Benchmarking confound regression strategies for the control of motion artifact in studies of functional connectivity

Since initial reports regarding the impact of motion artifact on measures of functional connectivity, there has been a proliferation of confound regression methods to limit its impact. However, recent techniques have not been systematically evaluated using consistent outcome measures. Here, we provide a systematic evaluation of 12 commonly used confound regression methods in 193 young adults. Specifically, we compare methods according to three benchmarks, including the residual relationship between motion and connectivity, distance-dependent effects of motion on connectivity, and additional degrees of freedom lost in confound regression. Our results delineate two clear trade-offs among methods. First, methods that include global signal regression minimize the relationship between connectivity and motion, but unmask distance-dependent artifact. In contrast, censoring methods mitigate both motion artifact and distance-dependence, but use additional degrees of freedom. Taken together, these results emphasize the heterogeneous efficacy of proposed methods, and suggest that different confound regression strategies may be appropriate in the context of specific scientific goals.

[1]  Beatriz Luna,et al.  The nuisance of nuisance regression: Spectral misspecification in a common approach to resting-state fMRI preprocessing reintroduces noise and obscures functional connectivity , 2013, NeuroImage.

[2]  M. Fox,et al.  Spontaneous fluctuations in brain activity observed with functional magnetic resonance imaging , 2007, Nature Reviews Neuroscience.

[3]  Thomas E. Nichols,et al.  Functional connectomics from resting-state fMRI , 2013, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[4]  Jonathan D. Power,et al.  Recent progress and outstanding issues in motion correction in resting state fMRI , 2015, NeuroImage.

[5]  Noah D. Brenowitz,et al.  Integrated strategy for improving functional connectivity mapping using multiecho fMRI , 2013, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[6]  Kathleen R. Merikangas,et al.  Prevalence and Treatment of Mental Disorders Among US Children in the 2001–2004 NHANES , 2010, Pediatrics.

[7]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Movement‐Related effects in fMRI time‐series , 1996, Magnetic resonance in medicine.

[8]  Hang Joon Jo,et al.  Effective Preprocessing Procedures Virtually Eliminate Distance-Dependent Motion Artifacts in Resting State FMRI , 2013, J. Appl. Math..

[9]  B. Leventhal,et al.  Unraveling the Miswired Connectome: A Developmental Perspective , 2014, Neuron.

[10]  Vince D. Calhoun,et al.  Save the Global: Global Signal Connectivity as a Tool for Studying Clinical Populations with Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging , 2014, Brain Connect..

[11]  B T Thomas Yeo,et al.  Disruption of cortical association networks in schizophrenia and psychotic bipolar disorder. , 2014, JAMA psychiatry.

[12]  Wen-Ming Luh,et al.  Differentiating BOLD and non-BOLD signals in fMRI time series using multi-echo EPI , 2012, NeuroImage.

[13]  Yufeng Zang,et al.  Standardizing the intrinsic brain: Towards robust measurement of inter-individual variation in 1000 functional connectomes , 2013, NeuroImage.

[14]  Yong He,et al.  BrainNet Viewer: A Network Visualization Tool for Human Brain Connectomics , 2013, PloS one.

[15]  Archana Venkataraman,et al.  Intrinsic functional connectivity as a tool for human connectomics: theory, properties, and optimization. , 2010, Journal of neurophysiology.

[16]  D. Hu,et al.  Neurobiological basis of head motion in brain imaging , 2014, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[17]  Evan M. Gordon,et al.  Functional System and Areal Organization of a Highly Sampled Individual Human Brain , 2015, Neuron.

[18]  R W Cox,et al.  AFNI: software for analysis and visualization of functional magnetic resonance neuroimages. , 1996, Computers and biomedical research, an international journal.

[19]  Brian B. Avants,et al.  N4ITK: Improved N3 Bias Correction , 2010, IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging.

[20]  Simon B. Eickhoff,et al.  An improved framework for confound regression and filtering for control of motion artifact in the preprocessing of resting-state functional connectivity data , 2013, NeuroImage.

[21]  Dost Öngür,et al.  Anticorrelations in resting state networks without global signal regression , 2012, NeuroImage.

[22]  Michael W. Cole,et al.  Altered global brain signal in schizophrenia , 2014, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[23]  Alberto Llera,et al.  ICA-AROMA: A robust ICA-based strategy for removing motion artifacts from fMRI data , 2015, NeuroImage.

[24]  Jonathan D. Power,et al.  Studying Brain Organization via Spontaneous fMRI Signal , 2014, Neuron.

[25]  M. Fox,et al.  The global signal and observed anticorrelated resting state brain networks. , 2009, Journal of neurophysiology.

[26]  Arno Klein,et al.  Evaluation of 14 nonlinear deformation algorithms applied to human brain MRI registration , 2009, NeuroImage.

[27]  Christos Davatzikos,et al.  Neuroimaging of the Philadelphia Neurodevelopmental Cohort , 2014, NeuroImage.

[28]  Yu Cao,et al.  Multi-atlas Segmentation with Learning-Based Label Fusion , 2014, MLMI.

[29]  Bing Chen,et al.  An open science resource for establishing reliability and reproducibility in functional connectomics , 2014, Scientific Data.

[30]  Mary Beth Nebel,et al.  Reduction of motion-related artifacts in resting state fMRI using aCompCor , 2014, NeuroImage.

