Since 1979, the Portuguese health care system has been based on a National Health Service structure that is expected to promote equity, efficiency, quality, accountability and the devolution of power. In this article, we analyse the content and impact of policies designed to reform the system between 1979 and 2002. This article differs from previous studies in that it uses a stage-based framework to evaluate the policy-making process and the impact of health care reform throughout different political cycles. We show that the NHS model has never been fully implemented and that many policies have diverted the system from its original objectives. Different governments have endorsed a progressive split between financing and provision and the institution of 'new public management' rules in public providers. We conclude that most policies put forward by Social Democratic governments have aimed at influencing demand, while Socialist governments have targeted the supply side. These policies have led to increases in health expenditure that have been comparatively more cost-shared by the State under Socialist governments. We show some overriding trends, namely as follows: despite huge improvements in health outcomes, the system is nonetheless lasting to meet its goals, particularly in terms of the equity of access and utilisation; accountability problems, inadequacies in the use of operational reforming tools (such as resource allocation mechanisms) and a lack of mechanisms to promote efficient behaviour, are all associated with cost containment problems. Structural reforms have been undertaken since 2002 and these have offered some potential for improving accountability and efficiency. Nonetheless, the success of these reforms calls for certain conditions that do not seem to have been fulfilled.
[1]
M M Pinto,et al.
HEALTH TECHNOLOGY ASSESSMENT IN PORTUGAL
,
2000,
International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care.
[2]
J. Magone,et al.
Nondecision making and inertia in Portuguese health policy.
,
2005,
Journal of health politics, policy and law.
[3]
M. Blanke,et al.
Rationing Of Medical Services In Europe: An Empirical Study / A European Survey
,
2004
.
[4]
P. Santana.
Poverty, social exclusion and health in Portugal.
,
2002,
Social science & medicine.
[5]
R. Klein,et al.
Big bang health care reform--does it work?: the case of Britain's 1991 National Health Service reforms.
,
1995,
The Milbank quarterly.
[6]
Elias Mossialos,et al.
Has the Portuguese NHS Achieved its Objectives of Equity and Efficiency?
,
2000
.
[7]
Andrew M. Jones,et al.
Explaining income-related inequalities in doctor utilisation in Europe.
,
2004,
Health economics.
[8]
P. Santana.
Ageing in Portugal: regional iniquities in health and health care.
,
2000,
Social science & medicine.
[9]
C. Propper,et al.
The redistributive effect of health care finance in twelve OECD countries.
,
1999,
Journal of health economics.
[10]
C. Oliveira,et al.
Achieving geographic equity in the Portuguese hospital financing system.
,
2003
.
[11]
E. Doorslaer,et al.
EQUITY IN THE USE OF PHYSICIAN VISITS IN OECD COUNTRIES: HAS EQUAL TREATMENT FOR EQUAL NEED BEEN ACHIEVED?
,
2003
.