Intercalibration of assessment methods for macrophytes in lowland streams: direct comparison and analysis of common metrics

The results of four macrophyte assessment methods (French Indice Biologique Macrophytique en Rivière, German Reference Index, British Mean Trophic Rank and Dutch Macrophyte Score) were compared, based on plant survey data of medium-sized lowland streams in Central Europe. To intercalibrate the good quality class boundaries two alternative methods were applied: direct comparison and the use of “common metrics”. While the French and British methods were highly related (R2>0.75), the German RI showed less (0.20<R2<0.55) and the Dutch DMS least correlation (R2<0.10) with other methods. Of 70 macrophyte metrics tested only Ellenberg_N was considerably related to three of the national assessment methods, thus representing a potential common metric for intercalibration. Comparison of quality class boundaries via regression analysis using both intercalibration approaches revealed major differences between classifications of the French, German and British methods, which are, in addition, related in a nonlinear way.

[1]  Sebastian Birk,et al.  Direct comparison of assessment methods using benthic macroinvertebrates: a contribution to the EU Water Framework Directive intercalibration exercise , 2006, Hydrobiologia.

[2]  Georg A. Janauer,et al.  Is what has been measured of any direct relevance to the success of the macrophyte in its particular environment , 2001 .

[3]  G. Wiegleb.  Die Lebens- und Wuchsformen der makrophytischen Wasserpflanzen und deren Beziehungen zur Ökologie, Verbreitung und Vergesellschaftung der Arten , 1991 .

[4]  J. Foerster,et al.  Ecological classification of macrophytes and phytobenthos for rivers in Germany according to the water framework directive , 2004 .

[5]  E. C. Pielou.  The measurement of diversity in different types of biological collections , 1966 .

[6]  Peter Haase,et al.  The STAR project: context, objectives and approaches , 2006, Hydrobiologia.

[7]  Andrea Buffagni,et al.  The STAR common metrics approach to the WFD intercalibration process: Full application for small, lowland rivers in three European countries , 2006, Hydrobiologia.

[8]  John Davy-Bowker,et al.  European river plant communities: the importance of organic pollution and the usefulness of existing macrophyte metrics , 2006, Hydrobiologia.

[9]  Vladimir Sládecek,et al.  System of water quality from the biological point of view , 1973 .

[10]  G. Wiegleb.  Analysis of Flora and Vegetation in Rivers: Concepts and Applications , 1988 .

[11]  R. Clarke,et al.  Towards European Inter-Calibration for the Water Framework Directive Procedures and Examples for Different River Types from the BC Project STAR , 2005 .