A randomized controlled study of human Day 3 embryo cryopreservation by slow freezing or vitrification: vitrification is associated with higher survival, metabolism and blastocyst formation.

BACKGROUND The aim of this study was to compare two methods of cryopreservation for the cleavage-stage human embryo: slow freezing and vitrification. METHODS A total of 466 Day 3 embryos, donated with consent, underwent cryopreservation by either slow freezing in straws or vitrification using the cryoloop. The vitrification procedure did not include dimethyl sulfoxide, but rather employed ethylene glycol and 1,2-propanediol as the cryoprotectants. Survival, embryonic metabolism and subsequent development to the blastocyst were used to determine the efficacy of the two procedures. RESULTS Significantly, more embryos survived the vitrification procedure (222/234, 94.8%) than slow freezing (206/232, 88.7%; P < 0.05). Consistent with this observation, pyruvate uptake was significantly greater in the vitrification group, reflecting a higher metabolic rate. Development to the blastocyst was also higher following vitrification (134/222, 60.3%) than following freezing (106/206, 49.5%; P < 0.05). In a separate cohort of 73 patients who had their supernumerary embryos cyropreserved with vitrification, the resulting implantation rate and clinical pregnancy rate were 30 and 49%, respectively. CONCLUSIONS Analysis of metabolism revealed that vitrification had less impact on the metabolic rate of the embryo than freezing, which was reflected in higher survival rate and subsequent development in vitro. Excellent pregnancy outcomes followed the warming and transfer of vitrified cleavage-stage embryos. These data provide further evidence that vitrification imparts less trauma to cells and is, therefore, a more effective means of cryopreserving the human embryo than conventional slow freezing. Clinicaltrials.gov identifier: NCT00608010.

[1]  C. Flamigni,et al.  Criteria to assess human oocyte quality after cryopreservation. , 2005, Reproductive biomedicine online.

[2]  L. Veeck.  Does the developmental stage at freeze impact on clinical results post-thaw? , 2003, Reproductive biomedicine online.

[3]  M. Kuwayama,et al.  Highly efficient vitrification for cryopreservation of human oocytes and embryos: the Cryotop method. , 2007, Theriogenology.

[4]  A. Trounson,et al.  Nutrient uptake and utilization can be used to select viable day 7 bovine blastocysts after cryopreservation , 1996, Molecular reproduction and development.

[5]  D. Gardner,et al.  Vitrification of mouse and human blastocysts using a novel cryoloop container-less technique. , 1999, Fertility and sterility.

[6]  L. Rienzi,et al.  Maintenance of the meiotic spindle during vitrification in human and mouse oocytes , 2007 .

[7]  G. Vajta,et al.  Are programmable freezers still needed in the embryo laboratory? Review on vitrification. , 2006, Reproductive biomedicine online.

[8]  Eun Young Kim,et al.  Ultra-rapid freezing of human multipronuclear zygotes using electron microscope grids. , 2000, Human reproduction.

[9]  D. Gardner,et al.  Vitrification of Human Blastocysts Using the Cryoloop Method: Successful Clinical Application and Birth of Offspring , 2002, Journal of Assisted Reproduction and Genetics.

[10]  W. Son,et al.  Ongoing twin pregnancy after vitrification of blastocysts produced by in-vitro matured oocytes retrieved from a woman with polycystic ovary syndrome: Case report. , 2002, Human Reproduction.

[11]  S. Nadin-Davis,et al.  Viral contamination of embryos cryopreserved in liquid nitrogen. , 2000, Cryobiology.

[12]  D. Gardner,et al.  Vitrification of mouse oocytes using a nylon loop , 2001, Molecular reproduction and development.

[13]  S. Roberts,et al.  Identification of viable embryos in IVF by non-invasive measurement of amino acid turnover. , 2004, Human reproduction.

[14]  D. Gardner,et al.  The CryoLoop facilitates re-vitrification of embryos at four successive stages of development without impairing embryo growth. , 2006, Human reproduction.

