Inspiration for wing design: how forelimb specialization enables active flight in modern vertebrates

Harnessing flight strategies refined by millions of years of evolution can help expedite the design of more efficient, manoeuvrable and robust flying robots. This review synthesizes recent advances and highlights remaining gaps in our understanding of how bird and bat wing adaptations enable effective flight. Included in this discussion is an evaluation of how current robotic analogues measure up to their biological sources of inspiration. Studies of vertebrate wings have revealed skeletal systems well suited for enduring the loads required during flight, but the mechanisms that drive coordinated motions between bones and connected integuments remain ill-described. Similarly, vertebrate flight muscles have adapted to sustain increased wing loading, but a lack of in vivo studies limits our understanding of specific muscular functions. Forelimb adaptations diverge at the integument level, but both bird feathers and bat membranes yield aerodynamic surfaces with a level of robustness unparalleled by engineered wings. These morphological adaptations enable a diverse range of kinematics tuned for different flight speeds and manoeuvres. By integrating vertebrate flight specializations—particularly those that enable greater robustness and adaptability—into the design and control of robotic wings, engineers can begin narrowing the wide margin that currently exists between flying robots and vertebrates. In turn, these robotic wings can help biologists create experiments that would be impossible in vivo.

[1]  J. Currey The effect of porosity and mineral content on the Young's modulus of elasticity of compact bone. , 1988, Journal of biomechanics.

[2]  Joseph W Bahlman,et al.  Design and characterization of a multi-articulated robotic bat wing , 2013, Bioinspiration & biomimetics.

[3]  Tucker Drag reduction by wing tip slots in a gliding Harris' hawk, Parabuteo unicinctus , 1995, The Journal of experimental biology.

[4]  P. O’Connor,et al.  Bone Laminarity in the Avian Forelimb Skeleton and Its Relationship to Flight Mode: Testing Functional Interpretations , 2012, Anatomical record.

[5]  B T Dickinson,et al.  Hair receptor sensitivity to changes in laminar boundary layer shape , 2010, Bioinspiration & biomimetics.

[6]  R. Norberg,et al.  Scaling of wingbeat frequency with body mass in bats and limits to maximum bat size , 2012, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[7]  S. Swartz Allometric patterning in the limb skeleton of bats: Implications for the mechanics and energetics of powered flight , 1997, Journal of morphology.

[8]  Melissa S. Bowlin,et al.  Vortex wake, downwash distribution, aerodynamic performance and wingbeat kinematics in slow-flying pied flycatchers , 2012, Journal of The Royal Society Interface.

[9]  Stanislav N Gorb,et al.  Unzipping bird feathers , 2014, Journal of The Royal Society Interface.

[10]  R. M. Alexander Factors of safety in the structure of animals. , 1981, Science progress.

[11]  U. Norberg Structure, form, and function of flight in engineering and the living world. , 2002 .

[12]  R. M. Alexander,et al.  Tendon elasticity and muscle function. , 2002, Comparative biochemistry and physiology. Part A, Molecular & integrative physiology.

[13]  R. Fearing,et al.  Optimal energy density piezoelectric bending actuators , 2005 .

[14]  Bret W. Tobalske,et al.  Aerodynamics of intermittent bounds in flying birds , 2009 .

[15]  Sharon M Swartz,et al.  Changes in kinematics and aerodynamics over a range of speeds in Tadarida brasiliensis, the Brazilian free-tailed bat , 2012, Journal of The Royal Society Interface.

[16]  Sharon M. Swartz,et al.  Biomechanics of the Bat Limb Skeleton: Scaling, Material Properties and Mechanics , 2007, Cells Tissues Organs.

[17]  R. Bullen,et al.  Scaling bat wingbeat frequency and amplitude. , 2002, The Journal of experimental biology.

[18]  David Lentink,et al.  Fruit fly scale robots can hover longer with flapping wings than with spinning wings , 2016, Journal of The Royal Society Interface.

[19]  S. Hasan,et al.  Relationship between vertical ground reaction force and speed during walking, slow jogging, and running. , 1996, Clinical biomechanics.

[20]  K. Breuer,et al.  Upstroke wing flexion and the inertial cost of bat flight , 2012, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[21]  C. Pennycuick A wind tunnel study of gliding flight in the pigeon Columba livia , 1968 .

