In this work we investigated different thickness shear mode resonators (TSMRs) with fundamental frequencies of 10 and 30 MHz and surface acoustic wave devices with fundamental frequencies of 80 and 433 MHz. Four aspects were of primary interest in this comparison: noise levels and signal-to-noise ratios (S/N), influence of the polymer film thickness, influence of temperature on the transducer signal before and after coating, and minimum threshold values for monitoring different volatile organic compounds in the environment. We limited our investigations to a temperature range between 298 and 308 K, with 303 K the routine measuring temperature. Analyte concentrations (n-octane, tetrachloroethene) were chosen from the minimum detection limit up to 5000 μg/L. The temperature was found to strongly affect the performance of all the devices. The sorption of the analyte vapors into the polymeric films was demonstrated to be transducer-independent (identical partition coefficients for all the devices). The 30 MHz TSMRs showed very satisfying results in terms of S/N and limits of detection.