[15]  M. Vandervorst,et al.  Vitrification of human blastocysts with the Hemi-Straw carrier: application of assisted hatching after thawing. , 2003, Human reproduction.

[16]  H. Leese,et al.  Concentrations of nutrients in mouse oviduct fluid and their effects on embryo development and metabolism in vitro. , 1990, Journal of reproduction and fertility.

[17]  J. Whitfield,et al.  The differentiation inducer, dimethyl sulfoxide, transiently increases the intracellular calcium ion concentration in various cell types , 1993, Journal of cellular physiology.

[18]  M. Tucker,et al.  Vitrification in Assisted Reproduction : A User's Manual and Trouble-shooting Guide , 2007 .

[19]  M. Larman,et al.  Calcium-free vitrification reduces cryoprotectant-induced zona pellucida hardening and increases fertilization rates in mouse oocytes. , 2006, Reproduction.

[20]  L. Kuleshova,et al.  Vitrification can be more favorable than slow cooling. , 2002, Fertility and sterility.

[21]  Toshifumi Takahashi,et al.  Application of Vitrification to Human Embryo Freezing , 2000, Gynecologic and Obstetric Investigation.

[22]  Katsuhiko Takahashi,et al.  Perinatal outcome of blastocyst transfer with vitrification using cryoloop: a 4-year follow-up study. , 2005, Fertility and sterility.

[23]  L. Rienzi,et al.  Analysis of oocyte physiology to improve cryopreservation procedures. , 2007, Theriogenology.

[24]  L. Rienzi,et al.  Laser-assisted removal of necrotic blastomeres from cryopreserved embryos that were partially damaged. , 2002, Fertility and sterility.

[25]  Shee-Uan Chen,et al.  Vitrification of oocytes: various procedures , 2007 .

[26]  Kohta Ikegami,et al.  Dimethyl Sulfoxide Has an Impact on Epigenetic Profile in Mouse Embryoid Body , 2006, Stem cells.

[27]  G. Vajta,et al.  Highly efficient vitrification method for cryopreservation of human oocytes. , 2005, Reproductive biomedicine online.

[28]  D. Gardner,et al.  Addition of ascorbate during cryopreservation stimulates subsequent embryo development. , 2002, Human reproduction.

[29]  B. Balaban,et al.  Comparison of two sequential media for culturing cleavage-stage embryos and blastocysts: embryo characteristics and clinical outcome. , 2005, Reproductive biomedicine online.

[30]  M. Tucker,et al.  Vitrifying and warming of human oocytes, embryos, and blastocysts: vitrification procedures as an alternative to conventional cryopreservation. , 2004, Methods in molecular biology.

[31]  M. Kasai,et al.  Vitrification of human embryos based on the assessment of suitable conditions for 8-cell mouse embryos. , 1998, Human reproduction.

[32]  P. Lau,et al.  Microbial contamination of embryos and semen during long term banking in liquid nitrogen. , 2003, Cryobiology.

[33]  S. Nakamura,et al.  Successful birth after transfer of vitrified human blastocysts with use of a cryoloop containerless technique. , 2001, Fertility and sterility.

[34]  G. J. Morris.  The origin, ultrastructure, and microbiology of the sediment accumulating in liquid nitrogen storage vessels. , 2005, Cryobiology.

[35]  M. Larman,et al.  1,2-propanediol and the type of cryopreservation procedure adversely affect mouse oocyte physiology. , 2007, Human reproduction.

[36]  R. Benjamin,et al.  Liquid nitrogen freezers: a potential source of microbial contamination of hematopoietic stem cell components , 1997, Transfusion.

[37]  A. Anderson,et al.  Reduction of high order multiples in frozen embryo transfers. , 2005, Reproductive biomedicine online.

[38]  Vladimir Isachenko,et al.  Potential Importance of Vitrification in Reproductive Medicine , 2002, Biology of reproduction.

[39]  D. Gardner,et al.  A Laboratory Guide to the Mammalian Embryo , 2004 .

[40]  D. Gardner,et al.  Selection of viable mouse blastocysts prior to transfer using a metabolic criterion. , 1996, Human reproduction.