[22]  David R. Carrier,et al.  Wing bone stresses in free flying bats and the evolution of skeletal design for flight , 1992, Nature.

[23]  A. M. Berg,et al.  Wing and body kinematics of takeoff and landing flight in the pigeon (Columba livia) , 2010, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[24]  A. Hedenström,et al.  A quantitative comparison of bird and bat wakes , 2010, Journal of The Royal Society Interface.

[25]  Kenneth C. Hall,et al.  Power Requirements for Large-Amplitude Flapping Flight , 1997 .

[26]  A. Kuznetsov,et al.  Flight of Mammals: From Terrestrial Limbs to Wings , 2015, Springer International Publishing.

[27]  R. E. Brown,et al.  AIRFLOW SENSORS IN THE AVIAN WING , 1993 .

[28]  G. E. Goslow,et al.  The contractile properties of the M. supracoracoideus In the pigeon and starling: a case for long-axis rotation of the humerus , 1997, The Journal of experimental biology.

[29]  A. Hedenström,et al.  The wake of hovering flight in bats , 2015, Journal of The Royal Society Interface.

[30]  E. de Margerie,et al.  Torsional resistance as a principal component of the structural design of long bones: comparative multivariate evidence in birds. , 2004, The anatomical record. Part A, Discoveries in molecular, cellular, and evolutionary biology.

[31]  C. J. Pennycuick,et al.  Modelling the Flying Bird , 2008 .

[32]  Andrew Balmford,et al.  Walk on the Wild Side: Estimating the Global Magnitude of Visits to Protected Areas , 2015, PLoS biology.

[33]  Mujahid Abdulrahim,et al.  Design and analysis of biomimetic joints for morphing of micro air vehicles , 2010, Bioinspiration & biomimetics.

[34]  R. J. Vazquez,et al.  The automating skeletal and muscular mechanisms of the avian wing (Aves) , 1994, Zoomorphology.

[35]  J Colorado,et al.  Corrigendum: Biomechanics of smart wings in a bat robot: morphing wings using SMA actuators , 2012, Bioinspiration & biomimetics.

[36]  York Winter,et al.  Kinematics and wing shape across flight speed in the bat, Leptonycteris yerbabuenae , 2012, Biology Open.

[37]  A. Feduccia,et al.  Feathers of Archaeopteryx: Asymmetric Vanes Indicate Aerodynamic Function , 1979, Science.

[38]  Bret W. Tobalske,et al.  How cockatiels (Nymphicus hollandicus) modulate pectoralis power output across flight speeds , 2003, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[39]  Ulla M. Norberg,et al.  Functional osteology and myology of the wing of the dog-faced bat Rousettus aegyptiacus (É. Geoffroy) (Mammalia, Chiroptera) , 1972, Zeitschrift für Morphologie der Tiere.

[40]  U. M. Norberg Hovering Flight in the Pied Flycatcher (Ficedula Hypoleuca) , 1975 .

[41]  Andrew A Biewener,et al.  Muscle function during takeoff and landing flight in the pigeon (Columba livia) , 2012, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[42]  G. Taylor,et al.  Animal flight dynamics I. Stability in gliding flight. , 2001, Journal of theoretical biology.

[43]  Andrew A. Biewener,et al.  In vivo strain in the humerus of pigeons (Columba livia) during flight , 1995 .

[44]  J. V. Berge A Comparative Study of the Appendicular Mus- culature of the Order Ciconiiformes , 1970 .

[45]  Adrian L. R. Thomas,et al.  Automatic aeroelastic devices in the wings of a steppe eagle Aquila nipalensis , 2007, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[46]  A. Hedenström,et al.  Kinematics of flight and the relationship to the vortex wake of a Pallas' long tongued bat (Glossophaga soricina) , 2010, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[47]  Andrew A Biewener,et al.  Muscle function in avian flight: achieving power and control , 2011, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[48]  G. Askew,et al.  The mechanical power output of the pectoralis muscle of cockatiel (Nymphicus hollandicus): the in vivo muscle length trajectory and activity patterns and their implications for power modulation , 2010, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[49]  R. Behringer,et al.  Development of bat flight: morphologic and molecular evolution of bat wing digits. , 2006, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[50]  Tobalske,et al.  Flight kinematics of black-billed magpies and pigeons over a wide range of speeds , 1996, The Journal of experimental biology.

