Optimal features for online seizure detection

This study identifies characteristic features in scalp EEG that simultaneously give the best discrimination between epileptic seizures and background EEG in minimally pre-processed scalp data; and have minimal computational complexity to be suitable for online, real-time analysis. The discriminative performance of 65 previously reported features has been evaluated in terms of sensitivity, specificity, area under the sensitivity–specificity curve (AUC), and relative computational complexity, on 47 seizures (split in 2,698 2 s sections) in over 172 h of scalp EEG from 24 adults. The best performing features are line length and relative power in the 12.5–25 Hz band. Relative power has a better seizure detection performance (AUC = 0.83; line length AUC = 0.77), but is calculated after the discrete wavelet transform and is thus more computationally complex. Hence, relative power achieves the best performance for offline detection, whilst line length would be preferable for online low complexity detection. These results, from the largest systematic study of seizure detection features, aid future researchers in selecting an optimal set of features when designing algorithms for both standard offline detection and new online low computational complexity detectors.

[1]  W. R. Adey,et al.  Contamination of scalp EEG spectrum during contraction of cranio-facial muscles. , 1974, Electroencephalography and clinical neurophysiology.

[2]  J. Gotman,et al.  Frequency content of EEG and EMG at seizure onset: possibility of removal of EMG artefact by digital filtering. , 1981, Electroencephalography and clinical neurophysiology.

[3]  M. Zweig,et al.  Receiver-operating characteristic (ROC) plots: a fundamental evaluation tool in clinical medicine. , 1993, Clinical chemistry.

[4]  G. Comi,et al.  IFCN standards for digital recording of clinical EEG. International Federation of Clinical Neurophysiology. , 1998, Electroencephalography and clinical neurophysiology.

[5]  J Gotman,et al.  Automatic detection of seizures and spikes. , 1999, Journal of clinical neurophysiology : official publication of the American Electroencephalographic Society.

[6]  D. Lowe,et al.  Using dynamical embedding to isolate seizure components in the ictal EEG , 2000 .

[7]  D. Lowe,et al.  Using independent component analysis & dynamical embedding to isolate seizure activity in the EEG , 2000, Proceedings of the 22nd Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society (Cat. No.00CH37143).

[8]  Kaspar Anton Schindler,et al.  Using simulated neuronal cell models for detection of epileptic seizures in foramen ovale and scalp EEG , 2001, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[9]  Richard D. Jones,et al.  Automated detection of epileptic seizures in the EEG , 2001, 2001 Conference Proceedings of the 23rd Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society.

[10]  M. Akay,et al.  Statistical Mapping of Scalp‐Recorded Ictal EEG Records Using Wavelet Analysis , 2003, Epilepsia.

[11]  Michael J. A. M. Van Putten,et al.  Nearest neighbor phase synchronization as a measure to detect seizure activity from scalp EEG recordings. , 2003 .

[12]  W. van Paesschen,et al.  Characterization of interictal and ictal scalp EEG signals with the Hilbert transform , 2003, Proceedings of the 25th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society (IEEE Cat. No.03CH37439).

[13]  J. Wolpaw,et al.  EMG contamination of EEG: spectral and topographical characteristics , 2003, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[14]  S. Cerutti,et al.  Analysis of multichannel EEG synchronization before and during generalized epileptic seizures , 2003, First International IEEE EMBS Conference on Neural Engineering, 2003. Conference Proceedings..

[15]  M. V. van Putten Nearest Neighbor Phase Synchronization as a Measure to Detect Seizure Activity from Scalp EEG Recordings , 2003, Journal of clinical neurophysiology : official publication of the American Electroencephalographic Society.

[16]  S. Sanei,et al.  Support vector machines for seizure detection , 2003, Proceedings of the 3rd IEEE International Symposium on Signal Processing and Information Technology (IEEE Cat. No.03EX795).

[17]  Abdulhamit Subasi,et al.  Neural Networks with Periodogram and Autoregressive Spectral Analysis Methods in Detection of Epileptic Seizure , 2004, Journal of Medical Systems.

[18]  Scott B. Wilson,et al.  Seizure detection: evaluation of the Reveal algorithm , 2004, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[19]  M. Ursino,et al.  A wavelet based analysis of energy redistribution in scalp EEG during epileptic seizures , 2004, The 26th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society.

[20]  C.J. James,et al.  Stepwise model order estimation in blind source separation applied to ictal EEG , 2004, The 26th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society.

[21]  L. Shoker,et al.  Detection and localization of epileptic seizures using ICA , 2004, Processing Workshop Proceedings, 2004 Sensor Array and Multichannel Signal.

