State of the art of simplified analytical methods for seismic vulnerability assessment of unreinforced masonry buildings

Abstract Cities in the developing world are facing outstanding economic and human losses caused by natural hazards such as earthquakes, and the amount of losses is affected by the quality of preventive measures and emergency management. For this reason, seismic vulnerability assessment is considered a crucial part of a strategy for seismic risk mitigation and for improving the resiliency of cities. Due to the high number of building archetypes for the seismic vulnerability assessment at a large scale, fast, simplified methods have been proposed that can facilitate the assessment procedure with low computational effort. Simplified methods can be categorized into three groups: analytical, empirical, and hybrid methods. In this study, simplified analytical methods for the seismic vulnerability assessment of unreinforced masonry (URM) buildings were reviewed, starting with their classification into three main groups: collapse mechanism-based, capacity spectrum-based, and fully displacement-based methods. Finally, attention was given to the corresponding software packages that were developed to facilitate the assessment procedure.

[1]  Rui Pinho,et al.  Displacement-Based Earthquake Loss Assessment of Masonry Buildings in Mansehra City, Pakistan , 2010 .

[2]  Miguel Cervera,et al.  Structural Analysis of Masonry Historical Constructions. Classical and Advanced Approaches , 2010 .

[3]  Peter Fajfar,et al.  A Nonlinear Analysis Method for Performance-Based Seismic Design , 2000 .

[4]  Guido Magenes,et al.  Evaluation of Uncertainties in the Seismic Assessment of Existing Masonry Buildings , 2012 .

[5]  Serena Cattari,et al.  PERPETUATE guidelines for seismic performance-based assessment of cultural heritage masonry structures , 2014, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[6]  Guido Magenes,et al.  Seismic assessment of masonry buildings accounting for limited knowledge on materials by Bayesian updating , 2016, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[7]  Dimitrios Vamvatsikos,et al.  Current Challenges and Future Trends in Analytical Fragility and Vulnerability Modeling , 2019, Earthquake Spectra.

[8]  Omid Esmaili,et al.  Developing a Rapid Seismic Performance based Rating System in Safety Assessment of Buildings , 2014 .

[9]  Dina D'Ayala,et al.  Definition of Collapse Mechanisms and Seismic Vulnerability of Historic Masonry Buildings , 2003 .

[10]  Barbara Borzi,et al.  Calibration of a mechanics-based method for large-scale vulnerability assessment , 2019, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[11]  A. Khan,et al.  Developing Seismic Risk Prediction Functions for Structures , 2018 .

[12]  Viviana Novelli,et al.  Evaluation of uncertainties in determining the seismic vulnerability of historic masonry buildings in Slovenia: use of macro-element and structural element modelling , 2014, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[13]  Michel Bruneau,et al.  Seismic evaluation of unreinforced masonry buildings — a state-of-the-art report , 1994 .

[14]  Paulo B. Lourenço,et al.  Seismic vulnerability and risk analysis of the old building stock at urban scale: application to a neighbourhood in Lisbon , 2017, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[15]  James E. Daniell,et al.  Open Source Procedure for Assessment of Loss using Global Earthquake Modelling software (OPAL) , 2011 .

[16]  Sara Paganoni,et al.  Assessment and analysis of damage in L’Aquila historic city centre after 6th April 2009 , 2011 .

[17]  Francesco Fabbrocino,et al.  Evaluation of different approaches for the estimation of the seismic vulnerability of masonry towers , 2018, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[18]  Hugo Bachmann,et al.  ON THE SEISMIC VULNERABILITY OF EXISTING UNREINFORCED MASONRY BUILDINGS , 2003 .

[19]  Alex H. Barbat,et al.  Ground-shaking scenarios and urban risk evaluation of Barcelona using the Risk-UE capacity spectrum based method , 2011 .

[20]  Chin-Hsiung Loh,et al.  Overview of Taiwan Earthquake Loss Estimation System , 2006 .

[21]  Andrea Penna,et al.  Damage classification and derivation of damage probability matrices from L’Aquila (2009) post-earthquake survey data , 2018, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[22]  V. Silva,et al.  Modeling the Residential Building Inventory in South America for Seismic Risk Assessment , 2017 .

[23]  Julian J. Bommer,et al.  A Probabilistic Displacement-based Vulnerability Assessment Procedure for Earthquake Loss Estimation , 2004 .

[24]  Sonia Giovinazzi,et al.  Earthquake-altered flooding hazard induced by damage to storm water systems , 2016 .

