Trophic Cascades in Terrestrial Systems: A Review of the Effects of Carnivore Removals on Plants

We present a quantitative synthesis of trophic cascades in terrestrial systems using data from 41 studies, reporting 60 independent tests. The studies covered a wide range of taxa in various terrestrial systems with varying degrees of species diversity. We quantified the average magnitude of direct effects of carnivores on herbivore prey and indirect effects of carnivores on plants. We examined how the effect magnitudes varied with type of carnivores in the study system, food web diversity, and experimental protocol. A metaanalysis of the data revealed that trophic cascades were common among the studies. Exceptions to this general trend did arise. In some cases, trophic cascades were expected not to occur, and they did not. In other cases, the direct effects of carnivores on herbivores were stronger than the indirect effects of carnivores on plants, indicating that top‐down effects attenuated. Top‐down effects usually attenuated whenever plants contained antiherbivore defenses or when herbivore species diversity was high. Conclusions about the strength of top‐down effects of carnivores varied with the type of carnivore and with the plant‐response variable measured. Vertebrate carnivores generally had stronger effects than invertebrate carnivores. Carnivores, in general, had stronger effects when the response was measured as plant damage rather than as plant biomass or plant reproductive output. We caution, therefore, that conclusions about the strength of top‐down effects could be an artifact of the plant‐response variable measured. We also found that mesocosm experiments generally had weaker effect magnitudes than open‐plot field experiments or observational experiments. Trophic cascades in terrestrial systems, although not a universal phenomenon, are a consistent response throughout the published studies reviewed here. Our analysis thus suggests that they occur more frequently in terrestrial systems than currently believed. Moreover, the mechanisms and strengths of top‐down effects of carnivores are equivalent to those found in other types of systems (e.g., aquatic environments).

[1]  U. Maschwitz,et al.  Protective function of the plant-ant Cladomyrma maschwitzi to its host, Crypteronia griffithii, and the dissolution of the mutualism (Hymenoptera: Formicidae) , 1998 .

[2]  D. Letourneau,et al.  Coping with enemy-filled space: herbivores on Endospermum in Papua New Guinea , 1993 .

[3]  Mark A. McPeek,et al.  Predation, Competition, and Prey Communities: A Review of Field Experiments , 1985 .

[4]  Jessica Gurevitch,et al.  A Meta-Analysis of Competition in Field Experiments , 1992, The American Naturalist.

[5]  Andrew M. Barton.  Spatial Variation in the Effect of Ants on Extrafloral Nectary Plant , 1986 .

[6]  M. Uriarte,et al.  Experimental evidence for a behavior-mediated trophic cascade in a terrestrial food chain. , 1997, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[7]  J. Roughgarden,et al.  Experimental Removal of Insectivores from Rain Forest Canopy: Direct and Indirect Effects , 1995 .

[8]  Jonathan M. Chase.  CENTRAL-PLACE FORAGER EFFECTS ON FOOD WEB DYNAMICS AND SPATIAL PATTERN IN NORTHERN CALIFORNIA MEADOWS , 1998 .

[9]  Neo D. Martinez,et al.  Improving Food Webs , 1993 .

[10]  R. Marquis,et al.  Insectivorous Birds Increase Growth of White Oak through Consumption of Leaf‐Chewing Insects , 1994 .

[11]  M. Moran,et al.  A trophic cascade in a diverse arthropod community caused by a generalist arthropod predator , 1997, Oecologia.

[12]  Jonathan M. Chase.  Abiotic Controls of Trophic Cascades in a Simple Grassland Food Chain , 1996 .

[13]  D. Letourneau.  Ants, stem-borers, and fungal pathogens: experimental tests of a fitness advantage in Piper ant-plants , 1998 .

[14]  G. Polis,et al.  Why Are Parts of the World Green? Multiple Factors Control Productivity and the Distribution of Biomass , 1999 .

[15]  H. Olff,et al.  Effects of herbivores on grassland plant diversity. , 1998, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[16]  R. Paine.  Food webs : linkage, interaction strength and community infrastructure , 1980 .