[51]  Noble S. Proctor,et al.  Manual of Ornithology: Avian Structure and Function , 1993 .

[52]  Ennos,et al.  Functional morphology of the vanes of the flight feathers of the pigeon Columba livia , 1995, The Journal of experimental biology.

[53]  York Winter,et al.  The near and far wake of Pallas' long tongued bat (Glossophaga soricina) , 2008, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[54]  G C H E de Croon,et al.  Design, aerodynamics and autonomy of the DelFly , 2012, Bioinspiration & biomimetics.

[55]  Rick J Vazquez,et al.  Functional osteology of the avian wrist and the evolution of flapping flight , 1992, Journal of morphology.

[56]  K A Holbrook,et al.  A collagen and elastic network in the wing of the bat. , 1978, Journal of anatomy.

[57]  M. Dickinson,et al.  Rotational accelerations stabilize leading edge vortices on revolving fly wings , 2009, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[58]  Robert G Hoey,et al.  Exploring bird aerodynamics using radio-controlled models , 2010, Bioinspiration & biomimetics.

[59]  Hyungmin Park,et al.  The Function of the Alula in Avian Flight , 2015, Scientific Reports.

[60]  O. Schmitt The heat of shortening and the dynamic constants of muscle , 2017 .

[61]  Cynthia F Moss,et al.  Echolocating Bats Use a Nearly Time-Optimal Strategy to Intercept Prey , 2006, PLoS biology.

[62]  David Lentink,et al.  Folding in and out: passive morphing in flapping wings , 2015, Bioinspiration & biomimetics.

[63]  Bret W Tobalske,et al.  Biomechanics of bird flight , 2007, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[64]  Gillian L. Currie,et al.  Risk of Bias in Reports of In Vivo Research: A Focus for Improvement , 2015, PLoS biology.

[65]  Tobalske,et al.  NEUROMUSCULAR CONTROL AND KINEMATICS OF INTERMITTENT FLIGHT IN BUDGERIGARS (MELOPSITTACUS UNDULATUS) , 1994, The Journal of experimental biology.

[66]  J. Scott Altenbach,et al.  Functional anatomy of the shoulder and arm of the fruit‐eating bat Artibeus jamaicensis , 1985 .

[67]  David C. Douglas,et al.  Extreme endurance flights by landbirds crossing the Pacific Ocean: ecological corridor rather than barrier? , 2008, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[68]  Andrew A Biewener,et al.  Pigeons produce aerodynamic torques through changes in wing trajectory during low speed aerial turns , 2015, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[69]  Sharon M. Swartz,et al.  Spring or string: does tendon elastic action influence wing muscle mechanics in bat flight? , 2015, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[70]  Sharon M Swartz,et al.  Kinematics of slow turn maneuvering in the fruit bat Cynopterus brachyotis , 2008, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[71]  Holbrook Ka,et al.  A Collagen and Elastic Network in the Wing of the Bat , 1978 .

[72]  U. M. Norberg,et al.  Aerodynamics, kinematics, and energetics of horizontal flapping flight in the long-eared bat Plecotus auritus. , 1976, The Journal of experimental biology.

[73]  E. de Margerie Laminar bone as an adaptation to torsional loads in flapping flight , 2002, Journal of anatomy.

[74]  Gabriel Taubin,et al.  Falling with Style: Bats Perform Complex Aerial Rotations by Adjusting Wing Inertia , 2015, PLoS biology.

[75]  Tobalske,et al.  Kinematics of flap-bounding flight in the zebra finch over a wide range of speeds , 1999, The Journal of experimental biology.

[76]  Nick Cramer,et al.  Digital Morphing Wing: Active Wing Shaping Concept Using Composite Lattice-Based Cellular Structures , 2016, Soft robotics.

[77]  C. J. Clark,et al.  Aeroelastic flutter of feathers, flight and the evolution of non-vocal communication in birds , 2015, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[78]  Robert J. Wood,et al.  The First Takeoff of a Biologically Inspired At-Scale Robotic Insect , 2008, IEEE Transactions on Robotics.

[79]  Mujahid Abdulrahim,et al.  Flight Dynamics of a Morphing Aircraft Utilizing Independent Multiple-Joint Wing Sweep , 2010 .

[80]  Vladimir Brailovski,et al.  SMA actuators for morphing wings , 2010 .