[41]  G. Vajta,et al.  Comparison of open and closed methods for vitrification of human embryos and the elimination of potential contamination. , 2005, Reproductive biomedicine online.

[42]  D. Gardner,et al.  Blastocyst score affects implantation and pregnancy outcome: towards a single blastocyst transfer. , 2000, Fertility and sterility.

[43]  B. Balaban,et al.  Utilization of high-security straws for embryo freezing in an in vitro fertilization program: a prospective, randomized study. , 2007, Fertility and sterility.

[44]  K. P. Katayama,et al.  Vitrification demonstrates significant improvement versus slow freezing of human blastocysts. , 2005, Reproductive biomedicine online.

[45]  H. Leese,et al.  Pyruvate and glucose uptake by mouse ova and preimplantation embryos. , 1984, Journal of reproduction and fertility.

[46]  Naomi Nakagata,et al.  Experimental evaluation of cross-contamination between cryotubes containing mouse 2-cell embryos and murine pathogens in liquid nitrogen tanks. , 2003, Experimental animals.

[47]  H. Selman,et al.  Successful pregnancies and deliveries after a simple vitrification protocol for day 3 human embryos. , 2001, Fertility and sterility.

[48]  B. Balaban,et al.  Impact of fresh-cycle variables on the implantation potential of cryopreserved-thawed human embryos. , 2007, Fertility and sterility.

[49]  M. Tucker,et al.  Comparison of vitrification and conventional cryopreservation of day 5 and day 6 blastocysts during clinical application. , 2006, Fertility and sterility.

[50]  M. Tucker,et al.  Effect of carrier system on the yield of human oocytes and embryos as assessed by survival and developmental potential after vitrification. , 2002, Reproduction.

[51]  G. Haranath,et al.  Vitrification of human 8-cell embryos, a modified protocol for better pregnancy rates. , 2005, Reproductive biomedicine online.

[52]  S. Nakamura,et al.  Vitrification of human blastocysts using cryoloops: clinical outcome of 223 cycles. , 2003, Human reproduction.

[53]  T. Nagai,et al.  High survival rate of bovine oocytes matured in vitro following vitrification. , 2004, The Journal of reproduction and development.

[54]  C. Venetis,et al.  Cryopreservation of human embryos by vitrification or slow freezing: a systematic review and meta-analysis. , 2008, Fertility and sterility.

[55]  N. Desai,et al.  Cryoloop vitrification of human day 3 cleavage-stage embryos: post-vitrification development, pregnancy outcomes and live births. , 2007, Reproductive biomedicine online.

[56]  M. Kasai,et al.  Blastocyst cryopreservation: ultrarapid vitrification using cryoloop technique. , 2003, Reproductive biomedicine online.

[57]  J. Ou,et al.  Comparison of the survival of human biopsied embryos after cryopreservation with four different methods using non-transferable embryos. , 2005, Human reproduction.

[58]  M. Larman,et al.  Vitrification of mouse pronuclear oocytes with no direct liquid nitrogen contact. , 2006, Reproductive biomedicine online.

[59]  Shee-Uan Chen,et al.  Successful pregnancy following blastocyst cryopreservation using super-cooling ultra-rapid vitrification. , 2005, Human reproduction.

[60]  D. Gardner.  Noninvasive metabolic assessment of single cells. , 2007, Methods in molecular medicine.

[61]  H. Leese,et al.  Assessment of embryo viability prior to transfer by the noninvasive measurement of glucose uptake. , 1987, The Journal of experimental zoology.

[62]  G. Vajta,et al.  Improving cryopreservation systems. , 2006, Theriogenology.

[63]  M. Kinutani,et al.  Blastocoele collapse by micropipetting prior to vitrification gives excellent survival and pregnancy outcomes for human day 5 and 6 expanded blastocysts. , 2004, Human reproduction.

[64]  M. Vandervorst,et al.  Births after vitrification at morula and blastocyst stages: effect of artificial reduction of the blastocoelic cavity before vitrification. , 2002, Human reproduction.