Ergonomic intervention research for improved musculoskeletal health: A critical review

Abstract This literature review of ergonomic intervention studies aims to identify effective ergonomic interventions for improved musculoskeletal health in the workplace and to make recommendations for quality criteria in ergonomic intervention research. To avoid ambiguity in terminology a list of definitions of the ergonomic terms used in this paper is provided in an appendix. Models were developed for use in the classification of ergonomic intervention research and to illustrate the problems in interpreting ergonomic intervention data. The relevant literature was identified by a two-step process. First the relevant literature was identified by inclusion criteria, then, quality criteria were applied to identify studies of good quality for effective intervention. These appear to be firstly “organizational culture” and secondly modifier interventions, the former using multiple interventions with high stakeholder commitment to reduce identified risk factors, and the latter especially focusing workers at risk and using measures which actively involve the individual. A list of recommendations is provided.

[1]  B Owen,et al.  Reducing back stress to nursing personnel: an ergonomic intervention in a nursing home. , 1992, Ergonomics.

[2]  V. H. Hildebrandt,et al.  Psychosocial factors at work and musculoskeletal disease , 1993 .

[3]  C G Drury,et al.  A field methodology for the control of musculoskeletal injuries. , 1994, Applied ergonomics.

[4]  Paula Tadano,et al.  A safety/prevention program for VDT operators: One company’s approach , 1990 .

[5]  J Ekholm,et al.  Effects of arm support or suspension on neck and shoulder muscle activity during sedentary work. , 1987, Scandinavian journal of rehabilitation medicine.

[6]  Martin G. Helander,et al.  Cost effectiveness of ergonomics and quality improvements in electronics manufacturing , 1995 .

[7]  L. Nordholm,et al.  Effects of an exercise program on sick leave due to back pain. , 1991, Physical therapy.

[8]  D A Stubbs,et al.  Back pain in the nursing profession. II. The effectiveness of training. , 1983, Ergonomics.

[9]  Donald S. Bloswick,et al.  Effect of Mailbag Design on Musculoskeletal Fatigue and Metabolic Load , 1994, Human factors.

[10]  C Zwerling,et al.  Teaching and Social Support: Effects on Knowledge, Attitudes, and Behaviors to Prevent Low Back Injuries in Industry , 1993, Health education quarterly.

[11]  K. Hansen,et al.  Trapezius muscle load as a risk indicator for occupational shoulder-neck complaints , 1993, International archives of occupational and environmental health.

[12]  Alex BURDORFf,et al.  AN EVALUATION OF ERGONOMIC IMPROVEMENTS IN THE WOODWORKING INDUSTRY , 1993 .

[13]  L. Forcier,et al.  Work related musculoskeletal disorders (WMSDs) : a reference book for prevention , 1995 .

[14]  Ilkka Kuorinka,et al.  Prevention of musculoskeletal disorders at work: Validation and reliability in a multicenter intervention study , 1995 .

[15]  P Knauth,et al.  Physical training intervention in female shift workers: I. The effects of intervention on fitness, fatigue, sleep, and psychosomatic symptoms. , 1988, Ergonomics.

[16]  Tomas Engström,et al.  Intra–group Work Patterns in Final Assembly of Motor Vehicles , 1993 .

[17]  I. Chalmers,et al.  The UK Cochrane Centre and the NHS Centre for reviews and dissemination: respective roles within the information systems strategy of the NHS R&D programme, coordination and principles underlying collaboration. , 1994, Health economics.

[18]  W. M. Keyserling,et al.  The effectiveness of a joint labor-management program in controlling awkward postures of the trunk, neck, and shoulders: Results of a field study , 1993 .

[19]  J Petzäll,et al.  Ergonomics in parallelized car assembly: a case study, with reference also to productivity aspects. , 1996, Applied ergonomics.

[20]  A. Indahl,et al.  Good Prognosis for Low Back Pain When Left Untampered: A Randomized Clinical Trial , 1995, Spine.

