadian national parks (~ 21,000 km2). With n = 183 cameras, the top occupancy model estimated regional occupancy to be 0.79 across all 5 parks. We evaluate the statistical power to detect simulated 5–40% declines in occupancy between two sampling years and test applied questions of how power is affected by the spatial scale of interest (park level vs. regional level), the number of cameras deployed, and duration of camera deployment. We also explore several ecological mechanisms (i.e., spatial patterns) of decline in occupancy, and examine how power changes when focusing only on grizzly bears family groups. As hypothesized, statistical power increased with the number of cameras and with the number of days deployed. Power was unaffected, however, by the ecological mechanisms of decline, indicating that our systematic sampling design can detect a decline regardless of whether occupancy declined due to range edge attrition, ecological trap or other mechanisms. Despite their lower occupancy, power was similarly high for grizzly bear family groups compared to grizzly bears in general. We highlight which study design attributes contributed to high power and we provide advice for establishing cost-effective camera-based programs for monitoring large carnivore occupancy at large spatial scales.

[1]  Robert J. Steidl,et al.  Statistical power analysis in wildlife research , 1997 .

[2]  J. Andrew Royle,et al.  Scaling-up camera traps: monitoring the planet's biodiversity with networks of remote sensors , 2017 .

[3]  P. Lukacs,et al.  Estimating occupancy using spatially and temporally replicated snow surveys , 2015 .

[4]  L. L. Bailey,et al.  Efficient Species‐Level Monitoring at the Landscape Scale , 2012, Conservation biology : the journal of the Society for Conservation Biology.

[5]  M. Hebblewhite,et al.  Status and Ecological Effects of the World’s Largest Carnivores , 2014, Science.

[6]  Quresh S. Latif,et al.  A broader definition of occupancy: Comment on Hayes and Monfils , 2016 .

[7]  Gordon B. Stenhouse,et al.  Identification of Priority Areas for Grizzly Bear Conservation and Recovery in Alberta, Canada , 2009 .

[8]  Andrew Gelman,et al.  Data Analysis Using Regression and Multilevel/Hierarchical Models , 2006 .

[9]  Rob Channell,et al.  Splendid Isolation: Patterns of Geographic Range Collapse in Endangered Mammals , 1995 .

[10]  Rachel M. Fewster,et al.  Estimating population size by spatially explicit capture–recapture , 2013 .

[11]  James D Nichols,et al.  Relaxing the closure assumption in occupancy models: staggered arrival and departure times. , 2013, Ecology.

[12]  F. Juanes,et al.  The importance of statistical power analysis: an example from Animal Behaviour , 1996, Animal Behaviour.

[13]  Gordon B. Stenhouse,et al.  A habitat-based framework for grizzly bear conservation in Alberta , 2006 .

[14]  R. Kays,et al.  A Comparison of Noninvasive Techniques to Survey Carnivore Communities in Northeastern North America , 2006 .

[15]  J. Berger,et al.  USING BLACK BEARS TO TEST IDEAL-FREE DISTRIBUTION MODELS EXPERIMENTALLY , 2003 .

[16]  S. Breck Book Review: Sampling Rare or Elusive Species: Concepts, Designs, and Techniques for Estimating Population Parameters , 2006 .

[17]  Darryl I. MacKenzie,et al.  Designing occupancy studies: general advice and allocating survey effort , 2005 .

[18]  R. Noss,et al.  CARNIVORES AS FOCAL SPECIES FOR CONSERVATION PLANNING IN THE ROCKY MOUNTAIN REGION , 2001 .

[19]  Justin A. Gude,et al.  Estimating occupancy and predicting numbers of gray wolf packs in Montana using hunter surveys , 2013 .

[20]  Anthony P. Clevenger,et al.  Grizzly bear response to human development and activities in the Bow River Watershed, Alberta, Canada , 2002 .

[21]  Jacob S. Ivan,et al.  Spatially Explicit Power Analyses for Occupancy‐Based Monitoring of Wolverine in the U.S. Rocky Mountains , 2014, Conservation biology : the journal of the Society for Conservation Biology.