[81]  Henry Won,et al.  Tailless Flapping Wing Propulsion and Control Development for the Nano Hummingbird Micro Air Vehicle , 2012 .

[82]  Mary Frecker,et al.  Passively morphing ornithopter wings constructed using a novel compliant spine: design and testing , 2012 .

[83]  M Di Luca,et al.  Bioinspired morphing wings for extended flight envelope and roll control of small drones , 2017, Interface Focus.

[84]  Rickard Bensow,et al.  Large-Eddy Simulation of an Oscillating Cylinder in a Steady Flow , 2013 .

[85]  K. Dial,et al.  Kinematic, aerodynamic and anatomical mechanisms in the slow, maneuvering flight of pigeons , 1998, The Journal of experimental biology.

[86]  Bret W Tobalske,et al.  Hovering and intermittent flight in birds , 2010, Bioinspiration & biomimetics.

[87]  Bret W Tobalske,et al.  Kinematics and aerodynamics of avian upstrokes during slow flight , 2015, The Journal of Experimental Biology.

[88]  Kenneth Breuer,et al.  Aeromechanics of Membrane Wings with Implications for Animal Flight ArnoldSong, ∗ XiaodongTian, † EmilyIsraeli, ‡ RicardoGalvao, § KristinBishop, ¶ SharonSwartz, ∗∗ , 2008 .

[89]  David J. Willis,et al.  Wing structure and the aerodynamic basis of flight in bats , 2007 .

[90]  Melissa S. Bowlin,et al.  Comparing Aerodynamic Efficiency in Birds and Bats Suggests Better Flight Performance in Birds , 2012, PloS one.

[91]  Gottfried Sachs,et al.  Effect of slotted wing tips on yawing moment characteristics. , 2006, Journal of theoretical biology.

[92]  Bat flight with bad wings: is flight metabolism affected by damaged wings? , 2013, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[93]  A. Krogh,et al.  The Mechanism of Flight Preparation in Some Insects , 1941 .

[94]  H. Wagner,et al.  Flexural stiffness of feather shafts: geometry rules over material properties , 2012, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[95]  L. Chiappe Rise of Birds , 2007 .

[96]  R. Dudley,et al.  An integrative approach to understanding bird origins , 2014, Science.

[97]  James Richard Usherwood,et al.  Physiological, aerodynamic and geometric constraints of flapping account for bird gaits, and bounding and flap-gliding flight strategies , 2016, Journal of theoretical biology.

[98]  Teresa J. Feo,et al.  Barb geometry of asymmetrical feathers reveals a transitional morphology in the evolution of avian flight , 2015, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[99]  K. Breuer,et al.  Wake structure and wing kinematics: the flight of the lesser dog-faced fruit bat, Cynopterus brachyotis , 2010, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[100]  A. Hedenström,et al.  Ear-body lift and a novel thrust generating mechanism revealed by the complex wake of brown long-eared bats (Plecotus auritus) , 2016, Scientific Reports.

[101]  Diana D Chin,et al.  Flapping wing aerodynamics: from insects to vertebrates , 2016, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[102]  G. Taylor,et al.  Animal flight dynamics II. Longitudinal stability in flapping flight. , 2003, Journal of theoretical biology.

[103]  Kamran Safi,et al.  Airplane tracking documents the fastest flight speeds recorded for bats , 2016, Royal Society Open Science.

[104]  A. Biewener,et al.  Contractile properties of the pigeon supracoracoideus during different modes of flight , 2008, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[105]  J. Swaddle,et al.  The effects of molt on the flight performance, body mass, and behavior of European starlings (Sturnus vulgaris): an experimental approach , 1997 .

[106]  Andrew H Lee,et al.  Wing bone laminarity is not an adaptation for torsional resistance in bats , 2015, PeerJ.

[107]  A. J. Ward-Smith,et al.  Analysis of the aerodynamic performance of birds during bounding flight , 1984 .

[108]  Tyson L. Hedrick,et al.  Experimental Study of Low Speed Turning Flight in Cockatoos and Cockatiels , 2007 .

[109]  D. Warrick,et al.  The turning- and linear-maneuvering performance of birds : the cost of efficiency for coursing insectivores , 1998 .

[110]  William R. Walsh,et al.  Mechanical properties of bat wing membrane skin , 1996 .

[111]  C. J. Clark,et al.  Courtship dives of Anna's hummingbird offer insights into flight performance limits , 2009, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[112]  Daniel E. Re,et al.  Wound Healing in the Flight Membranes of Big Brown Bats , 2009 .

[113]  Gregg F. Gunnell,et al.  Primitive Early Eocene bat from Wyoming and the evolution of flight and echolocation , 2008, Nature.

[114]  K. Middleton,et al.  Hummingbirds control turning velocity using body orientation and turning radius using asymmetrical wingbeat kinematics , 2016, Journal of The Royal Society Interface.

[115]  Soon-Jo Chung,et al.  A biomimetic robotic platform to study flight specializations of bats , 2017, Science Robotics.

[116]  David Lentink,et al.  The biophysics of bird flight: functional relationships integrate aerodynamics, morphology, kinematics, muscles and sensors , 2015 .

[117]  A. Hedenström,et al.  Leading-Edge Vortex Improves Lift in Slow-Flying Bats , 2008, Science.

[118]  Mary Frecker,et al.  Flight Testing of Novel Compliant Spines for Passive Wing Morphing on Ornithopters , 2013 .

[119]  Emmanuel de Margerie,et al.  Laminar bone as an adaptation to torsional loads in flapping flight , 2002 .

[120]  W. Kenchington Animal mechanics , 1950, Nature.

[121]  E. Dumont Bone density and the lightweight skeletons of birds , 2010, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[122]  T. Vaughan Chapter 4 – The Muscular System , 1970 .

[123]  Thomas Ward,et al.  A Review of Biomimetic Air Vehicle Research: 1984-2014 , 2015 .

[124]  J. Gordon Leishman,et al.  Principles of Helicopter Aerodynamics , 2000 .

[125]  S. Kirkpatrick Scale effects on the stresses and safety factors in the wing bones of birds and bats. , 1994, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[126]  T. Hedrick,et al.  Wingbeat Time and the Scaling of Passive Rotational Damping in Flapping Flight , 2009, Science.

[127]  A. Biewener,et al.  Low speed maneuvering flight of the rose-breasted cockatoo (Eolophus roseicapillus). II. Inertial and aerodynamic reorientation , 2007, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[128]  Emanuel Azizi,et al.  Flexible mechanisms: the diverse roles of biological springs in vertebrate movement , 2011, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[129]  Alexander Rm,et al.  Factors of safety in the structure of animals. , 1981 .

[130]  H. Aldridge,et al.  Kinematics and aerodynamics of the greater horseshoe bat, Rhinolophus ferrumequinum, in horizontal flight at various flight speeds. , 1986, The Journal of experimental biology.

[131]  K. Breuer,et al.  Aeromechanics in aeroecology: flight biology in the aerosphere. , 2007, Integrative and comparative biology.

[132]  David Lentink,et al.  In vivo recording of aerodynamic force with an aerodynamic force platform: from drones to birds , 2014, Journal of The Royal Society Interface.

[133]  Jorn A. Cheney,et al.  Membrane muscle function in the compliant wings of bats , 2014, Bioinspiration & biomimetics.

[134]  C. J. Clark,et al.  Three-dimensional kinematics of hummingbird flight , 2007, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[135]  Ulla M Lindhe Norberg,et al.  Structure, form, and function of flight in engineering and the living world , 2002, Journal of morphology.

[136]  A. Hedenström,et al.  Leading edge vortices in lesser long-nosed bats occurring at slow but not fast flight speeds , 2014, Bioinspiration & biomimetics.

[137]  C. J. Pennycuick,et al.  Gliding Flight of the Dog-Faced Bat Rousettus Aegyptiacus Observed in a Wind Tunnel , 1971 .

[138]  The mechanical performance of medullary foam from feathers , 2001 .

[139]  Andrew A Biewener,et al.  Pigeons steer like helicopters and generate down- and upstroke lift during low speed turns , 2011, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[140]  N. Simmons,et al.  Fossil Evidence and the Origin of Bats , 2005, Journal of Mammalian Evolution.

[141]  A. Hedenström,et al.  Bird or bat: comparing airframe design and flight performance , 2009, Bioinspiration & biomimetics.

[142]  Tobalske Neuromuscular control and kinematics of intermittent flight in the European starling (Sturnus vulgaris) , 1995, The Journal of experimental biology.

[143]  Wei Xian,et al.  Bat wing sensors support flight control , 2011, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[144]  Reinhold Necker,et al.  Observations on the function of a slowly-adapting mechanoreceptor associated with filoplumes in the feathered skin of pigeons , 1985, Journal of Comparative Physiology A.

[145]  Bret Stanford,et al.  Simultaneous Topology Optimization of Membrane Wings and Their Compliant Flapping Mechanisms , 2012 .

[146]  V. Tucker,et al.  Aerodynamics of Gliding Flight in a Falcon and Other Birds , 1970 .

[147]  A. Hedenström,et al.  Bat flight: aerodynamics, kinematics and flight morphology , 2015, The Journal of Experimental Biology.

[148]  Soon-Jo Chung,et al.  Bat Bot (B2), a biologically inspired flying machine , 2016, 2016 IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation (ICRA).

[149]  David Lentink,et al.  Feather roughness reduces flow separation during low Reynolds number glides of swifts , 2015, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[150]  Robert Dudley,et al.  The ecological and evolutionary interface of hummingbird flight physiology. , 2002, The Journal of experimental biology.

[151]  Mary Frecker,et al.  Free Flight Testing and Performance Evaluation of a Passively Morphing Ornithopter , 2015 .

[152]  P. Chai,et al.  Hummingbird hovering energetics during moult of primary flight feathers. , 1997, The Journal of experimental biology.

[153]  A. Hedenström,et al.  Bat Flight Generates Complex Aerodynamic Tracks , 2007, Science.

[154]  Adrian L. R. Thomas,et al.  Flying and swimming animals cruise at a Strouhal number tuned for high power efficiency , 2003, Nature.

[155]  R J Full,et al.  How animals move: an integrative view. , 2000, Science.

[156]  J. Wild,et al.  Muscle Activation Patterns and Motor Anatomy of Anna’s Hummingbirds Calypte anna and Zebra Finches Taeniopygia guttata , 2012, Physiological and Biochemical Zoology.

[157]  Junliang Tao,et al.  Hair flow sensors: from bio-inspiration to bio-mimicking—a review , 2012 .

[158]  F. Liechti,et al.  Flexibility in flight behaviour of barn swallows (Hirundo rustica) and house martins (Delichon urbica) tested in a wind tunnel. , 2001, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[159]  T. Vaughan Morphology and Flight Characteristics of Molossid Bats , 1966 .

[160]  V. Tucker,et al.  GLIDING BIRDS: REDUCTION OF INDUCED DRAG BY WING TIP SLOTS BETWEEN THE PRIMARY FEATHERS , 1993 .

[161]  A. Adams,et al.  The Muscular System , 2004 .

[162]  B. Tobalske,et al.  Specialized primary feathers produce tonal sounds during flight in rock pigeons (Columba livia) , 2016, Journal of Experimental Biology.

[163]  Ulla M. Norberg,et al.  Evolution of Vertebrate Flight: An Aerodynamic Model for the Transition from Gliding to Active Flight , 1985, The American Naturalist.

[164]  J. L. Leeuwen,et al.  How swifts control their glide performance with morphing wings , 2006, Nature.

[165]  C. Pennycuick Power requirements for horizontal flight in the pigeon Columba livia , 1968 .

[166]  A. Biewener,et al.  Estimates of circulation and gait change based on a three-dimensional kinematic analysis of flight in cockatiels (Nymphicus hollandicus) and ringed turtle-doves (Streptopelia risoria). , 2002, The Journal of experimental biology.

[167]  Jeremy M. V. Rayner,et al.  Bounding and undulating flight in birds , 1985 .

[168]  C. J. Clark,et al.  Aeroelastic Flutter Produces Hummingbird Feather Songs , 2011, Science.

[169]  Mujahid Abdulrahim,et al.  Flight Characteristics of Shaping the Membrane Wing of a Micro Air Vehicle , 2005 .

[170]  K. Dial,et al.  AVIAN FORELIMB MUSCLES AND NONSTEADY FLIGHT: CAN BIRDS FLY WITHOUT USING THE MUSCLES IN THEIR WINGS? , 1992 .

[171]  R. Bonser,et al.  The Young's modulus of feather keratin , 1995, The Journal of experimental biology.

[172]  Henry D. Prange,et al.  Scaling of Skeletal Mass to Body Mass in Birds and Mammals , 1979, The American Naturalist.