Refinement in the European Union: A Systematic Review

Simple Summary More than 10 years have passed since the publication of Directive 2010/63/EU on the protection of animals used for scientific purposes based on replacement, reduction, and refinement (3Rs). These principles state that if animals have to be used in experiments, researchers should make every effort to replace them with non-sentient alternatives, reduce them to a minimum, and refine experiments and housing conditions so as to cause the minimum possible pain and distress. In this systematic review, we aimed to identify and summarize published advances in the refinement protocols made by European Union-based research groups from 2011 to 2021, and to determine whether or not said research was financially supported. Our results indicated that the majority of advances were related to improvements in experimental procedures for mice, and the research groups were mostly from universities and the United Kingdom. More than two thirds of the studies received financial support, mostly national. There is a clear willingness in the scientific community to improve the welfare of laboratory animals. However, we believe that more progress in refinement would have been made during these years if there had been more specific financial support available at both the national and European Union levels. Abstract Refining experiments and housing conditions so as to cause the minimum possible pain and distress is one of the three principles (3Rs) on which Directive 2010/63/EU is based. In this systematic review, we aimed to identify and summarize published advances in the refinement protocols made by European Union-based research groups from 2011 to 2021, and to determine whether or not said research was supported by European or national grants. We included 48 articles, the majority of which were related to improvements in experimental procedures (37/77.1%) for mice (26/54.2%) and were written by research groups belonging to universities (36/57.1%) and from the United Kingdom (21/33.9%). More than two thirds (35/72.9%) of the studies received financial support, 26 (mostly British) at a national level and 8 at a European level. Our results indicated a clear willingness among the scientific community to improve the welfare of laboratory animals, as although funding was not always available or was not specifically granted for this purpose, studies were published nonetheless. However, in addition to institutional support based on legislation, more financial support is needed. We believe that more progress would have been made in refinement during these years if there had been more specific financial support available at both the national and European Union levels since our data suggest that countries investing in refinement have the greatest productivity in successfully publishing refinements.

[1]  R. Sánchez-Pernaute,et al.  Mice in translational neuroscience: What R we doing? , 2022, Progress in Neurobiology.

[2]  G. Azkona,et al.  A survey on the use of mice, pigs, dogs and monkeys as animal models in biomedical research in Spain , 2022, Laboratory animal research.

[3]  J. Bartek,et al.  An efficient, non-invasive approach for in-vivo sampling of hair follicles: design and applications in monitoring DNA damage and aging , 2021, Aging.

[4]  K. Baumgartner,et al.  Comparison of Two Different Feather Sampling Methods to Measure Corticosterone in Wild Greater Flamingos (Phoenicopterus roseus) and Wild Mallards (Anas platyrhynchos) , 2021, Animals : an open access journal from MDPI.

[5]  A. Richter,et al.  The software defined implantable modular platform (STELLA) for preclinical deep brain stimulation research in rodents , 2021, Journal of neural engineering.

[6]  O. Vegas,et al.  Professional Quality of Life in Research Involving Laboratory Animals , 2021, Animals : an open access journal from MDPI.

[7]  G. Azkona,et al.  Working with laboratory rodents in Spain: a survey on welfare and wellbeing , 2021, Laboratory animal research.

[8]  A. Bestin,et al.  Sex identification in immature Eurasian perch ( Perca fluviatilis ) using ultrasonography , 2021, Aquaculture Research.

[9]  P. Hedenqvist,et al.  Training Pigs for Oral Glucose Tolerance Test—Six Years’ Experience of a Refined Model , 2021, Animals : an open access journal from MDPI.

[10]  S. Killen,et al.  Identification of Individual Zebrafish (Danio rerio): A Refined Protocol for VIE Tagging Whilst Considering Animal Welfare and the Principles of the 3Rs , 2021, Animals : an open access journal from MDPI.

[11]  G. Azkona,et al.  Postweaning Grouping as a Strategy to Reduce Singly Housed Male Mice , 2020, Animals : an open access journal from MDPI.

[12]  R. Palme,et al.  Impact of three commonly used blood sampling techniques on the welfare of laboratory mice: Taking the animal’s perspective , 2020, PloS one.

[13]  M. Vogt,et al.  The ‘Cage Climber’ - A new enrichment for use in large-dimensioned mouse facilities , 2020, Applied Animal Behaviour Science.

[14]  R. Palme,et al.  Social enrichment by separated pair housing of male C57BL/6JRj mice , 2020, Scientific Reports.

