Trends in mathematical modeling of host–pathogen interactions

Pathogenic microorganisms entail enormous problems for humans, livestock, and crop plants. A better understanding of the different infection strategies of the pathogens enables us to derive optimal treatments to mitigate infectious diseases or develop vaccinations preventing the occurrence of infections altogether. In this review, we highlight the current trends in mathematical modeling approaches and related methods used for understanding host–pathogen interactions. Since these interactions can be described on vastly different temporal and spatial scales as well as abstraction levels, a variety of computational and mathematical approaches are presented. Particular emphasis is placed on dynamic optimization, game theory, and spatial modeling, as they are attracting more and more interest in systems biology. Furthermore, these approaches are often combined to illuminate the complexities of the interactions between pathogens and their host. We also discuss the phenomena of molecular mimicry and crypsis as well as the interplay between defense and counter defense. As a conclusion, we provide an overview of method characteristics to assist non-experts in their decision for modeling approaches and interdisciplinary understanding.

[1]  David Ross,et al.  Evolutionary Game between Commensal and Pathogenic Microbes in Intestinal Microbiota , 2016, Games.

[2]  Gary An,et al.  Agent-based dynamic knowledge representation of Pseudomonas aeruginosa virulence activation in the stressed gut: Towards characterizing host-pathogen interactions in gut-derived sepsis , 2011, Theoretical Biology and Medical Modelling.

[3]  S. Schuster,et al.  Game theoretical modelling of survival strategies of Candida albicans inside macrophages. , 2010, Journal of theoretical biology.

[4]  P. Zipfel,et al.  Complement regulators and inhibitory proteins , 2009, Nature Reviews Immunology.

[5]  F. Renaud,et al.  A simple model of host-parasite evolutionary relationships. Parasitism: compromise or conflict? , 1991, Journal of theoretical biology.

[6]  Selecting Against Antibiotic-Resistant Pathogens: Optimal Treatments in the Presence of Commensal Bacteria , 2012, Bulletin of mathematical biology.

[7]  Dan Ryan,et al.  Optimal Control in Individual-Based Models: Implications from Aggregated Methods , 2012, The American Naturalist.

[8]  K. Foster,et al.  The Evolution of Mutualism in Gut Microbiota Via Host Epithelial Selection , 2012, PLoS biology.

[9]  J. Rubin,et al.  Using nonlinear model predictive control to find optimal therapeutic strategies to modulate inflammation , 2011 .

[10]  P. Dittrich,et al.  Molecular Codes Through Complex Formation in a Model of the Human Inner Kinetochore , 2014, Biosemiotics.

[11]  John H. Werren,et al.  Holes in the Hologenome: Why Host-Microbe Symbioses Are Not Holobionts , 2016, mBio.

[12]  Harold Houba Game Theory Evolving: a Problem-centered Introduction to Modeling Stratgeic Behavior [Review of: H. Gintis (2000) Game Theory Evolving: a Problem-centered Introduction to Modeling Strategic Behavior] , 2001 .

[13]  Jorge Nuno Silva,et al.  Mathematical Games , 1959, Nature.

[14]  C. Beauchemin,et al.  Progress and trends in mathematical modelling of influenza A virus infections , 2018, Current Opinion in Systems Biology.

[15]  Mohammad Soheilypour,et al.  Agent‐Based Modeling in Molecular Systems Biology , 2018, BioEssays : news and reviews in molecular, cellular and developmental biology.

[16]  M. A. Javarone The Host-Pathogen Game: An Evolutionary Approach to Biological Competitions , 2016, Front. Phys..

[17]  John T. Workman,et al.  Optimal Control Applied to Biological Models , 2007 .

[18]  Michael Meyer-Hermann,et al.  Modeling Influenza Virus Infection: A Roadmap for Influenza Research , 2015, Viruses.

[19]  S. Schuster,et al.  Molecular crypsis by pathogenic fungi using human factor H. A numerical model , 2018, bioRxiv.

[20]  C. L. Ventola The antibiotic resistance crisis: part 1: causes and threats. , 2015, P & T : a peer-reviewed journal for formulary management.

[21]  Wayne T. A. Enanoria,et al.  When Does Overuse of Antibiotics Become a Tragedy of the Commons? , 2012, PloS one.

[22]  Raluca Eftimie,et al.  Mathematical Models for Immunology: Current State of the Art and Future Research Directions , 2016, Bulletin of mathematical biology.

[23]  Edda Klipp,et al.  The game theory of Candida albicans colonization dynamics reveals host status-responsive gene expression , 2016, BMC Systems Biology.

[24]  Raffaele Ghigliazza,et al.  Stochastic optimal therapy for enhanced immune response. , 2004, Mathematical biosciences.

[25]  A. Leach,et al.  Molecular Surveillance of True Nontypeable Haemophilus influenzae: An Evaluation of PCR Screening Assays , 2012, PloS one.

[26]  John J Tyson,et al.  Control of cell growth, division and death: information processing in living cells , 2014, Interface Focus.

[27]  S. Schuster,et al.  Continuous model for the rock–scissors–paper game between bacteriocin producing bacteria , 2007, Journal of mathematical biology.

[28]  Jacky L. Snoep,et al.  Targeting pathogen metabolism without collateral damage to the host , 2017, Scientific Reports.

[29]  Stefan N. Lang,et al.  Playing ‘hide-and-seek’ with factor H: game-theoretical analysis of a single nucleotide polymorphism , 2018, Journal of The Royal Society Interface.

[30]  Tomas Veloz,et al.  Cycles and the Qualitative Evolution of Chemical Systems , 2012, PloS one.

[31]  Jean Krivine,et al.  The Kappa platform for rule-based modeling , 2018, Bioinform..

[32]  J. M. Dow,et al.  Partial characterization of avenacinase from Gaeumannomyces graminis var. avenae , 1991 .

[33]  S. Eswarappa Location of Pathogenic Bacteria during Persistent Infections: Insights from an Analysis Using Game Theory , 2009, PloS one.

[34]  Barbara M. Bakker,et al.  What Controls Glycolysis in Bloodstream Form Trypanosoma brucei?* , 1999, The Journal of Biological Chemistry.

[35]  Christoph Kaleta,et al.  Deciphering the regulation of metabolism with dynamic optimization: an overview of recent advances. , 2017, Biochemical Society transactions.

[36]  K. Kuchler,et al.  Candida albicans cell surface superoxide dismutases degrade host-derived reactive oxygen species to escape innate immune surveillance , 2009, Molecular microbiology.

[37]  S. Schuster,et al.  Host-pathogen interactions between the human innate immune system and Candida albicans—understanding and modeling defense and evasion strategies , 2015, Front. Microbiol..

[38]  S. Schuster,et al.  Modelling the host–pathogen interactions of macrophages and Candida albicans using Game Theory and dynamic optimization , 2017, Journal of The Royal Society Interface.

[39]  P. Ehrlich Address in Pathology, ON CHEMIOTHERAPY , 1913, British medical journal.

[40]  Stefan Schuster,et al.  Agent-Based Modeling Approach of Immune Defense Against Spores of Opportunistic Human Pathogenic Fungi , 2012, Front. Microbio..

[41]  David W. Denning,et al.  Hidden Killers: Human Fungal Infections , 2012, Science Translational Medicine.

[42]  Eric Bonabeau,et al.  Agent-based modeling: Methods and techniques for simulating human systems , 2002, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[43]  A. Best,et al.  Predation on infected host promotes evolutionary branching of virulence and pathogens' biodiversity. , 2012, Journal of theoretical biology.

[44]  Neil McRoberts,et al.  The global burden of pathogens and pests on major food crops , 2019, Nature Ecology & Evolution.

[45]  Bashar Ibrahim,et al.  A Mathematical Framework for Kinetochore-Driven Activation Feedback in the Mitotic Checkpoint , 2017, Bulletin of mathematical biology.

[46]  Edda Klipp,et al.  Modelling the Regulation of Thermal Adaptation in Candida albicans, a Major Fungal Pathogen of Humans , 2012, PloS one.

[47]  Alan S. Perelson,et al.  Agent-based modeling of host–pathogen systems: The successes and challenges , 2008, Information Sciences.

[48]  Thomas E. Gorochowski,et al.  BSim: An Agent-Based Tool for Modeling Bacterial Populations in Systems and Synthetic Biology , 2012, PloS one.

[49]  João Leite,et al.  A Survey of Programming Languages and Platforms for Multi-Agent Systems , 2006, Informatica.

[50]  Herbert Gintis,et al.  Game Theory Evolving: A Problem-Centered Introduction to Modeling Strategic Interaction - Second Edition , 2009 .

[51]  S. West,et al.  Crystal toxins and the volunteer's dilemma in bacteria , 2019, Journal of evolutionary biology.

[52]  Douglas E. Jones,et al.  Parameter estimation and sensitivity analysis in an agent-based model of Leishmania major infection. , 2010, Journal of theoretical biology.

[53]  Christopher Lawrence,et al.  A computational model of invasive aspergillosis in the lung and the role of iron , 2016, BMC Systems Biology.

[54]  E. Klipp,et al.  Assessing the advantage of morphological changes in Candida albicans: a game theoretical study , 2014, Front. Microbiol..

[55]  M. C. Ruíz-Roldan,et al.  Tomatinase from Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lycopersici is required for full virulence on tomato plants. , 2008, Molecular plant-microbe interactions : MPMI.

[56]  R. Johnstone,et al.  The Evolution of Mimicry under Constraints , 2004, The American Naturalist.

[57]  Austin Burt,et al.  Impact of mosquito gene drive on malaria elimination in a computational model with explicit spatial and temporal dynamics , 2016, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[58]  Andrew Adamatzky,et al.  Multi-scale Modelling of Computers Made from Excitable Chemical Droplets , 2013, Int. J. Unconv. Comput..

[59]  Lucia Russo,et al.  Mathematical modeling of infectious disease dynamics , 2013, Virulence.

[60]  B. Kingwell,et al.  Plasma Sphingosine-1-Phosphate Is Elevated in Obesity , 2013, PloS one.

[61]  R. Damian Molecular Mimicry: Antigen Sharing by Parasite and Host and Its Consequences , 1964, The American Naturalist.

[62]  P. Dittrich,et al.  Stochastic effects in a compartmental model for mitotic checkpoint regulation , 2007, J. Integr. Bioinform..

[63]  Anand Kumar,et al.  An alternate pathophysiologic paradigm of sepsis and septic shock , 2013, Virulence.

[64]  Alexander G. Fletcher,et al.  Comparing Individual-Based Approaches to Modelling the Self-Organization of Multicellular Tissues , 2016 .

[65]  G. Ruxton,et al.  Imperfect Batesian Mimicry and the Conspicuousness Costs of Mimetic Resemblance , 2010, The American Naturalist.

[66]  Hendrik Richter,et al.  Dynamic landscape models of coevolutionary games , 2016, Biosyst..

[67]  A. Perelson,et al.  Optimal strategies in immunology , 1976, Journal of mathematical biology.

[68]  Julio R. Banga,et al.  Optimization in computational systems biology , 2008, BMC Systems Biology.

[69]  Robert F. Stengel,et al.  Optimal control of innate immune response , 2002, Optimal Control Applications and Methods.

[70]  Christoph Kaleta,et al.  Pervasive Selection for Cooperative Cross-Feeding in Bacterial Communities , 2016, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[71]  B. Ibrahim Spindle assembly checkpoint is sufficient for complete Cdc20 sequestering in mitotic control , 2015, Computational and structural biotechnology journal.

[72]  Peter Dittrich,et al.  A Dynamical Model for Activating and Silencing the Mitotic Checkpoint , 2017, Scientific Reports.

[73]  S. Schuster,et al.  Evolutionary game theory: cells as players. , 2014, Molecular bioSystems.

[74]  P. Zipfel,et al.  Human complement control and complement evasion by pathogenic microbes--tipping the balance. , 2013, Molecular immunology.

[75]  Hana M. Dobrovolny,et al.  Assessing Mathematical Models of Influenza Infections Using Features of the Immune Response , 2013, PloS one.

[76]  Katherine C. Chen,et al.  Sniffers, buzzers, toggles and blinkers: dynamics of regulatory and signaling pathways in the cell. , 2003, Current opinion in cell biology.

[77]  Bashar Ibrahim,et al.  Modeling potent pathways for APC/C inhibition: pivotal roles for MCC and BubR1 , 2016, 1611.04781.

[78]  Mario di Bernardo,et al.  BSim 2.0: An Advanced Agent-Based Cell Simulator. , 2017, ACS synthetic biology.

[79]  Eva Balsa-Canto,et al.  AMIGO2, a toolbox for dynamic modeling, optimization and control in systems biology , 2016, Bioinform..

[80]  D. Ebert,et al.  Optimal killing for obligate killers: the evolution of life histories and virulence of semelparous parasites , 1997, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences.

[81]  David Ben-Arieh,et al.  Agent-Based Model: A Surging Tool to Simulate Infectious Diseases in the Immune System , 2014 .

[82]  Marc Thilo Figge,et al.  Agent-Based Model of Human Alveoli Predicts Chemotactic Signaling by Epithelial Cells during Early Aspergillus fumigatus Infection , 2014, PloS one.

[83]  Pierre Lemarinier,et al.  Agent Based Modelling and Simulation tools: A review of the state-of-art software , 2017, Comput. Sci. Rev..

[84]  Giuseppe De Nicolao,et al.  Model predictive control of glucose concentration in type I diabetic patients: An in silico trial , 2009, Biomed. Signal Process. Control..

[85]  William S. Hlavacek,et al.  BioNetGen: software for rule-based modeling of signal transduction based on the interactions of molecular domains , 2004, Bioinform..

[86]  Ferdinando Chiacchio,et al.  Agent-Based Modeling of the Immune System: NetLogo, a Promising Framework , 2014, BioMed research international.

[87]  Seddik M Djouadi,et al.  Combining robust state estimation with nonlinear model predictive control to regulate the acute inflammatory response to pathogen. , 2015, Mathematical biosciences and engineering : MBE.

[88]  Gary An,et al.  Agent-based model of epithelial host-pathogen interactions in anastomotic leak. , 2013, The Journal of surgical research.

[89]  Bashar Ibrahim,et al.  Active Transport Can Greatly Enhance Cdc20:Mad2 Formation , 2014, International journal of molecular sciences.

[90]  G. An,et al.  Agent-based model of fecal microbial transplant effect on bile acid metabolism on suppressing Clostridium difficile infection: an example of agent-based modeling of intestinal bacterial infection , 2014, Journal of Pharmacokinetics and Pharmacodynamics.

[91]  Bashar Ibrahim,et al.  Spatial Rule-Based Modeling: A Method and Its Application to the Human Mitotic Kinetochore , 2013, Cells.

[92]  Tomas Veloz,et al.  Effects of small particle numbers on long-term behaviour in discrete biochemical systems , 2014, Bioinform..

[93]  Peter Dittrich,et al.  Spatial Rule-Based Simulations: The SRSim Software. , 2019, Methods in molecular biology.

[94]  I. Androulakis,et al.  Agent-Based Modeling of Endotoxin-Induced Acute Inflammatory Response in Human Blood Leukocytes , 2010, PloS one.

[95]  Bashar Ibrahim,et al.  Toward a systems-level view of mitotic checkpoints. , 2015, Progress in biophysics and molecular biology.

[96]  Peter Dittrich,et al.  Structure and Hierarchy of Influenza Virus Models Revealed by Reaction Network Analysis , 2019, Viruses.

[97]  Josef Hofbauer,et al.  Evolutionary Games and Population Dynamics , 1998 .

[98]  C. Lively,et al.  Parasite adaptation to locally common host genotypes , 2000, Nature.

[99]  Rob Knight,et al.  Current understanding of the human microbiome , 2018, Nature Medicine.

[100]  Robert F. Stengel,et al.  Optimal enhancement of immune response , 2002, Bioinform..

[101]  Andreas Handel,et al.  A review of mathematical models of influenza A infections within a host or cell culture: lessons learned and challenges ahead , 2011, BMC public health.

[102]  M. Aon,et al.  Mitochondria: hubs of cellular signaling, energetics and redox balance. A rich, vibrant, and diverse landscape of mitochondrial research , 2015, Front. Physiol..

[103]  Christoph Kaleta,et al.  Optimality principles reveal a complex interplay of intermediate toxicity and kinetic efficiency in the regulation of prokaryotic metabolism , 2017, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[104]  M. Marathe,et al.  Predictive Computational Modeling of the Mucosal Immune Responses during Helicobacter pylori Infection , 2013, PloS one.

[105]  R Laubenbacher,et al.  Optimization and Control of Agent-Based Models in Biology: A Perspective , 2016, Bulletin of mathematical biology.

[106]  Jonathan Timmis,et al.  Computational Models of the NF-KB Signalling Pathway , 2014, Comput..

[107]  H J Bremermann,et al.  A game-theoretical model of parasite virulence. , 1983, Journal of theoretical biology.

[108]  O Bara,et al.  Immune therapeutic strategies using optimal controls with L1 and L2 type objectives. , 2016, Mathematical biosciences.

[109]  S. Schuster,et al.  Optimizing defence, counter-defence and counter-counter defence in parasitic and trophic interactions -- A modelling study , 2019, 1907.04820.

[110]  M. Pangburn,et al.  The alternative pathway of complement , 1984, Springer Seminars in Immunopathology.

[111]  G. Drusano,et al.  Dosing Regimen Matters: the Importance of Early Intervention and Rapid Attainment of the Pharmacokinetic/Pharmacodynamic Target , 2012, Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy.

[112]  Benyamin Grosman,et al.  Glucose Outcomes with the In-Home Use of a Hybrid Closed-Loop Insulin Delivery System in Adolescents and Adults with Type 1 Diabetes , 2017, Diabetes technology & therapeutics.

[113]  Peter Dittrich,et al.  Mad2 binding is not sufficient for complete Cdc20 sequestering in mitotic transition control (an in silico study). , 2008, Biophysical chemistry.

[114]  M. Figge,et al.  Comparative Assessment of Aspergillosis by Virtual Infection Modeling in Murine and Human Lung , 2019, Front. Immunol..

[115]  O. Sharomi,et al.  Optimal control in epidemiology , 2017, Ann. Oper. Res..

[116]  Y. Iwasa,et al.  Dynamic optimization of host defense, immune memory, and post-infection pathogen levels in mammals. , 2004, Journal of theoretical biology.

[117]  Pengfei Hao,et al.  A Heading Maintaining Oriented Compression Algorithm for GPS Trajectory Data , 2019, Informatica.

[118]  A. Doeschl-Wilson,et al.  The role of mathematical models of host-pathogen interactions for livestock health and production - a review. , 2011, Animal : an international journal of animal bioscience.

[119]  Y. Iwasa,et al.  Inducible defense against pathogens and parasites: optimal choice among multiple options. , 2001, Journal of theoretical biology.

[120]  Thomas Hinze,et al.  Rule-based spatial modeling with diffusing, geometrically constrained molecules , 2010, BMC Bioinformatics.

[121]  Lars Kaderali,et al.  Mathematical Analysis of Viral Replication Dynamics and Antiviral Treatment Strategies: From Basic Models to Age-Based Multi-Scale Modeling , 2018, Front. Microbiol..

[122]  Cristian Picioreanu,et al.  iDynoMiCS: next-generation individual-based modelling of biofilms. , 2011, Environmental microbiology.

[123]  S. Ellner,et al.  Dynamic Models in Biology , 2006 .

[124]  D. Meyer,et al.  Economic Game Theory to Model the Attenuation of Virulence of an Obligate Intracellular Bacterium , 2016, Front. Cell. Infect. Microbiol..

[125]  Cathrine A. McKenzie Antibiotic dosing in critical illness. , 2011, The Journal of antimicrobial chemotherapy.

[126]  A. Perelson,et al.  Optimal strategies in immunology , 1978, Journal of mathematical biology.

[127]  S. Schuster,et al.  Deciphering the Counterplay of Aspergillus fumigatus Infection and Host Inflammation by Evolutionary Games on Graphs , 2016, Scientific Reports.

[128]  P. Dittrich,et al.  In-Silico Modeling of the Mitotic Spindle Assembly Checkpoint , 2008, PloS one.

[129]  A. Perelson,et al.  Optimal strategies in immunology III. The IgM-IgG switch , 1980, Journal of mathematical biology.

[130]  L B Kier,et al.  Cellular automata modelling of biomolecular networks dynamics , 2010, SAR and QSAR in environmental research.

[131]  Peter Dittrich,et al.  Multi-scale stochastic organization-oriented coarse-graining exemplified on the human mitotic checkpoint , 2019, Scientific Reports.

[132]  Bashar Ibrahim,et al.  In silico spatial simulations reveal that MCC formation and excess BubR1 are required for tight inhibition of the anaphase-promoting complex. , 2015, Molecular bioSystems.

[133]  Edda Klipp,et al.  Prediction of temporal gene expression. Metabolic opimization by re-distribution of enzyme activities. , 2002, European journal of biochemistry.

[134]  Gigliola Sica,et al.  Local Overexpression of V1a-Vasopressin Receptor Enhances Regeneration in Tumor Necrosis Factor-Induced Muscle Atrophy , 2014, BioMed research international.

[135]  Peter Dittrich,et al.  Structural analysis of in silico mutant experiments of human inner-kinetochore structure , 2015, Biosyst..

[136]  Andreas Deutsch,et al.  Evolutionary game theory: molecules as players. , 2014, Molecular bioSystems.

[137]  M. Figge,et al.  Deciphering chemokine properties by a hybrid agent-based model of Aspergillus fumigatus infection in human alveoli , 2015, Front. Microbiol..

[138]  Philippe Buchy,et al.  Kinetics of neutralizing antibodies in patients naturally infected by H5N1 virus , 2010, PloS one.

[139]  M. Gustafsson,et al.  Facing the challenges of multiscale modelling of bacterial and fungal pathogen–host interactions , 2016, Briefings in functional genomics.

[140]  Peter Dittrich,et al.  Rule-based modeling and simulations of the inner kinetochore structure. , 2013, Progress in biophysics and molecular biology.

[141]  Sean Luke,et al.  MASON: A Multiagent Simulation Environment , 2005, Simul..

[142]  T. Porco,et al.  Antibiotic resistance as collateral damage: the tragedy of the commons in a two-disease setting. , 2015, Mathematical biosciences.

[143]  Bor-Sen Chen,et al.  Robust model matching control of immune systems under environmental disturbances: dynamic game approach. , 2008, Journal of theoretical biology.