[21]  S E Mathiassen,et al.  Assessment of physical work load in epidemiologic studies: concepts, issues and operational considerations. , 1994, Ergonomics.

[22]  M Mattila Improvement in the occupational health program in a Finnish construction company by means of systematic workplace investigation of job load and hazard analysis. , 1989, American journal of industrial medicine.

[23]  Ottar Vasseljen,et al.  Can stress-related shoulder and neck pain develop independently of muscle activity? , 1996, Pain.

[24]  R H Westgaard,et al.  A case-control study of psycholotical and psychosocial risk factors for shoulder and neck pain at the workplace , 1995, International archives of occupational and environmental health.

[25]  A. Garg,et al.  An ergonomic evaluation of nursing assistants' job in a nursing home. , 1992, Ergonomics.

[26]  L Punnett,et al.  The impact of health and safety committees. A study based on survey, interview, and Occupational Safety and Health Administration data. , 1984, Journal of occupational medicine. : official publication of the Industrial Medical Association.

[27]  D S Chatterjee,et al.  Workplace upper limb disorders: a prospective study with intervention. , 1992, Occupational medicine.

[28]  K. Grant,et al.  Ergonomics: Summary of Studies on the Effectiveness of Ergonomic Interventions , 1995 .

[29]  L. Fine,et al.  Hand-wrist disorders among investment casting plant workers. , 1987, The Journal of hand surgery.

[30]  T Björkman,et al.  The rationalisation movement in perspective and some ergonomic implications. , 1996, Applied ergonomics.

[31]  G Parenmark,et al.  Ergonomic on-the-job training of assembly workers. Arm-neck-shoulder complaints drastically reduced amongst beginners. , 1988, Applied ergonomics.

[32]  M Hagberg,et al.  Evaluation of two floor-mopping work methods by measurement of load. , 1989, Ergonomics.

[33]  W S Marras,et al.  Effects of Handle Angle and Work Orientation on Hammering: II. Muscle Fatigue and Subjective Ratings of Body Discomfort , 1989, Human factors.

[34]  Choon-Nam Ong Ergonomic intervention for better health and productivity: two case studies , 1991 .

[35]  Sally Casswell,et al.  Formative and Process Evaluation of Health Promotion and Disease Prevention Programs , 1993 .

[36]  J. Versloot,et al.  The Cost‐Effectiveness of a Back School Program in Industry: A Longitudinal Controlled Field Study , 1992, Spine.

[37]  Jan Persson,et al.  Disorders of the cervicobrachial region among female workers in the electronics industry , 1986 .

[38]  M. P. J. M. Van Riel,et al.  Improving the sitting posture of CAD/CAM workers by increasing VDU monitor working height , 1992 .

[39]  A M Genaidy,et al.  Active microbreak effects on musculoskeletal comfort ratings in meatpacking plants. , 1995, Ergonomics.

[40]  S E Mathiassen,et al.  Physiological comparison of three interventions in light assembly work: reduced work pace, increased break allowance and shortened working days , 1996, International archives of occupational and environmental health.

[41]  K Kemmlert Preventive effects of work place investigations in connection with musculo-skeletal occupational injuries. , 1994, Scandinavian journal of rehabilitation medicine.

[42]  S J Linton,et al.  A controlled study of the effect of neck school in medical secretaries. , 1991, Scandinavian journal of rehabilitation medicine.

[43]  Alan F. Westin Organizational culture and VDT policies: a case study of the Federal Express corporation , 1991 .

[44]  Jan Persson,et al.  Disorders of the cervicobrachial region among female workers in the electronics industry: A two-year follow up , 1988 .

[45]  L. Frederick,et al.  Musculoskeletal discomfort in grocery express checkstand workers. An ergonomic intervention study. , 1992, Journal of occupational medicine. : official publication of the Industrial Medical Association.

