The use of mechanistic data and the handling of scientific uncertainty in carcinogen risk assessments. The trichloroethylene example.

The purpose of this paper is to explore how risk assessors actually use mechanistic data in carcinogen risk assessment and to discuss how the handling of scientific uncertainty may affect the outcome of the risk assessment. The analysis is performed by comparing 29 trichloroethylene risk assessment documents in general and 2 of these, namely the ECETOC (1994, Trichloroethylene: Assessment of Human Carcinogenic Hazard, Technical Report No. 60) and the OECD/EU (1996, Initial Assessment Report for the 4th SIAM (Screening Information Data Set Initial Assessment Meeting), May 1996: Trichloroethylene, sponsor country, United Kingdom [Draft]), in more detail. It is concluded that in this example the ECETOC required less evidence for considering a carcinogenic mechanism irrelevant to humans than did the OECD/EU risk assessors. There are examples of when two risk assessors have selected different primary data for their argumentation and also examples of how one and the same primary publication was interpreted differently. Biased data selection and evaluation of primary data that correlate to the risk assessor's overall conclusions have also been identified. The general comparison of all 29 TCE risk assessment documents indicates that the assessment of scientific uncertainty in the mechanistic data affects the overall conclusions.

[1]  B. Terracini,et al.  A PATHOLOGICAL STUDY ON THE TOXICITY OF S-DICHLOROVINYL-L-CYSTEINE. , 1965, Food and cosmetics toxicology.

[2]  E. Bingham,et al.  Metabolism of trichloroethylene by the isolated perfused lung. , 1978, Toxicology and applied pharmacology.

[3]  D. Grauman,et al.  Causes of death among laundry and dry cleaning workers. , 1979, American journal of public health.

[4]  S. Greenberg,et al.  The Clara cell: a comparative ultrastructural study in mammals. , 1979, The American journal of anatomy.

[5]  D. Jowett,et al.  Female laundry and dry cleaning workers in Wisconsin: a mortality analysis. , 1981, American journal of public health.

[6]  H Tsuruta,et al.  Inhalation carcinogenicity of trichloroethylene in mice and rats. , 1983, Industrial health.

[7]  J. Poland,et al.  Lung injury induced by trichloroethylene. , 1985, Toxicology.

[8]  M S Prout,et al.  Species differences in response to trichloroethylene. I. Pharmacokinetics in rats and mice. , 1985, Toxicology and applied pharmacology.

[9]  C. Elcombe.  Species differences in carcinogenicity and peroxisome proliferation due to trichloroethylene: a biochemical human hazard assessment. , 1985, Archives of toxicology. Supplement. = Archiv fur Toxikologie. Supplement.

[10]  J. Kaldor,et al.  Response of experimental animals to human carcinogens: an analysis based upon the IARC Monographs programme. , 1986, Carcinogenesis.

[11]  K. Rao,et al.  Induction of neoplastic lesions in the livers of C57BL x C3HF1 mice by chloral hydrate. , 1986, Cancer detection and prevention.

[12]  M. A. Pereira,et al.  The carcinogenicity of trichloroethylene and its metabolites, trichloroacetic acid and dichloroacetic acid, in mouse liver. , 1987, Toxicology and applied pharmacology.

[13]  T. Goldsworthy,et al.  Chlorinated hydrocarbon-induced peroxisomal enzyme activity in relation to species and organ carcinogenicity. , 1987, Toxicology and applied pharmacology.

[14]  A. Deangelo,et al.  Species and strain sensitivity to the induction of peroxisome proliferation by chloroacetic acids. , 1989, Toxicology and applied pharmacology.

[15]  P. Forkert,et al.  Pulmonary toxicity of trichloroethylene in mice. Covalent binding and morphological manifestations. , 1989, Drug metabolism and disposition: the biological fate of chemicals.

[16]  R. Wolman,et al.  Acute renal failure due to trichloroethylene poisoning. , 1989, British journal of industrial medicine.

[17]  T. Nagaya,et al.  Urinary total protein and beta-2-microglobulin in workers exposed to trichloroethylene. , 1989, Environmental research.

[18]  R J Bull,et al.  Liver tumor induction in B6C3F1 mice by dichloroacetate and trichloroacetate. , 1990, Toxicology.

[19]  I. Issemann,et al.  Activation of a member of the steroid hormone receptor superfamily by peroxisome proliferators , 1990, Nature.

