Is there a u-shaped relationship between load levels and fatigue and recovery? An examination of possible mechanisms

In a previous study, an unexpected u-shaped relationship was observed between load level and fatigue/recovery responses. Moderate load levels resulted in lower perceived discomfort, pain, and fatigue, and shorter recovery times compared to either low or high load levels. This phenomenon has been reported in other studies, but no article has examined the possible mechanisms that might explain this u-shaped relationship. In this paper, we re-examined the previously published data and found that the phenomenon does not appear to be due to experimental artefact; the u-shape may be due to unexpectedly lower fatigue effects at moderate loads, and higher fatigue effects at lower loads. We then conducted a literature review and identified several possible physiological, perceptual, and biomechanical explanatory mechanisms. No single mechanism explains the entirety of the phenomenon. Further research is needed on the relationship between work exposures, fatigue, and recovery, and the mechanisms related to the u-shaped relationship.Practitioner's Summary: We examine a previously observed u-shaped relationship between load level and fatigue/recovery, where moderate force resulted in lower perceived fatigue and shorter recovery times. A u-shaped fatigue response suggests that simply minimising load levels might not be an optimal approach to reduce the risk of workplace injuries.

[1]  W P Neumann,et al.  A comparison of work-rest models using a “breakpoint” analysis raises questions , 2020, IISE transactions on occupational ergonomics and human factors.

[2]  Maury A. Nussbaum,et al.  Effects of exoskeleton design and precision requirements on physical demands and quality in a simulated overhead drilling task. , 2019, Applied ergonomics.

[3]  Svend Erik Mathiassen,et al.  Promoting health and physical capacity during productive work: the Goldilocks Principle. , 2018, Scandinavian journal of work, environment & health.

[4]  W. Neumann,et al.  Examining the fatigue-quality relationship in manufacturing. , 2019, Applied ergonomics.

[5]  Richard Wells,et al.  Production quality and human factors engineering: A systematic review and theoretical framework. , 2018, Applied ergonomics.

[6]  Homayoon Kazerooni,et al.  Evaluation of an adjustable support shoulder exoskeleton on static and dynamic overhead tasks , 2018, Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting.

[7]  C. Beauchemin,et al.  Modelling endurance and resumption times for repetitive one-hand pushing , 2018, Ergonomics.

[8]  R. Wells,et al.  Documenting the Temporal Pattern of Fatigue Development , 2017 .

[9]  Jim R. Potvin,et al.  A motor unit-based model of muscle fatigue , 2017, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[10]  Carrie R. H. Innes,et al.  Attention lapses and behavioural microsleeps during tracking, psychomotor vigilance, and dual tasks , 2016, Consciousness and Cognition.

[11]  W. Patrick Neumann,et al.  Integrating human factors into discrete event simulation: a proactive approach to simultaneously design for system performance and employees’ well being , 2016 .

[12]  Mohamad Y. Jaber,et al.  Production planning in DRC systems considering worker performance , 2015, Comput. Ind. Eng..

[13]  M. Bigliassi.  Corollary discharges and fatigue-related symptoms: the role of attentional focus , 2015, Front. Psychol..

[14]  Göran M Hägg,et al.  Fatigue and recovery during and after static loading , 2014, Ergonomics.

[15]  B. Pageaux.  The Psychobiological Model of Endurance Performance: An Effort-Based Decision-Making Theory to Explain Self-Paced Endurance Performance , 2014, Sports Medicine.

[16]  Sean Gallagher,et al.  Examining the Interaction of Force and Repetition on Musculoskeletal Disorder Risk , 2013, Hum. Factors.

[17]  S. Mathiassen,et al.  Motor variability in occupational health and performance. , 2012, Clinical biomechanics.

[18]  Ranjana K Mehta,et al.  Muscle- and task-dependent responses to concurrent physical and mental workload during intermittent static work , 2012, Ergonomics.

[19]  M. Amann.  Significance of Group III and IV muscle afferents for the endurance exercising human , 2012, Clinical and experimental pharmacology & physiology.

[20]  S. Mathiassen,et al.  Variation of force amplitude and its effects on local fatigue , 2012, European Journal of Applied Physiology.

[21]  Ranjana K. Mehta,et al.  Influence of mental workload on muscle endurance, fatigue, and recovery during intermittent static work , 2012, European Journal of Applied Physiology.

[22]  David E. Sherwood,et al.  Defining the Focus of Attention: Effects of Attention on Perceived Exertion and Fatigue , 2011, Front. Psychology.

[23]  Bo Hu,et al.  A novel approach for determining fatigue resistances of different muscle groups in static cases , 2011, ArXiv.

[24]  Adam Hamrol,et al.  Impact of selected work condition factors on quality of manual assembly process , 2011 .

[25]  S Boyas,et al.  Neuromuscular fatigue in healthy muscle: underlying factors and adaptation mechanisms. , 2011, Annals of physical and rehabilitation medicine.

[26]  T. Bosch,et al.  The effect of work pace on workload, motor variability and fatigue during simulated light assembly work , 2011, Ergonomics.