[15]  Rowland R. Sillito,et al.  Temporal dissociation of phencyclidine: Induced locomotor and social alterations in rats using an automated homecage monitoring system – implications for the 3Rs and preclinical drug discovery , 2020, Journal of psychopharmacology.

[16]  U. Meyer,et al.  Preclinical validation of the micropipette-guided drug administration (MDA) method in the maternal immune activation model of neurodevelopmental disorders , 2020, Brain, Behavior, and Immunity.

[17]  T. Johnson,et al.  Refining the unilateral ureteral obstruction mouse model: No sham, no shame , 2020, Laboratory animals.

[18]  N. Greene,et al.  Refinement of inducible gene deletion in embryos of pregnant mice , 2019, Birth defects research.

[19]  York Winter,et al.  Automated radial 8-arm maze: A voluntary and stress-free behavior test to assess spatial learning and memory in mice , 2019, Behavioural Brain Research.

[20]  J. Roughan,et al.  A refinement approach in a mouse model of rehabilitation research. Analgesia strategy, reduction approach and infrared thermography in spinal cord injury , 2019, PloS one.

[21]  P. Flecknell,et al.  Opportunities for refinement in neuroscience: Indicators of wellness and post-operative pain in laboratory macaques. , 2019, ALTEX.

[22]  N. Kostomitsopoulos,et al.  A Noninvasive Ocular (Tear) Sampling Method for Genetic Ascertainment of Transgenic Mice and Research Ethics Innovation. , 2019, Omics : a journal of integrative biology.

[23]  U. Klose,et al.  Enhanced Central Neural Gain Compensates Acoustic Trauma-induced Cochlear Impairment, but Unlikely Correlates with Tinnitus and Hyperacusis , 2019, Neuroscience.

[24]  G. Azkona,et al.  Implementing strategies to reduce singly housed male mice , 2019, Laboratory animals.

[25]  Anna S. Mitchell,et al.  Effective chair training methods for neuroscience research involving rhesus macaques (Macaca mulatta) , 2019, Journal of Neuroscience Methods.

[26]  J. Palarea‐Albaladejo,et al.  A novel, high-welfare methodology for evaluating poultry red mite interventions in vivo. , 2019, Veterinary parasitology.

[27]  Jan Baumgart,et al.  Environmental enrichment prevents pup mortality in laboratory mice , 2019, Laboratory animals.

[28]  A. Ott,et al.  Comparison of pre-emptive butorphanol or metamizole with ketamine +medetomidine and s-ketamine + medetomidine anaesthesia in improving intraoperative analgesia in mice , 2018, Laboratory animals.

[29]  A. Bleich,et al.  Running in the wheel: Defining individual severity levels in mice , 2018, PLoS biology.

[30]  P. Dayan,et al.  Assessing animal affect: an automated and self-initiated judgement bias task based on natural investigative behaviour , 2018, Scientific Reports.

[31]  V. Kersemans,et al.  Refinement of in vivo optical imaging: Development of a real-time respiration monitoring system , 2018, Laboratory animals.

[32]  G. Wegener,et al.  Syringe-feeding as a novel delivery method for accurate individual dosing of probiotics in rats. , 2017, Beneficial microbes.

[33]  P. Flecknell,et al.  Minimally invasive technique for intrathecal administration of morphine in rats: practicality and antinociceptive properties , 2017, Laboratory animals.

[34]  Y. Açil,et al.  Longitudinal micro-computed tomography monitoring of progressive liver regeneration in a mouse model of partial hepatectomy , 2017, Laboratory animals.

[35]  H. Hagberg,et al.  Continual conscious bioluminescent imaging in freely moving somatotransgenic mice , 2017, Scientific Reports.

[36]  A. Thiele,et al.  The use of preferred social stimuli as rewards for rhesus macaques in behavioural neuroscience , 2017, PloS one.

[37]  P. Sandøe,et al.  Protecting Animals and Enabling Research in the European Union: An Overview of Development and Implementation of Directive 2010/63/EU. , 2017, ILAR journal.

[38]  Jan Baumgart,et al.  Introducing Clicker Training as a Cognitive Enrichment for Laboratory Mice. , 2017, Journal of visualized experiments : JoVE.

[39]  W. Norton,et al.  A Low-Cost Method of Skin Swabbing for the Collection of DNA Samples from Small Laboratory Fish , 2017, Zebrafish.