[22]  Ahmet Alkan,et al.  Comparison of AR and Welch Methods in Epileptic Seizure Detection , 2006, Journal of Medical Systems.

[23]  A. Chandrakasan,et al.  A 180-mV subthreshold FFT processor using a minimum energy design methodology , 2005, IEEE Journal of Solid-State Circuits.

[24]  Abdulhamit Subasi,et al.  Epileptic seizure detection using dynamic wavelet network , 2005, Expert Syst. Appl..

[25]  Ahmet Alkan,et al.  Automatic seizure detection in EEG using logistic regression and artificial neural network , 2005, Journal of Neuroscience Methods.

[26]  S. Osowski,et al.  Lyapunov exponent of EEG signal for epileptic seizure characterization , 2005, Proceedings of the 2005 European Conference on Circuit Theory and Design, 2005..

[27]  C.J. James,et al.  Tracking Epileptiform Activity in the Multichannel Ictal EEG using Spatially Constrained Independent Component Analysis , 2005, 2005 IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology 27th Annual Conference.

[28]  V. Lagerburg,et al.  Detecting temporal lobe seizures from scalp EEG recordings: A comparison of various features , 2005, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[29]  C.J. James,et al.  On the use of Spectrally Constrained ICA applied to single-channel Ictal EEG recordings within a Dynamical Embedding Framework , 2005, 2005 IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology 27th Annual Conference.

[30]  W. van Paesschen,et al.  A new muscle artifact removal technique to improve the interpretation of the ictal scalp electroencephalogram , 2005, 2005 IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology 27th Annual Conference.

[31]  I. Mareels,et al.  Patient Un-Specific Detection of Epileptic Seizures Through Changes in Variance , 2006, 2006 International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society.

[32]  C. Stam,et al.  Seizure detection in adult ICU patients based on changes in EEG synchronization likelihood , 2006, Neurocritical care.

[33]  Abdulhamit Subasi Automatic detection of epileptic seizure using dynamic fuzzy neural networks , 2006, Expert Syst. Appl..

[34]  Jian Wang,et al.  Automatic Seizure Detection Based on Support Vector Machines with Genetic Algorithms , 2006, SEAL.

[35]  L. Tarassenko,et al.  Linear and non-linear methods for automatic seizure detection in scalp electro-encephalogram recordings , 2002, Medical and Biological Engineering and Computing.

[36]  Abdulhamit Subasi,et al.  Comparison of subspace-based methods with AR parametric methods in epileptic seizure detection , 2006, Comput. Biol. Medicine.

[37]  C. W. Hesse,et al.  Tracking and detection of epileptiform activity in multichannel ictal EEG using signal subspace correlation of seizure source scalp topographies , 2006, Medical & Biological Engineering & Computing.

[38]  Hamid Reza Mohseni,et al.  Epileptic Seizure Detection Using Neural Fuzzy Networks , 2006, 2006 IEEE International Conference on Fuzzy Systems.

[39]  Javad Hashemi,et al.  Automatic detection of epileptic seizure using time-frequency distributions , 2006 .

[40]  Scott B. Wilson Algorithm architectures for patient dependent seizure detection , 2006, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[41]  François G. Meyer,et al.  Nonlinear classification of EEG data for seizure detection , 2006, 3rd IEEE International Symposium on Biomedical Imaging: Nano to Macro, 2006..

[42]  Mohammad B. Shamsollahi,et al.  Seizure Detection in EEG signals: A Comparison of Different approaches , 2006, 2006 International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society.

[43]  Wim Van Paesschen,et al.  Canonical Correlation Analysis Applied to Remove Muscle Artifacts From the Electroencephalogram , 2006, IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering.

[44]  Hojjat Adeli,et al.  A Wavelet-Chaos Methodology for Analysis of EEGs and EEG Subbands to Detect Seizure and Epilepsy , 2007, IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering.

[45]  H. Stefan,et al.  An efficient, robust and fast method for the offline detection of epileptic seizures in long-term scalp EEG recordings , 2007, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[46]  Dimitrios I. Fotiadis,et al.  A Time-Frequency Based Method for the Detection of Epileptic Seizures in EEG Recordings , 2007, Twentieth IEEE International Symposium on Computer-Based Medical Systems (CBMS'07).

[47]  W. van Paesschen,et al.  Improving the Interpretation of Ictal Scalp EEG: BSS–CCA Algorithm for Muscle Artifact Removal , 2007, Epilepsia.

[48]  E. Acar,et al.  Seizure Recognition on Epilepsy Feature Tensor , 2007, 2007 29th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society.