[46]  L. Kaplan,et al.  Secondary Prevention of Low‐Back Pain: A Clinical Trial , 1990, Spine.

[47]  R H Westgaard,et al.  Development of trapezius myalgia among female workers performing light manual work. , 1993, Scandinavian journal of work, environment & health.

[48]  C. Swanson,et al.  A Prospective Study Evaluating Early Rehabilitation in Preventing Back Pain Chronicity in Mine Workers , 1995, Spine.

[49]  A Aarås,et al.  The impact of ergonomic intervention on individual health and corporate prosperity in a telecommunications environment. , 1994, Ergonomics.

[50]  R H Westgaard,et al.  Working hours as a risk factor in the development of musculoskeletal complaints. , 1991, Ergonomics.

[51]  J D Troup,et al.  Patient-Handling Skill, Back Injuries, and Back Pain: An Intervention Study in Nursing , 1989, Spine.

[52]  S. Snook,et al.  A study of three preventive approaches to low back injury. , 1978, Journal of occupational medicine. : official publication of the Industrial Medical Association.

[53]  B Knave,et al.  Incidence of work-related disorders and absenteeism as tools in the implementation of work environment improvements: the Sweden Post strategy. , 1991, Ergonomics.

[54]  F J van Dijk,et al.  Evaluation of an occupational health care programme: negative results, positive results or a failure? , 1993, Occupational medicine.

[55]  J. Winkel,et al.  Occupational and individual risk factors for shoulder-neck complaints: Part II — The scientific basis (literature review) for the guide , 1992 .

[56]  H Wos,et al.  Evaluation of impact loading in overhead work using a bolt pistol support. , 1992, Ergonomics.

[57]  T. Hansson,et al.  Primary Prevention of Back Symptoms and Absence from Work: A Prospective Randomized Study Among Hospital Employees , 1993, Spine.

[58]  M Hagberg,et al.  Discomfort and load on the upper trapezius muscle when operating a wordprocessor. , 1986, Ergonomics.

[59]  K F Murrell,et al.  An Industrial Experiment in Organized Rest Pauses , 1969, Human factors.

[60]  A Kilbom,et al.  Intervention programmes for work-related neck and upper limb disorders: strategies and evaluation. , 1988, Ergonomics.

[61]  E Grandjean,et al.  VDT Workstation Design: Preferred Settings and Their Effects , 1983, Human factors.

[62]  J. Winkel,et al.  Towards optimizing physical activity in VDT/office work , 1991 .

[63]  S. Linton,et al.  A controlled study of the effects of an early intervention on acute musculoskeletal pain problems , 1993, Pain.

[64]  A Aarås,et al.  The effect of improved workplace design on the development of work-related musculo-skeletal illnesses. , 1985, Applied ergonomics.

[65]  A. Aarås Relationship between trapezius load and the incidence of musculoskeletal illness in the neck and shoulder , 1994 .

[66]  L J Fine,et al.  Musculoskeletal disorders among visual display terminal users in a telecommunications company. , 1994, Ergonomics.

[67]  Marvin J. Dainoff Ergonomic improvements in VDT workstations: health and performance effects , 1991 .

[68]  Montgomery Ch,et al.  Preemployment back X-rays. , 1976 .

[69]  Craig A. Halpern,et al.  An Evaluation of Workstation Adjustment and Musculoskeletal Discomfort , 1993 .

[70]  G Lutz,et al.  Cumulative trauma disorder controls: the ergonomics program at Ethicon, Inc. , 1987, The Journal of hand surgery.

[71]  D. W. Grieve BookThe ergonomics of working postures: Models, methods and cases: N. Corlett, J. Wilson and I. Manineca (Eds) Taylor and Francis, London, 1986, ISBN 0 85066 338 5, pp 429 + ix, £42 , 1987 .

[72]  Bengt Edgren Perceived Exertion, Motivation, and Health — an Industrial Experience , 1986 .

[73]  Gunnar Borg,et al.  The Perception of Exertion in Physical Work , 1986, Wenner-Gren Center International Symposium Series.

