Abstract The method of characteristics, used in previous paper [7, 8] to calculate limiting stress fields in two-dimensional bins and hoppers containing granular material, is used to solve the switch stress problem, i.e. to find the stress field associated with a change in state from active to passive. The solution involves a discontinuity which, at the centre-line, is vertical rather than horizontal as has previously been assumed in other analyses. The peak stress does not occur at the transition but below it where the discontinuity reaches the wall. Wall stresses given by the present method are compared with those by the approximate methods of Walker [11], Walter [4], Enstad [5] and Jenike and Johanson [2, 3]. Substantial differences are found in the form of stress distribution and in the location and magnitude of the peak stresses. It is concluded that the approximate methods leave much to be desired.
[1]
O. F. Theimer.
Failures of Reinforced Concrete Grain Silos
,
1969
.
[2]
R. M. Nedderman,et al.
Stress distribution in hoppers
,
1978
.
[3]
R. J. Cornish.
Pressure on a hopper wall at a stress discontinuity during mass flow
,
1973
.
[4]
S. Savage,et al.
Stresses developed by cohesionless granular materials in bins
,
1970
.
[5]
P. M. Blair-Fish,et al.
Wall stresses in mass-flow bunkers
,
1974
.
[6]
J. R. Johanson,et al.
On the Theory of Bin Loads
,
1969
.
[7]
J. K. Walters,et al.
A theoretical analysis of stresses in axially-symmetric hoppers and bunkers
,
1973
.
[8]
D. M. Walker.
An approximate theory for pressures and arching in hoppers
,
1966
.
[9]
G. Enstad,et al.
ON THE THEORY OF ARCHING IN MASS FLOW HOPPERS
,
1975
.