[22]  Scott E. Nielsen,et al.  Modelling the spatial distribution of human-caused grizzly bear mortalities in the Central Rockies ecosystem of Canada , 2004 .

[23]  Uma Ramakrishnan,et al.  Evaluation of non-invasive genetic sampling methods for estimating tiger population size , 2009 .

[24]  A. Laliberte,et al.  Range Contractions of North American Carnivores and Ungulates , 2004 .

[25]  S. S. Stevens,et al.  Noninvasive Survey Methods for Carnivores , 2010 .

[26]  E J Milner-Gulland,et al.  Quantification of Extinction Risk: IUCN's System for Classifying Threatened Species , 2008, Conservation biology : the journal of the Society for Conservation Biology.

[27]  A. Zuur,et al.  Analysing Ecological Data , 2007 .

[28]  W. Thogmartin,et al.  Small sample bias in dynamic occupancy models , 2013 .

[29]  Darryl I MacKenzie,et al.  Sampling design trade-offs in occupancy studies with imperfect detection: examples and software. , 2007, Ecological applications : a publication of the Ecological Society of America.

[30]  M. Proctor,et al.  ESTIMATING GRIZZLY BEAR DISTRIBUTION AND ABUNDANCE RELATIVE TO HABITAT AND HUMAN INFLUENCE , 2004 .

[31]  S. Andelman,et al.  Umbrellas and flagships: efficient conservation surrogates or expensive mistakes? , 2000, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[32]  James D. Nichols,et al.  Analysis and Management of Animal Populations: Modeling, Estimation and Decision Making , 2002 .

[33]  Michael Schaub,et al.  Bayesian Population Analysis using WinBUGS: A Hierarchical Perspective , 2011 .

[34]  Alberta.,et al.  Status of the Grizzly Bear (Ursus arctos) in Alberta , 2010 .

[35]  Mark S Boyce,et al.  Grizzly bear habitat selection is scale dependent. , 2007, Ecological applications : a publication of the Ecological Society of America.

[36]  José J. Lahoz‐Monfort,et al.  Designing studies to detect differences in species occupancy: power analysis under imperfect detection , 2012 .

[37]  G. Stenhouse,et al.  Grizzly Bear Population Vital Rates and Trend in the Northern Continental Divide Ecosystem, Montana , 2012 .

[38]  Larissa L. Bailey,et al.  Inference for Occupancy and Occupancy Dynamics , 2011 .

[39]  Frank Rosell,et al.  Scent-marking investment and motor patterns are affected by the age and sex of wild brown bears , 2014, Animal Behaviour.

[40]  William J. Zielinski,et al.  EVALUATION OF A MULTIPLE‐SPECIES APPROACH TO MONITORING SPECIES AT THE ECOREGIONAL SCALE , 2004 .

[41]  Katherine C. Kendall,et al.  Demography and Genetic Structure of a Recovering Grizzly Bear Population , 2009 .

[42]  M. Kéry,et al.  Predicting species distributions from checklist data using site‐occupancy models , 2010 .

[43]  Samuel T. Turvey,et al.  Estimating animal density using camera traps without the need for individual recognition , 2008 .

[44]  J. Nichols,et al.  Monitoring for conservation. , 2006, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[45]  Daniel B. Mark,et al.  TUTORIAL IN BIOSTATISTICS MULTIVARIABLE PROGNOSTIC MODELS: ISSUES IN DEVELOPING MODELS, EVALUATING ASSUMPTIONS AND ADEQUACY, AND MEASURING AND REDUCING ERRORS , 1996 .

[46]  M. Willig,et al.  Standardized Assessment of Biodiversity Trends in Tropical Forest Protected Areas: The End Is Not in Sight , 2016, PLoS biology.

[47]  J. Boulanger,et al.  A multiple data source approach to improve abundance estimates of small populations: The brown bear in the Apennines, Italy , 2012 .

[48]  M. Hebblewhite,et al.  Transcending scale dependence in identifying habitat with resource selection functions. , 2012, Ecological applications : a publication of the Ecological Society of America.