[74]  E Viikari-Juntura,et al.  Does group gymnastics at the workplace help in neck pain? A controlled study. , 1994, Scandinavian journal of rehabilitation medicine.

[75]  P A Schulte,et al.  Intervention research in occupational health and safety. , 1994, Journal of occupational medicine. : official publication of the Industrial Medical Association.

[76]  W. Vollmer,et al.  The Back Injury Prevention Project pilot study. Assessing the effectiveness of back attack, an injury prevention program among nurses, aides, and orderlies. , 1993, Journal of occupational medicine. : official publication of the Industrial Medical Association.

[77]  A Aarås,et al.  Further studies of postural load and musculo-skeletal injuries of workers at an electro-mechanical assembly plant. , 1987, Applied ergonomics.

[78]  Robert Henning,et al.  Compensatory rest breaks for VDT operators , 1994 .

[79]  W Karwowski,et al.  Effects of job-simulated flexibility and strength-flexibility training protocols on maintenance employees engaged in manual handling operations. , 1992, Ergonomics.

[80]  A Garg,et al.  A biomechanical and ergonomic evaluation of patient transferring tasks: wheelchair to shower chair and shower chair to wheelchair. , 1991, Ergonomics.

[81]  T J Armstrong,et al.  Can in-plant exercise control musculoskeletal symptoms? , 1988, Journal of occupational medicine. : official publication of the Industrial Medical Association.

[82]  J Winkel,et al.  Ergonomic effects of a management-based rationalization in assembly work - a case study. , 1996, Applied ergonomics.

[83]  Jan Dul,et al.  A participatory ergonomics approach to reduce mental and physical workload , 1995 .

[84]  K. Brown,et al.  A flexibility intervention to reduce the incidence and severity of joint injuries among municipal firefighters. , 1990, Journal of occupational medicine. : official publication of the Industrial Medical Association.

[85]  D. Ferguson,et al.  A trial of physiotherapy for symptoms in keyboard operating. , 1976, The Australian journal of physiotherapy.

[86]  R. Westgaard,et al.  Postural angles as an indicator of postural load and muscular injury in occupational work situations. , 1988, Ergonomics.

[87]  Jeffrey K. Liker,et al.  Institutional conformity and technology implementation: A process model of ergonomics dissemination , 1992 .

[88]  Laurence A. Bradley,et al.  The secondary prevention of low back pain: a controlled study with follow-up , 1989, Pain.

[89]  T J Armstrong,et al.  A program for control of repetitive trauma disorders associated with hand tool operations in a telecommunications manufacturing facility. , 1985, American Industrial Hygiene Association journal.

[90]  Barbara Silverstein,et al.  Evaluation of in-plant ergonomics training , 1991 .

[91]  David A. Thompson Effect of exercise breaks on musculoskeletal strain among data-entry operators: a case study , 1991 .

[92]  Mukund Narayan,et al.  Ergonomic Improvements in a Medical Device Assembly Plant: A Field Study , 1993 .

[93]  Berger Ra,et al.  Chelsea Back Program: one year later. , 1983 .

[94]  J L Bonsall,et al.  Effect of physiotherapy on sickness absence in industry: a comparative study. , 1991, The Journal of the Society of Occupational Medicine.

[95]  M. Hagberg,et al.  Prevalence rates and odds ratios of shoulder-neck diseases in different occupational groups. , 1987, British journal of industrial medicine.

[96]  Reidar J. Mykletun,et al.  Effects of different psychological interventions on neck, shoulder and low back pain in female hospital staff. , 1994, Psychology & health.

[97]  J Winkel,et al.  An EMG-study of work methods and equipment in crane coupling as a basis for job redesign. , 1988, Applied ergonomics.

[98]  L Shi,et al.  A cost-benefit analysis of a California county's back injury prevention program. , 1993, Public health reports.