[17]  F. Messier.  Trophic interactions in two northern wolf-ungulate systems , 1995 .

[18]  D. Inouye,et al.  A Temperate Region Plant‐Ant‐Seed Predator System: Consequences of Extra Floral Nectar Secretion by Helianthella Quinquenervis , 1979 .

[19]  J. W. Smith,et al.  Natural Enemies of Dactylopius confusus (Homoptera: Dactylopiidae): Exclusion and Subsequent Impact on Opuntia (Cactaceae) , 1988 .

[20]  Jessica Gurevitch,et al.  THE META‐ANALYSIS OF RESPONSE RATIOS IN EXPERIMENTAL ECOLOGY , 1999 .

[21]  J. Wootton,et al.  ESTIMATES AND TESTS OF PER CAPITA INTERACTION STRENGTH: DIET, ABUNDANCE, AND IMPACT OF INTERTIDALLY FORAGING BIRDS , 1997 .

[22]  P. Oliveira.  The ecological function of extrafloral nectaries : herbivore deterrence by visiting ants and reproductive output in Caryocar brasiliense (Caryocaraceae) , 1997 .

[23]  Thomas P. Rooney,et al.  Top-down cascade from a bitrophic predator in an old-field community , 1996 .

[24]  H. Vasconcelos,et al.  Influence of Azteca alfari Ants on the Exploitation of Cecropia Trees by a Leaf‐Cutting Ant , 1997 .

[25]  Nancy Huntly,et al.  Herbivores and the dynamics of communities and ecosystems , 1991 .

[26]  M. Anstett,et al.  Benefits conferred by “timid” ants: active anti-herbivore protection of the rainforest tree Leonardoxa africana by the minute ant Petalomyrmex phylax , 1997, Oecologia.

[27]  L. Oksanen,et al.  Exploitation Ecosystems in Gradients of Primary Productivity , 1981, The American Naturalist.

[28]  G. Arnqvist,et al.  MetaWin: Statistical Software for Meta-Analysis with Resampling Tests. Version 1.Michael S. Rosenberg , Dean C. Adams , Jessica Gurevitch , 1998 .

[29]  D. Mackay,et al.  Patterns of ant and herbivore activity on five understory euphorbiaceous saplings in submontane Papua New Guinea , 1988 .

[30]  O. Schmitz,et al.  Direct and Indirect Effects of Predation and Predation Risk in Old‐Field Interaction Webs , 1998, The American Naturalist.

[31]  G. Polis,et al.  Food Web Complexity and Community Dynamics , 1996, The American Naturalist.

[32]  S. Koptur.  EXPERIMENTAL EVIDENCE FOR DEFENSE OF INGA (MIMOSOIDEAE) SAPLINGS BY ANTS , 1984 .

[33]  J. H. Bock,et al.  EFFECTS OF BIRD PREDATION ON GRASSHOPPER DENSITIES IN AN ARIZONA GRASSLAND , 1992 .

[34]  Peter Arcese,et al.  Serengeti II : dynamics, management, and conservation of an ecosystem , 1996 .

[35]  T. Schoener,et al.  Food-Web Dynamics on Some Small Subtropical Islands: Effects of Top and Intermediate Predators , 1996 .

[36]  Regino Zamora,et al.  Top‐Down Effects in a Tritrophic System: Parasitoids Enhance Plant Fitness , 1994 .

[37]  L. Slobodkin,et al.  Community Structure, Population Control, and Competition , 1960, The American Naturalist.

[38]  J. Whittaker,et al.  An experimental field study of different levels of insect herbivory induced by Formica rufa predation on Sycamore (Acer pseudoplatanus). I: Lepidoptera la rvae , 1985 .

[39]  S. D. Cooper,et al.  Effect Size in Ecological Experiments: The Application of Biological Models in Meta‐Analysis , 1997, The American Naturalist.

