Defective pantomime of object use in left brain damage: apraxia or asymbolia?

Disturbance of pantomime of object use in patients with left brain damage (LBD) and aphasia has been firmly established but its nature remains controversial. It may be due to an inability to perform movements from memory without external support by objects (apraxia) or to an inability to produce signs referring to absent objects and actions (asymbolia). The need to perform movements without external support is shared with imitation of gestures, and the demand to designate absent objects with drawing from memory. Both of these tasks have been found to be impaired in LBD. We examined pantomime of object use, drawing objects from memory, imitation of meaningless gestures, and aphasia in 40 patients with LBD and aphasia and compared them to healthy controls and to patients with right brain damage (RBD). Whereas drawing showed comparable sensitivity to LBD and RBD, pantomime was distinctly more disturbed in LBD than in RBD patients. Pantomime was worse than drawing in LBD but better than drawing in RBD. In the LBD group scores on pantomime showed significant correlations of very similar strength to drawing, imitation, and all language tests. Multidimensional scaling of the correlational structure placed pantomime in an intermediate position between verbal and non-verbal tests. We conclude that neither apraxia nor asymbolia can satisfactorily explain our results. It seems as if pantomime of object use taps a central aspect of left hemisphere function which is compromised by any LBD. We propose that this may be the ability to select and combine distinctive features of objects and actions.

[1]  J. Ferro,et al.  Lesion size and location in ideomotor apraxia. , 1984, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[2]  J. Duffy,et al.  Three studies of deficits in pantomimic expression and pantomimic recognition in aphasia. , 1981, Journal of speech and hearing research.

[3]  Forrest W. Young Multidimensional Scaling: History, Theory, and Applications , 1987 .

[4]  W. Singer,et al.  Interhemispheric asymmetries of the modular structure in human temporal cortex. , 2000, Science.

[5]  P. Sommers A system for drawing and drawing-related neuropsychology , 1989 .

[6]  P. Gartside,et al.  Structure of the Cerebral Cortex in Men and Women , 2002, Journal of neuropathology and experimental neurology.

[7]  Dr. phil. et med. H. Liepmann Das Krankheitsbild der Apraxie (“motorische Asymbolie”) auf Grund eines Falles von einseitiger Apraxie (Schluss.) , 1900 .

[8]  J. Duffy,et al.  An investigation of body part as object (BPO) responses in normal and brain-damaged adults , 1989, Brain and Cognition.

[9]  R T Knight,et al.  Neural representations of skilled movement. , 2000, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[10]  G. Goldenberg,et al.  Hemisphere asymmetries for imitation of novel gestures , 2002, Neurology.

[11]  K. Heilman,et al.  A Cognitive Neuropsychological Model of Limb Praxis , 1991 .

[12]  C. Hall,et al.  Chapter 11 Limb Apraxia: A Process Approach , 1992 .

[13]  K. Goldstein Language and Language Disturbances , 1948 .

[14]  Harold Goodglass,et al.  Pantomime, praxis, and aphasia , 1992, Brain and Language.

[15]  R. Cubelli,et al.  Cognition in Action: Testing a Model of Limb Apraxia , 2000, Brain and Cognition.

[16]  R. Jakobson,et al.  Six leçons sur le son et le sens , 1976 .

[17]  K Willmes,et al.  The Aachen Aphasia Test. , 1984, Advances in neurology.

[18]  H. Spinnler,et al.  Is ideomotor apraxia the outcome of damage to well-defined regions of the left hemisphere? Neuropsychological study of CAT correlation. , 1980, Journal of neurology, neurosurgery, and psychiatry.

[19]  Stephanie Kelter,et al.  Analytical competence and language impairment in aphasia , 1980, Brain and Language.

[20]  P. Faglioni,et al.  Impairment of color sorting behavior after hemispheric damage: an experimental study with the Holmgren skein test. , 1972, Cortex; a journal devoted to the study of the nervous system and behavior.

[21]  Joel B. Greenhouse,et al.  Characteristics of recovery of drawing ability in left and right brain-damaged patients , 1988, Brain and Cognition.

[22]  G. Goldenberg Matching and imitation of hand and finger posturesin patients with damage in the left or right hemispheres , 1999, Neuropsychologia.

[23]  E. Renzi,et al.  The Executive And Ideational Components of Apraxia , 1988, Cortex.

[24]  G. Goldenberg,et al.  The meaning of meaningless gestures: A study of visuo-imitative apraxia , 1997, Neuropsychologia.

[25]  E. Bay Aphasia and non-verbal disorders of language. , 1962, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[26]  C Caltagirone,et al.  Drawing objects from memory in aphasia. , 1983, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[27]  C. Caltagirone,et al.  The relationships between conceptual and semantic-lexical disorders in aphasia. , 1979, The International journal of neuroscience.

[28]  D. Buxhoeveden,et al.  Comparative lateralisation patterns in the language area of human, chimpanzee, and rhesus monkey brains , 2000, Laterality.

[29]  G. Goldenberg Defective imitation of gestures in patients with damage in the left or right hemispheres. , 1996, Journal of neurology, neurosurgery, and psychiatry.

[30]  D. Westwood,et al.  Task Demands and Limb Apraxia in Stroke , 2000, Brain and Cognition.

[31]  L. Jakobson,et al.  Differences in the visual control of pantomimed and natural grasping movements , 1994, Neuropsychologia.

[32]  Joachim Hermsdörfer,et al.  Imitation of gestures by disconnected hemispheres , 2001, Neuropsychologia.

[33]  Alan P. Neuren The Lopsided Ape , 1992, Neurology.

[34]  H. Liepmann Drei Aufsätze aus dem Apraxiegebiet , 1908 .

[35]  J. Duffy,et al.  Testing causal theories of pantomimic deficits in aphasia using path analysis , 1994 .

[36]  L. Buxbaum,et al.  The Role of the Dynamic Body Schema in Praxis: Evidence from Primary Progressive Apraxia , 2000, Brain and Cognition.

[37]  E. Kaplan,et al.  DISTURBANCE OF GESTURE AND PANTOMIME IN APHASIA. , 1963, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[38]  T. L. Hayes,et al.  Anatomical Specialization of the Anterior Motor Speech Area: Hemispheric Differences in Magnopyramidal Neurons , 1995, Brain and Language.

[39]  Thomas J. Boll,et al.  Handbook of clinical neuropsychology , 1981 .