An evaluation of likelihood-based bandwidth selectors for spatial and spatiotemporal kernel estimates

ABSTRACT Spatial point pattern data sets are commonplace in a variety of different research disciplines. The use of kernel methods to smooth such data is a flexible way to explore spatial trends and make inference about underlying processes without, or perhaps prior to, the design and fitting of more intricate semiparametric or parametric models to quantify specific effects. The long-standing issue of ‘optimal’ data-driven bandwidth selection is complicated in these settings by issues such as high heterogeneity in observed patterns and the need to consider edge correction factors. We scrutinize bandwidth selectors built on leave-one-out cross-validation approximation to likelihood functions. A key outcome relates to previously unconsidered adaptive smoothing regimens for spatiotemporal density and multitype conditional probability surface estimation, whereby we propose a novel simultaneous pilot-global selection strategy. Motivated by applications in epidemiology, the results of both simulated and real-world analyses suggest this strategy to be largely preferable to classical fixed-bandwidth estimation for such data.