[49]  D. Gupta,et al.  Narrowband vs. Broadband Phase Synchronization Analysis Applied to Independent Components of Ictal and Interictal EEG , 2007, 2007 29th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society.

[50]  Fabrice Wendling,et al.  Extraction of reproducible seizure patterns based on EEG scalp correlations , 2007, Biomed. Signal Process. Control..

[51]  Wouter A. Serdijn,et al.  A ultra low power CMOS pA/V transconductor and its application to wavelet filters , 2007, SBCCI '07.

[52]  Saeid Sanei,et al.  Seizure signals separation using constrained topographic blind source separation , 2007, 2007 15th European Signal Processing Conference.

[53]  Awais M. Kamboh,et al.  Area-Power Efficient VLSI Implementation of Multichannel DWT for Data Compression in Implantable Neuroprosthetics , 2007, IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Circuits and Systems.

[54]  Hojjat Adeli,et al.  Mixed-Band Wavelet-Chaos-Neural Network Methodology for Epilepsy and Epileptic Seizure Detection , 2007, IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering.

[55]  D.I. Fotiadis,et al.  The Use of Time-Frequency Distributions for Epileptic Seizure Detection in EEG Recordings , 2007, 2007 29th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society.

[56]  E. John,et al.  Automatic Identification of Spike-Wave Events and Non-Convulsive Seizures with a Reduced Set of Electrodes , 2007, 2007 29th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society.

[57]  Abdulhamit Subasi,et al.  Application of adaptive neuro-fuzzy inference system for epileptic seizure detection using wavelet feature extraction , 2007, Comput. Biol. Medicine.

[58]  G. Dumont,et al.  Electroconvulsive Therapy: A Model for Seizure Detection by a Wavelet Packet Algorithm , 2007, 2007 29th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society.

[59]  S. Sisodiya Etiology and management of refractory epilepsies , 2007, Nature Clinical Practice Neurology.

[60]  I. Mareels,et al.  A Complete Strategy for Patient Un-specific Detection of Epileptic Seizures Using Crude Estimations of Entropy , 2007, 2007 29th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society.

[61]  Yi-gang He,et al.  Detection of Cardiac Signal Characteristic Point Using Log-Domain Wavelet Transform Circuits , 2008 .

[62]  G. Lightbody,et al.  A comparison of quantitative EEG features for neonatal seizure detection , 2008, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[63]  Ye Yuan,et al.  Automated Detection of Epileptic Seizure Using Artificial Neural Network , 2008, 2008 2nd International Conference on Bioinformatics and Biomedical Engineering.

[64]  B.V. Vahdat,et al.  Epileptic Seizure Detection using AR Model on EEG Signals , 2008, 2008 Cairo International Biomedical Engineering Conference.

[65]  A. Aertsen,et al.  Detecting Epileptic Seizures in Long-term Human EEG: A New Approach to Automatic Online and Real-Time Detection and Classification of Polymorphic Seizure Patterns , 2008, Journal of clinical neurophysiology : official publication of the American Electroencephalographic Society.

[66]  I.M.Y. Mareels,et al.  Correlation analysis of seizure detection features , 2008, 2008 International Conference on Intelligent Sensors, Sensor Networks and Information Processing.

[67]  Hojjat Adeli,et al.  Principal Component Analysis-Enhanced Cosine Radial Basis Function Neural Network for Robust Epilepsy and Seizure Detection , 2008, IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering.

[68]  Reza Tafreshi,et al.  A novel wavelet-based index to detect epileptic seizures using scalp EEG signals , 2008, 2008 30th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society.

[69]  Ram Bilas Pachori,et al.  Discrimination between Ictal and Seizure-Free EEG Signals Using Empirical Mode Decomposition , 2008, J. Electr. Comput. Eng..

[70]  N. Sriraam,et al.  Automated detection of epileptic seizures using wavelet entropy feature with recurrent neural network classifier , 2008, TENCON 2008 - 2008 IEEE Region 10 Conference.

[71]  Yodchanan Wongsawat Epileptic seizure detection in EEG recordings using phase congruency , 2008, 2008 30th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society.

[72]  Hojjat Adeli,et al.  A new supervised learning algorithm for multiple spiking neural networks with application in epilepsy and seizure detection , 2009, Neural Networks.

[73]  H. Khamis,et al.  Seizure state detection of temporal lobe seizures by autoregressive spectral analysis of scalp EEG , 2009, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[74]  Dimitrios I. Fotiadis,et al.  Epileptic Seizure Detection in EEGs Using Time–Frequency Analysis , 2009, IEEE Transactions on Information Technology in Biomedicine.