[31]  S. Petersen,et al.  The maturing architecture of the brain's default network , 2008, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[32]  Mark A. Elliott,et al.  Impact of in-scanner head motion on multiple measures of functional connectivity: Relevance for studies of neurodevelopment in youth , 2012, NeuroImage.

[33]  Kevin Murphy,et al.  The impact of global signal regression on resting state correlations: Are anti-correlated networks introduced? , 2009, NeuroImage.

[34]  Timothy O. Laumann,et al.  Methods to detect, characterize, and remove motion artifact in resting state fMRI , 2014, NeuroImage.

[35]  Mark A. Elliott,et al.  The Philadelphia Neurodevelopmental Cohort: A publicly available resource for the study of normal and abnormal brain development in youth , 2016, NeuroImage.

[36]  R. Cameron Craddock,et al.  A comprehensive assessment of regional variation in the impact of head micromovements on functional connectomics , 2013, NeuroImage.

[37]  Maurizio Corbetta,et al.  The human brain is intrinsically organized into dynamic, anticorrelated functional networks. , 2005, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[38]  Yong He,et al.  Addressing head motion dependencies for small-world topologies in functional connectomics , 2013, Front. Hum. Neurosci..

[39]  Stephen M. Smith,et al.  Multiplexed Echo Planar Imaging for Sub-Second Whole Brain FMRI and Fast Diffusion Imaging , 2010, PloS one.

[40]  Jonathan D. Power,et al.  Prediction of Individual Brain Maturity Using fMRI , 2010, Science.

[41]  Timothy O. Laumann,et al.  Functional Network Organization of the Human Brain , 2011, Neuron.

[42]  Thomas T. Liu,et al.  A component based noise correction method (CompCor) for BOLD and perfusion based fMRI , 2007, NeuroImage.

[43]  Kevin Murphy,et al.  Removing motion and physiological artifacts from intrinsic BOLD fluctuations using short echo data , 2013, NeuroImage.

[44]  Kevin Murphy,et al.  Is fMRI “noise” really noise? Resting state nuisance regressors remove variance with network structure , 2015, NeuroImage.

[45]  Abraham Z. Snyder,et al.  Spurious but systematic correlations in functional connectivity MRI networks arise from subject motion , 2012, NeuroImage.

[46]  Timothy O. Laumann,et al.  Generation and Evaluation of a Cortical Area Parcellation from Resting-State Correlations. , 2016, Cerebral cortex.

[47]  Maarten Mennes,et al.  Evaluation of ICA-AROMA and alternative strategies for motion artifact removal in resting state fMRI , 2015, NeuroImage.

[48]  Hang Joon Jo,et al.  Trouble at Rest: How Correlation Patterns and Group Differences Become Distorted After Global Signal Regression , 2012, Brain Connect..

[49]  Keith Heberlein,et al.  Imaging human connectomes at the macroscale , 2013, Nature Methods.

[50]  Rajesh Kumar,et al.  A method for removal of global effects from fMRI time series , 2004, NeuroImage.

[51]  John Suckling,et al.  A wavelet method for modeling and despiking motion artifacts from resting-state fMRI time series , 2014, NeuroImage.

[52]  Mert R. Sabuncu,et al.  The influence of head motion on intrinsic functional connectivity MRI , 2012, NeuroImage.

[53]  Bruce Fischl,et al.  Accurate and robust brain image alignment using boundary-based registration , 2009, NeuroImage.

[54]  Swathi P. Iyer,et al.  Distinct neural signatures detected for ADHD subtypes after controlling for micro-movements in resting state functional connectivity MRI data , 2012, Front. Syst. Neurosci..

[55]  Ludovica Griffanti,et al.  Automatic denoising of functional MRI data: Combining independent component analysis and hierarchical fusion of classifiers , 2014, NeuroImage.

[56]  Steen Moeller,et al.  ICA-based artefact removal and accelerated fMRI acquisition for improved resting state network imaging , 2014, NeuroImage.

[57]  D. Schacter,et al.  The Brain's Default Network , 2008, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[58]  B. Biswal,et al.  Functional connectivity in the motor cortex of resting human brain using echo‐planar mri , 1995, Magnetic resonance in medicine.

[59]  Brian B. Avants,et al.  An Open Source Multivariate Framework for n-Tissue Segmentation with Evaluation on Public Data , 2011, Neuroinformatics.

[60]  Arno Klein,et al.  Large-scale evaluation of ANTs and FreeSurfer cortical thickness measurements , 2014, NeuroImage.

[61]  Arno Klein,et al.  A reproducible evaluation of ANTs similarity metric performance in brain image registration , 2011, NeuroImage.

[62]  Stephen M. Smith,et al.  Investigations into resting-state connectivity using independent component analysis , 2005, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[63]  Marisa O. Hollinshead,et al.  The organization of the human cerebral cortex estimated by intrinsic functional connectivity. , 2011, Journal of neurophysiology.

[64]  Michael Brady,et al.  Improved Optimization for the Robust and Accurate Linear Registration and Motion Correction of Brain Images , 2002, NeuroImage.

[65]  S. Rombouts,et al.  Consistent resting-state networks across healthy subjects , 2006, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[66]  Hang Joon Jo,et al.  The perils of global signal regression for group comparisons: a case study of Autism Spectrum Disorders , 2013, Front. Hum. Neurosci..