[49]  R. J. Gutiérrez,et al.  Relation between Occupancy and Abundance for a Territorial Species, the California Spotted Owl , 2013, Conservation biology : the journal of the Society for Conservation Biology.

[50]  Douglas H. Johnson THE COMPARISON OF USAGE AND AVAILABILITY MEASUREMENTS FOR EVALUATING RESOURCE PREFERENCE , 1980 .

[51]  Kevin J. Gaston,et al.  Abundance–occupancy relationships , 2000 .

[52]  Per Wegge,et al.  Effects of trapping effort and trap shyness on estimates of tiger abundance from camera trap studies , 2004 .

[53]  J. Brodie,et al.  Brown Bear Population Trends from Demographic and Monitoring-based Estimators , 2007 .

[54]  P. M. Galetti,et al.  Estimating puma Puma concolor population size in a human-disturbed landscape in Brazil, using DNA mark–recapture data , 2014, Oryx.

[55]  D. Dawson,et al.  Occupancy in continuous habitat , 2012 .

[56]  David R. Anderson,et al.  Model selection and multimodel inference : a practical information-theoretic approach , 2003 .

[57]  U. Fish Endangered and threatened wildlife and plants , 1987 .

[58]  K. Kendall,et al.  Evaluation of Bear Rub Surveys to Monitor Grizzly Bear Population Trends , 2010 .

[59]  Saul Greenberg,et al.  A Tool Supporting the Extraction of Angling Effort Data from Remote Camera Images , 2015 .

[60]  J. Andrew Royle,et al.  ESTIMATING SITE OCCUPANCY AND ABUNDANCE USING INDIRECT DETECTION INDICES , 2005 .

[61]  Göran Ericsson,et al.  Estimating population size and trends of the Swedish brown bear Ursus arctos population , 2011 .

[62]  Howard B. Stauffer,et al.  Monitoring Martes Populations in California: Survey Design and Power Analysis , 1996 .

[63]  Grant M Harris,et al.  Range Size and Extinction Risk in Forest Birds , 2008, Conservation biology : the journal of the Society for Conservation Biology.

[64]  D. MacKenzie Occupancy Estimation and Modeling: Inferring Patterns and Dynamics of Species Occurrence , 2005 .

[65]  M. A. Sawaya,et al.  A Comparison of Grizzly Bear Demographic Parameters Estimated from Non-Spatial and Spatial Open Population Capture-Recapture Models , 2015, PloS one.

[66]  Michelle Thorn,et al.  Brown hyaenas on roads : estimating carnivore occupancy and abundance using spatially auto-correlated sign survey replicates , 2011 .

[67]  R. G. Wright,et al.  Defining landscapes suitable for restoration of grizzly bears Ursus arctos in Idaho , 1999 .

[68]  P. Sherman,et al.  Ecological and evolutionary traps. , 2002 .

[69]  Mark Hebblewhite,et al.  Caribou encounters with wolves increase near roads and trails: a time‐to‐event approach , 2011 .

[70]  J. Andrew Royle,et al.  Hierarchical Modeling and Inference in Ecology: The Analysis of Data from Populations, Metapopulations and Communities , 2008 .

[71]  Steve Cherry,et al.  Evaluation of Rules to Distinguish Unique Female Grizzly Bears With Cubs in Yellowstone , 2008 .

[72]  R Core Team,et al.  R: A language and environment for statistical computing. , 2014 .

[73]  Erin M. Bayne,et al.  REVIEW: Wildlife camera trapping: a review and recommendations for linking surveys to ecological processes , 2015 .

[74]  Hugh P. Possingham,et al.  Minimizing the cost of environmental management decisions by optimizing statistical thresholds , 2004 .

[75]  J. Nichols,et al.  ESTIMATION OF TIGER DENSITIES IN INDIA USING PHOTOGRAPHIC CAPTURES AND RECAPTURES , 1998 .

[76]  R. Naiman,et al.  Keystone Interactions: Salmon and Bear in Riparian Forests of Alaska , 2006, Ecosystems.

[77]  Todd W. Arnold Uninformative Parameters and Model Selection Using Akaike's Information Criterion , 2010 .