[75]  Christopher J. James,et al.  On spatio-temporal component selection in space-time independent component analysis: An application to ictal EEG , 2009, 2009 Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society.

[76]  Catherine Stamoulis,et al.  Application of matched-filtering to extract EEG features and decouple signal contributions from multiple seizure foci in brain malformations , 2009, 2009 4th International IEEE/EMBS Conference on Neural Engineering.

[77]  S. Kara,et al.  Log Energy Entropy-Based EEG Classification with Multilayer Neural Networks in Seizure , 2009, Annals of Biomedical Engineering.

[78]  Yüksel Özbay,et al.  A new approach for epileptic seizure detection using adaptive neural network , 2009, Expert Syst. Appl..

[79]  Clodoaldo Ap. M. Lima,et al.  Automatic recognition of epileptic seizure in EEG via support vector machine and dimension fractal , 2009, 2009 International Joint Conference on Neural Networks.

[80]  Abibullaev Berdakh,et al.  Epileptic Seizures Detection Using Continuous Time Wavelet Based Artificial Neural Networks , 2009, 2009 Sixth International Conference on Information Technology: New Generations.

[81]  R. Lesser Epilepsy: Does continuous EEG monitoring improve seizure control? , 2009, Nature Reviews Neurology.

[82]  Stephen Faul,et al.  Age-independent seizure detection , 2009, 2009 Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society.

[83]  Hee Don Seo,et al.  Seizure Detection in Temporal Lobe Epileptic EEGs Using the Best Basis Wavelet Functions , 2010, Journal of Medical Systems.

[84]  David B. Grayden,et al.  Seizure Detection Using Seizure Probability Estimation: Comparison of Features Used to Detect Seizures , 2009, Annals of Biomedical Engineering.

[85]  Malek Adjouadi,et al.  Seizure Detection: An Assessment of Time- and Frequency-Based Features in a Unified Two-Dimensional Decisional Space Using Nonlinear Decision Functions , 2009, Journal of clinical neurophysiology : official publication of the American Electroencephalographic Society.

[86]  R. Harner,et al.  Patient-Specific Early Seizure Detection From Scalp Electroencephalogram , 2010, Journal of clinical neurophysiology : official publication of the American Electroencephalographic Society.

[87]  Ahmad Mirzaei,et al.  Spectral Entropy for Epileptic Seizures Detection , 2010, 2010 2nd International Conference on Computational Intelligence, Communication Systems and Networks.

[88]  Pedro P. Irazoqui,et al.  A hardware-algorithm co-design approach to optimize seizure detection algorithms for implantable applications , 2010, Journal of Neuroscience Methods.

[89]  Ravishankar K. Iyer,et al.  An efficient embedded hardware for high accuracy detection of epileptic seizures , 2010, 2010 3rd International Conference on Biomedical Engineering and Informatics.

[90]  Sheng-Fu Liang,et al.  Combination of EEG Complexity and Spectral Analysis for Epilepsy Diagnosis and Seizure Detection , 2010, EURASIP J. Adv. Signal Process..

[91]  Sheng-Chih Yang,et al.  Epileptic seizure detection in grouped multi-channel EEG signal using ICA and wavelet transform , 2010, Proceedings of 2010 IEEE International Symposium on Circuits and Systems.

[92]  Anna T. Lawniczak,et al.  Feature extraction via dynamic PCA for epilepsy diagnosis and epileptic seizure detection , 2010, 2010 IEEE International Workshop on Machine Learning for Signal Processing.

[93]  Daniel Rivero,et al.  Epileptic seizure detection using multiwavelet transform based approximate entropy and artificial neural networks , 2010, Journal of Neuroscience Methods.

[94]  C. W. Hall,et al.  Mutual information in natural position order of electroencephalogram is significantly increased at seizure onset , 2011, Medical & Biological Engineering & Computing.

[95]  Ahmad Ayatollahi,et al.  EEG analysis based on wavelet-spectral entropy for epileptic seizures detection , 2010, 2010 3rd International Conference on Biomedical Engineering and Informatics.

[96]  Johannes J. Struijk,et al.  Early seizure detection in rats based on vagus nerve activity , 2011, Medical & Biological Engineering & Computing.

[97]  Esther Rodriguez-Villegas,et al.  Wearable Electroencephalography , 2010, IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Magazine.

[98]  Deng-Shan Shiau,et al.  Signal regularity-based automated seizure detection system for scalp EEG monitoring , 2010, Cybernetics and systems analysis.

[99]  Pietro Liò,et al.  A new approach for epileptic seizure detection: sample entropy based feature extraction and extreme learning machine , 2010 .

