Design and analysis issues in cluster-randomized trials of interventions against infectious diseases

This paper discusses the application of the cluster-randomized trial (CRT) design to evaluate the effectiveness of interventions against infectious diseases. In addition to the usual rationale for this design, there are a number of other advantages that are peculiar to the study of infectious diseases. In particular, CRTs are able to measure the overall effect of an intervention at the population level, capturing both the direct effect of an intervention on an individual's susceptibility to infection, and also the indirect effects due to changes in risks of transmission to other individuals, or to the mass effect or `herd immunity' resulting from intervening in a large proportion of the population. We briefly review published CRTs of interventions against infectious diseases, most of which have been conducted in the developing countries where such diseases predominate. The focus is on trials in which communities or other large groupings are randomized, and in which impacts on infectious disease incidence or mortality are assessed. We then discuss three issues that are of special relevance to CRTs of infectious diseases. First, issues relating to the definition and size of clusters; secondly, the role of matching or stratification, and the choice of matching factors; and thirdly, the definition of direct and indirect effects of intervention, and methods of assessing these components in a CRT. We conclude by outlining some areas for future research.

[1]  R. Anderson,et al.  The concept of herd immunity and the design of community-based immunization programmes. , 1992, Vaccine.

[2]  T. Freeman,et al.  Illness after measles-mumps-rubella vaccination. , 1993, CMAJ : Canadian Medical Association journal = journal de l'Association medicale canadienne.

[3]  J. Hatcher,et al.  Randomised controlled trial of treatment of chronic suppurative otitis media in Kenyan schoolchildren , 1996, The Lancet.

[4]  M E Halloran,et al.  Direct and indirect effects in vaccine efficacy and effectiveness. , 1991, American journal of epidemiology.

[5]  M E Halloran,et al.  Study designs for evaluating different efficacy and effectiveness aspects of vaccines. , 1997, American journal of epidemiology.

[6]  J. Mcghee,et al.  Progress towards a vaccine to prevent sexual transmission of HIV , 1996, Nature Medicine.

[7]  S. Yerly,et al.  Transmission of antiretroviral-drug-resistant HIV-1 variants , 1999, The Lancet.

[8]  P E Fine,et al.  Herd immunity: history, theory, practice. , 1993, Epidemiologic reviews.

[9]  R. Hayes,et al.  Control of sexually transmitted diseases for HIV-1 prevention: understanding the implications of the Mwanza and Rakai trials , 2000, The Lancet.

[10]  U. d’Alessandro,et al.  Nationwide survey of bednet use in rural Gambia. , 1994, Bulletin of the World Health Organization.

[11]  A. Sommer,et al.  IMPACT OF VITAMIN A SUPPLEMENTATION ON CHILDHOOD MORTALITY A Randomised Controlled Community Trial , 1986, The Lancet.

[12]  R. May,et al.  Directly transmitted infections diseases: control by vaccination. , 1982, Science.

[13]  M. Joffres,et al.  Reduced measles immunity in infants in a well-vaccinated population. , 1992, The Pediatric infectious disease journal.

[14]  P Diehr,et al.  Breaking the matches in a paired t-test for community interventions when the number of pairs is small. , 1995, Statistics in medicine.

[15]  R. Snow,et al.  Insecticide‐treated bednets reduce mortality and severe morbidity from malaria among children on the Kenyan coast , 1996, Tropical medicine & international health : TM & IH.

[16]  M. Halloran,et al.  Design and interpretation of vaccine field studies. , 1999, Epidemiologic reviews.

[17]  Alan D. Lopez,et al.  Mortality by cause for eight regions of the world: Global Burden of Disease Study , 1997, The Lancet.

[18]  A Donner,et al.  A methodological review of non-therapeutic intervention trials employing cluster randomization, 1979-1989. , 1990, International journal of epidemiology.

[19]  J. Meuwissen.  Current studies related to the development of transmission-blocking malaria vaccines: a review. , 1989, Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene.

[20]  A Donner,et al.  Methods for comparing event rates in intervention studies when the unit of allocation is a cluster. , 1994, American journal of epidemiology.

[21]  M. C. Thomson,et al.  Mortality and morbidity from malaria in Gambian children after introduction of an impregnated bednet programme , 1995, The Lancet.