[40]  H. Ugail,et al.  The use of thermographic imaging to evaluate therapeutic response in human tumour xenograft models , 2016, Scientific Reports.

[41]  C. Meredith,et al.  Cigarette smoke induced genotoxicity and respiratory tract pathology: evidence to support reduced exposure time and animal numbers in tobacco product testing , 2016, Inhalation toxicology.

[42]  A. Hensel,et al.  The animal experimentation quandary: stuck between legislation and scientific freedom , 2016, EMBO reports.

[43]  J. Prins,et al.  Directive 2010/63/EU: facilitating full and correct implementation , 2016, Laboratory animals.

[44]  E. Robinson,et al.  Reducing the stress of drug administration: implications for the 3Rs , 2015, Scientific Reports.

[45]  K. Brown,et al.  An Extraperitoneal Technique for Murine Heterotopic Cardiac Transplantation , 2015, American journal of transplantation : official journal of the American Society of Transplantation and the American Society of Transplant Surgeons.

[46]  M. Graham,et al.  The multifactorial role of the 3Rs in shifting the harm-benefit analysis in animal models of disease , 2015, European journal of pharmacology.

[47]  A. Sirigu,et al.  Blood microsampling from the ear capillary in non-human primates , 2015, Laboratory Animals. Journal of the Laboratory Animal Science Association.

[48]  E. Liehn,et al.  Minimal Invasive Surgical Procedure of Inducing Myocardial Infarction in Mice , 2015, Journal of visualized experiments : JoVE.

[49]  H. Buchanan-Smith,et al.  Refining dosing by oral gavage in the dog: A protocol to harmonise welfare , 2015, Journal of pharmacological and toxicological methods.

[50]  A. Grierson,et al.  Early Detection of Motor Dysfunction in the SOD1G93A Mouse Model of Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS) Using Home Cage Running Wheels , 2014, PloS one.

[51]  Gonzalo Moreno Del Val,et al.  In vivo serial sampling of epididymal sperm in mice , 2013, Laboratory animals.

[52]  R. Deacon.  Shallow Water (Paddling) Variants of Water Maze Tests in Mice , 2013, Journal of visualized experiments : JoVE.

[53]  E. Törnqvist,et al.  Group housing of male CD1 mice: Reflections from toxicity studies , 2013, Laboratory animals.

[54]  K. Abelson,et al.  Voluntary ingestion of nut paste for administration of buprenorphine in rats and mice , 2012, Laboratory animals.

[55]  L. Furian,et al.  Refinement of a macaque transplantation model: application of a subcutaneous port as a means for long-term enteral drug administration and nutritional supplementation , 2012, Laboratory animals.

[56]  A. Schmid,et al.  Quantitative analysis of the growth kinetics of chemically induced mouse liver tumors by magnetic resonance imaging. , 2012, Toxicological sciences : an official journal of the Society of Toxicology.

[57]  Ian Davies,et al.  Dried Blood Spot Bioanalysis: An Evaluation of Techniques and Opportunities for Reduction and Refinement in Mouse and Juvenile Rat Toxicokinetic Studies , 2012, International journal of toxicology.

[58]  J. Hurst,et al.  Taming anxiety in laboratory mice , 2010, Nature Methods.

[59]  R. Kolář,et al.  ECVAM: Desperately Needed or Superfluous? An Animal Welfare Perspective , 2002, Alternatives to laboratory animals : ATLA.

[60]  P. Flecknell.  Refinement of animal use-assessment and alleviation of pain and distress , 1994, Laboratory animals.

[61]  W. Russell,et al.  The Principles of Humane Experimental Technique , 1960 .

[62]  Matthias Stefan Eggel,et al.  The logic, methodological and practical limitations in the current benefit concept in the harm-benefit-analysis : an investigation in the context of the EU directive 2010/63 on the protection of animals used for scientific purposes , 2018 .

[63]  D. Mutter,et al.  Survival variability of controls and definition of imaging endpoints for longitudinal follow-up of pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma in rats , 2016, Journal of Cancer Research and Clinical Oncology.

[64]  B Taylor Bennett,et al.  Russell and Burch's 3Rs then and now: the need for clarity in definition and purpose. , 2015, Journal of the American Association for Laboratory Animal Science : JAALAS.

[65]  U. Panne,et al.  Non-invasive monitoring of immunization progress in mice via IgG from feces. , 2012, In vivo.

[66]  Susanna Louhimies.  EU Directive 2010 / 63 / EU : “ Implementing the Three Rs Through Policy ” , 2012 .