[27]  Håkan Westerblad,et al.  Skeletal muscle: energy metabolism, fiber types, fatigue and adaptability. , 2010, Experimental cell research.

[28]  B J Martin,et al.  Please Scroll down for Article Ergonomics Low Mean Level Sustained and Intermittent Grip Exertions: Influence of Age on Fatigue and Recovery Low Mean Level Sustained and Intermittent Grip Exertions: Influence of Age on Fatigue and Recovery , 2022 .

[29]  Clark R Dickerson,et al.  The effect of added degrees of freedom and handle type on upper limb muscle activity during simulated hand tool use , 2009, Ergonomics.

[30]  A. Booth,et al.  Unpacking your literature search toolbox: on search styles and tactics. , 2008, Health information and libraries journal.

[31]  J. Semmler,et al.  Low-frequency fatigue and neuromuscular performance after exercise-induced damage to elbow flexor muscles. , 2008, Journal of applied physiology.

[32]  M. McKenna,et al.  Fatigue Mechanisms Determining Exercise Performance Muscle K , Na , and Cl disturbances and Na-K pump inactivation : implications for fatigue , 2008 .

[33]  D. Allen,et al.  Skeletal muscle fatigue: cellular mechanisms. , 2008, Physiological reviews.

[34]  Svend Erik Mathiassen,et al.  Time--a key issue for musculoskeletal health and manufacturing. , 2007, Applied ergonomics.

[35]  Svend Erik Mathiassen,et al.  Diversity and variation in biomechanical exposure: what is it, and why would we like to know? , 2006, Applied ergonomics.

[36]  Bart Visser,et al.  Pathophysiology of upper extremity muscle disorders. , 2006, Journal of electromyography and kinesiology : official journal of the International Society of Electrophysiological Kinesiology.

[37]  F. Zijlstra,et al.  Job characteristics and off-job activities as predictors of need for recovery, well-being, and fatigue. , 2006, The Journal of applied psychology.

[38]  David G. Behm,et al.  Force maintenance with submaximal fatiguing contractions. , 2004, Canadian journal of applied physiology = Revue canadienne de physiologie appliquee.

[39]  T. Clanton,et al.  diaphragm: a new experimental model Tension-time index, fatigue, and energetics in isolated rat , 2013 .

[40]  D. Allen,et al.  Recent advances in the understanding of skeletal muscle fatigue. , 2002, Current opinion in rheumatology.

[41]  B. Martin,et al.  Vibration-induced muscle fatigue, a possible contribution to musculoskeletal injury , 2002, European Journal of Applied Physiology.

[42]  J. Duchateau,et al.  Motor unit behaviour and contractile changes during fatigue in the human first dorsal interosseus , 2001, The Journal of physiology.

[43]  Hans Forssberg,et al.  Human brain activity in the control of fine static precision grip forces: an fMRI study , 2001, The European journal of neuroscience.

[44]  K Saito,et al.  Measurement of fatigue in industries. , 1999, Industrial health.

[45]  Donald L. Fisher,et al.  Minimizing Fatigue during Repetitive Jobs: Optimal Work-Rest Schedules , 1997, Hum. Factors.

[46]  J Winkel,et al.  Guidelines for occupational musculoskeletal load as a basis for intervention: a critical review. , 1996, Applied ergonomics.

[47]  C Fransson-Hall,et al.  Acceptability of Intermittent Handgrip Contractions Based on Physiological Response , 1994, Human factors.

[48]  T. Armstrong,et al.  A conceptual model for work-related neck and upper-limb musculoskeletal disorders. , 1993, Scandinavian journal of work, environment & health.

[49]  C G Drury,et al.  An exponential model of isometric muscular fatigue as a function of age and muscle groups. , 1992, Ergonomics.

[50]  D G Stuart,et al.  Neurobiology of muscle fatigue. , 1992, Journal of applied physiology.

[51]  S. Lehman,et al.  Dantrolene sodium and fatigue of long duration , 1992, Muscle & nerve.

[52]  S E Mathiassen,et al.  Quantifying variation in physical load using exposure-vs-time data. , 1991, Ergonomics.

[53]  G Sjøgaard,et al.  Potassium homeostasis during and following exhaustive submaximal static handgrip contractions. , 1991, Acta physiologica Scandinavica.

[54]  D. Jones,et al.  Mechanical influences on long‐lasting human muscle fatigue and delayed‐onset pain. , 1989, The Journal of physiology.

[55]  M Wangenheim,et al.  A study stressing the need for a static postural force model for work analysis. , 1986, Ergonomics.

[56]  J. J. Woods,et al.  Excitation frequency and muscle fatigue: Electrical responses during human voluntary and stimulated contractions , 1979, Experimental Neurology.

[57]  R. Edwards.  Physiological analysis of skeletal muscle weakness and fatigue. , 1978, Clinical science and molecular medicine.

[58]  P A Merton,et al.  Fatigue of long duration in human skeletal muscle after exercise. , 1977, The Journal of physiology.

[59]  E. Henneman.  Relation between size of neurons and their susceptibility to discharge. , 1957, Science.