[25]  Enrico Spacone,et al.  Seismic Vulnerability of Buildings in Historic Centers: From the “Urban” to the “Aggregate” Scale , 2019, Front. Built Environ..

[26]  Daniel P. Abrams,et al.  Performance‐based engineering concepts for unreinforced masonry building structures , 2001 .

[27]  Maria Zucconi,et al.  Assessment of a vulnerability model against post-earthquake damage data: the case study of the historic city centre of L'Aquila in Italy , 2013 .

[28]  L. Sbrogiò,et al.  Mechanics-based fragility curves for Italian residential URM buildings , 2020, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[29]  C. Modena,et al.  Macro-Scale Analysis of Damage to Churches after Earthquake in Abruzzo (Italy) on April 6, 2009 , 2012 .

[30]  Luigi Sorrentino,et al.  Principal component analysis for a seismic usability model of unreinforced masonry buildings , 2017 .

[31]  Andrea Chiozzi,et al.  Collapse behavior of masonry domes under seismic loads: An adaptive NURBS kinematic limit analysis approach , 2019 .

[32]  S. Lagomarsino,et al.  Displacement-Based Simplified Seismic Loss Assessment of Masonry Buildings , 2020, Journal of Earthquake Engineering.

[33]  James D. Myers,et al.  Overview and Applications of Maeviz-Hazturk 2007 , 2008 .

[34]  M. Parisi,et al.  Seismic vulnerability and risk evaluation for old urban nuclei , 1988 .

[35]  Giuseppe Brando,et al.  The effects of L’Aquila earthquake on the St. Gemma church in Goriano Sicoli: part I—damage survey and kinematic analysis , 2015, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[36]  Christina Corbane,et al.  Pan-European seismic risk assessment: a proof of concept using the Earthquake Loss Estimation Routine (ELER) , 2016, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[37]  Luigi Sorrentino,et al.  Validation and extension of a statistical usability model for unreinforced masonry buildings with different ground motion intensity measures , 2019, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[38]  N. Tarque,et al.  Assessment of Combined In-Plane and Out-of-Plane Fragility Functions for Adobe Masonry Buildings in the Peruvian Andes , 2020, Frontiers in Built Environment.

[39]  Humberto Varum,et al.  A mechanical model for the seismic vulnerability assessment of old masonry buildings , 2011 .

[40]  Nuno Mendes,et al.  Multiscale Seismic Vulnerability Assessment and Retrofit of Existing Masonry Buildings , 2019, Buildings.

[41]  Nelson Lam,et al.  Displacement-based seismic analysis for out-of-plane bending of unreinforced masonry walls , 2002 .

[42]  Humberto Varum,et al.  Seismic vulnerability of building aggregates through hybrid and indirect assessment techniques , 2015, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[43]  Miroslav Nastev,et al.  Seismic loss estimation software: A comprehensive review of risk assessment steps, software development and limitations , 2021 .

[44]  Sergio Lagomarsino,et al.  Seismic assessment of rocking masonry structures , 2014, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[45]  Lucrezia Cascini,et al.  LiABlock_3D: A Software Tool for Collapse Mechanism Analysis of Historic Masonry Structures , 2018, International Journal of Architectural Heritage.

[46]  J. Mendes,et al.  Seismic vulnerability and risk assessment: case study of the historic city centre of Coimbra, Portugal , 2011 .

[47]  Donat Fäh,et al.  Development and validation of simplified mechanics-based capacity curves for scenario-based risk assessment of school buildings in Basel , 2020 .

[48]  Peter Fajfar,et al.  Capacity spectrum method based on inelastic demand spectra , 1999 .

[49]  Sergio Lagomarsino,et al.  A MECHANICAL METHOD FOR THE VULNERABILITY ASSESMENT OF MASONRY BUILDINGS , 2008 .

[50]  Gabriele Milani,et al.  Fast Vulnerability Evaluation of Masonry Towers by Means of an Interactive and Adaptive 3D Kinematic Limit Analysis with Pre-assigned Failure Mechanisms , 2019, International Journal of Architectural Heritage.

[51]  S. Lagomarsino,et al.  Macroseismic and mechanical models for the vulnerability and damage assessment of current buildings , 2006 .

[52]  G. Milani,et al.  Advanced numerical strategies for seismic assessment of historical masonry aggregates , 2020, Engineering Structures.

[53]  D D Ayala,et al.  An integrated procedure for the assessment of seismic vulnerability of historic buildings , 2002 .

