Alcohol‐Induced Blackout as a Criminal Defense or Mitigating Factor: An Evidence‐Based Review and Admissibility as Scientific Evidence

Alcohol‐related amnesia—alcohol blackout—is a common claim of criminal defendants. The generally held belief is that during an alcohol blackout, other cognitive functioning is severely impaired or absent. The presentation of alcohol blackout as scientific evidence in court requires that the science meets legal reliability standards (Frye, FRE702/Daubert). To determine whether “alcohol blackout” meets these standards, an evidence‐based analysis of published scientific studies was conducted. A total of 26 empirical studies were identified including nine in which an alcohol blackout was induced and directly observed. No objective or scientific method to verify the presence of an alcoholic blackout while it is occurring or to confirm its presence retrospectively was identified. Only short‐term memory is impaired and other cognitive functions—planning, attention, and social skills—are not impaired. Alcoholic blackouts would not appear to meet standards for scientific evidence and should not be admissible.

[1]  J. Chwast.  Amnesia and Homicide , 1961 .

[2]  Aaron M White,et al.  What Happened? Alcohol, Memory Blackouts, and the Brain , 2003, Alcohol research & health : the journal of the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism.

[3]  M. Barnett,et al.  The Association of Alcohol‐Induced Blackouts and Grayouts to Blood Alcohol Concentrations , 2006, Journal of forensic sciences.

[4]  J. Mendelson,et al.  Alcohol and memory: amnesia and short-term memory function during experimentally induced intoxication. , 1971, The American journal of psychiatry.

[5]  R. Tarter,et al.  Blackouts: relationship with memory capacity and alcoholism history. , 1976, Archives of general psychiatry.

[6]  Kim Fromme,et al.  Fragmentary and en bloc blackouts: similarity and distinction among episodes of alcohol-induced memory loss. , 2003, Journal of studies on alcohol.

[7]  J. Risberg,et al.  Regional cerebral blood flow during alcoholic blackout , 1989, Psychiatry Research.

[8]  Alcohol amnesia. Observations in seven drinking inpatient alcoholics. , 1970, Quarterly journal of studies on alcohol.

[9]  D. W. Goodwin.  Alcohol amnesia. , 1995, Addiction.

[10]  D. W. Goodwin,et al.  Effect of Alcohol on Short Term Memory in Alcoholics , 1973, British Journal of Psychiatry.

[11]  R. Robinson.  Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals and the Local Construction of Reliability , 2009 .

[12]  J. Bradford,et al.  Sex offenders who claim amnesia for their alleged offense. , 1995, The Bulletin of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law.

[13]  S. Lisman.  Alcoholic "blackout": state dependent learning? , 1974, Archives of general psychiatry.

[14]  C. Lieber,et al.  Association between low plasma tryptophan and blackouts in male alcoholic patients. , 1985, Alcoholism, clinical and experimental research.

[15]  D. W. Goodwin,et al.  An electroencephalographic study of memory loss during alcoholic intoxication. , 1971, Diseases of the nervous system.

[16]  P. Fenwick.  Automatism and the Law , 1986, The Lancet.

[17]  R. Granacher.  Commentary: Alcoholic blackout and allegation of amnesia during criminal acts. , 2004, The journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law.

[18]  W. Miller,et al.  Effects of Alcohol and Expectancy Upon Episodic Memory in Individuals Reporting Alcoholic Blackouts , 1994 .

[19]  D. Marlowe,et al.  Voluntary intoxication and criminal responsibility. , 1999, Behavioral sciences & the law.

[20]  A. J. Cunnien.  Alcoholic blackouts: Phenomenology and legal relevance , 1986 .

[21]  Harald Merckelbach,et al.  Alcoholic blackout for criminally relevant behavior. , 2004, The journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law.

[22]  H. Merckelbach,et al.  Claims of crime-related amnesia in forensic patients. , 2004, International journal of law and psychiatry.

[23]  D. W. Goodwin.  Two species of alcoholic "blackout". , 1971, The American journal of psychiatry.

[24]  L. Branchey,et al.  Variables associated with alcoholic blackouts in men. , 1985, The American journal of drug and alcohol abuse.

[25]  A. S. Wolf.  Homicide and blackout in alaskan natives: a report and reproduction of five cases. , 1980, Journal of studies on alcohol.

[26]  D. W. Goodwin,et al.  Loss of Short Term Memory as a Predictor of the Alcoholic “Blackout” , 1970, Nature.

[27]  H. Swartzwelder,et al.  Experiential Aspects of Alcohol‐Induced Blackouts Among College Students , 2004, The American journal of drug and alcohol abuse.

[28]  J. Merikangas.  Commentary: Alcoholic blackout--does it remove mens rea? , 2004, The journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law.

[29]  A. Ehlers,et al.  Amnesia for violent crime among young offenders , 2009, The journal of forensic psychiatry & psychology.

[30]  A Study of the Effects of Alcohol on Mental Functions * , 1964, Canadian Psychiatric Association journal.

[31]  M. Bradley.  Washington University in St , 2006 .

[32]  SHORT‐TERM MEMORY AND THE ALCOHOLIC BLACKOUT * , 1973, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[33]  N. Martin,et al.  Genetic epidemiology of alcohol-induced blackouts. , 2004, Archives of general psychiatry.

[34]  J. Buchanan.  Crime in England and Wales 2005—6: A summary of the main statistics , 2007 .

[35]  Alcoholic blackouts and Korsakoff's syndrome. , 1975, Advances in experimental medicine and biology.

[36]  D W Goodwin,et al.  Phenomenological aspects of the alcoholic "blackout". , 1969, The British journal of psychiatry : the journal of mental science.

[37]  K. Jennison,et al.  Drinking-induced blackouts among young adults: results from a national longitudinal study. , 1994, The International journal of the addictions.

[38]  M. Kopelman,et al.  Amnesia for criminal offences , 1984, Psychological Medicine.

[39]  David E. Bernstein,et al.  The Daubert Trilogy in the States , 2004 .

[40]  J. O'mahony.  A Comparison of Alcohol Abusers Who Have and Have Not Experienced Blackouts , 2004, European Addiction Research.