[100]  L. Koessler,et al.  Influence of source separation and montage on ictal source localization , 2010, 2010 Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology.

[101]  Meng Tan,et al.  9. The optimization of 2-channel EEG for the detection of generalized and temporal seizures: A pilot study for EEG monitoring study in the intensive care unit (CU) , 2010, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[102]  Sung-Nien Yu,et al.  Detection of seizures in EEG using subband nonlinear parameters and genetic algorithm , 2010, Comput. Biol. Medicine.

[103]  Francisco Sales,et al.  Ontology and Knowledge Management System on Epilepsy and Epileptic Seizures , 2010, SWAT4LS.

[104]  William P. Marnane,et al.  Ambulatory REACT: Real-time seizure detection with a DSP microprocessor , 2010, 2010 Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology.

[105]  Daniel Rivero,et al.  Automatic epileptic seizure detection in EEGs based on line length feature and artificial neural networks , 2010, Journal of Neuroscience Methods.

[106]  Omar Farooq,et al.  Automatic Seizure Detection Using Higher Order Moments , 2010, 2010 International Conference on Recent Trends in Information, Telecommunication and Computing.

[107]  Yajun Ha,et al.  Ultra Storage-Efficient Time Digitizer for Pseudorandom Single Photon Counter Implemented on a Field-Programmable Gate Array , 2010, IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Circuits and Systems.

[108]  Natarajan Sriraam,et al.  Entropies based detection of epileptic seizures with artificial neural network classifiers , 2010, Expert Syst. Appl..

[109]  I. Karakis,et al.  A Quick and Reliable EEG Montage for the Detection of Seizures in the Critical Care Setting , 2010, Journal of clinical neurophysiology : official publication of the American Electroencephalographic Society.

[110]  R. Panda,et al.  Classification of EEG signals for epileptic seizure evaluation , 2010, 2010 IEEE Students Technology Symposium (TechSym).

[111]  Reza Tafreshi,et al.  Automated Real-Time Epileptic Seizure Detection in Scalp EEG Recordings Using an Algorithm Based on Wavelet Packet Transform , 2010, IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering.

[112]  K. M. Kelly,et al.  Assessment of a scalp EEG-based automated seizure detection system , 2010, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[113]  Cristian Guarnizo Lemus,et al.  EEG single-channel seizure recognition using Empirical Mode Decomposition and normalized mutual information , 2010, IEEE 10th INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON SIGNAL PROCESSING PROCEEDINGS.

[114]  R. E. Madsen,et al.  Automatic seizure detection: going from sEEG to iEEG , 2010, 2010 Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology.

[115]  Naveen Verma,et al.  A Micro-Power EEG Acquisition SoC With Integrated Feature Extraction Processor for a Chronic Seizure Detection System , 2010, IEEE Journal of Solid-State Circuits.

[116]  Ahmad Reza Naghsh-Nilchi,et al.  Epilepsy seizure detection using eigen-system spectral estimation and Multiple Layer Perceptron neural network , 2010, Biomed. Signal Process. Control..

[117]  Carlos Guerrero-Mosquera,et al.  New feature extraction approach for epileptic EEG signal detection using time-frequency distributions , 2010, Medical & Biological Engineering & Computing.

[118]  M. Pooyan,et al.  Classification of EEG signals in four groups, including healthy subjects with open/closed eyes and epilepsy subjects with/without seizure by PSD estimate (using the multitaper method) and ANN , 2010, 2010 5th International Symposium on Health Informatics and Bioinformatics.

[119]  Ye Yuan,et al.  Detection of epileptic seizure based on EEG signals , 2010, 2010 3rd International Congress on Image and Signal Processing.

[120]  Hyunchul Kim,et al.  Epileptic seizure detection - an AR model based algorithm for implantable device , 2010, 2010 Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology.

[121]  Faisal Abdurabu Mubarak Binjadhnan,et al.  EEG signals during epileptic seizure as a semigroup of upper triangular matrices , 2010 .

[122]  Esther Rodríguez-Villegas,et al.  A 60 pW g$_{m}$C Continuous Wavelet Transform Circuit for Portable EEG Systems , 2011, IEEE Journal of Solid-State Circuits.

[123]  Hillel J. Chiel,et al.  Ultra-Low-Power and Robust Digital-Signal-Processing Hardware for Implantable Neural Interface Microsystems , 2011, IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Circuits and Systems.

[124]  R. Badawy,et al.  A blinded comparison of continuous versus sampled review of video-EEG monitoring data , 2011, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[125]  Mohamad Z. Koubeissi,et al.  Inpatient video-EEG monitoring: How much shall we review? , 2011, Clinical Neurophysiology.