[54]  M. Erdik,et al.  Rapid earthquake hazard and loss assessment for Euro-Mediterranean region , 2010 .

[55]  M. Valluzzi,et al.  Vulnerability of Architectural Heritage in Seismic Areas: Constructive Aspects and Effect of Interventions , 2019, Lecture Notes in Civil Engineering.

[56]  Gian Michele Calvi,et al.  A DISPLACEMENT-BASED APPROACH FOR VULNERABILITY EVALUATION OF CLASSES OF BUILDINGS , 1999 .

[57]  S. Galassi,et al.  A Novel Numerical Tool for Seismic Vulnerability Analysis of Ruins in Archaeological Sites , 2018, International Journal of Architectural Heritage.

[58]  Mete A. Sozen,et al.  SUBSTITUTE-STRUCTURE METHOD FOR SEISMIC DESIGN IN R/C , 1976 .

[59]  G. Cardani,et al.  Seismic vulnerability methods for masonry buildings in historical centres: validation and application for prediction analyses and intervention proposals , 2006 .

[60]  Gian Michele Calvi,et al.  A study on damage scenarios for residential buildings in Catania city , 1999 .

[61]  G. Manfredi,et al.  Analytical versus observational fragilities: the case of Pettino (L’Aquila) damage data database , 2015, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[62]  A. Penna,et al.  A methodology for deriving analytical fragility curves for masonry buildings based on stochastic nonlinear analyses , 2010 .

[63]  Paulo B. Lourenço,et al.  The Use of a Large-Scale Seismic Vulnerability Assessment Approach for Masonry Façade Walls as an Effective Tool for Evaluating, Managing and Mitigating Seismic Risk in Historical Centers , 2018, International Journal of Architectural Heritage.

[64]  Antonio Borri,et al.  Seismic vulnerability assessment of a monumental masonry building , 2017 .

[65]  Guido Magenes,et al.  A framework for the seismic assessment of existing masonry buildings accounting for different sources of uncertainty , 2014 .

[66]  Serena Cattari,et al.  Modeling Strategies for the Computational Analysis of Unreinforced Masonry Structures: Review and Classification , 2019, Archives of Computational Methods in Engineering.

[67]  Dominik H. Lang,et al.  SELENA - An open-source tool for seismic risk and loss assessment using a logic tree computation procedure , 2010, Comput. Geosci..

[68]  Gianni Bartoli,et al.  Analytical and numerical seismic assessment of heritage masonry towers , 2019, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[69]  H. Crowley,et al.  European Seismic Risk Model 2020: Focus on Croatia , 2019, Future Trends in Civil Engineering.

[70]  Luigi Sorrentino,et al.  Simplified survey form of unreinforced masonry buildings calibrated on data from the 2009 L’Aquila earthquake , 2017, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[71]  Nicola Grillanda,et al.  ANUB-Aggregates: a fully automatic NURBS-based software for advanced local failure analyses of historical masonry aggregates , 2020, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[72]  Antonio Formisano,et al.  Simplified and Refined Analyses for Seismic Investigation of Historical Masonry Clusters: Comparison of Results and Influence of the Structural Units Position , 2019, Front. Built Environ..

[73]  Michele Paradiso,et al.  BrickWORK Software-aided Analysis of Masonry Structures , 2014 .

[74]  Miroslav Nastev,et al.  Seismic fragility assessment of low-rise stone masonry buildings , 2013, Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Vibration.

[75]  D. D’Ayala,et al.  A procedure for the identification of the seismic vulnerability at territorial scale. Application to the Casbah of Algiers , 2014, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[76]  Luisa Basset-Salom,et al.  Seismic performance of masonry residential buildings in Lorca’s city centre, after the 11th May 2011 earthquake , 2013, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[77]  Guido Magenes,et al.  DEVELOPMENT OF SEISMIC VULNERABILITY ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGIES OVER THE PAST 30 YEARS , 2006 .

[78]  Barbara Ferracuti,et al.  SEISMIC FRAGILITY CURVES FOR RC BUILDINGS AT TERRITORIAL SCALE , 2019, Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on Computational Methods in Structural Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering (COMPDYN 2015).

[79]  Serena Cattari,et al.  TREMURI program: An equivalent frame model for the nonlinear seismic analysis of masonry buildings , 2013 .

[80]  G. Atkinson,et al.  Ground-Motion Prediction Equations for the Average Horizontal Component of PGA, PGV, and 5%-Damped PSA at Spectral Periods between 0.01 s and 10.0 s , 2008 .