[99]  R. Westgaard,et al.  Electromyographic evaluation of muscular work pattern as a predictor of trapezius myalgia. , 1993, Scandinavian journal of work, environment & health.

[100]  Roland Örtengren,et al.  Ergonomic moves in an engineering industry: Effects on sick leave frequency, labor turnover and productivity , 1993 .

[101]  J. Steven Moore Flywheel Truing—A Case Study of an Ergonomic Intervention , 1994 .

[102]  H Ohara,et al.  Health hazard among cash register operators and the effect of improved working conditions. , 1976, Journal of human ergology.

[103]  S. Snook,et al.  Comparison of Different Approaches for the Prevention of Low Back Pain , 1988 .

[104]  R E Janaro,et al.  A Study of the Reduction of Fatigue Impact on Productivity through Optimal Rest Break Scheduling , 1985, Human factors.

[105]  Tarald O. Kvålseth Ergonomics of workstation design , 1983 .

[106]  Gustav Wickström,et al.  A five-year intervention study to reduce low back disorders in the metal industry , 1993 .

[107]  J Winkel,et al.  A model for solving work related musculoskeletal problems in a profitable way. , 1996, Applied ergonomics.

[108]  Roger C. Jensen,et al.  Four methods for identification of most back-stressing tasks performed by nursing assistants in nursing homes , 1992 .

[109]  F J van Dijk,et al.  Development and evaluation of an occupational health services programme on the prevention and control of effects of vibration. , 1993, Occupational medicine.

[110]  S. Linton,et al.  A Behavioral Workshop for Training Immediate Supervisors: The Key to Neck and Back Injuries? , 1991, Perceptual and motor skills.

[111]  T. Cook,et al.  Quasi-experimentation: Design & analysis issues for field settings , 1979 .

[112]  S J Schurman,et al.  An Action Research Approach to Workplace Health: Integrating Methods , 1992, Health education quarterly.

[113]  J G Greenwood,et al.  Early intervention in low back disability among coal miners in West Virginia: negative findings. , 1990, Journal of occupational medicine. : official publication of the Industrial Medical Association.

[114]  J Winkel,et al.  Guidelines for occupational musculoskeletal load as a basis for intervention: a critical review. , 1996, Applied ergonomics.

[115]  A Garg,et al.  A biomechanical and ergonomic evaluation of patient transferring tasks: bed to wheelchair and wheelchair to bed. , 1991, Ergonomics.

[116]  J Verbeek The use of adjustable furniture: Evaluation of an instruction programme for office workers. , 1991, Applied ergonomics.

[117]  D. J. Wood,et al.  Design and Evaluation of a Back Injury Prevention Program Within a Geriatric Hospital , 1987, Spine.

[118]  H Shahnavaz,et al.  Evaluation of an ergonomics intervention programme in VDT workplaces. , 1995, Applied ergonomics.

[119]  S H Snook,et al.  Perceived exertion and discomfort versus work height with a pistol-shaped screwdriver. , 1990, American Industrial Hygiene Association journal.

[120]  H. Toivanen,et al.  Impact of regular relaxation training and psychosocial working factors on neck-shoulder tension and absenteeism in hospital cleaners. , 1993, Journal of occupational medicine. : official publication of the Industrial Medical Association.

[121]  R H Westgaard,et al.  The effect of pain reduction on perceived tension and EMG-recorded trapezius muscle activity in workers with shoulder and neck pain. , 1995, Scandinavian journal of rehabilitation medicine.

[122]  E Viikari-Juntura,et al.  Seasonal variation in neck and shoulder symptoms. , 1992, Scandinavian journal of work, environment & health.

[123]  Steven L. Sauter,et al.  Promoting health and productivity in the computerized office : models of successful ergonomic interventions , 1990 .

[124]  Tomas Engström,et al.  Musculoskeletal Symptoms, Ergonomic Aspects and Psychosocial Factors in Two Different Truck Assembly Concepts , 1993 .