[22]  A. J. Hall,et al.  Preparation for a pneumococcal vaccine trial in The Gambia: individual or community randomisation? , 1999, Vaccine.

[23]  Ronald H Gray,et al.  Control of sexually transmitted diseases for AIDS prevention in Uganda: a randomised community trial , 1999, The Lancet.

[24]  Valérie Buthion,et al.  ColoNav: patient navigation for colorectal cancer screening in deprived areas – Study protocol , 1999, BMC Cancer.

[25]  M E Halloran,et al.  Augmented HIV vaccine trial design for estimating reduction in infectiousness and protective efficacy. , 1998, Statistics in medicine.

[26]  G Dreyer,et al.  Direct assessment of the adulticidal efficacy of a single dose of ivermectin in bancroftian filariasis. , 1995, Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene.

[27]  R. Anderson.  The pandemic of antibiotic resistance , 1999, Nature Medicine.

[28]  R. Snow,et al.  Averting a malaria disaster , 1999, The Lancet.

[29]  E. Magbity,et al.  A controlled trial of lambda-cyhalothrin-impregnated bed nets and/or dapsone/pyrimethamine for malaria control in Sierra Leone. , 1998, The American journal of tropical medicine and hygiene.

[30]  B. Kirkwood,et al.  Vitamin A supplementation in northern Ghana: effects on clinic attendances, hospital admissions, and child mortality , 1993, The Lancet.

[31]  R. Hayes.  Design of human immunodeficiency virus intervention trials in developing countries , 1998 .

[32]  B. Loevinsohn.  Health education interventions in developing countries: a methodological review of published articles. , 1990, International journal of epidemiology.

[33]  A. Sommer,et al.  Double blind, cluster randomised trial of low dose supplementation with vitamin A or βcarotene on mortality related to pregnancy in Nepal , 1999 .

[34]  P. Mäkelä,et al.  Vaccination with Haemophilus influenzae type b meningococcal protein conjugate vaccine reduces oropharyngeal carriage of Haemophilus influenzae type b among American Indian children , 1993, The Pediatric infectious disease journal.

[35]  J. Bouyer,et al.  Prevention of sexually transmitted diseases: a randomised community trial. , 1991, Journal of epidemiology and community health.

[36]  J. Clemens,et al.  An educational intervention for altering water-sanitation behaviors to reduce childhood diarrhea in urban Bangladesh. II. A randomized trial to assess the impact of the intervention on hygienic behaviors and rates of diarrhea. , 1987, American journal of epidemiology.

[37]  S. Cousens,et al.  Impact of fly control on childhood diarrhoea in Pakistan: community-randomised trial , 1999, The Lancet.

[38]  B. Greenwood,et al.  Evaluation of vaccines for the prevention of pneumonia in children in developing countries. , 1999, Epidemiologic reviews.

[39]  R. Snow,et al.  A trial of bed nets (mosquito nets) as a malaria control strategy in a rural area of The Gambia, West Africa. , 1988, Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene.

[40]  A. Sommer,et al.  Mortality of infants < 6 mo of age supplemented with vitamin A: a randomized, double-masked trial in Nepal. , 1995, The American journal of clinical nutrition.

[41]  W. Haskell,et al.  COMMUNITY EDUCATION FOR CARDIOVASCULAR HEALTH , 1977, The Lancet.

[42]  D. Fleming,et al.  From epidemiological synergy to public health policy and practice: the contribution of other sexually transmitted diseases to sexual transmission of HIV infection. , 1999, Sexually transmitted infections.

[43]  S. Cousens,et al.  Wide-scale installation of insecticide-treated curtains confers high levels of protection against malaria transmission in a hyperendemic area of Burkina Faso. , 1999, Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene.

[44]  Allan Donner,et al.  Cluster randomization trials in epidemiology: theory and application , 1994 .

[45]  C. Broome,et al.  Diphtheria in the United States, 1971-81. , 1985, American journal of public health.

[46]  P G Smith,et al.  Assessment of the protective efficacy of vaccines against common diseases using case-control and cohort studies. , 1984, International journal of epidemiology.