[81]  N. Horspool,et al.  Development of a global seismic risk model , 2020 .

[82]  Dina D'Ayala,et al.  Assessing the seismic vulnerability of masonry buildings , 2013 .

[83]  Vitor Silva,et al.  Development of Fragility Curves for Confined Masonry Buildings in Lima, Peru , 2018, Earthquake Spectra.

[84]  Andreas J. Kappos,et al.  A hybrid method for the vulnerability assessment of R/C and URM buildings , 2006 .

[85]  Sergio Lagomarsino,et al.  Seismic Vulnerability of Ancient Churches: I. Damage Assessment and Emergency Planning , 2004 .

[86]  Al Mouayed Bellah Nafeh,et al.  Displacement-Based Framework for Simplified Seismic Loss Assessment , 2020, Journal of Earthquake Engineering.

[87]  A. Campos Costa,et al.  Evaluation of seismic risk and mitigation strategies for the existing building stock: application of LNECloss to the metropolitan area of Lisbon , 2009 .

[88]  D. D’Ayala,et al.  Non linear push over assessment of heritage buildings in Istanbul to define seismic risk , 2012, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[89]  Andrea Chiozzi,et al.  A Genetic Algorithm NURBS-based new approach for fast kinematic limit analysis of masonry vaults , 2017 .

[90]  Gianni Bartoli,et al.  A numerical study on seismic risk assessment of historic masonry towers: a case study in San Gimignano , 2016, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[91]  M. Dolce,et al.  Estimation of repair costs for RC and masonry residential buildings based on damage data collected by post-earthquake visual inspection , 2017, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[92]  Antonio Formisano,et al.  Comparative Seismic Assessment Methods for Masonry Building Aggregates: A Case Study , 2019, Front. Built Environ..

[94]  Rui Pinho,et al.  Development of the OpenQuake engine, the Global Earthquake Model’s open-source software for seismic risk assessment , 2014, Natural Hazards.

[95]  Sergio Lagomarsino,et al.  Damage assessment of churches after L’Aquila earthquake (2009) , 2012, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[96]  Rui Pinho,et al.  Simplified Pushover-Based Earthquake Loss Assessment (SP-BELA) Method for Masonry Buildings , 2008 .

[97]  Rosario Gigliotti,et al.  Comparative seismic loss analysis of an existing non-ductile RC building based on element fragility functions proposals , 2018, Engineering Structures.

[98]  M. Di Ludovico,et al.  Damage assessment and the effectiveness of prevention: the response of ordinary unreinforced masonry buildings in Norcia during the Central Italy 2016–2017 seismic sequence , 2018, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[99]  Rui Pinho,et al.  Deriving vulnerability curves using Italian earthquake damage data , 2008 .

[101]  Dina D'Ayala,et al.  Vulnerability assessment of the historical masonry building typologies of Vittorio Veneto (NE Italy) , 2008 .

[102]  Pierre Mouroux,et al.  Presentation of RISK-UE Project , 2006 .

[103]  B. Ferracuti,et al.  Post-Seismic Damage Assessment of a Historical Masonry Building: The Case Study of a School in Teramo , 2017 .

[104]  A. Formisano,et al.  Damage Probability Matrices and Empirical Fragility Curves From Damage Data on Masonry Buildings After Sarpol-e-zahab and Bam Earthquakes of Iran , 2020, Frontiers in Built Environment.

[105]  Helmut Krawinkler,et al.  PROS AND CONS OF A PUSHOVER ANALYSIS OF SEISMIC PERFORMANCE EVALUATION , 1998 .

[106]  D. D’Ayala,et al.  Force and Displacement Based Vulnerability Assessment for Traditional Buildings , 2005 .

[107]  Gian Michele Calvi,et al.  In‐plane seismic response of brick masonry walls , 1997 .

[108]  A. Prota,et al.  Empirical fragility curves for masonry buildings after the 2009 L’Aquila, Italy, earthquake , 2019, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.

[109]  G. Milani,et al.  UB-ALMANAC: An adaptive limit analysis NURBS-based program for the automatic assessment of partial failure mechanisms in masonry churches , 2018 .

[110]  Vitor Silva,et al.  Evaluation of the seismic risk of the unreinforced masonry building stock in Antioquia, Colombia , 2017, Natural Hazards.

[111]  V. Silva,et al.  Development of a probabilistic earthquake loss model for Iran , 2018, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering.