Spirituality as an ethical challenge in Indian palliative care: A systematic review

Abstract Objective: Spiritual care is recognized as an essential component of palliative care (PC). However, patients' experience of spirituality is heavily context dependent. In addition, Western definitions and findings regarding spirituality may not be applicable to patients of non-Western origin, such as Indian PC patients. Given the particular sociocultural, religious, and economic conditions in which PC programs in India operate, we decided to undertake a systematic review of the literature on spirituality among Indian PC patients. We intended to assess how spirituality has been interpreted and operationalized in studies of this population, to determine which dimensions of spirituality are important for patients, and to analyze its ethical implications. Method: In January of 2015, we searched five databases (ATLA, CINAHL, EMBASE, PsycINFO, and PubMed) using a combination of controlled and noncontrolled vocabulary. A content analysis of all selected reports was undertaken to assess the interpretation and dimensions of spirituality. Data extraction from empirical studies was done using a data-extraction sheet. Results: A total of 39 empirical studies (12 qualitative, 21 quantitative, and 6 mixed-methods) and 18 others (10 reviews, 4 opinion articles, and 4 case studies) were retrieved. To date, no systematic review on spirituality in Indian PC has been published. Spirituality was the main focus of only six empirical studies. The content analysis revealed three dimensions of spirituality: (1) the relational dimension, (2) the existential dimension, and (3) the values dimension. Religion is prominent in all these dimensions. Patients' experiences of spirituality are determined by the specifically Indian context, which leads to particular ethical issues. Significance of results: Since spiritual well-being greatly impacts quality of life, and because of the substantial presence of people of Indian origin living outside the subcontinent, the findings of our review have international relevance. Moreover, our review illustrates that spirituality can be an ethical challenge and that more ethical reflection on provision of spiritual care is needed.

[1]  Hamilton Inbadas.  The Philosophical and Cultural Situatedness of Spirituality at the End of Life in India , 2017, Indian journal of palliative care.

[2]  S. Noble,et al.  Signs of Spiritual Distress and its Implications for Practice in Indian Palliative Care , 2017, Indian journal of palliative care.

[3]  I. Khanna,et al.  Palliative Care - An Indian Perspective , 2016 .

[4]  M. Fegg,et al.  Meaning in life experience at the end of life: validation of the Hindi version of the Schedule for Meaning in Life Evaluation and a cross-cultural comparison between Indian and German palliative care patients. , 2015, Journal of pain and symptom management.

[5]  R. Chacko,et al.  End-of-life care perspectives of patients and health professionals in an Indian health-care setting. , 2014, International journal of palliative nursing.

[6]  C. Loiselle,et al.  Communication in cancer care: psycho-social, interactional, and cultural issues. A general overview and the example of India , 2014, Front. Psychol..

[7]  N. Salins,et al.  Spiritual well-being and its influence on fatigue in patients undergoing active cancer directed treatment: a correlational study. , 2014, Journal of cancer research and therapeutics.

[8]  A. Shukla,et al.  Quality of Life among People Living with HIV/AIDS (PLHA) , 2014 .

[9]  G. Patel.  Black and South Asian women’s experiences of breast cancer: A qualitative study , 2014 .

[10]  S. Bhatnagar,et al.  Management of Total Cancer Pain: A Case of Young Adult , 2014, Indian journal of palliative care.

[11]  R. Kamath,et al.  Psychosocial Determinants of Health-Related Quality of Life of People Living with HIV/AIDS on Antiretroviral Therapy at Udupi District, Southern India , 2014, International journal of preventive medicine.

[12]  Oxford Centre for Evidence-based Medicine Levels of Evidence (January 2001) , 2014 .

[13]  I. Higginson,et al.  'My dreams are shuttered down and it hurts lots’–a qualitative study of palliative care needs and their management by HIV outpatient services in Kenya and Uganda , 2013, BMC Palliative Care.

[14]  A. Talukdar,et al.  Determinants of Quality of Life in HIV-Infected Patients Receiving Highly Active Antiretroviral Treatment at a Medical College ART Center in Kolkata, India , 2013, Journal of the International Association of Providers of AIDS Care.

[15]  N. Salins,et al.  Distress Screening Using Distress Thermometer in Head and Neck Cancer Patients Undergoing Radiotherapy and Evaluation of Causal Factors Predicting Occurrence of Distress , 2013, Indian journal of palliative care.

[16]  S. Noble,et al.  Spiritual Concerns in Hindu Cancer Patients Undergoing Palliative Care: A Qualitative Study , 2013, Indian journal of palliative care.

[17]  Yu-Te Huang.  Challenges and responses in providing palliative care for people living with HIV/AIDS. , 2013, International journal of palliative nursing.

[18]  S. Singh-Carlson,et al.  Breast cancer survivorship and South Asian women: understanding about the follow-up care plan and perspectives and preferences for information post treatment. , 2013, Current oncology.

[19]  P. Selwyn,et al.  The role of palliative care in the current HIV treatment era in developed countries. , 2013, Topics in antiviral medicine.

[20]  T. Lynch,et al.  Mapping levels of palliative care development: a global update. , 2008, Journal of pain and symptom management.

[21]  P. Deshpande,et al.  Patient-reported quality of life outcomes in Indian breast cancer patients: importance, review of the researches, determinants and future directions. , 2013, Journal of cancer research and therapeutics.

[22]  N. Gopalkrishnan.  India: a country report , 2013 .

[23]  F. Elsner,et al.  Psychosocial and spiritual problems of terminally ill patients in Kerala, India. , 2012, Future oncology.

[24]  D. Goswami.  A Reflective Study of Symptom Management in Terminal Cancer , 2012, Journal of pain & palliative care pharmacotherapy.

[25]  S. Skevington,et al.  Is quality of life poorer for older adults with HIV/AIDS? International evidence using the WHOQOL-HIV , 2012, AIDS care.

[26]  Trupti N. Bodhare,et al.  Health-related Quality of Life and Existential Concerns Among Patients with End-stage Renal Disease , 2012, Indian journal of palliative care.

[27]  E. Raj.  The changing scenario in oncologist-patient communication: we need to adapt. , 2012, Oncology.

[28]  M. Fowler.  Religion, religious ethics, and nursing , 2012 .

[29]  T. Mahalakshmy,et al.  Quality of Life and its Determinants in People Living with Human Immunodeficiency Virus Infection in Puducherry, India , 2011, Indian journal of community medicine : official publication of Indian Association of Preventive & Social Medicine.

[30]  J. Mehta.  Spirituality and medicine: dying with grace. , 2011, Southern medical journal.

[31]  T. Altilio,et al.  Oxford textbook of palliative social work , 2011 .

[32]  S. Garg,et al.  Quality of Life of Women with Breast Cancer at the Time of Diagnosis in New Delhi , 2011 .

[33]  Agnes Panikulam.  Total Pain Management , 2011, Indian journal of palliative care.

[34]  A. Kandasamy,et al.  Spirituality, distress, depression, anxiety, and quality of life in patients with advanced cancer. , 2011, Indian journal of cancer.

[35]  I. Higginson,et al.  'A softening of edges': a comparison of yoga classes at palliative care services in New Delhi and London. , 2010, International journal of palliative nursing.

[36]  S. Bhatnagar,et al.  Psychosocial Concerns in Patients With Advanced Cancer: An Observational Study at Regional Cancer Centre, India , 2010, The American journal of hospice & palliative care.

[37]  D. Moher,et al.  Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. , 2010, International journal of surgery.

[38]  J. Ioannidis,et al.  The PRISMA Statement for Reporting Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses of Studies That Evaluate Health Care Interventions : Explanation and Elaboration , 2009 .

[39]  A. Jagannathan,et al.  Life After Cancer in India: Coping with Side Effects and Cancer Pain , 2009, Journal of psychosocial oncology.

[40]  J. Ioannidis,et al.  The PRISMA Statement for Reporting Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses of Studies That Evaluate Health Care Interventions: Explanation and Elaboration , 2009, Annals of Internal Medicine [serial online].

[41]  S. Garg,et al.  Assessment of quality of life among HIV positive people attending tertiary hospital of Delhi, India. , 2009, The Journal of communicable diseases.

[42]  M. O’Connor,et al.  Palliative Care Services for Indian Migrants in Australia: Experiences of the Family of Terminally Ill Patients , 2009, Indian journal of palliative care.

[43]  P. Satishchandra,et al.  Do Men and Women with HIV Differ in Their Quality of Life? A Study from South India , 2009, AIDS and Behavior.

[44]  W. Braun.  Sallekhana: the ethicality and legality of religious suicide by starvation in the Jain religious community. , 2008, Medicine and law.

[45]  S. Chaturvedi,et al.  Ethical dilemmas in palliative care in traditional developing societies, with special reference to the Indian setting , 2008, Journal of Medical Ethics.

[46]  D. Clark,et al.  Hospice and palliative care development in India: a multimethod review of services and experiences. , 2008, Journal of pain and symptom management.

[47]  S. Chattopadhyay,et al.  East meets West: Cross-cultural perspective in end-of-life decision making from Indian and German viewpoints , 2008, Medicine, health care, and philosophy.

[48]  B. Gurm,et al.  Understanding Canadian Punjabi-speaking South Asian women's experience of breast cancer: a qualitative study. , 2008, International journal of nursing studies.

[49]  J. Paley.  Spirituality and secularization: nursing and the sociology of religion. , 2007, Journal of clinical nursing.

[50]  T. Lynch,et al.  Mapping levels of palliative care development: a global view. , 2008, Journal of pain and symptom management.

[51]  N. Raghuram,et al.  Effects of an Integrated Yoga Program in Modulating Psychological Stress and Radiation-Induced Genotoxic Stress in Breast Cancer Patients Undergoing Radiotherapy , 2007, Integrative cancer therapies.

[52]  R. Lunn.  Spiritual care in a multi-religious setting revisited , 2007 .

[53]  S. Bauer-Wu,et al.  Spiritual perspectives and practices at the end-of-life: A review of the major world religions and application to palliative care , 2007 .

[54]  Joy L. Johnson,et al.  Punjabi Women's Stories of Breast Cancer Symptoms: Gulti (Lumps), Bumps, and Darad (Pain) , 2007, Cancer nursing.

[55]  J. Bottorff,et al.  Punjabi Immigrant Women’s Breast Cancer Stories , 2007, Journal of Immigrant and Minority Health.

[56]  P. Satishchandra,et al.  Quality of life in HIV subtype C infection among asymptomatic subjects and its association with CD4 counts and viral loads – a study from South India , 2006, Quality of Life Research.

[57]  Y. Chapman,et al.  Development of palliative care in India: an overview. , 2006, International journal of nursing practice.

[58]  Hsiu-Fang Hsieh,et al.  Three Approaches to Qualitative Content Analysis , 2005, Qualitative health research.

[59]  B. Rajan,et al.  Quality of Life determinants in women with breast cancer undergoing treatment with curative intent , 2005, World journal of surgical oncology.

[60]  E. Vidhubala,et al.  Validation of quality of life questionnaire for patients with cancer--Indian scenario. , 2005, Indian journal of cancer.

[61]  Jennifer Beste.  Instilling hope and respecting patient autonomy: reconciling apparently conflicting duties. , 2005, Bioethics.

[62]  A. Ramanakumar,et al.  Coping mechanisms among long-term survivors of breast and cervical cancers in Mumbai, India. , 2005, Asian Pacific journal of cancer prevention : APJCP.

[63]  S. Bhatnagar,et al.  Fighting cancer is half the battle... living life is the other half. , 2005, Journal of cancer research and therapeutics.

[64]  M. C. Reid,et al.  Attitudes of Asian‐Indian Hindus Toward End‐of‐Life Care , 2005, Journal of The American Geriatrics Society.

[65]  M. Wright,et al.  Exploring the meaning of spiritual care in the Indian context: findings from a survey and interviews , 2004 .

[66]  S. Saxena,et al.  WHOQOL-HIV for quality of life assessment among people living with HIV and AIDS: results from the field test. , 2004, AIDS care.

[67]  B. Majumdar.  An exploration of socioeconomic, spiritual, and family support among HIV-positive women in India. , 2004, The Journal of the Association of Nurses in AIDS Care : JANAC.

[68]  G. Bhattacharya.  Health care seeking for HIV/AIDS among South Asians in the United States. , 2004, Health & social work.

[69]  S. Channabasavanna,et al.  Psychological well-being among cancer patients receiving radiotherapy –a prospective study , 1998, Quality of Life Research.

[70]  B. Ferrell,et al.  Measurement of the quality of life in cancer survivors , 1995, Quality of Life Research.

[71]  A. Lipman,et al.  Commentary: Spirituality and Religion in Palliative Care—Potential Benefits and Risks , 2004 .

[72]  S. Vasudevan.  Coping with terminal illness: a spiritual perspective , 2003 .

[73]  G. Palat,et al.  Kerala, India: status of cancer pain relief and palliative care. , 2002, Journal of pain and symptom management.

[74]  K. Ashcraft.  Spiritual issues at the end of life. , 2002, The West Virginia medical journal.

[75]  T. Walter.  Spirituality in palliative care: opportunity or burden? , 2002, Palliative medicine.

[76]  D. Cella,et al.  Measuring spiritual well-being in people with cancer: The functional assessment of chronic illness therapy—spiritual well-being scale (FACIT-Sp) , 2002, Annals of behavioral medicine : a publication of the Society of Behavioral Medicine.

[77]  M. Pandey,et al.  Development of a distress inventory for cancer: preliminary results. , 2002, Journal of postgraduate medicine.

[78]  D. Clark.  Religion, medicine, and community in the early origins of St. Christopher's Hospice. , 2001, Journal of palliative medicine.

[79]  A. Bradshaw,et al.  The spiritual dimension of hospice: the secularization of an ideal. , 1996, Social science & medicine.

[80]  S. Chaturvedi.  What's important for quality of life to Indians--in relation to cancer. , 2003, Social science & medicine.

[81]  T. Clay.  The Clay column. Sore points. , 1991, Nursing standard (Royal College of Nursing (Great Britain) : 1987).

[82]  W. Bainbridge.  Care of the dying: dying East, dying West. , 1991, Nursing standard (Royal College of Nursing (Great Britain) : 1987).

[83]  R. Roul,et al.  Lessons of self‐help for Indian women with breast cancer , 1988, Cancer nursing.

[84]  M. Francis.  Concerns of terminally ill adult Hindu cancer patients , 1986 .