[47]  A. Nicoll,et al.  A community trial of the impact of improved sexually transmitted disease treatment on the HIV epidemic in rural Tanzania: 1. Design , 1995, AIDS.

[48]  A. Halstensen,et al.  Effect of outer membrane vesicle vaccine against group B meningococcal disease in Norway , 1991, The Lancet.

[49]  M E Halloran,et al.  Optimal vaccine trial design when estimating vaccine efficacy for susceptibility and infectiousness from multiple populations. , 1998, Statistics in medicine.

[50]  M E Halloran,et al.  Study designs for dependent happenings. , 1991, Epidemiology.

[51]  B. Munoz,et al.  Impact of face-washing on trachoma in Kongwa, Tanzania , 1995, The Lancet.

[52]  J. Katz,et al.  Efficacy of vitamin A in reducing preschool child mortality in Nepal , 1991, The Lancet.

[53]  Chris Newbold,et al.  Relation between severe malaria morbidity in children and level of Plasmodium falciparum transmission in Africa , 1997, The Lancet.

[54]  Estimation of the direct and indirect effects of vaccination. , 1999, Statistics in medicine.

[55]  G. Comstock.  Uncontolled ruminations on modern controlled trials. , 1978, American journal of epidemiology.

[56]  T D Koepsell,et al.  The effect of matching on the power of randomized community intervention studies. , 1993, Statistics in medicine.

[57]  J. Todd,et al.  Impact of improved treatment of sexually transmitted diseases on HIV infection in rural Tanzania: randomised controlled trial , 1995, The Lancet.

[58]  C. Curtis,et al.  Anti-sporozoite immunity and impregnated bednets in Tanzanian villages. , 1998, Annals of Tropical Medicine and Parasitology.

[59]  A Donner,et al.  The merits of matching in community intervention trials: a cautionary tale. , 1997, Statistics in medicine.

[60]  R. May.  Vaccination programmes and herd immunity , 1982, Nature.

[61]  M. Alpers,et al.  Mass treatment with ivermectin for filariasis control in Papua New Guinea: impact on mosquito survival , 1999, Medical and veterinary entomology.

[62]  C. Lengeler,et al.  Impact of permethrin impregnated bednets on child mortality in Kassena‐Nankana district, Ghana: a randomized controlled trial , 1996, Tropical medicine & international health : TM & IH.

[63]  B. Kirkwood,et al.  Community-based hygiene education to reduce diarrhoeal disease in rural Zaire: impact of the intervention on diarrhoeal morbidity. , 1994, International journal of epidemiology.

[64]  P. Smith,et al.  Measles incidence, case fatality, and delayed mortality in children with or without vitamin A supplementation in rural Ghana. , 1997, American journal of epidemiology.

[65]  Lowe,et al.  A community randomized controlled trial of insecticide‐treated bednets for the prevention of malaria and anaemia among primigravid women on the Kenyan coast , 1998, Tropical medicine & international health : TM & IH.

[66]  B T Grenfell,et al.  Oscillatory fluctuations in the incidence of infectious disease and the impact of vaccination: time series analysis , 1984, Journal of Hygiene.

[67]  J. Simpson,et al.  Accounting for cluster randomization: a review of primary prevention trials, 1990 through 1993. , 1995, American journal of public health.

[68]  S. Thompson.  Letter to the Editor: The merits of matching in community intervention trials: a cautionary tale by N. Klar and A. Donner, Statistics in Medicine, 16, 1753–1764 (1997) , 1998 .

[69]  M. Alpers,et al.  Randomised community-based trial of annual single-dose diethylcarbamazine with or without ivermectin against Wuchereria bancrofti infection in human beings and mosquitoes , 1998, The Lancet.

[70]  C. Lengeler,et al.  Do insecticide‐treated curtains reduce all‐cause child mortality in Burkina Faso? , 1997, Tropical medicine & international health : TM & IH.

[71]  D. Carlson,et al.  A community-based randomized trial of home-made oral rehydration therapies. , 1993, International journal of epidemiology.

[72]  R. Snow,et al.  Permethrin-treated bed nets (mosquito nets) prevent malaria in Gambian children. , 1988, Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene.

[73]  B. Greenwood,et al.  The microepidemiology of malaria and its importance to malaria control. , 1989, Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene.