Organ Donation, Brain Death and the Family: Valid Informed Consent

In July 2013, parents in Ohio objected to their 21-year-old son becoming an organ donor. Elijah Smith was involved in an accident and pronounced dead using neurological criteria. The organ procurement organization (OPO) went to court and argued that because the young man was brain dead and because his driver's license indicated that he wished to be a donor, the court should allow them to use his organs. The mother argued that her son did not understand what he was signing when he signed his license and that his signature did not reflect an informed decision. The court disagreed with her, saying that he had indicated a wish to donate his organs and that no one but Elijah could revoke that wish. His organs were removed. Elijah's mother suspected that he did not understand what he was signing. She might have been right, given what we know about the process for obtaining permission for organ donation and the limited public understanding of brain death.

[1]  M. Potts,et al.  The ethics of limiting informed debate: censorship of select medical publications in the interest of organ transplantation. , 2013, The Journal of medicine and philosophy.

[2]  Michael Nair-Collins.  Brain Death, Paternalism, and the Language of “Death” , 2013, Kennedy Institute of Ethics journal.

[3]  Daniel E. Hall,et al.  Informed consent for clinical treatment , 2012, Canadian Medical Association Journal.

[4]  J. Duff,et al.  A survey of American neurologists about brain death: understanding the conceptual basis and diagnostic tests for brain death , 2012, Annals of Intensive Care.

[5]  Evan Selinger,et al.  Nudge, Nudge or Shove, Shove—The Right Way for Nudges to Increase the Supply of Donated Cadaver Organs , 2012, The American journal of bioethics : AJOB.

[6]  T. Beauchamp.  Informed Consent: Its History, Meaning, and Present Challenges , 2011, Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics.

[7]  Seema K. Shah,et al.  Death and legal fictions , 2011, Journal of Medical Ethics.

[8]  V. Falk,et al.  NICE guidance for off-pump CABG: turn off the pump , 2011, Heart.

[9]  S. Rivkees.  Pediatric Graves’ Disease: Controversies in Management , 2010, Hormone Research in Paediatrics.

[10]  B. Gersh,et al.  Five-Year Follow-Up of a Randomized Comparison Between Off-Pump and On-Pump Stable Multivessel Coronary Artery Bypass Grafting. The MASS III Trial , 2010, Circulation.

[11]  J. DuBois.  The ethics of creating and responding to doubts about death criteria. , 2010, The Journal of medicine and philosophy.

[12]  Seema K. Shah,et al.  Can We Handle the Truth? Legal Fictions in the Determination of Death , 2010, American Journal of Law & Medicine.

[13]  A. Waterman,et al.  Is Rapid Organ Recovery a Good Idea? An Exploratory Study of the Public's Knowledge and Attitudes , 2009, American journal of transplantation : official journal of the American Society of Transplantation and the American Society of Transplant Surgeons.

[14]  J. Verheijde,et al.  Brain death, states of impaired consciousness, and physician-assisted death for end-of-life organ donation and transplantation , 2009, Medicine, health care, and philosophy.

[15]  D. Shewmon,et al.  Brain Death: Can It Be Resuscitated? , 2009, Issues in law & medicine.

[16]  A. Iltis,et al.  Organ donation, patients’ rights, and medical responsibilities at the end of life* , 2009, Critical care medicine.

[17]  P. Helft,et al.  Brain Death Revisited: The Case for a National Standard , 2008, Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics.

[18]  R. Howard,et al.  The Instability of Organ Donation Decisions by Next‐of‐Kin and Factors That Predict It , 2008, American journal of transplantation : official journal of the American Society of Transplantation and the American Society of Transplant Surgeons.

[19]  M. Sque,et al.  What does a diagnosis of brain death mean to family members approached about organ donation? A review of the literature. , 2008, Progress in transplantation.

[20]  R. Truog.  Consent for organ donation--balancing conflicting ethical obligations. , 2008, The New England journal of medicine.

[21]  E. Hannan,et al.  Off-Pump Versus On-Pump Coronary Artery Bypass Graft Surgery: Differences in Short-Term Outcomes and in Long-Term Mortality and Need for Subsequent Revascularization , 2007, Circulation.

[22]  R. Truog.  Brain Death — Too Flawed to Endure, Too Ingrained to Abandon , 2007, Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics.

[23]  J. Verheijde,et al.  Organ procurement organizations Internet enrollment for organ donation: Abandoning informed consent , 2006, BMC medical ethics.

[24]  T. Bellali,et al.  Parental Grief Following the Brain Death of a Child: Does Consent or Refusal to Organ Donation Affect Their Grief? , 2006, Death studies.

[25]  J. Fisk,et al.  Report of the Board of Directors , 2006 .

[26]  Sheldon Zink,et al.  A study of the presumptive approach to consent for organ donation: a new solution to an old problem. , 2006, Critical care nurse.

[27]  J. Bernat.  The Whole-Brain Concept of Death Remains Optimum Public Policy , 2006, Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics.

[28]  E. Anderson,et al.  Attitudes toward death criteria and organ donation among healthcare personnel and the general public. , 2006, Progress in transplantation.

[29]  L. Siminoff,et al.  Death and organ procurement: public beliefs and attitudes. , 2004, Social science & medicine.

[30]  M. Lock.  Living Cadavers and the Calculation of Death , 2004 .

[31]  Laurence B McCullough,et al.  A Typology of Shared Decision Making, Informed Consent, and Simple Consent , 2004, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[32]  S. Youngner.  Some Must Die , 2003 .

[33]  R. Arnold,et al.  Families' understanding of brain death. , 2003, Progress in transplantation.

[34]  H. Draper,et al.  Modified mandated choice for organ procurement , 2003, Journal of medical ethics.

[35]  O. O’neill,et al.  Some limits of informed consent , 2003, Journal of medical ethics.

[36]  R. Veatch.  The foundations of bioethics. , 1999, Bioethics.

[37]  D. Shewmon,et al.  Spinal shock and `brain death': Somatic pathophysiological equivalence and implications for the integrative-unity rationale , 1999, Spinal Cord.

[38]  T. Burroughs,et al.  The Stability of Family Decisions to Consent or Refuse Organ Donation: Would You Do It Again , 1998, Psychosomatic medicine.

[39]  Lippincott Williams Wilkins.  Practice parameters for determining brain death in adults , 1995, Neurology.

[40]  P. Bazeley,et al.  A Survey of Families of Brain Dead Patients: Their Experiences, Attitudes to Organ Donation and Transplantation , 1995, Anaesthesia and intensive care.

[41]  D. Sapsford,et al.  Haemodynamic responses to surgery in brain‐dead organ donors , 1994, Anaesthesia.

[42]  C. Hoffman.  Rationing Americaʼs Medical Care: The Oregon Plan and Beyond , 1993 .

[43]  B. Brody,et al.  Brain Death: Reconciling Definitions, Criteria, and Tests , 1993, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[44]  R. Veatch.  The impending collapse of the whole-brain definition of death. , 1993, The Hastings Center report.

[45]  S. Youngner,et al.  Defining death. A superficial and fragile consensus. , 1992, Archives of neurology.

[46]  J. Bernat.  How Much of the Brain Must Die in Brain Death? , 1992, The Journal of Clinical Ethics.

[47]  F. Della Corte,et al.  Do brainstem auditory evoked potentials detect the actual cessation of cerebral functions in brain dead patients? , 1990, Critical care medicine.

[48]  P. Catalano,et al.  MATERNAL BRAIN DEATH AND PROLONGED FETAL SURVIVAL , 1989, Obstetrics and gynecology.

[49]  S. Alahuhta,et al.  Nutrition during ten-week life support with successful fetal outcome in a case with fatal maternal brain damage. , 1989, JPEN. Journal of parenteral and enteral nutrition.

[50]  C. Coulton,et al.  'Brain death' and organ retrieval. A cross-sectional survey of knowledge and concepts among health professionals. , 1989, JAMA.

[51]  K. Arita,et al.  [Hypothalamic pituitary function in brain death patients--from blood pituitary hormones and hypothalamic hormones]. , 1988, No shinkei geka. Neurological surgery.

