In Defense of Imperative Inference

Abstract“Surrender; therefore, surrender or fight” is apparently an argument corresponding to an inference from an imperative to an imperative. Several philosophers, however (Williams 1963; Wedeking 1970; Harrison 1991; Hansen 2008), have denied that imperative inferences exist, arguing that (1) no such inferences occur in everyday life, (2) imperatives cannot be premises or conclusions of inferences because it makes no sense to say, for example, “since surrender” or “it follows that surrender or fight”, and (3) distinct imperatives have conflicting permissive presuppositions (“surrender or fight” permits you to fight without surrendering, but “surrender” does not), so issuing distinct imperatives amounts to changing one’s mind and thus cannot be construed as making an inference. In response I argue inter alia that, on a reasonable understanding of ‘inference’, some everyday-life inferences do have imperatives as premises and conclusions, and that issuing imperatives with conflicting permissive presuppositions does not amount to changing one’s mind.

[1]  Hector-Neri Castañeda,et al.  Thinking and Doing , 1975 .

[2]  Jörgen Jörgensen,et al.  Imperatives and logic , 1937, Erkenntnis.

[3]  Bernard Williams,et al.  Problems of the self : philosophical papers, 1956-1972 , 1973 .

[4]  Elizabeth Lane Beardsley.  Imperative Sentences in Relation to Indicatives , 1944 .

[5]  Zoltan Domotor.  Review: Ladislav Tondl, Sémantika otázky v problémové situaci (Semantics of the Question in the Problem-Solving Situation) , 1970 .

[6]  R. Hursthouse.  THE LOGIC OF DECISION AND ACTION , 1969 .

[7]  Ernest Sosa.  On Practical Inference and the Logic of Imperatives , 2008 .

[8]  Harold Marcellars Zellner.  The Logic Of Imperatives , 1971 .

[9]  J. C. C. McKinsey,et al.  On the Logic of Imperatives , 1939, Philosophy of Science.

[10]  A. F. Peters.  R. M. HARE ON IMPERATIVE SENTENCES: A CRITICISM , 1949 .

[11]  S. Toulmin.  The Language of Morals , 1954, Philosophy.

[12]  Robert Walter,et al.  Allgemeine Theorie der Normen , 1979 .

[13]  Ota Weinberger.  Normentheorie als Grundlage der Jurisprudenz und Ethik : eine Auseinandersetzung mit Hans Kelsens Theorie der Normen , 1981 .

[14]  Herbert A. Simon,et al.  The Logic of Rational Decision , 1965 .

[15]  Herbert A. Simon,et al.  The Logic of Heuristic Decision Making , 1977 .

[16]  Hector-Neri Castañeda,et al.  Thinking and Doing: The Philosophical Foundations of Institutions , 1975 .

[17]  J. C. C. McKinsey.  Review: A. F. Peters, R. M. Hare on Imperative Sentences: A Criticism , 1950 .

[18]  Nuel D. Belnap.  Declaratives are not enough , 1990 .

[19]  Nicholas Rescher.  The Logic Of Commands , 1966 .

[20]  Xiuhuang He.  Deontic Logic And Imperative Logic , 1970 .

[21]  Peter B. M. Vranas,et al.  New Foundations for Imperative Logic I: Logical Connectives, Consistency, and Quantifiers* , 2008 .

[22]  Hector-Neri Castañeda,et al.  Morality and the language of conduct , 1965 .

[23]  Fengkui Ju,et al.  Imperatives and Logic ∗ , 2010 .

[24]  Andre Gombay,et al.  What is imperative inference , 1967 .

[25]  R. M. Hare.  Some Alleged Differences between Imperatives and Indicatives , 1967 .

[26]  Arthur R. Miller.  IN DEFENSE OF A LOGIC OF IMPERATIVES , 1984 .

[27]  Christopher Cherry.  MORALITY AND THE LANGUAGE OF CONDUCT , 1964 .

[28]  C. W. Super.  Ethics and Language , 1910, The International Journal of Ethics.

[29]  Nicholas J. Moutafakis.  Imperatives and their logics , 1978 .

[30]  Nicholas Rescher,et al.  Can One Infer Commands from Commands , 1964 .

[31]  Gary A. Wedeking.  Are there command arguments , 1970 .

[32]  P. B. Vranas.  New Foundations for Imperative Logic: Pure Imperative Inference , 2011 .

[33]  Hector-Neri Castañeda.  There are command sh-inferences , 1971 .

[34]  Nicholas Rescher,et al.  The Logic of Decision and Action , 1967 .

[35]  John Turk Saunders.  Fatalism and Linguistic Reform , 1962 .

[37]  Lennart Åqvist.  Choice-offering and alternative-presenting disjunctive commands , 1965 .

[38]  Andre Gombay.  Imperative inference and disjunction , 1965 .

[39]  G. Volpe,et al.  A minimalist solution to Jørgensen's dilemma , 1999 .