A long-term study comparing membrane filtration with Colilert defined substrates in detecting fecal coliforms and Escherichia coli in natural waters.

Assessment methods for determining the presence and number of fecal bacteria and Escherichia coli (E. coli) in waters, foodstuffs, sewage effluent, and soils have evolved from multiple tube fermentations (MTF's) to membrane filtrations (MF's) to, most recently, defined substrate technologies (DST's). Mounting evidence indicates Colilert DST (IDEXX, Westbrook, ME) to be a versatile assessment technique for detecting and enumerating E. coli over a range of applications. This study compared the performance of Colilert DST with a confirmed standard MF technique using m-FC broth (Millipore, Bedford, MA) in assessing E. coli in ten different environmental water samples obtained monthly over a 3-year period from the upper Appomattox River, VA. For the duration of the study, E. coli counts measured by Colilert DST were positively correlated (Pearson's correlation coefficient=0.956; slope=0.979; p<0.0001) with E. coli counts measured by confirmed MF procedures. The results of a two-factor ANOVA revealed that Colilert DST counts compared equally to confirmed MF counts by year (p=0.974), by stream sampled (p=1.0), and by season (p=0.696). E. coli counts were significantly lower during cold season months (Dec/Jan/Feb) than during warm season months (Jun/Jul/Aug) for each year contributing to marked variation in sample quality. Counts obtained by Colilert DST compared equally to those obtained by MF across all samples and dates for the three years. Colilert DST presents a laboratory protocol that is simpler to manage, quicker to process, and easier to quantify results than MF. These factors, plus the enhanced precision and versatility of Colilert DST over the span of this three-year study attests to its suitability for testing ambient surface waters.

[1]  J. Liu,et al.  Enumeration of Coliform Bacteria in Wastewater Solids Using Defined Substrate Technology , 2002, Water environment research.

[2]  M. Doyle,et al.  Fate of Escherichia coli O157:H7 in Manure-Amended Soil , 2002, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[3]  H. L. Jeter,et al.  The membrane filter in sanitary bacteriology. , 1951, Public health reports.

[4]  C. Fricker,et al.  A comparison of the International Standards Organisation reference method for the detection of coliforms and Escherichia coli in water with a defined substrate procedure , 2003, Journal of applied microbiology.

[5]  K. Walter,et al.  A preliminary study of the use of Colilert for water quality monitoring , 1994 .

[6]  C. Fricker,et al.  Use of two presence/absence systems for the detection of E. coli and coliforms from water , 1996 .

[7]  A. E. Greenberg,et al.  Standard methods for the examination of water and wastewater : supplement to the sixteenth edition , 1988 .

[8]  J. Eccles,et al.  A comparison of methods used to enumerate Escherichia coli in conventionally treated sewage sludge , 2004, Journal of applied microbiology.

[9]  E. Rice,et al.  Comparison of Escherichia coli, Total Coliform, and Fecal Coliform Populations as Indicators of Wastewater Treatment Efficiency , 1999 .

[10]  C. R. Fricker,et al.  Use of two formulations of Colilert and QuantiTray™ for assessment of the bacteriological quality of water , 1997 .

[11]  G. Ripabelli,et al.  Enumeration of Escherichia coli and coliforms in surface water by multiple tube fermentation and membrane filter methods. , 2000, Microbios.

[12]  S. Edberg,et al.  Advances in the bacteriology of the coliform group: their suitability as markers of microbial water safety. , 2001, Annual review of microbiology.

[13]  Alexander Goetz,et al.  Application of Molecular Filter Membranes to the Bacteriological Analysis of Water , 1951 .

[14]  D. Strong,et al.  Modification of M-FC medium by eliminating rosolic acid , 1978, Applied and environmental microbiology.

[15]  Liv Fiksdal,et al.  Enzyme Characteristics of β-d-Galactosidase- and β-d-Glucuronidase-Positive Bacteria and Their Interference in Rapid Methods for Detection of Waterborne Coliforms andEscherichia coli , 1998, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[16]  M. Pommepuy,et al.  Monitoring of fecal pollution in coastal waters by use of rapid enzymatic techniques , 1994, Applied and environmental microbiology.

[17]  K. Schiff,et al.  A Regional Survey of the Microbiological Water Quality along the Shoreline of the Southern California Bight , 2000 .

[18]  D. Mossel.  Marker (index and indicator) organisms in food and drinking water. Semantics, ecology, taxonomy and enumeration , 2004, Antonie van Leeuwenhoek.

[19]  K. Venkateswaran,et al.  Comparison of a fluorogenic assay with a conventional method for rapid detection of Vibrio parahaemolyticus in seafoods , 1996, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[20]  J. Snow.  On the Mode of Communication of Cholera , 1856, Edinburgh medical journal.

[21]  R. Darner,et al.  Comparison of methods for determining Escherichia coli concentrations in recreational waters , 2000 .

[22]  L. W. Leiter.  THE EIJKMAN FERMENTATION TEST AS AN AID IN THE DETECTION OF FECAL ORGANISMS IN WATER , 1929 .

[23]  V. Cabelli,et al.  Membrane filter method for enumerating Escherichia coli , 1981, Applied and environmental microbiology.

[24]  W Litsky,et al.  Improved membrane filter method for fecal coliform analysis. , 1975, Applied microbiology.

[25]  Edwin E. Geldreich,et al.  Fecal‐Coliform‐Organism Medium for the Membrane Filter Technique , 1965 .

[26]  P. Bremer,et al.  Evaluation of the effectiveness of a commercially available defined substrate medium and enumeration system for measuring Escherichia coli numbers in faeces and soil samples * , 2004, Letters in applied microbiology.

[27]  E. Rice,et al.  Evaluation of beta-glucuronidase assay for the detection of Escherichia coli from environmental waters. , 1991, Canadian journal of microbiology.

[28]  D. B. Smith,et al.  Defined substrate technology method for rapid and specific simultaneous enumeration of total coliforms and Escherichia coli from water: collaborative study. , 1991, Journal - Association of Official Analytical Chemists.

[29]  D. B. Smith,et al.  National field evaluation of a defined substrate method for the simultaneous enumeration of total coliforms and Escherichia coli from drinking water: comparison with the standard multiple tube fermentation method , 1988, Applied and environmental microbiology.

[30]  S. Apte,et al.  Plant and algal interference in bacterial beta-D-galactosidase and beta-D-glucuronidase assays , 1994, Applied and environmental microbiology.

[31]  G A McFeters,et al.  Chlorine injury and the comparative performance of Colisure (TM), ColiLert (TM) and ColiQuik (TM) for the enumeration of coliform bacteria and E.coli in drinking water. , 1993, Water science and technology : a journal of the International Association on Water Pollution Research.

[32]  Eugene W. Rice,et al.  Comparing Defined- Substrate Coliform Tests for the Detection of Escherichia coli in Water , 1992 .

[33]  M. Levin,et al.  Membrane filter technique for enumeration of enterococci in marine waters. , 1975, Applied microbiology.

[34]  Y. Hara-Kudo,et al.  Improved Method for Detection of Vibrio parahaemolyticus in Seafood , 2001, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[35]  Karl F. Eckner,et al.  Comparison of Membrane Filtration and Multiple-Tube Fermentation by the Colilert and Enterolert Methods for Detection of Waterborne Coliform Bacteria, Escherichia coli, and Enterococci Used in Drinking and Bathing Water Quality Monitoring in Southern Sweden , 1998, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[36]  J. Messer,et al.  A Rapid, Specific Membrane Filtration Procedure for Enumeration of Enterococci in Recreational Water , 1998, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[37]  W. Chao,et al.  Suitability of the traditional microbial indicators and their enumerating methods in the assessment of fecal pollution of subtropical freshwater environments. , 2003, Journal of microbiology, immunology, and infection = Wei mian yu gan ran za zhi.

[38]  M. Blažina,et al.  Evaluation of Colilert and Enterolert Defined Substrate Methodology for Wastewater Applications , 2002, Water environment research : a research publication of the Water Environment Federation.

[39]  John M. Pisciotta,et al.  Marine Bacteria Cause False-Positive Results in the Colilert-18 Rapid Identification Test for Escherichia coli in Florida Waters , 2002, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.