[52]  A. Jonsen,et al.  Maternal brain death during pregnancy. Medical and ethical issues. , 1988, JAMA.

[53]  G G Celesia,et al.  Electroencephalographic activity after brain death. , 1987, Archives of neurology.

[54]  D. Fiser,et al.  Diabetes insipidus in children with brain death , 1987, Critical care medicine.

[55]  E. Rodin,et al.  Brainstem Death , 1985, Clinical EEG.

[56]  M. C. Rogers,et al.  Hemodynamic Responses in Brain Dead Organ Donor Patients , 1985, Anesthesia and analgesia.

[57]  M. Rockoff,et al.  Diabetes insipidus accompanying brain death in children , 1984, Neurology.

[58]  J. Drane.  Competency to give an informed consent. A model for making clinical assessments. , 1984, JAMA.

[59]  W. Dillon,et al.  Life Support and Maternal Brain Death During Pregnancy , 1982 .

[60]  M. Jastremski,et al.  Cessation of therapy in terminal illness and brain death , 1978, Critical care medicine.

[61]  E. Deliyannakis,et al.  Brain Stem Death with Persistence of Bioelectric Activity of the Cerebral Hemispheres , 1975 .

[62]  L. Kass,et al.  Statutory Definition of the Standards for Determining Human Death: An Appraisal and a Proposal , 1972 .

[63]  J. Bernat.  The definition and criterion of death. , 2013, Handbook of clinical neurology.

[64]  D. Shaw,et al.  Persuading bereaved families to permit organ donation , 2013, Intensive Care Medicine.

[65]  A. Vincent,et al.  Consent for organ donation. , 2012, British journal of anaesthesia.

[66]  V. Rajput.  Is Rapid Organ Recovery a Good Idea? An Exploratory Study of the Public's Knowledge and Attitudes , 2011 .

[67]  Arrow Buttons.  Frequently asked questions , 2009 .

[68]  M. Sque,et al.  Why relatives do not donate organs for transplants: 'sacrifice' or 'gift of life'? , 2008, Journal of advanced nursing.

[69]  H. Takagi,et al.  Off-pump coronary artery bypass sacrifices graft patency: meta-analysis of randomized trials. , 2007, The Journal of thoracic and cardiovascular surgery.

[70]  A. Joffe.  The neurological determination of death: what does it really mean? , 2007, Issues in law & medicine.

[71]  H. Schrader,et al.  Changes of pituitary hormones in brain death , 2005, Acta Neurochirurgica.

[72]  J. Laffey,et al.  Maternal brain death and somatic support , 2005, Neurocritical care.

[73]  R. Veatch.  The death of whole-brain death: the plague of the disaggregators, somaticists, and mentalists. , 2005, The Journal of medicine and philosophy.

[74]  M. Hohenegger,et al.  Serum vasopressin (AVP) levels in polyuric brain-dead organ donors , 2005, European archives of psychiatry and neurological sciences.

[75]  S. Holtkamp.  Wrapped in mourning : the gift of life and organ donor family trauma , 2002 .

[76]  R. Arnold,et al.  Philosophical debates about the definition of death: who cares? , 2001, The Journal of medicine and philosophy.

[77]  D. Shewmon,et al.  The brain and somatic integration: insights into the standard biological rationale for equating "brain death" with death. , 2001, The Journal of medicine and philosophy.

[78]  E. Wijdicks,et al.  Chronic "brain death": meta-analysis and conceptual consequences. , 1999, Neurology.

[79]  D. Shewmon,et al.  "Brainstem death," "brain death" and death: a critical re-evaluation of the purported equivalence. , 1998, Issues in law & medicine.

[80]  R. Taylor,et al.  Reexamining the Definition and Criteria of Death , 1997, Seminars in neurology.

[81]  T. Bodenheimer.  The Oregon Health Plan--lessons for the nation. First of two parts. , 1997, The New England journal of medicine.

[82]  G. F. Judisch,et al.  Informed Consent. Legal Theory and Clinical Practice , 1988 .

[83]  L. Kass,et al.  A Statutory Definition of the Standards for Determining Human Death , 1979 .

[84]  M. Goulon,et al.  Le coma dépassé. , 1971 .