[20]  C. C. Lombardi,et al.  Damage and repair of mouse bronchial epithelium following acute inhalation of trichloroethylene. , 1991, Experimental lung research.

[21]  F. Leuschner,et al.  Evaluation of the mutagenicity of chloral hydrate in vitro and in vivo. , 1991, Arzneimittel-Forschung.

[22]  H. Vainio.  Mechanisms of Carcinogenesis in Risk Identification , 1992 .

[23]  J. Larson,et al.  Species differences in the metabolism of trichloroethylene to the carcinogenic metabolites trichloroacetate and dichloroacetate. , 1992, Toxicology and applied pharmacology.

[24]  J. Larson,et al.  Metabolism and lipoperoxidative activity of trichloroacetate and dichloroacetate in rats and mice. , 1992, Toxicology and applied pharmacology.

[25]  M. Rao,et al.  Peroxisome proliferation and hepatocarcinogenesis. , 1987, IARC scientific publications.

[26]  G. Olson,et al.  Hepatocarcinogenicity of chloral hydrate, 2-chloroacetaldehyde, and dichloroacetic acid in the male B6C3F1 mouse☆ , 1992 .

[27]  P. Hext,et al.  Methylene chloride--an inhalation study to investigate pathological and biochemical events occurring in the lungs of mice over an exposure period of 90 days. , 1992 .

[28]  J. Odum,et al.  A mechanism for the development of Clara cell lesions in the mouse lung after exposure to trichloroethylene. , 1992, Chemico-biological interactions.

[29]  C. Brogren,et al.  Subclinical affection of liver and kidney function and solvent exposure , 1993, International archives of occupational and environmental health.

[30]  D Henschler,et al.  Nephrotoxic and genotoxic N-acetyl-S-dichlorovinyl-L-cysteine is a urinary metabolite after occupational 1,1,2-trichloroethene exposure in humans: implications for the risk of trichloroethene exposure. , 1993, Environmental health perspectives.

[31]  M. Templin,et al.  The role of dichloroacetate in the hepatocarcinogenicity of trichloroethylene. , 1993, Toxicology letters.

[32]  G. Diggle,et al.  Science and Judgement in Risk Assessment , 1995 .

[33]  G. Olson,et al.  The carcinogenicity of dichloroacetic acid in the male Fischer 344 rat. , 1996, Toxicology.

[34]  J. Foster,et al.  Regular ArticleTrichloroethylene-Induced Mouse Lung Tumors: Studies of the Mode of Action and Comparisons between Species☆ , 1997 .

[35]  Sven Ove Hansson,et al.  Setting the Limit: Occupational Health Standards and the Limits of Science , 1998 .

[36]  W. Dekant,et al.  Renal cell cancer correlated with occupational exposure to trichloroethene , 1998, Journal of Cancer Research and Clinical Oncology.

[37]  R. Roberts,et al.  Perturbation of rodent hepatocyte growth control by nongenotoxic hepatocarcinogens: mechanisms and lack of relevance for human health (review). , 1998, Oncology reports.

[38]  H. Brauch,et al.  Trichloroethylene exposure and specific somatic mutations in patients with renal cell carcinoma. , 1999, Journal of the National Cancer Institute.

[39]  J. Fisher,et al.  Identification of S-(1,2-dichlorovinyl)glutathione in the blood of human volunteers exposed to trichloroethylene. , 1999, Journal of toxicology and environmental health. Part A.

[40]  R J Bull,et al.  Mode of action of liver tumor induction by trichloroethylene and its metabolites, trichloroacetate and dichloroacetate. , 2000, Environmental health perspectives.

[41]  M M Moore,et al.  Mutagenicity of trichloroethylene and its metabolites: implications for the risk assessment of trichloroethylene. , 2000, Environmental health perspectives.

[42]  J. Mandel,et al.  Renal cell cancer correlated with occupational exposure to trichloroethylene , 2001, Journal of Cancer Research and Clinical Oncology.

[43]  S. Hansson.  Choosing Priority-Setting Criteria for Carcinogens , 2001 .

[44]  C Rudén,et al.  Interpretations of primary carcinogenicity data in 29 trichloroethylene risk assessments. , 2001, Toxicology.

[45]  C Rudén,et al.  The use and evaluation of primary data in 29 trichloroethylene carcinogen risk assessments. , 2001, Regulatory toxicology and pharmacology : RTP.