Routine scale and polish for periodontal health in adults.

BACKGROUND Many dentists or hygienists provide scaling and polishing for patients at regular intervals, even if those patients are considered to be at low risk of developing periodontal disease. There is debate over the clinical effectiveness and cost effectiveness of 'routine scaling and polishing' and the 'optimal' frequency at which it should be provided. OBJECTIVES The main objectives were: to determine the beneficial and harmful effects of routine scaling and polishing for periodontal health; to determine the beneficial and harmful effects of providing routine scaling and polishing at different time intervals on periodontal health; to compare the effects of routine scaling and polishing provided by a dentist or professionals complementary to dentistry (PCD) (dental therapists or dental hygienists) on periodontal health. SEARCH STRATEGY We searched the Cochrane Oral Health Group Trials Register, the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL), MEDLINE and EMBASE. Reference lists from relevant articles were scanned and the authors of eligible studies were contacted where possible to identify trials and obtain additional information. Date of most recent searches: 5th March 2007. SELECTION CRITERIA Trials were selected if they met the following criteria: design - random allocation of participants; participants - anyone with an erupted permanent dentition who were judged to have received a 'routine scale and polish' (as defined in this review); interventions - 'routine scale and polish' (as defined in this review) and routine scale and polish provided at different time intervals; outcomes - tooth loss, plaque, calculus, gingivitis, bleeding and periodontal indices, changes in probing depth, attachment change, patient-centred outcomes and economic outcomes. DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS Information regarding methods, participants, interventions, outcome measures and results were independently extracted, in duplicate, by two review authors. Authors were contacted where possible and where deemed necessary for further details regarding study design and for data clarification. A quality assessment of all included trials was carried out. The Cochrane Collaboration's statistical guidelines were followed and both standardised mean differences and mean differences were calculated as appropriate using random-effects models. MAIN RESULTS Nine studies were included in this review. All studies were assessed as having a high risk of bias.Two split-mouth studies provided data for the comparison between scale and polish versus no scale and polish. One study, involving patients attending a recall programme following periodontal treatment, found no statistically significant differences for plaque, gingivitis and attachment loss between experimental and control units at each time point during the 1 year trial. The other study, involving adolescents in a developing country with high existing levels of calculus who had not received any dental treatment for at least 5 years, reported statistically significant differences in calculus and gingivitis (bleeding) scores between treatment and control units at 6, 12 and 22 months (in favour of 'scale and polish units') following a single scale and polish provided at baseline to treatment units. For comparisons between routine scale and polish provided at different time intervals, there were some statistically significant differences in favour of scaling and polishing provided at more frequent intervals: 2 weeks versus 6 months, 2 weeks versus 12 months (for the outcomes plaque, gingivitis, pocket depth and attachment change); 3 months versus 12 months (for the outcomes plaque, calculus and gingivitis). There were no studies comparing the effects of scaling and polishing provided by dentists or professionals complementary to dentistry. AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS The research evidence is of insufficient quality to reach any conclusions regarding the beneficial and adverse effects of routine scaling and polishing for periodontal health and regarding the effects of providing this intervention at different time intervals. High quality clinical trials are required to address the basic questions posed in this review.

[1]  H V Worthington,et al.  Recall intervals for oral health in primary care patients. , 2005, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews.

[2]  C. McGrath,et al.  Impact of oral health on the life quality of periodontal patients. , 2004, Journal of clinical periodontology.

[3]  D. Locker,et al.  Assessing the responsiveness of measures of oral health-related quality of life. , 2004, Community dentistry and oral epidemiology.

[4]  H. Worthington,et al.  A systematic review of guided tissue regeneration for periodontal infrabony defects. , 2002, Journal of periodontal research.

[5]  A. Sheiham,et al.  Periodontal diseases in Europe. , 2002, Periodontology 2000.

[6]  J. Albandar Global risk factors and risk indicators for periodontal diseases. , 2002, Periodontology 2000.

[7]  E. Lo,et al.  Periodontal diseases in Asia and Oceania. , 2002, Periodontology 2000.

[8]  W. Bowen,et al.  Preventive dentistry: practitioners' recommendations for low-risk patients compared with scientific evidence and practice guidelines. , 2000, American journal of preventive medicine.

[9]  G. Smith,et al.  Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test , 1997, BMJ.

[10]  G. Greenstein Periodontal response to mechanical non-surgical therapy: a review. , 1992, Journal of periodontology.

[11]  P Axelsson,et al.  On the prevention of caries and periodontal disease. Results of a 15-year longitudinal study in adults. , 1991, Journal of clinical periodontology.

[12]  P. Papapanou,et al.  A model for decision making regarding periodontal treatment needs. , 1990, Journal of clinical periodontology.

[13]  S. Socransky,et al.  Periodontal loser sites in untreated adult subjects. , 1989, Journal of clinical periodontology.

[14]  P. Axelsson,et al.  A 30-month Longitudinal Study of the Effects of Some Oral Hygiene Measures on Streptococcus mutans and Approximal Dental Caries , 1987, Journal of dental research.

[15]  B. Wade Changes in periodontal health in a cohort of British workers over a 14-year period' , 1986, British Dental Journal.

[16]  P. Cormier,et al.  The rural dental health program: the effect of a school-based, dental health education program on children's utilization of dental services. , 1983, American journal of public health.

[17]  P. Axelsson,et al.  The significance of maintenance care in the treatment of periodontal disease. , 1981, Journal of clinical periodontology.

[18]  P Axelsson,et al.  Effect of controlled oral hygiene procedures on caries and periodontal disease in adults. , 1978, Journal of clinical periodontology.

[19]  P. Axelsson,et al.  The Effect of a Plaque Control Program on Gingivitis and Dental Caries in Schoolchildren , 1977, Journal of dental research.

[20]  P. Axelsson,et al.  Effect of fluoride on gingivitis and dental caries in a preventive program based on plaque control. , 1975, Community dentistry and oral epidemiology.

[21]  P. Axelsson,et al.  The effect of a preventive programme on dental plaque, gingivitis and caries in schoolchildren. Results after one and two years. , 1974, Journal of clinical periodontology.

[22]  H Löe,et al.  The Gingival Index, the Plaque Index and the Retention Index Systems. , 1967, Journal of periodontology.

[23]  M. Oxford The Examination System , 1920, Nature.

[24]  Burke Fjt Gingivitis as a risk factor in periodontal disease , 2009, BDJ.

[25]  H. Schünemann [GRADE: from grading the evidence to developing recommendations. A description of the system and a proposal regarding the transferability of the results of clinical research to clinical practice]. , 2009, Zeitschrift fur Evidenz, Fortbildung und Qualitat im Gesundheitswesen.

[26]  K. Lohr,et al.  Effectiveness of antimicrobial adjuncts to scaling and root-planing therapy for periodontitis. , 2004, Evidence report/technology assessment.

[27]  R. Anderson,et al.  Effective oral health promotion: literature review , 1996 .

[28]  B. Eley,et al.  The prevention of periodontal disease. , 1989, Dental update.

[29]  F. R. Ketron Periodontal screening examination. , 1984, The Journal of the Tennessee Dental Association.

[30]  A. Sheiham The prevention and control of periodontal disease. , 1979, Dental health.

[31]  Sigurd P. Ramfjord,et al.  Indices for Prevalence and Incidence of Periodontal Disease , 1959 .