[40]  D. Mackay.  The effects of ants on herbivory and herbivore numbers on foliage of the mallee eucalypt, Eucalyptus incrassata Labill.* , 1991 .

[41]  P. Hambäck,et al.  Associational resistance: insect damage to purple loosestrife reduced in thickets of sweet gale. , 2000 .

[42]  Fabian M Jaksic,et al.  Effects of small mammals and vertebrate predators on vegetation in the Chilean semiarid zone , 1997, Oecologia.

[43]  L. Oksanen,et al.  Long-term microtine dynamics in north Fennoscandian tundra: the vole cycle and the lemming chaos , 1992 .

[44]  J. P. Grime,et al.  Top-down control and its effect on the biomass and composition of three grasses at high and low soil fertility in outdoor microcosms , 1998, Oecologia.

[45]  Oswald J. Schmitz,et al.  Behaviorally mediated trophic cascades : Effects of predation risk on food web interactions , 1997 .

[46]  Donald R. Strong,et al.  ARE TROPHIC CASCADES ALL WET? DIFFERENTIATION AND DONOR-CONTROL IN SPECIOSE ECOSYSTEMS' , 1992 .

[47]  O. Schmitz.  Exploitation in model food chains with mechanistic consumer-resource dynamics , 1992 .

[48]  Stan Boutin,et al.  Predation and Moose Population Dynamics: A Critique , 1992 .

[49]  B. Menge,et al.  Dection of Direct Versus Indirect Effects: Were Experiments Long Enough? , 1997, The American Naturalist.

[50]  R. Peterson,et al.  Wolves, Moose, and Tree Rings on Isle Royale , 1994, Science.

[51]  Jessica Gurevitch,et al.  MetaWin: Statistical Software for Meta-analysis with Resampling Tests , 1997 .

[52]  B. Menge,et al.  Indirect Effects in Marine Rocky Intertidal Interaction Webs: Patterns and Importance , 1995 .

[53]  C. Fonseca.  Herbivory and the Long-Lived Leaves of an Amazonian Ant-Tree , 1994 .

[54]  C. Goldman,et al.  A meta-analysis of the freshwater trophic cascade. , 1996, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[55]  O. Schmitz,et al.  Resource edibility and trophic exploitation in an old-field food web. , 1994, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[56]  L. B. Thien,et al.  Factors influencing the reproductive success of Ipomoea pes-caprae (Convolvulaceae) around the Gulf of Mexico , 1989 .

[57]  L. Hedges,et al.  Meta-analysis: Combining the results of independent experiments , 1993 .

[58]  S. Fretwell.  Food chain dynamics: the central theory of ecology? , 1987 .

[59]  G. Polis,et al.  Allochthonous Input Across Habitats, Subsidized Consumers, and Apparent Trophic Cascades: Examples from the Ocean-Land Interface , 1996 .

[60]  F. Messina.  Plant Protection as a Consequence of an Ant‐Membracid Mutualism: Interactions on Goldenrod (Solidago Sp.) , 1981 .

[61]  C. Horvitz,et al.  EFFECTS OF ANTS AND AN ANT-TENDED HERBIVORE ON SEED PRODUCTION OF A NEOTROPICAL HERB , 1984 .

[62]  D. Schemske.  THE EVOLUTIONARY SIGNIFICANCE OF EXTRAFLORAL NECTAR PRODUCTION BY COSTUS WOODSONII (ZINGIBERACEAE): AN EXPERIMENTAL ANALYSIS OF ANT PROTECTION , 1980 .

[63]  A. Stephenson.  THE ROLE OF THE EXTRAFLORAL NECTARIES OF CATALPA SPECIOSA IN LIMITING HERBIVORY AND INCREASING FRUIT PRODUCTION , 1982 .

[64]  L. Dyer,et al.  EXPERIMENTAL TEST IN LOWLAND TROPICAL FOREST SHOWS TOP‐DOWN EFFECTS THROUGH FOUR TROPHIC LEVELS , 1998 .